37 ms·
You're right, but I suspect that one couldn't find a modern naval engineer who would approve any design based on a boat with insufficient flotation. If you cut
by jessaustin 8y ago
You're right, but I suspect that one couldn't find a modern naval engineer who would approve any design based on a boat with insufficient flotation. If you cut a modern factory-built boat in half, both halves will float. If one of these duck coffins springs a leak, it's going to the bottom. So, the focus on the engineering degree isn't totally off-base, because a qualified engineer would just "nope" the whole thing.
The NTSB really should have put an end to this industry in 1999. It's tough to imagine that they won't fix their mistake this time around.
- downandout 8y agoThe NTSB really should have put an end to this industry in 1999. They did everything they could legally do, which is to say that they issued many strongly worded recommendations. Unfortunately they don’t have the legal authority to actually force anyone to do anything.
- dbcurtis 8y agoIsn't the Coast Guard also involved, it being a water craft used for hire?
- rockinghigh 8y agoWho has the authority to ban these boats?
- downandout 8y agoI could be wrong, but I believe both the federal Department of Transportation and their state equivalents have this authority. So far, they haven’t done it though. As with most of these issues, it’s quite likely that a private market solution would be most effective. If insurance companies refused to cover these boats, or they at least forced clients to implement all NTSB recommendations, the problems associated with this industry would largely disappear overnight. According to the NTSB, the reason the death rate is so high when these things sink is because the canopy doesn’t come off. They had specific recommendations that would address this problem, and the industry seems to have entirely ignored them.
- yellowapple 8y agoIt's a bit harsh to want to end the whole industry, no? By all means let's get some proper safety standards for these things, but banning them outright seems excessive.
- ghaff 8y agoYou don't really deserve the downvotes you're getting. This is a widespread tourist attraction and I'd have to see some statistics to conclude that it's an especially unsafe one. That said, they deserve a serious look at what could be practically done to retrofit for greater safety (flotation, sorry but you get wet if it rains, wear PFDs) and otherwise set stricter operating guidelines.
- MBCook 8y agoThe article says there are versions that don’t have the top, that would fix most of the issue. Wearing lifevest you’d be able to get out safely instead of being trapped inside.
- ghaff 8y agoI suspect that would help a lot. Literal capsizing would still be an issue but filling up with water and sinking would be much less of one.
- evil-olive 8y agoThat would address most of the concern about the boats sinking, because every passenger could safely wear a floatation device. However, they're unsafe in other ways. The 2015 crash in Seattle, which killed 4, was caused by a snapped axle. When I read that the duck design was "stretched" by someone with zero engineering training, that sounds awfully suspicious. An additional concern is the the safety & maintenance records themselves. As part of the settlement in Seattle, the company admitted to 463 separate violations: https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/ducks-admits-to-463-safety-violations-to-pay-222000/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/duc...
- 8y ago
- nradov 8y agoYou're probably thinking of boats like Boston Whalers that have flotation foam built into the hull and will float when cut in half. But there are many other types of modern factory-built boats which will sink immediately if they take on enough water.
- jessaustin 8y agoAnything 20' or less has to have that flotation by law. Lots of brands install it in all boats regardless of length. There's a video of the back half of a 35' Carolina Skiff motoring around. [0] Obviously ducks are longer than 20', but no engineer would sign off on "sinks immediately". Larger vessels have various methods of buoyancy control. Nothing modern is built like a duck. [0] https://youtu.be/6Tv1EBb-MqE?t=425 https://youtu.be/6Tv1EBb-MqE?t=425
- stickfigure 8y agoErr... pretty much every monohull sailboat ever manufactured will "sink immediately" if the hull is punctured. Keels are heavy.
- jessaustin 8y agoMost monohull sailboats don't even have keels let alone weights. Certainly any sailboat designed to handle a capsize, which is all but the very largest, will not sink from a puncture, with keel-weight or without. Remember that interminable Robert Redford movie? That boat had a puncture the size of a shipping container...
- _hl_ 8y ago> Most monohull sailboats don't even have keels let alone weights. That's factually incorrect. Smaller monohulls that focus on racing performance often do not have weights, though they will certainly have a keel to reduce drift when sailing upwind. The exceptions are certain classes of tiny sports vessels. Larger monohulls that are designed to be lived on are generally categorised under "class A" according to Europe's CE certification, but are probably sold with equal safety standards around the world. Class A means that they are impossible to fully capsize and will not sink with even a reasonable amount of water in them (well, de facto at least, de jure they only need to survive certain wind and sea conditions). For example, a class A yacht may roll over 90° onto its side and fill up with water, but will not sink. To pull this off, these yachts have heavy weights on the end of their keels to counterbalance the force of the wind pushing them into the water. However, given enough water in them, even class A yachts will begin to sink.
- RIMR 8y agoThe one in Seattle suffered an axle break on a bridge, slamming into a charter bus. These things are insanely heavy, put through daily stress, and are basically maintained by carnies. Whether they're sinking like brick or eviscerating the sides of buses, it's clear that they don't belong on the road. Can't they just sunset these stupid things for the sake of the businesses, let wealthy collectors buy the old boats for their own purposes (and at their own risk), and force "Ride the Ducks" (who constantly insists that is not a single entity, despite having the same brand and business model), to purchase modern amphibious tour buses that pass safety regulations. Surely there would become an immediate demand for a safe, comfortable, maneuverable amphibious vehicle in the wake of a crackdown on these deathtraps.
- projektir 8y agoHmmmmm. And here I was thinking Ride the Ducks could be fun, and a friend recommended it to me some while ago...
- pssflops 8y agoMy wife recently rode one in the lower Wisconsin Dells and the outboard motor blew while they were breaching the water. The tour guide said this was the first it's ever happend. :rolleyes:
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ataturk 8y agoI have trouble with making everything require official training and certification. We would not be where we are today technologically if innovation were left only to "the experts" whose track record on safety is just as abysmal as anyone else's. Stupid article is stupid. Duck boats are 1930s technology, it's probably long past time they became museum items and new designs took over. It's just such a niche, touristy concern to begin with. Going on vacation should not get you killed. But then again, I took one look at those stupid things at the Wisconsin Dells and thought "hard pass on that" and took my family for other entertainment. That said, they operate them safely more than 99.9% of the time and the media has always had a problem understanding statistics.