16 ms·
Inventory of CO2 available for terraforming Mars
- ryanmercer 8y ago>The only greenhouse gas present in high enough quantities on Mars to warm it up is carbon dioxide Annnnnnnnd that's why some plans call for manufacturing far more efficient greenhouse gasses in situ. You can also Free the oxygen locked in the regolith itself with enough energy (so enough time). You could hurl smaller comets and asteroids at the planet to add to the atmosphere. http://www.pnas.org/content/98/5/2154 http://www.pnas.org/content/98/5/2154 for an example of making other greenhouse gasses. The polar caps alone have more than a million cubic kilometers of dry ice and more than a million cubic kilometers of water ice, the regolith over the entire planet is also lousy with both in varying concentrations which will release as the planet thaws. When we actually have the technology abilities to influence the Martian atmosphere in any appreciable quantity, eventually getting the atmosphere up to a decent pressure will be more than doable given the interest. Remember, just few decades ago we didn't even think Mars had water and now we know there's more than a million cubic kilometers of water ice (and there's something like 50,669,625,000,000,000 gallons/191,805,395,565,860,992 liters of water in the caps alone). The real problem with ever properly terraforming Mars is the nitrogen which still isn't that big of an issue as again you can import it from comets and asteroids or heat silicate to release nitrogen. Hell we could get to Mars, dig a 5ft hole and go "woah! There's all kinds of organic material down here, this must have been an ancient ocean teeming with life!" and have all sorts of usable stuff for terraforming frozen in thick layers of permafrost.
- tomerico 8y agoUsing low units (liters) so that the numbers look big, can be misleading. To put it in perspective: The CO2 mass in the polar ice caps is 1/5000 of the mass of earth atmosphere The water mass underneath is 1/4 of the volume of water in the mediterranean sea.
- ryanmercer 8y ago>The water mass underneath is 1/4 of the volume of water in the mediterranean sea. And Mars has about 38% the surface area of Earth, roughly the surface area of all the dry land on Earth. For Mars that's a hell of a lot of water. >The CO2 mass in the polar ice caps is 1/5000 of the mass of earth atmosphere Which is more than enough to sustain above freezing temperatures when melted. Add in what is frozen in the regolith all over the planet as permafrost and you're well on your way to a pressure humans can survive without pressure suits. Which allows you to start bringing in comets/asteroids as well as heating various rocks to release various gasses as energy generation allows. It makes terraforming quite doable for even our current civilization and if we crack affordable fusion (we almost certainly will, probably in our lifetimes assuming middle age or younger now) energy generation becomes a non-issue and then it's just a matter of setting up shop on Mars, again with largely (if not entirely) automated facilities that start chugging away generating 'designer' greenhouse gasses to start the runaway greenhouse effect to melt the caps.
- SolarNet 8y agoThe Mediterranean Sea was/is not enough water for each of the human civilizations that has ever lived on it's borders. Let alone the entire (habitable area of the) planet.
- azernik 8y ago> The CO2 mass in the polar ice caps is 1/5000 of the mass of earth atmosphere The CO2 mass in the earth's atmosphere is only 1/2000 of the mass of the earth's atmosphere. That is to say, Mars ice has almost half as much CO2 has the atmosphere of a much larger planet.
- mrfusion 8y agoI wish your comment were at top instead of the don’t-go-to-mars folks :-(
- creaghpatr 8y agoNot with that attitude.
- flyinglizard 8y ago"Whether you think you can or you can't, you are probably right"
- 394549 8y agoAttitude doesn't trump facts or reality.
- madeuptempacct 8y agoThrowing (water-rich) asteroids at things does.
- bargl 8y agoBut it does trump potential and progress.
- Yetanfou 8y agoIf $deity wanted man to fly he would have given him wings. (enter Montgolfier, Lilienthal, Santos-Dumont, the Wright brothers, etc) Flying faster than the speed of sound is impossible, there is a wall out there which will crush any plane trying to break through it. (enter Lippisch, those British researchers who realised a moving tail can keep a plane stable across the sound barrier but for some reason were not allowed to test their ideas in practice, Bell Aerospace and Chuck Yeager) Notice the pattern?
- 394549 8y ago> Notice the pattern? No. For ages, people have sought to convert lead to gold though alchemy. Some skeptics said that was impossible or uneconomical. (Enter... no one) Turns out the skeptics are right and no amount of positive attitude and can-do spirit can change that fact. Terraforming Mars is a lot closer to alchemy than powered flight, if the literal matter needed does not already exist on Mars. If we have the technology for space-tugs that can transport an atmosphere's worth of matter to it, I doubt we'd still be interested in the project.
- lainga 8y agoAnd yet again, there isn't a single link to the paper anywhere in the article. A pop-up autoplaying video doesn't replace good journalism. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41550-018-0529-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41550-018-0529-6
- bargl 8y agoThis is a much better article. The current one is just click-bait. I'm glad I read it but I'm even more glad it was with the context of other comments on HN.
- geoalchimista 8y agoThat is because Nature Perspectives are written by real scientists for a wider audience than their niche. Not only are those articles scientifically more accurate, but the writers usually try to engage in a dialogue with the readers, which you don't often see in today's journalism.
- sctb 8y agoThanks! We've updated the link from https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/mars-earth-like-terraforming-atmosphere-carbon-dioxide-space-nasa-red-planet-a8469981.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/mars-earth-like-t....
- fallingfrog 8y agoI love the idea of colonizing Mars, on a purely romantic level. But on a more practical level, let's compare Mars with Antarctica as candidates for large human populations. Mars: no oxygen, atmospheric pressure essentially zero Antarctica: breathable, oxygenated air Mars: maybe a little salty ice below the surface near the poles Antarctica: Covered with freshwater ice Mars: 34 million miles away across empty space Antarctica: a few hundred miles away by boat I mean, Antarctica, or the bottom of the sea, or the peak of Mount Everest all wipe the floor with Mars on every metric you can think of. And I know that various people have suggested that Mars might be a useful second home for humanity in case some event wipes us all out.. but really, if we get wiped out it's going to be self-inflicted, and compared with the difficulty of setting up a viable colony on Mars, the difficulty of sending a few nukes over there is negligible. It just doesn't buy very much insurance. Sorry to be a downer but this is pretty farfetched.
- ryanmercer 8y ago>Mars: maybe a little salty ice below the surface near the poles Erm, there's more than a million cubic kilometers of water ice in the poles that's literally oceans worth, the liquid water below the poles is only of interest for astrobiology. >I mean, Antarctica, or the bottom of the sea, or the peak of Mount Everest all wipe the floor with Mars on every metric you can think of. Except Antarctica is on Earth. The point of colonizing an off-world body is so that we can spread ourselves out. Earth = eggs in one basket. A super volcano like Yellowstone could easily kill 90%+ of our species in the first year after an eruption and most of the other animal (and plant) life. Big rocks have smashed into Earth before and will again. A pandemic could easily spread across the planet in months decimating population and launching us back into the stone age as you just lost most of the people that knew how the power plants work, how medicine worked, how making concrete worked, how growing crops in worthwhile quantities worked. Mars isn't about gaining more resources, it's about giving humanity an extra life.
- GW150914 8y agoThis only works if your planetary colonies can survive without Earth, and even the most hysterically optimistic dreamer doesn’t see that on the horizon. We don’t even know how to make a biosphere work in a bubble on Earth never mind on Mars. A colony is not insurance against disaster if it relies on shipments of bacteria, seeds, and probsbly much more from Earth. Our eggs are in this one basket for generations to come no matter what we do, so let’s try to unfuck this basket.
- dperfect 8y agoEven if there was enough carbon dioxide, is seems likely that solar wind would erode away any terraformed atmosphere as some believe happened in the past[1] due to the lack of shielding from a global magnetic field. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Mars#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Mars#History
- jessriedel 8y agoMany of the terraforming plans include creating a magnetic field, e.g., a fully artificial one situated at L1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terraforming_of_Mars#Magnetic_shield_on_L1_orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terraforming_of_Mars#Magnetic_...
- ryanmercer 8y ago>Even if there was enough carbon dioxide, is seems likely that solar wind would erode away any terraformed atmosphere as some believe happened in the past It will. Over MILLIONS of years. That happened on a geological time scale. People clutch to this claiming 'the solar wind will blow it away' but fail to realize how long this process takes.
- dperfect 8y agoThanks. That's true, though to be fair, the kind of changes needed to terraform Mars also normally happen on geological time scales. That's not to say it can't be done faster, but as others have mentioned, plans to terraform the planet are incomplete if they don't address the issue of solar wind.
- ryanmercer 8y ago>the kind of changes needed to terraform Mars also normally happen on geological time scales. Not when humans are involved. All you need to do is raise the average temperature 5C to create a runaway greenhouse effect on Mars. While that's more than we've done on Earth, what we've done here was entirely on accident. With an actual effort... we could probably do that in a few decades with technology not much more advanced than what we have now. Just doing something like the Russian Znamya project (orbital mirrors), and a little bit of seeding the polar regions with carbon to help absorb sunlight, we could bathe the caps in sunlight 24:37 687 days a year. That combined with creation of 'designer' artificial greenhouse gasses could get you to the runaway process quicker than the natural human lifespan and if you kept generating your own greenhouse gasses/reflecting light to the surface/importing smaller comets (smaller so you're burning the bulk up in the slowly thickening atmosphere instead of impacting and throwing up dust), you could get it there in a few centuries and have the process largely, if not entirely, automated.
- jchin 8y agoTitle reminded me of this board game called Terraforming Mars: https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/167791/terraforming-mars https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/167791/terraforming-mars For me, each play-through has taken hours but after finally playing it correctly (first two times I played I misinterpreted some crucial rules), I enjoyed the game quite a bit.
- adamredwoods 8y agoI'm curious how much scientific research they did for the cards.
- logfromblammo 8y ago... by relying on the greenhouse effect from carbon dioxide. And you wouldn't want to do that, anyway, since it would result in a carbon dioxide concentration too high for an eventually breathable atmosphere. What you really want there is water vapor and perfluorocarbons. But cranking those out takes time. Mars might be warm in 1000 years. Still, shorter than the trip to another star.
- linuxftw 8y agoThe amount of capital required (both human and material) is too large to achieve colonizing Mars, even in a small capacity. It's a pipe dream, never going to happen without some science-fiction physics-bending solution (teleporting, free energy, etc). Let's spend those countless billions on improving conditions here.
- eigenloss 8y ago> The amount of capital required (both human and material) is too large to achieve colonizing Mars, even in a small capacity. Sending people to Mars would cost a few times as much as the construction (inflation adjusted) of the US interstate highway system. [1] There is a reason physicists, economists, and engineers, but usually not Linux container experts, are consulted when evaluating megaproject proposals. > Let's spend those countless billions on improving conditions here. How do you propose we allocate those billions? Who do you delegate to allocate those billions? Is the marginal benefit of that reallocation greater than the marginal cost of killing off all interplanetary colonization efforts? [1] https://spacenews.com/op-ed-mars-for-only-1-5-trillion/ https://spacenews.com/op-ed-mars-for-only-1-5-trillion/
- linuxftw 8y ago> How do you propose we allocate those billions? I propose we don't collect the billions in the first place. > Sending people to Mars would cost a few times as much as the construction (inflation adjusted) of the US interstate highway system. [1] Sending a few people and even establishing some kind of 'base' is not the same as colonizing. That's just the cost of getting 9 crews there and back. If the article is implying Apollo-sized crews, that's not very many people. Heavy machinery, concrete, steel/aluminum, fuel, everything needed to create structures. The costs will be innumerable, and for what benefit? So potentially a select few people get to fly to Mars and live there?
- chris_va 8y agoI was curious about the potential for other compounds. SF6, per molecule is about 22,000x better than CO2: https://whatsyourimpact.org/high-global-warming-potential-gases https://whatsyourimpact.org/high-global-warming-potential-ga... And there is a seemingly nice paper here on the potential for designer gas mixes: http://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/98/5/2154.full.pdf http://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/98/5/2154.full.pdf
- kraig911 8y agoWould it be impractical to just send a bunch of large asteroids to collide with Mars to get the minerals and gases we need?
- ryanmercer 8y agoImpractical? That just depends on what resources you have to tackle the problem with. Identifying candidate comets and asteroids is the first step, then coming up with some sort of propulsion system is the next step. You won't need a lot of thrust at once, you'll just need continuous thrust for weeks, months or even years. Nudge the body into an intercept with Mars and wait. Could easily take decades (if not longer) to start impacting depending on where in the system you are shopping. Good news is, comets and asteroids already come reeeeeallllllly close to the rocky planets so it's just a matter of meeting them far enough out and applying just the right amount of thrust. Bad news is, if your math isn't right... whoops you just put something on a collision course with Earth BUT you'd detect this WAYYYYYY before it would happen and you'd just apply more thrust, unless of course something happened to your propulsion system so you'd absolutely want something out there that could move fast enough to intercept, land, apply thrust. Impacting won't do much though to raise temperature or atmosphere, the atmosphere is thin enough you won't burn up much right now so you'd still need to thicken the atmosphere up some another way.
- kraig911 8y agoActually found an interesting article about this. Sounds like it's just more of an energy expense with a small amount of benefit. https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/16898/what-would-be-the-effect-of-increasing-the-mass-of-mars https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/16898/what-would-b...
- unchocked 8y agoThat link discusses bringing mass to Mars to increase its gravity. This conversation is about bringing gas to Mars to thicken its atmosphere. They’re very different ideas, and the second one is a lot more interesting than the first.
- ohitsdom 8y ago> Plans to do so have included dropping thermonuclear weapons at the planet's poles – an idea supported by Elon Musk. This is misleading at best. Elon hasn't endorsed one way of terraforming Mars. He has said it's a question best left to Mars settlers.
- 24gttghh 8y agoCould anyone comment feasibility on the 'Cowboy Bebop'-style para-terraforming postulated on Mars by creating a small non-domed, livable section inside of a large crater, where the crater walls are high enough to 'contain' enough of the greenhouse gases being produced by the settlements? [0] Would we be better off just building huge domes, or digging underground? [0]https://i1.wp.com/www.inetres.com/gp/anime/bebop/02/bebop_02_04.jpg https://i1.wp.com/www.inetres.com/gp/anime/bebop/02/bebop_02...
- scardine 8y agoNot exactly this one but you could dig moholes. I guess a mohole deep enough to get you 1 atm would be too hot for humans but I will not even try to do the math.
- maerF0x0 8y agoit strikes me that the terraforming goal is often expressed to be habitable to humans... Why not some economic middle ground? For example, if the oxygen was sufficient for me to survive ~1hour, it would add a bunch of safety in case of ripped suit etc. In many areas of life these middle grounds are much easier/faster to accomplish than the "pure" solution. Maybe that concept applies to colonies on mars too?
- anticensor 8y agoBecause that kind of rating is by definition unstable and would shift as you adapt. Minimal concentration for you to breathe for a lifetime is a stable level.
- kanox 8y agoOne decent "middle ground" would be if you could step outside using just an oxygen mask instead of a full spacesuit. Unfortunately the conclusion of this paper is that there isn't nearly enough CO2 to reach the required pressure.
- azernik 8y agoI've actually heard this idea bandied about in talk about the artificial-magnetosphere proposal - just getting things to a point where environmental systems are less expensive and temperatures are easier on hardware.
- baybal2 8y agoLets not be too optimistic. The biggest problem for mars is not pressure, but nitrogen. You can make oxygen from CO2, obviously. But where do you get nitrogen?
- Robotbeat 8y agoThis article is essentially an opinion article. It is paywalled, and the Abstract contains no actual quantitative data on which to judge the contents. It uses "today's technology" as some sort of viability deteriminant, but this is really kind of tautological: we haven't really perfected the art of sending large payloads to Mars, yet. We struggle to do about one ton. So of course current technology is insufficient. They speak of CO2 greenhouse effect not being sufficient to cause sufficient warming... But that's kind of obvious, isn't it? Because if it was sufficient with easily accessible reservoirs, that'd imply Mars is in some sort of unequilibrium state that could randomly trigger into a partial runaway greenhouse effect (to terraform the planet, not make it like Venus) without even our intervention. And another thing, warmth is fairly easy to address. What's critical is pressure. I'm much less interested in the amount of CO2 to heat the whole planet by itself than I am in the amount of CO2 needed to exceed the Armstrong Limit (0.9psi, the minimum pressure you can survive without a pressure suit and only a forced air oxygen mask) at the lowest points on Mars (like Hellas Basin). That's not addressed in the abstract at all, and I'm not about to pay for an article that doesn't even bother to answer such a basic question in the abstract as what mass of CO2 exists in these reservoirs (from which one can easily determine the pressure... Mars needs about 6e16kg of additional volatiles added to its atmosphere to reach the Armstrong Limit in Hellas Basin... Mars' atmosphere is currently 2.5e16kg). Every terraforming proposal I've seen does something like this: 1) Increase albedo of surface via dust on the poles or black powder. 2) Increase greenhouse effect by industrial production of super greenhouse gases that are far more effective (>20,000?) than CO2. 3) Increase insolation of Mars via giant orbital mirrors (more realistic than you might think, as you can use micron-thick solar sail type material). 4) Adding more volatiles from exterior sources like comets or asteroids or moons. 5) Vaporize very deep reservoirs of volatiles using fission or fusion or geothermal or sunlight or impact energy, reservoirs not considered here. Many of these require "new" technology, but the principles behind each one are pretty well understood. ...it's simply impossible to have a serious discussion of this paper as it's paywalled and contains no quantitative information in the public abstract. Instead, it serves as just a conversation piece for what people already think about Mars terraforming.
- cabaalis 8y agoReading through this led me to also Google the unrelated issue of estimates of how long fossil fuels will last at current pace. I'd never thought about that before, and I am actually now concerned about my child's future. (Which of course I worry about other things, but is a first for that aspect.) Without a major shift in energy source, soon, we will never be able to leave our planet. Humanity will end here.
- windows_tips 8y agoA long time. With uranium, ground-fuels will last even longer. Sun's supposed to explode and consume the planet soon though.
- lxmorj 8y agoStep 1: Go to Ceres Step 2: Build Very Large Railgun™ Step 3: Make Ice Block Harvesting Robots Step 4: Fire railgun for approximately a crapload of years, changing Ceres' orbit to collide with Mars. If you get the math Really Quite Spot On, you may be able to slow Ceres while putting the ice projectiles on a highly elliptical orbit that will also hit Mars. Get the final collision right as well, and you could spin up Mars a bit (closer to 24hr days, though I think I'd like 28 better TBH), or slow it's orbit down a bit. It'd probably take a couple centuries, and the cool down period might take the same, but when you're done you've got loads of water, a touch more mass, and a great little bootstrapped planet.
- dvasdekis 8y agoWhy would you need to build a railgun? Nuking Ceres a bunch of times at the correct angle should achieve the same thing. But - there's a non-zero chance that this collision, whether by railgun or nuke, endangers life on earth. Problematic, but I love the idea otherwise.
- senectus1 8y agopfft, Why bother. I reckon the first serious population on mars will be miners and industrialists. They'll mine the crap out of it, setup horribly polluting industry and makes shit to sell elsewhere.
- natch 8y agoJudging by the abstract, they set aside and don't even consider the question of whether we could change humans to meet Mars halfway.
- rebelde 8y agoA heartfelt discussion about terraforming Mars. This is HN at its most entertaining. I'm serious. Thank you!
- solresident 8y agoidk why you can't just grind up a shit-ton of plastic and create sand-plastic electrostatic differential on the surface to produce more green house gases, ch4
- a008t 8y agoWould it not be easier to build and maintain a space station in a stable Lagrangian point? Gerard O'Neill described a roadmap to one in 1976 in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_High_Frontier:_Human_Colonies_in_Space https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_High_Frontier:_Human_Colon... The ideas were brought to life in Hideo Kojima's Policenauts, which is an interesting, rather detailed illustration of how the whole thing might work out. Somehow, I find the idea of a space station like that more exciting than the idea of colonizing Mars.