7 ms·
South Korean cam-hunter squads conduct electronic sweeps of public spaces
- al_ramich 8y agoWonder if there is a way to have a device that can detect whether you are being recorded. Is that even possible, if yes, that would be a good idea for someone to build? Would make lots of cash given the current climate of concern (especially for kids). Interesting article on this topic https://mashable.com/2017/12/04/airbnb-host-spying-webcam/ https://mashable.com/2017/12/04/airbnb-host-spying-webcam/
- Tharkun 8y agoA device to detect cameras would likely be a camera, thus aggrevating the problem. I'm not sure what the solution might be.
- al_ramich 8y agotrue, suppose you could have a small camera that in real-time scans live stream using AI to detect camera's point at you. But that would be adding to the problem.
- NickNameNick 8y agoSome sensors (CCDs, i think) are strong retro-reflectors. So you could detect possible cameras with a strobe light and some more cameras.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoAnd their camera (array) detects yours and tries to disable it ... we're going to need lasers (sharks optional).
- reustle 8y agoI know there's that cool hack of pointing your IR tv remote at your camera to see if the battery still works. Could you create some kind of IR ball that shoots beams of IR in all directions constantly? Would that blur the cameras vision?
- SiempreViernes 8y agoI would guess any heat lamp warm enough to blind a camera is also liable to make you uncomfortably hot too.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nsnick 8y agoIR LEDs aren't hot.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoWeak IR LEDs aren't hot, but they aren't likely to be blinding either.
- sdiepend 8y agoRelevant hackernews thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16381592 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16381592
- kbumsik 8y agoAll smartphones sold in Korea are required to make shutter sound when taking a photo, to prevent spy cam using a phone in a public place. If you buy an iPhone in Korea there is no way to turn it off.
- al_ramich 8y agowhat about video? and I think small/hidden devices are of more concern...
- kbumsik 8y agoIt makes sound only when start recording. Small cams are actually regulated by the government (you need to get a permission to buy one) but of course there are black markets.
- dogma1138 8y agoThat used to be pretty common in all smartphones in the early days I was surprised that the feature was removed same goes for the mandatory recording LED. On Android ofc you can always disable them if you root or flash your phone.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kbumsik 8y agoOn top of that, iPhone makes shutter sound when taking a screenshot as well. I heard jailbreak also could disable them but not sure it is possible lately.
- dogma1138 8y agoThe iPhone isn’t making any shutter sounds when silent these days, not sure when they were removed I remember the 3G having those and not being able to disable them.
- 8y ago
- yorwba 8y ago> though there are scores of such teams nationwide, police officials say none has ever found a camera – but perhaps that is not the point. ... > Last month, the province’s police force received about $267,000 (£203,000) to focus on the problem, according to local police official Chae Kyoung-deok. ... > despite the focus on hidden cameras, 90 per cent of the crimes involved filming with regular smartphones, statistics show. This is seems to be similar to terrorism, in that the fear of the problem is much bigger than the problem itself, and because attacking the root causes is too difficult, most of the effort is spent on useless security theater.
- mrweasel 8y agoI was wondering the same thing. The focus seems to be on a small/virtually non-existing part of a bigger underlying issue. Dealing with the issue of everyone always carrying a camera, disguise as a phone, and sometimes someone will take your picture without your approval is going to be extremely difficult.
- noobermin 8y agoYou really shouldn't downplay the issue. From what I've read, the issue of peeping toms is a real issue in SK, especially given the gender norms there. That said, of course people should be mindful of unintended consequences or the co-opting of movements for women's right like these recent SK protests specifically to push in culturally conservative directions. SK has in the past been more receptive to a strong government in the private realm including censorship of satire and the like. This was under the previous government that was at the center of a corruption drama but those elements still exist of course. I guess what I mean is both could and might be true: molka is a problem and it is being used to push the society in culturally conservative directions.
- mrweasel 8y agoSorry, I wasn't meaning to downplay the issue. What I am question is how the issue is handled. Going around looking for hidden cameras apparently haven't yielded any result, nor have it addressed the underlying issue.
- nasredin 8y ago...while in California you almost have to stay indoors if you are to avoid seeing scantily clad - sometimes a bit too young - women!
- meshr 8y agoI guess better copyright enforcement may help. They should also read about deepfakes and stop thinking that filming once body itself is already a serious crime. It matters how that info is used. Homosapien personality is not his body but his brain. PS: Ironically another news on that page says “Women stage topless protest over Facebook ‘discrimination’ Did police arrest everyone who filmed this? Did police arrest these women for five years in prison for using their body as a weapon? Is it ok for the same woman to appear in both these news?
- tdb7893 8y agoThere's a difference between a public display and a private display that seems pretty clear so these aren't the same thing.
- meshr 8y agoBut it is “virtual” projection of the same info (body). There is a difference in the history of the picture shooting but the picture is the same and may falsely say was it shot in public or in private with the help of photoshop. So the same picture may be the serious crime or profitable shot for newspaper depending on unclear history or how good you can fake it or what body owner says. You can’t make something a serious crime if it could be faked.
- tdb7893 8y agoThe justice system is designed to handle these ambiguities, it's literally the job of the system to gather the facts and experts and make a decision. If it gets to the point where you can't tell at all out seems like you would just need a new law that requires you to prove it was in public or get consent (which you should get anyway, even in public). Proving it was in public would be trivial for the case of something like a protest (lots of eye witnesses and security cameras). I guess I'm not seeing the scenario where it will ever be that unsolvable of a problem in society.
- meshr 8y ago
- mbrumlow 8y agoProbably a unpopular view / idea. But if we just took the tabo out of being nude... It would resolve the issue 2 fold, people would not be afraid of being seen nude, and the drive for people wanting to take pictures of people nude would go down too. There once was a time a ankle showing, then it was the knee was taboo too. Remember we were all born nude, and the idea that being nude is taught. I have a meeting, wanted to say more, but no time, sorry. TTL!
- miguelrochefort 8y agoThis is the only viable long-term solution. Cameras that can see through walls and drones the size of a fly are coming.
- Nightshaxx 8y agoThis is a pretty big privacy invasion and privacy is something very valuable to people. Our browsing activity doesn't seem like a big deal, but when companies are taking away our privacy and using it to create ads, a lot of people care! The big problem is that people have their privacy and personal space bubble, and if you reach into it they will be very angry.
- pjc50 8y agoIt's not just nudity but the fine details of body-shaming; entire magazines exist of clothed photos of celebrity women where details are circled and labelled as horrible.
- noobermin 8y agoSounds like a naturist point of view, also known as nudism.
- invalidOrTaken 8y ago"Just"
- miguelrochefort 8y agoThis is not a sustainable solution. What will happen when cameras become as small as a grain of rice, and drones become as small as a fly? This is the end of privacy. We should embrace it, rather than fight it.
- aaron695 8y ago> Some women have taken action into their own hands. A small group uploaded videos apparently filmed in men’s changing rooms – a revenge that upended the gender dynamics of a largely male-perpetrated crime. It's a 'serious' crime... but it's ok to do it to random, unrelated people in revenge. The fact the author could write this shows a serious problem in today's society. If you don't understand why some people seem to vote crazy, re-read that statement and see why people might not want to be on 'their' side. Swap in bombing random victims in a mosque, in response to another opposing religion randomly bombing their mosque and you'll see how the author is basically giving approval. It is 'revenge', but it's not taking 'action' and it's not 'upending' anything. (Washington Post to their credit have changed this line after their original posting)
- codedokode 8y agoI think that buying or posessing a hidden camera should be illegal. So that police could arrest people only for ordering such device. Also, there should be a punishment for porn site owners who host such videos. They should check the documents and verify that video is taken with permission from models.
- jerf 8y ago30 years ago that might have worked, when "hidden camera" was arguably a distinct category of device. But every cell phone has a camera in it that 30 years ago would have been government spy level tech, and it's not hard to buy the cameras alone or with minimal supporting electronics for perfectly reasonable reasons, and anything that fits in a cell phone is also small enough to be easy to hide. Even an old cell phone is not that hard to make into a "hidden camera", honestly, body and all. Here's a CNET article on the basic principles, just to show how mainstream this tech all is: https://www.cnet.com/how-to/turn-your-old-phone-into-a-home-security-camera/ https://www.cnet.com/how-to/turn-your-old-phone-into-a-home-... It takes only modest creativity to hide that fairly well. There isn't a such thing as a "hidden camera" as a distinct product any more to be banned.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoWhat? My phone is a hidden camera.
- DoctorOetker 8y agojust mandate image sensor manufacturers to include a resonant structure, to aid detection? then its a matter of time before old image sensors start to fail or get replaced...