8 ms·
As an outsider, I really don’t understand how the US economy continues to function. With almost nonexistent social safety nets, jobs you can be fired from if yo
by Sharlin 8y ago
As an outsider, I really don’t understand how the US economy continues to function. With almost nonexistent social safety nets, jobs you can be fired from if you don’t come to work while ill, lack of paid maternity leave combined with really expensive daycare, and healthcare you can only afford if you’re healthy anyway, the only way for an average person to be able to prepare for contingencies is to have a lot of savings. But at the same time an average person cannot afford to save any money! Boggles the mind.
- munki 8y agoThat's how powerful the ideology of 'the American dream' truly is.
- BartBoch 8y agoThis IS the reasons a US economy is so strong. You got it all wrong. Extreme consumerism, inability to be unemployed (unemployment can end up in being homeless, so the transition period between jobs is almost non-existent, so the economy won't feel it, and the government don't need to pay benefits long term), enforcing businesses and insurance companies to cover the healthcare (inflating costs, creating jobs for middleman to shift the responsibility, building fear in people that if their wealth decreases they will be uninsured), not many social programs (so more money can be spent on public projects). All of those things are fuel to the economy, not dead weight.
- walshemj 8y agoHow is having a lot of non productive middle man jobs in the health industry "good" ditto having 52 sets of employment laws if you had one you would not need so many HR overhead roles.
- BartBoch 8y agoWell, you can have 3 employees when 1 if needed, and then 2 unemployed people looking for social benefits, or 3 employed people that add some value. I think it is obvious which one is adding to the economy more. Not saying it is good, but this is one of the tools governments have to reduce the cost of social state and increase the production.
- jpatokal 8y agoThe tail end of your argument is the broken window fallacy. On every conceivable metric the vast amount of bureaucracy and paper-pushing required by the uniquely dysfunctional US healthcare system fails to deliver any benefit proportionate to its gargantuan costs. Put another way, if healthcare costs and the amount of insurance paperwork doubled yet again overnight, would that be "fuel to the economy" or "dead weight"?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- andy_ppp 8y agoThis is the strange think about market fundamentalism, market efficiency doesn’t really exist but it seems end stage capitalism isn’t about efficiency so much as people who believe they deserve it.
- BartBoch 8y agoThe question will be then if the increased amount of uninsured people will affect the economy badly (by the inability to access professional health services) and if this will result in creating a new market for more efficient, low-cost health providers. This will be controlled by the government as always by relaxing the laws. Once again - this is from a non-emotional point of view. I am not saying this is good. The way the US works and the way they push towards more "dead weight employee" rather than "social beneficient" works for now well enough to keep it as it is apparently. Otherwise, there will be a much stronger push for change.
- lewis1028282 8y agoYeah and the US has some of the worst social issues in the world. Proof by counter example, then. The Scandinavian countries have the exact opposite mindset to the US yet they are some of the richest and happiest countries. But that could be the oil money talking.
- kebman 8y agoOnly Norway has any real quantity of oil. Sweden has none. Denmark only has a little. Finland – albeit not technically in Scandinavia, but related since it's part of the Nordic Countries – also don't have oil. And while we're at it, also Iceland don't have oil. That should give you a better idea of how well these countries are being run. Also consider that the dream country of Reich – Venezuela – has tons of oil... While we're at it, neither Denmark nor Norway are "Democratic Socialist" states. Heck, not even Sweden, though they are marred with a Left-Wing government. They are instead Market-liberal Capitalist Welfare States. While the policies of these countries are "social" they're not Social-ist. Please make a clear distinction between the two, because Socialism – the thing Robert Reich stands for – is anything but what we have here in Norway. But like in most countries, you'll find commies also here. That doesn't mean either Communism or Socialism are viable political ideologies. Quite the contrary!
- mrob 8y ago>Iceland don't have oil But it does have abundant geothermal and hydropower. Aluminum smelting is a big part of Iceland's economy, and it wouldn't be possible without the cheap electricity those natural resources supply.
- mads_ravn 8y agoIn this context I think the Norwegian Oil Fund deserves a honorable mention (https://www.nbim.no https://www.nbim.no). It really is a testament to a well-run government that they are saving significant amounts to future generations - and I say this as a somewhat envious dane :)
- e12e 8y ago
- knuththetruth 8y agoStrong for whom? The tiny sliver of oligarchs who are vacuuming up all of the wealth? This seems like a pretty shitty outcome for everyone else.
- BartBoch 8y agoMy comment was not about if it is good, or bad for people, but for the economy (to a certain point). Again, I am not saying it is a good solution, but for now, it worked and works well enough.
- emodendroket 8y agoI don't think that's right. I think the US enjoys a lot of benefits that would make it an economic powerhouse even if it went to a Nordic model -- most importantly probably its hegemonic status
- e12e 8y agoMost importantly it's abundant resources!
- emodendroket 8y agoThat's a big one too, but having tremendous political influence, the reserve currency, etc. are major advantages.
- alkonaut 8y agoYou are probably mostly right. Yet I think there are probably also a huge untapped potential. If everyone doesn’t have access to higher education, you run into underuse if the talent pool through aristocracy in place of meritocracy. If families don’t have long paid parental leaves and subsidized daycare, you both get low birth rates and lower workforce participation. The overheads in the healthcare system are well known.
- BartBoch 8y agoAbsolutely. My comment was without the emotion - it is good enough to work for now, but there are so many better options that would have a better outcome in future.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoDebt.
- chvid 8y agoYes. You are correct to point out that having no cash savings is not a problem if you are creditworthy; that is you can put yourself in debt in time of need. In addition more than 20% of US households are home-owners and often have access to an inexpensive line of credit.
- matttproud 8y agoIt boggles the minds of many Americans, but a vast majority of the country doesn't know any better thanks to relative deprivation and lack of meaningful exposure to other ways of life (in other countries). That or they just "chalk it up to grit". After living abroad as American, I can't imagine returning. I've seen too many friends older, in my same cohort, and younger suffer in unimaginable ways — many through no fault of their own.
- ian1321 8y agoI've lived in Zurich for two years now. It would be very difficult to explain to an American who only lives in America how nice real public transit is. Or a good education system. Or the ability to let your kids walk 500m to a park on their own. Another thing I've noticed is that most Europeans see American as a "high tax" country, and they wonder what we get for those taxes. I can say that I pay less taxes to Switzerland than I pay to the US. I would bet the impression from America is that the Swiss pay more in taxes, but that does not seem to be the case.
- maxerickson 8y agoThe vast majority of the country has decent access to healthcare. Professional jobs, union jobs, they roll okay insurance into compensation and pay enough that people can manage their side of any bills, even if it is a few thousand dollars. And then ~¼ of the country gets insurance from Medicaid, with about ⅕ of the country getting insurance from Medicare. That doesn't make it a good system, but you've got the wrong idea about the number of people that can't afford healthcare at all.
- emodendroket 8y agoMost people who go bankrupt from medical bills have insurance, or at least did when they started. More and more insurance plans have substantial coinsurance, which is a way of passing off a lot of risk to the patient, and don't forget the baroque system of networks and excluded services.
- maxerickson 8y agoYes, the ~1 million personal bankruptcies that occur in the US are nothing to be proud of. But they don't really undermine an argument that plenty of people have decent access to healthcare.
- emodendroket 8y agoI don't see how the argument isn't undermined by a substantial number of people who are insured going into bankruptcy from medical bills. Many plans are also poor enough that the people using them forego necessary care
- maxerickson 8y agoWell, what's substantial? I'm sort of prepared to dismiss 0.2%. And before anyone gets too moralistic about how evil I am, I've contributed $0 so far this year towards my deductible that is thousands of dollars.
- anoncoward111 8y agoYou've pretty accurately described the situation here in the USA. I will describe some workarounds that most of us have had some exposure to. Some are better than others: 1) re housing: if you don't have much savings at all, you live with your parents (or you go on the streets, which is a very sad and tough reality for millions of Americans). if you have some savings but not much, usually you search for roommates or tenants if you have a house but still live paycheck to paycheck. 2) if you lose your job, in most states you can qualify for unemployment, which usually means 1-2k per month in post tax income for 6 months. unemployment has saved my ass twice already and im not even 30. it's very common to lose a job here, but it's also sort of easy to interview and get a job here compared to France. 3) regarding health insurance, if you don't have a job, you get it from your parents or spouse. if those don't work for you, you have to wait a long time until you eventually qualify for medicaid and food stamps (1-2 years if your income was too high this year). my gf didnt have any insurance for the first 20 years of her life, i havent had it in the last 6 years. so, it's definitely not optimal, but also not a death sentence. with roommates, i'm living on less than $1,000 a month right now and I feel extremely comfortable. I have gone as low as $500 a month but right now I live in NYC where the cheapest room possible is about $600
- pmoriarty 8y ago"if you don't have much savings at all, you live with your parents" This assumes your parents are alive, can afford their own place, have space for you, and you have a good enough relationship with them for them to let you stay without paying (much) for rent. "if you don't have a job, you get it from your parents or spouse" These assume that your parents or spouse have health insurance and that insurance will cover dependents. "if those don't work for you, you have to wait a long time until you eventually qualify for medicaid and food stamps (1-2 years if your income was too high this year)" In California, I was told that I'd qualify for Medi-Cal (California's Medicaid program) as soon as I had no job (ie. no income, or very low income -- you can get information on exact income limits from them).
- anoncoward111 8y ago>parents yes, it does assume all those things. I was kicked out at 18. I saved enough money such that I'll always have enough for a deposit on an apartment. I am very good at hawking rooms to roommates. Beyond 18, I wasn't afforded the privilege of living at home for cheap. >health insurance Yes, once again it assumes those things. I literally said that in the next sentence. I don't have health care. If I make below $20,000 next year, I get medicaid in 2020. >Medi-Cal each state is different. some go by tax return and not current income.
- dcgudeman 8y agoWell it’s pretty healthy (relative to most other western economies using traditional metrics like unemployment, inflation and gdp growth) so if you are interested in having an accurate mental model of how economies work you might want to do more research
- lotsofpulp 8y agoEconomies don’t care about quality of life. The US has natural resources, a stable government with not too many people trying to steal for themselves, a powerful military, and as a result, a desirable currency. The paycheck to paycheck life just means all of these amazing resources are being allocated in such a way that 20% are gaining a bigger share of the pie than 80%. The US has a good system of transacting with one another (sufficient security, trust, and credit check systems), but that doesn’t mean people are happier or that it will continue into the future. It very well may be a short lived local maxima.
- pmoriarty 8y ago"The paycheck to paycheck life just means all of these amazing resources are being allocated in such a way that 20% are gaining a bigger share of the pie than 80%." And that a tiny minority are basically ruling over the overwhelming majority, making the laws, and telling the rest of us what to do as we fight with each other over the crumbs that the rich let fall from their table. Many of us will never be able to afford to retire, while the ultra-rich will never have to work a day in their life, and neither will their children, or their children's children. We will be polishing these people's shoes for generations to come.
- gbacon 8y agoThis idea of the idle wealthy is a stereotype that harbors envy despite the fact that it does not match reality. In The Millionaire Next Door by Dr. Thomas J. Stanley, the author found that 80% of American millionaires had parents who were not millionaires and inherited no more than ten thousand dollars.
- sureaboutthis 8y agoAll of those false assumptions you made are gleaned from social media headlines and not reality. Family and friends still help you out. Jobs won't fire you because you're sick. Women can take leave for maternity (though they might not be paid). Daycare is not as expensive as you may think. Healthcare is provided by your employer. Now, not all those things are true for everyone but it's true for a lot of us. Quit using the internet as your only source of education.
- emodendroket 8y agoWell sure, if your social milieu is the top fifth, as I would presume it is for most of us here, then these problems do not touch you.
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoWomen definitely cannot always take leave for maternity. They can if they work for a place that falls under FMLA rules, but not if they don't. Not being paid is generally equal to not being able to take leave if you are low-income. Healthcare is not always provided by the employer, and the cost may be more than your paycheck if you want a family plan. Literally - I've worked such a job. The weekly cost was more than I brought home working 40 hours a week for a family plan: The individual cost was a very good chunk of the paycheck. This was not a high-paying job. Not only that, but it may be the bare minimum of insurance, rendering it basically major medical only. Lots of places won't do a surgery or screening without your copayment upfront, and this is a real issue. Jobs don't fire you becasue you are sick: They fire you for not having good enough attendance. This includes nearly everything, including you or your children being sick. These aren't abnormal in any sense.
- sureaboutthis 8y ago> Women definitely cannot always take leave for maternity. Then they give birth on the job? >Healthcare is not always provided by the employer I never said it was.
- Sharlin 8y agoI wonder if my Internet-mediated viewpoint actually gives me access to a greater diversity of voices than what an average fairly privileged HN commenter is exposed to in their social bubble. Certainly not an unreasonable hypothesis a priori. Not to mention the fact that the least privileged are as underrepresented on the Internet as everywhere else.
- cup-of-tea 8y agoHomo sapiens has continued to exist without government for far longer than it has existed with government. But existence isn't really the point. Quality of life is what matters. But this is very hard to measure. I imagine quality of life is good in the US. But they continue to build up an enormous debt to maintain it.
- saagarjha 8y agoI don't quite get where you're trying to direct this conversation. You're saying that an American's quality of life is high, but this seems to contradict what the parent comment mentions. You don't seem like you are disagreeing with that comment, though.
- mping 8y agoYet the US economy is huge. I don't understand either.
- cdoxsey 8y agoWhy do you think the social safety net is non-existent? The US has tons of social welfare programs: - TANF (temporary assistance for needy families) - Medicaid - SNAP (food stamps) - CHIP (child health insurance program) - unemployment - disability - housing assistance - social security - ... States and cities also have many welfare programs along with private charities. It is absolutely possible to save money on an average salary. In general, Americans are indebted and live beyond their means by choice, not by necessity. And once they get into the debt cycle it can be extremely difficult to get out. Check out Dave Ramsey for practical tips: https://www.daveramsey.com/store/product/the-total-money-makeover-book-by-dave-ramsey https://www.daveramsey.com/store/product/the-total-money-mak...
- jahaja 8y agoFrom my Scandinavian perspective US welfare has always seemed like a plausible deniability scheme rather than a genuine attempt.
- cdoxsey 8y agoIt's not for lack of trying. The US spends an enormous amount of money on social programs. See here for an example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_social_welfare_spending https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_social_we... It's less than Denmark/Norway/Sweden, but more than the UK for example (per capita).
- nojvek 8y agoYes but the welfare spending doesn't go as further as it does in in Australia, NZ, Denmark, Norway, Sweden e.t.c Mostly because US spends a ridiculous amount of money just moving records and doing busy work with layers and layers of middlemen. The healthcare complex is a good example.
- tptacek 8y agoThe US "safety-net" health system --- medicare in particular --- is significantly more efficient than the private market health care system in the US, which makes that example poor evidence for the argument you're trying to support.
- anonfunction 8y agoAll those factors are good incentives to stay employed. This keeps the economy moving forward. Credit is what keeps most people afloat during economic hardship which then provides even greater incentive to work more hours.
- harryh 8y agoYour lack of understanding probably comes from the fact that you're misinformed about the facts on the ground. - While not as robust as some Western European countries, the social safety net in the US is pretty strong. - The majority of US workers get paid sick days and even for those that don't you will almost never get fired for taking off when sick. - Maybe about half of US workers get paid maternity leave. - Only around 10% of Americans do not have health insurance and many of those people are young people unlikely to get sick. To be clear, I'm not trying to say that everything is perfect and that there is no room for improvement, but the US isn't the dystopia that you make it out to be. It also helps that incomes in the US are among the highest in the world due to the very robust economy.
- alkonaut 8y ago> Maybe about half of US workers get paid maternity leave. I think there is some confusion of terminology here: a European probably means paid leave for the first 12-18 months of the baby’s life, until it’s old enough to go to daycare so the parents can return to work. One or a few months leave doesn’t really help much if you still either have to quit or take a long unpaid leave until the kid can be in daycare during the day
- harryh 8y agoDaycare in the US routinely starts at 3 months. You don't have to take a long unpaid leave before daycare starts.
- alkonaut 8y agoWow. Did not know that. Here you aren’t recommended to leave kids until 12months, and the norm is 18. I suppose that will also happen in the US - that is, if you can afford it you stay home until 12-18 months (or longer). This of course leads to kids to more well off people getting more time with their parents than poorer kids. That would be an almost impossible situation to support politically here, so the solution is to ensure even the poorest kids get the minimum 12 month full time parenting, through tax funded parental leave
- benevol 8y agoI am 100% convinced that the US is in for a very rude awakening. It's been some time now that things are falling apart on multiple levels, not just regarding economic questions. A few years back, it was my dream to live in the US (I had won a green card thanks to the Diversity Visa program, but ended up letting it expire), but today, I'm glad I stayed put. And I don't think the US will recover in my lifetime to the point that I will see it as an attractive country again.
- gbacon 8y agoBut at the same time an average person cannot afford to save any money! This assumption is stated and accepted around here uncritically but with zero supporting evidence. Four out of five Americans are not desperately hand-to-mouth poor as this figure suggests. Accepting the extraordinary 80% claim for the sake of argument, some of them must be in stable, full-time job situations — and some those have to be in two-income households — by law of large numbers. Having identified a segment of the 80% with at least decent incomes, that shatters a premise of the Reich piece. They can afford to save money but do not because consumption is too high relative to income. The balance goes on credit cards, home equity lines of credit, or other debt instruments. Of those who are living paycheck-to-paycheck with no emergency fund for contingencies, how many have written goals? How many are executing an intentional plan where they make and follow a budget each month? Those are important questions that go unasked.
- danaris 8y agoYou seem to be operating on some unstated assumptions: one, that basic money management skills are just something that everyone should be expected to have, and two, that two stable full-time jobs make enough money for anyone to live comfortably on with those basic money management skills. First of all, I think it's worth noting that basic money management skills are no longer part of any curriculum with broad acceptance in America. They used to be taught in home economics classes, but those have been pared down to the bone in some places, outright eliminated in others. So expecting Americans to have basic money management skills at this point is, while not exactly unrealistic, at least not something that should be considered the obvious default. Secondly, there are plenty of places where a two-income household, with both earners making significantly above minimum wage, will still be just squeaking by, particularly in places with very high housing costs. That's not even taking into account other all-too-common situations, like large medical debts, or burdensome student loans. "But they should just move!" you cry. "They should have known better than to go to college!" you cry. (...I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt that you wouldn't say they should know better than to get cancer or some similar costly illness, but Poe's Law applies here.) Moving, when you cannot easily save up money, is, at best, highly impractical. It costs mental energy that you probably lack if you are stressed from worrying about your poor financial situation, in addition to the time costs of finding someplace to move to that fits your needs better than where you are now, and the obvious financial costs of hiring movers and potentially putting a down payment on a house, depending on whether you're trying to buy or rent. College has been sold to every generation in America for some time now as not merely the way to better your situation, but to many as the only way to get a stable job—or even to be a worthwhile person, depending on your (parents') social circles. Just within the past decade or two has the country started to turn around and say, "But we're going to make you pay through the nose for it. For the rest of your life. So if you aren't already wealthy, you better not go for a degree that can't get you six figures within 5 years of graduation!" So...yeah, assumptions. They're a bitch, and they lead to an awful lot of the kind of moralistic labor-theory-of-value crap that keeps us in this terrible situation, instead of working together to find a way to make it better.
- kamaal 8y ago>>the only way for an average person to be able to prepare for contingencies is to have a lot of savings. >>Boggles the mind. Why would it be Mind boggling? State funded social security schemes do not exist to make up for bad personal finance decisions. They are for circumstance when someone fails despite their best efforts. If they are used for the former, no amount of social cover will be enough, ever.