11 ms·
> Longer school days, 3 meals, and a longer school year helps students stay focused. The middle one is absolutely true, the other two I really doubt e.g. in Fi
by masklinn 8y ago
> Longer school days, 3 meals, and a longer school year helps students stay focused.
The middle one is absolutely true, the other two I really doubt e.g. in Finland or Germany, schoolday starts around 9AM and ends around 2PM, yielding 3h30 to 4h studies a day accounting for breaks, 5 days/week, with little homework (maybe 5h/week total). Afternoon is usually dedicated to clubs.
- organsnyder 8y agoFor kids with unstable home environments, I think it's valuable to give them more time at school. Hopefully, the extra time includes ample opportunities for arts, sports, clubs, and other "non-academic" pursuits.
- roland35 8y agoAbsolutely. Most of this extra time ("wraparound time") is not necessarily structured class/tutoring time but unstructured time allowing kids to explore things like art or even play in a safe environment.
- masklinn 8y agoSure but that's not how I interpret "longer school days" which sounds like more time butt-in-seat.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoI don’t see why that would be presumed. It’s less expensive to give kids supervised free time than to teach lessons.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoRatios for structured play tend to be 1:8 adults to children (in UK), whilst classrooms are 1:30. Teachers are usually paid more, but not 3½ times more. NSPCC recommend 1:6 ratio for 4-8 year olds doing activities. I'd say max 1:3 if you want to give parent level care engaging with a child in activities the child is choosing in a meaningful way.
- maxerickson 8y agoThere's really solid evidence that increasing classroom time increases learning. Of course, people haven't yet gotten the idea that we should try to accomplish sufficient learning with minimum classroom time.
- masklinn 8y ago> There's really solid evidence that increasing classroom time increases learning. There's really solid evidence that intellectual performance drops sharply long before 40h/week. Unless the "classroom time" you talk about includes a lot of off-time and non-butt-in-seat activities it seems you'll be deep into diminishing returns if not outright losing if you increase the length of the school day. My own memories of schools are that by late afternoon many students had stopped following altogether.
- jschwartzi 8y agoAs long as you pay teachers overtime for all the extra hours they'll be working to put together curriculum for your longer school days, I'm in. It's not just students who have to be working during those hours, it's also teachers.
- maxerickson 8y agoRead both sentences before getting ultra snarky please.
- toyg 8y agoYou absolutely cannot compare Northern Europe with inner-city black America. Different worlds, different values, different histories, different attitudes, different challenges. No model fits all, especially in education, but these two realities are so dramatically different that they don’t really belong in the same sentence.
- YinglingLight 8y ago100%.
- fhood 8y agoAgreed. Using Finland as an example is absurd. Finland has a very wealthy, very homogeneous population. Longer school days are designed, in this case, to keep many of these kids in a safe environment for as long as possible.
- moorhosj 8y ago==Using Finland as an example is absurd. Finland has a very wealthy, very homogeneous population.== Finland is 21% less wealthy than America on a per capita basis. Finland GDP per capita - $35,964.77 US GDP per capita - $45,759.46 -http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Finland/United-States/Economy http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Finland/Uni...
- ezzzzz 8y agoFinland has a drastically lower poverty rate, lower income inequality [1] and lower violent crime rate than the United States [2]. This fact, combined with Finland's well-known social safety nets leads to the obvious conclusion that you would be hard pressed to find living conditions like those in the slums of Akron/Cleveland in Finland. [1]https://data.oecd.org/finland.htm#profile-government https://data.oecd.org/finland.htm#profile-government [2]http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Finland/United-States/Crime http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Finland/Uni...
- dhekir 8y agoI believe it also depends on the environment around the school. In a third-world country, I'd probably prefer being safely indoors at school and in contact with friends, with free time if needed, than in a sketchy area without being able to see many friends. In a rich European country, there's enough public infrastructure (public transport, libraries, parks, etc.) that I'd probably prefer to be outside.
- eaurouge 8y ago> In a third-world country, I'd probably prefer being safely indoors at school That's a ridiculous generalization. Most developing countries have lower crime rates than some American inner cities. Heck, many developing countries are safer than some developed countries.
- lentil_soup 8y agoIn general the whole "third-world" or "developing" country categorization is wrong.
- sb52191 8y agoIf the kids we're coming from stable, supportive home environments where learning can take place outside the classroom, you might be right. But those aren't the target students for the program; IMO the student's from rough home lives will almost assuredly benefit from this model.
- masklinn 8y ago> If the kids we're coming from stable, supportive home environments where learning can take place outside the classroom, you might be right. The entire point of the finnish model is that this doesn't happen, there is no homework and there is no suggestion or expectations of parental teaching. There is extensive support for both kids and their parents (including good free meals and teacher-provided tutoring), but all teaching is done by the teacher.
- panzagl 8y agoFor lower socioeconomic status kids a stable environment means not being at school at 6 am because Mom kicked you out to 'party' with her new boyfriend, or not coming to school high because Dad hotboxed on the drive over.
- masklinn 8y agoSounds like a case for boarding schools. Does that technology not exist anymore in the US?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- panzagl 8y agoIf people can't get their shit together enough to make sure their kid has a sandwich everyday they certainly aren't putting their kid into boarding school. Parents found unfit for parenting have their kids placed in the foster system, but that is a lengthy legal process.
- mkhalil 8y agoI think the point is that school is safer and provides better nourishment than the students own home, considering the low-poverty and crime-ridden areas some - or even many - of the students live at.
- gnat 8y agoAnd research consistently shows that teenagers perform better if you start school later in the day than 7am. E.g., http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/019263650208663302 http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0192636502086633... "shifted the school start timefrom 7:15 a. m. to 8:40 a. m. This article examines that change, finding significant benefits such as improved attendance and enrollment rates, less sleeping in class, and less student-reported depression." https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15402000701263809 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/1540200070126380... "Students at the late-starting school reported waking up over 1 hr later on school mornings and obtaining 50 min more sleep each night, less sleepiness, and fewer tardies than students at the early school." https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/pol.3.3.62 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/pol.3.3.62 "Results show that starting the school day 50 minutes later has a significant positive effect on student achievement, which is roughly equivalent to raising teacher quality by one standard deviation."
- so33 8y agoFrom the article linked in the article: https://www.ohio.com/akron/news/education/i-promise-school-aims-to-educate-the-whole-child-and-their-families-too https://www.ohio.com/akron/news/education/i-promise-school-a... >I Promise kids’ school days will start an hour later than their peers. They’ll also receive an additional hour after school every day called the “illumination period,” which will be a time for extra mentoring, studying or club activities. Not only does the school day start an hour later, the extra time in the day comes from support of extracurricular activities.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoI don’t imagine most working adults would be willing to work starting so early. Why do we force children who need even more sleep to do so?
- xxpor 8y agoSo that the adults can get to work on time.
- Tepix 8y agoA school that starts at 9am is unheard of in Germany. The standard time is 7:45am or 8:00am. Also Ganztagsschulen (all-day schools) are getting very common (more than 60% and rising, see https://www.ganztagsschulen.org/de/19001.php https://www.ganztagsschulen.org/de/19001.php). Kids stay there at until 4pm or so. I don't know why you mention Germany in the first place, it's education system isn't top notch compared to Scandinavian schools.
- naravara 8y ago>The middle one is absolutely true, the other two I really doubt e.g. in Finland or Germany, schoolday starts around 9AM and ends around 2PM, yielding 3h30 to 4h studies a day accounting for breaks, 5 days/week, with little homework (maybe 5h/week total). Afternoon is usually dedicated to clubs. In the context of at-risk kids, I think the idea is to maximize the amount of time the kids get to spend away from their toxic and stressful home environments. I am a bit skeptical of the overall "minimize idle time" idea, though. They seem to be on board with giving the kids enough free time to do independent study and stuff, but whether that's any good will depend on how it's implemented.
- neuland 8y agoIf the problem is toxic home environments though, why aren't people suggesting that we cut out the middle man and focus on building a better foster / adoption system and encouraging people to use it? It seems that everyone is recognizing this is the problem, but the solutions all revolve around school, when it really doesn't have anything to do with schools. Edit: Or boarding schools.
- JamesBarney 8y agoBecause it is really hard to compete with the love a parent, even a really shitty one.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jschwartzi 8y agoIt's not even really that. Your home environment sets your barometer for what normal life looks like and for how strangers can be expected to behave. If your parents fight and assume ill intent in every mistake then you see that in every interaction. If they're constantly trying to get one over on each other then that's how you see human relationships. They don't have to love you or be particularly invested in you for you to learn some really screwed up lessons from them.
- ismail 8y agoMy working theory is, it is context dependent if longer school days, and terms are better or worse. For example: With Children that have a rich home environment, plenty of interactions that stimulate them, keeping them at school longer may hamper development. On the flip side you have an environment where this is not the case. Examples include socio-economic factors like parents/care givers working long hours. I recently did research into this exact problem in South Africa. What are the factors that impact on education in communities that have socio-economic challenges? The challenges are numerous and as this article says. The environment around the children just makes it extremely difficult for them to break out of the cycle of poverty. These factors include: being hungry, crime, lack of sanitation-this is a problem in South Africa they get sick more often then their counterparts in other areas.This results in them missing more school which puts them behind., Parents working long hours, travelling distances to get to work Lack of resources in schools or support There really is a multitude of problems each impacting the other creating a self perpetuating cycle of poverty. Out of the research into the problems I developed a concept for a social enterprise that could solve some of these problems. Trying to identify some funding sources as traditional vc will not be suitable. Maybe impact investors? If the above sounds interesting, you are keen to explore leveraging education for social change or exploring alternative educational models mail me. Email is in profile
- eitally 8y agoLonger school days help parents hold down full time jobs. A longer school year eliminates the need for babysitters or camps in the 10-12wk summer break, and also provides continuity of curriculum. Food is pretty easy and many schools are providing at least two meals already. A good number have things like backpack programs[1], also, to send food home (either in the evening or more commonly for the weekend). [1] http://www.feedingamerica.org/our-work/hunger-relief-programs/backpack-program/ http://www.feedingamerica.org/our-work/hunger-relief-program...
- ssdd 8y agoLonger school days might help kids with stressful home environment but it also poses risk to bonding b/w kids and parents especially for parents who are able to provide and are working towards holistic(moral, etc.) development of their kids. Longer school days should be optional with extra curricular activities to fill the later part of the day.
- cududa 8y agoWell then send them to a different school
- dragonwriter 8y agoThe longer school day and it's structure are, per the article, designed to provide compensation for at-home support that is deficient in the target population; done right—e.g., so it doesn't just look like normal classroom time stretched longer—this may well be the best available mitigation for the social problem it is addressing.
- naravara 8y agoI was one of the lucky kids who went to a very well funded school district because my parents managed to snag one of the, like, 15 housing units within it that didn't cost a million dollars a year to live in. They had a really good after-school program for me and the other 30 or so kids whose parents had to work long hours with no flexibility. We were supervised by an adult to make sure we didn't kill each other but it was mostly about having free-time to do homework, read books, and play pick-up soccer or whatever. Edit: To be honest, it's probably a better environment that we would have gotten at home, even with caring, attentive parents. We had access to the whole school library and our adult supervision actually knew our curricula so they could help us with the homework better than our parents could. Home computers weren't really a thing yet, so being able to use the shelf of encyclopedias was huge.
- clairity 8y agoyour example doesn't contradict the idea of having a longer school day or school year. as others have said, kids who lack a nurturing home environment can benefit from a nurturing environment at school (if that's what it truly is). for example, school could open at 6am for parents who work early, but not start until 9am. the intermediary time could be nap time, unstuctured play, or guided exploration (gardening, science experiments, even animal husbandry in rural areas). between structured classroom time, they could have more breaks for more naps, play or exploration. school could end later so parents can pick them up after work, and have shorter and more frequent vacations so kids don't forget so much in-between. you could even have morning or evening joint learning times, where parents join in to learn how to teach and encourage their kids (such programs seem to help break the cycle of poverty).
- dghughes 8y ago> Finland or Germany Both those countries are also very prosperous and innovative. It seems the people or culture are what makes them do so well not the amount of school hours. For all we know parents in those countries are far more supportive of their children. And may also be intelligent enough to assist their children with the homework. By intelligent I mean they are able to teach their children well I don't mean to be able to understand what a six year-old is learning (if not there is a far bigger problem!).
- polski-g 8y agoFYI parental involvement has no impact on educational attainment, a proxy for intelligence: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289617301757 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S016028961...
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoThe difference is that in Finland etc. there are social services and childcare systems in place to support those kids outside of school hours. Where does an inner city African American kid go after school if both parents (or single parent) are working? Who pays for that? In countries with adequate social services, this is less of an issue.