12 ms·
No Shirt, No Swipe, No Service
- gringoDan 8y agoI use a credit card for 95%+ of my transactions. At the same time, I'm scared of a cashless future. As the article mentions, cash transactions are one of the last vestiges of privacy that we have. A future where the US looks like China, where all of your transactions are visible, is not something I want to see. Additionally, cash is an equalizer for the unbanked/underbanked. Financial institutions take advantage of and punish their least profitable customers. Those who can barely afford overdraft fees, monthly checking account fees, etc. are the only ones who are forced to pay them. Yes, blockchain technologies can solve some of these problems, but there will always be those who are outside of the banking system, lose/don't have a smartphone, etc. Greenbacks are tangible to the person standing in line to cash a paycheck at Western Union - Ethereum isn't.
- lithos 8y agoYou're afraid of the loss of privacy, then immediately suggest block chain as a solution to a related problem.
- krageon 8y agoIt's ridiculous on the face of it (especially as they suggest Ethereum), but there are in fact blockchains that preserve the anonymity of the people involved in the transaction. I'm a little sad these distinctions aren't more well-known.
- phobosdeimos 8y agoIn my country banks can't refuse clients for a standard checking account. Besides how in gods name can someone even function in an advanced economy without a bank account? People have been paying with plastic since the late 80s. Its free, safe and its easier for the tax man to collect. I used to work night shifts in retail. You don't want to deal with cash.
- kwhitefoot 8y ago> People have been paying with plastic since the late 80s I've had my Barclaycard since 1972, when I was 16.
- 394549 8y agoRelevant: MasterCard mines data for marketers (https://www.ft.com/content/089f7cd0-16f2-11e2-b1df-00144feabdc0 https://www.ft.com/content/089f7cd0-16f2-11e2-b1df-00144feab...) > MasterCard is analysing transaction data to help marketers direct targeted advertising at consumers, after launching a controversial initiative to make money from its vast database of retail purchases. Using cash is currently the only way to opt out of this kind of tracking. Being credit card-only is also being anti-consumer-privacy.
- jonahhorowitz 8y agoOne thing that Neuromancer had, but we never got, was credsticks. I want a fee-free electronic wallet that is anonymous. Also, we really need a law saying that the credit card companies (and others in the toolchain) can't use our data for anything but payment processing. I'm sick of being tracked by my transactions.
- rebuilder 8y agoWell, it's easy to write "credsticks" into a novel, but rather hard to actually implement them. How would they work? The closest thing we have are probably physical Bitcoins, but there you need to trust the issuer not to have a copy of the private keys.
- SurrealSoul 8y agoWe combined our credsticks into our mobile devices
- ams6110 8y agoOf course you can rationalize that 3% is a reasonable cost and approximately a wash compared to the expense of dealing with cash. But if you're a small coffe house, and sell a $3.00 coffee, and are paying a typical 2.9% + $0.30 per charge, that $0.30 is ten percent of your sale. That's a huge cost. Transaction fees need to come way down for plastic to beat cash on small sales.
- rahimnathwani 8y agoOr you could just pay 2.75% to Square: https://squareup.com/pricing https://squareup.com/pricing They do have plans which include a fixed per-transaction fee on top of a (lower) percentage, but for a coffee shop I'd guess it's worth paying the higher percentage instead.
- gringoDan 8y agoAn even more extreme example would be a grocery store, whose overall profit margins are only 1-3%.
- reaperducer 8y agoWhich is why it's so surprising that it took so long for Albertsons to get on the Apple Pay bandwagon, which costs less per transaction than traditional swipes or chip+PIN.
- kevin_b_er 8y agoDo you have some details on the relative transaction fees of direct credit card usage vs indirect via apple pay?
- ac29 8y agoWhere'd you get that data? I looked up Albertson's and see they have a 43% gross margin and a 23% net margin: https://www.reuters.com/finance/stocks/financial-highlights/ABSP.WA https://www.reuters.com/finance/stocks/financial-highlights/...
- rahimnathwani 8y agoWhere I live (Beijing, China) is far ahead: - Most (or maybe all) beggars accept mobile payment by WeChat and/or AliPay - I cannot recall any time in the past year where a shop, fruit stall or street vendor could not accept mobile payment - There is a high-end food court nearby where none of the restaurants accept cash. If you can't pay by card/mobile, you need to go to a special counter on the ground floor, and exchange cash for some type of voucher - My haircuts cost 40 RMB (about 6 USD). I tried to pay with a 100 RMB note, expecting a 50 and a 10 in change, of which I would give the 10 back as a tip. The barber struggled to find the right change, as it's so uncommon for people to pay with cash. So I paid via WeChat, and handed him some extra cash for a tip.
- ams6110 8y agoMy barber takes cash only. It's caught me out a few times. He has a mobile phone, not sure why he's not set up with Square or something similar I'd think he'd make up for the costs with more business.
- nickthegreek 8y agoprobably isn't claiming the cash on his taxes. He cant make up that difference no matter how many cards he swipes.
- chickenfries 8y agoMy barber has a location next to several ATMs. I cannot see imagine a situation where he would start accepting cards. I never see anyone come in for a haircut, ask if they take cards, and then walk out and not come back because they don’t.
- reaperducer 8y agoahead For varying definitions of "ahead" in this context. Being monitored, followed, tracked, tabulated, bought and sold doesn't sound like "ahead."
- rahimnathwani 8y ago
- ddingus 8y agoNo cash, no sale. Privacy is a big deal to me. Plus downtime. Cash always works. Handling it is sometimes a PITA, but I must say we have a long way to go before electronic systems work well universally. Ordinary people are confused by them, and there are many janky, ultra cheapo type readers out there. For me personally, I leave my mobile unconnected to any payment system. I don't need or want that. I will and do use cards, but it is not very often.
- msla 8y ago> Cash always works. The falsity of this statement is the entire point of the article. I agree with you otherwise, I think, but this sentence is, now, in this time, unambiguously false.
- ddingus 8y agoNo it's not. Cash does not have downtime, and it can be used by anyone. Now, someone making a business choice to refuse legal tender does not speak to the robustness of said tender, only their choices. As long as things are good, payment systems running, networks up, that choice can be compelling. When those things are not true, the fall back is what? Not do business? Queue transactions and exchange the info needed? Refer customer elsewhere? People making cash not work is different from cash not always working. I agree with you as well, in that "always" needs qualification. Fair enough. Either way, I will very seriously reconsider most purchases where cash is not an option. It is likely I don't need whatever it is.
- msla 8y ago> Cash does not have downtime, and it can be used by anyone. But not at the store the article is talking about. Which is the point of the article.
- ddingus 8y agoYes, I could care less. I don't need what they're offering. Won't do business there. And now that I know, I'm going to Advocate others don't either.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoHaving seen the FB+Google interpretation of privacy, and the few times Venmo with their public feed have cropped up here, I'll be one of the last to abandon cash. I use it for most things that aren't online. That's despite my whole career being in tech and once thinking such views were the preserve of the tinfoil hat wearers. Most of the upsides are for the companies, the potential downsides are for the consumers. I don't much like that balance for a tiny bit more convenience.
- Taniwha 8y agoI travel to the US regularly, trying to use a foreign credit card there (especially to buy gas - what is my zip code?) is a real pain - unlike the rest of the western world the US is far from being able to go cashless
- dugditches 8y ago90210 Canadians can use the first 3 of their postal code.
- tonyarkles 8y agoExcept our postal codes are A#A #A#. I've definitely had trouble buying gas at American pumps before, and the staff couldn't figure out a solution.
- wvenable 8y agoFrom your postal code "A#A#A#", it becomes "###00" at the pump. Near the border, most pumps will have this as a sign on them. But I was recently in Florida and that worked fine for paying at the pump.
- tonyarkles 8y agoOh! Very cool! I'll keep that in mind next time I'm down south! It was in Florida where I ran into the problem... Definitely no sign where I was :)
- reaperducer 8y agounlike the rest of the western world the US is far from being able to go cashless That's a good thing. As people are learning in other countries like Sweden.
- mcbuilder 8y agoIt was a little strange, I was in Stockholm for two weeks and would have not have seen a single paper bill except for the glance I caught of one as a older man got in an argument with a bar owner, who "made it right" by quickly handing him back some cash.
- mmagin 8y agoI'm not sure if I'm more worried about the privacy implications, or that of a future where a Visa/MC duopoly collects a tax on all retail.
- orangechairs 8y agoTo echo what others have said, cashless systems -- especially in fast food chains -- are a quick way to discriminate against a whole population of the underbanked. I was in Dos Toros (burrito chain mentioned early in the article) about a month ago, and the woman in line ahead of me didn't have a card. She got so embarrassed at the register despite having ample cash to pay for her meal. I paid for her with my card, she paid me in cash, and all was fine, but no one walked away from that experience feeling good about it. It was such a unnecessary emotional stress on the woman. I feel weird returning to Dos Toros knowing this policy is creating these experiences for customers.
- hartator 8y agoCan't you buy a prepaid debit card at a Walmart? I think it's probably fine to let the business decide whatever means of payment they want to accept.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoWhy should you have to? Once upon a time the customer was always right. A business was supposed to serve the customer's needs and did what was necessary to achieve that. Now the business can insert multiple middlemen with commissions and transaction fees and the damn customers can just fall into line. Sharpish please, and no complaints or we'll close your account. Do we not see a problem travelling down this road? Or do we have to return to barter and hacksilver to decide perhaps cash was useful?
- dionidium 8y ago>Why should you have to? This is going to sound glib, but I assure you that it's offered genuinely: you don't have to do anything.
- electroSurveil 8y agoIncluding eat or breathe.
- classichasclass 8y agoI just prefer cash because it's easier to keep me to a weekly budget. And, because it's weekly, I'm not walking around with a terribly big wad (I'm not crazy). The privacy benefits of cash are a bonus as far as I'm concerned.
- cannonedhamster 8y agoHere's a weird question. Why hasn't the U.S. Government made an electronic cash platform with zero transaction fees yet? This should be something that falls under the treasury, it would help cut down on fraud and provide a backbone for small businesses and large businesses alike. Being able to pay debts is basic infrastructure for an economy and transaction fees are a giant tax on small businesses and large businesses alike.
- mortenjorck 8y agoThis is a great idea and is long overdue. However, lobbyists from Visa and MasterCard would saddle the program with all sorts of concessions to incumbent payment processors that would make the program cumbersome to use, stifle adoption, and ultimately reinforce their dominant positions.
- jonahhorowitz 8y agoThere is at least a kernel of this idea in a national postal bank.[0] [0] http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/history/2014/08/postal_banking_already_worked_in_the_usa_and_it_will_work_again.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/history/2014...
- Kipters 8y agoIn Italy the national post service (which also doubles as a bank) offers dirt cheap Visa Electron debit cards called Postepay (no recurring fee, 5€ una tantum for the card, 1€ fee everytime you deposit money into the card), and the minimum age for requesting one is 14. This fostered some competition from other banks which started to offer products with similar prices and even more features (like the ability to send or receive wire transfers). The national student card (which can be used to obtain discounts at museums and other cultural places) now also doubles up as a Postepay, so now basically every kid owns a free debit card that can use physically or online as he wants. Something like this can really speed up card's adoption while avoiding discrimination and in fact this is what I've seen since I was a kid and I had to borrow my dad's card: now all my little cousins own their own little yellow debit card in their name and even use it often in their daily life.
- amluto 8y agoI think the federal government should start using FDIC as a stick here. It could be fairly straightforward: if you want to be an FDIC member, you must offer basic banking. In particular, you must offer anyone who is legally in the US a free checking account. The terms must be more or less standardized. No arbitration clause, no limit on class-action lawsuits, no check deposit fees, no in-network ATM fees, no under-minimum fees, no overdraft fees. If a bank wants to participate, it should be required to offer banking.
- bena 8y agoEh. They do offer banking. But banks make their money investing your money. Also, I think "no overdraft fees" is just as wrong as overly punitive overdraft fees. If there were no overdraft fees, credit cards and small loans just wouldn't be a thing. Just overdraft your account and treat it as an interest free loan. When you overdraft, you are no longer dealing with your money. You're dealing with someone else's money.
- valleyer 8y agoBanks could easily simply reject overdrafts instead of allowing them while charging fees.
- bena 8y agoNot if I write a check. And from what I recall, when you make a purchase, they don't check against your projected balance at that time, but your actual balance. So if I have $100 in my account and a pending debit of $50, if I try to make a purchase of $60, it'll get approved because I have $100 in my account. Now, there are potential things it could do, like treat pending debits like cleared debits. I mean, when I check my balance on my app, it shows the balance with the pending transactions accounted for. And that does prevent overdrafts from ATMs and debit cards, but there are other debits to the account that could cause overdraft. It's practically a no-win scenario. If I have an automatic payment to my electric company and I don't have the funds in my account to pay it, I'm fucked no matter which way you look at it. Either I overdraft or my electricity gets shut off due to non-payment.
- United857 8y agoThis article burys the lede -- from the last paragraph: Take the overdraft fee, a punishment for desperate or careless customers that netted banks $15 billion in 2016. As many as half of overdraft fees aren’t assessed at an ATM, where customers can see their balance, but at the point of sale—debit card transactions at the counters of shops and restaurants. And the majority of overdraft fees, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau reported in 2014, came on transactions of $24 or under. Not people stretching to make a big purchase, in other words. Just trying to get lunch. Those fees are a big source of revenue for the banks. Nothing about convenience for the customer.
- bena 8y agoDo they still do the thing where they structure debits to maximize penalties? Say you have $100 in your account and 5 pending transactions: $6, $12, $1, $30, and $95. In that chronological order. The bank clears the $95 first, then the $6 which overdrafts you, then the rest, overdrafting you 3 more times. Whereas if they processed chronologically, you'd only overdraft the $95. Regardless, the person whose account it is does bear some responsibility for overdrafting, even for lunch.
- exegete 8y agoMy bank actually orders transactions to make it so that I avoid the overdraft fees. If I get paid one day and also make a debit that would overdraft my account if the payment didn't clear first, they will place the payment first then the debit.
- bena 8y agoThat's good of them. I mean, that's just good customer service and they'll probably keep you as a customer for far longer by not nickel and diming you at every chance.
- scarface74 8y agoAt least with my bank, if you don’t have the available cash on your card and you don’t have enough in a linked savings account to cover a transaction, you will be declined when you try to pay.
- savrajsingh 8y agoI noticed the “credit cards only” sign at Dos Toros for the first time yesterday. One of the things the sign says is cashless allows “more time for coaching” which I hope means training their employees? Coaching seemed like a strange word choice.
- bowlich 8y agoIt feels to me like we're moving away from cards back to cash in the last decade: - Gas stations offering cash discounts - Stores requiring minimum purchases for cards - Restaurants adding a service fee to use a card I don't think I every came upon these three items a decade ago, and now they seem standard.
- bena 8y agoBefore they were structured as "convenience fees". You could buy with a card, but they'd charge a small fee that was either a percentage of the total or a flat rate. Minimum purchase amounts were way more common when debit cards were becoming a thing. Basically, you'll find these things mostly in poorer places nowadays where even the store/restaurant owners are struggling and those card fees add up.
- zaarn 8y agoI don't really understand the american need for a credit card. In germany, I pay almost everything either in cash or via bank transfer, usually pull. I got a prepaid card a while ago, mostly to pay for american services (seriously, I only ever pay to american corporations with it). My debit card (EC card) is almost universal and directly connected to the bank account, no credit needed. CC is barely supported, EC is a lot better in terms of coverage. Even then I usually apologize when using the card for anything below 100€ or so at my local supermarket. I don't see much reason to go CC or EC fully, I always keep some cash in my wallet, not too much but enough to hold me over for a week. If I need more I go to the Bank's ATM and get more. Easy. Cash-free payment would also be fairly illegal, a business must accept cash payments (though a limit of 50 coins is there, notes are unrestricted) for any purchase in person (online businesses don't have to IIRC).
- supertrope 8y agoIt's a cultural and market network effect thing. A lot of Americans use debit card instead of credit card that can quickly accrue interest charges if not fully paid off every month. But plenty of people carry high interest debt. The average American who carries a balance owes 15000 USD. USA has high adoption of credit card network. In most places, debit cards are only accepted as Visa/MC not the low fee inter-bank network such as PLUS or STAR or NYCE. Then there's consumer credit history/score. Americans like to buy houses (it's de facto subsidized by the government through implicitly government guaranteed 30 year fixed rate loans). A high credit score can mean the difference of tens of thousands of dollars over the term of the mortgage. If you have no credit history, you get the worse possible rate. Housing choice determines school district, and therefore whether your children get a good excellent so-so or bad education. House prices are highly correlated with school quality - public schools are free but you have to be able to afford residency. The worse neighborhoods have shootings at night, rampant drug abuse and gangs, burglary/robbery, lack of jobs/grocery stores/medical service/non-convenience retail. Credit score usage has metastasized into many more facets of life than originally intended. Even if you want to only rent housing, the landlord will check your credit. Good landlords only reject for evictions or out of control debt that suggests you cannot afford rent, but some decide based off score e.g. if your score is below 20th percentile you will not get approved. You cannot get electricity/water/natural gas turned on without a credit check unless you place a large security deposit. Some companies will not hire you if you have bad credit! Those with bad credit have to pay up to double for car insurance. Of course many people like to spend beyond their means. But even responsible people put themselves at a disadvantage by not participating in the credit system.
- RandyRanderson 8y agoFees rising in 5, 4, 3....