13 ms·
Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts in company’s culture
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y agoOf course employees within Facebook should push back but do they have the ability? The fact that notes like these only get published when someone is already out the door throw into question the idea that employees have any power here. Corporations are just mini-governments and are prone to punishing workers who question their ethical position.
- gboudrias 8y ago> question their ethical position Or in Facebook's case, lack thereof.
- erobbins 8y agoWe pushed back all the time! It was nearly useless though, as our objections would either be dismissed with platitudes by the execs or ignored by the team actually working on the feature (and therefore caring more about their PSC review than the right thing)
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y agoI'd say that proves my point. The people actually programming the feature or responsible for the thing never push back because the PSC review is more important. A limp-wristed "push back" that never materializes at the most crucial moment - when you are asked to do something unethical - isn't really push back at all.
- gowld 8y agoI read that at Facebook anyone can build any feature. Is that true? Was that true in the past?
- nextlevelwizard 8y agoWhat push back have you offered for "something unethical"? It is easy to be armchair activist who doesn't have to actually put their neck on the line. On HN a lot of people talk about how people should just resign instead of implementing something "immoral", but never take into account that people have debt and lives to live and while you might lose sleep over a piece of code you wrote at least you won't go hungry or die of exposure in ultimately futile effort at stopping the feature, since the company will always find someone who needs money badly enough to complete the job.
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y agoI haven't. Like I said in my original comment I don't believe employees actually have the power to push back here. The corporation is too powerful. I'm not armchair activisting.
- Cypher 8y agosounds like game of thrones reference
- sandworm101 8y ago>> We need to deprioritze short-term growth and revenue and to explain to Wall Street why that is ok. We need to be willing to pick sides when there are clear moral or humanitarian issues. And we need to be open, honest and transparent about challenges and what we are doing to fix them. Those who want facebook to step up on various issues may regret it. Don't assume that Facebook will pick good over evil. Many Facebook people have spoken about the end of privacy, that it would be a good thing. Note that those who run Facebook don't actually use it, at least not in the way they want the rest of us to use Facebook. Do not expect Facebook to take the popular side. They have their own opinions that are likely very different than those of the common person.
- jonny_eh 8y ago> Don't assume that Facebook will pick good over evil If Facebook doesn't, a new competitor will. People will switch if they no longer feel safe.
- DonaldPShimoda 8y agoIf Facebook becomes too thoroughly ingrained in everything then it would be rather difficult for a new competitor to step up. People are too willing to sacrifice privacy in the name of convenience.
- ilikehurdles 8y agoI feel like facebook is getting less, not more ingrained in everything. Not being on facebook has only gotten easier for me, and young people don't seem keen on signing up for the service anymore.
- DonaldPShimoda 8y agoThat's a fair point. I pulled myself out of it last year (only check occasionally for updates on events my friends are planning), so I don't see its influence as much anymore... for which I am grateful haha. Instagram seems to be the hot new thing for the younger generation, from what I understand, but Instagram is owned by Facebook. So while Facebook itself may not be keeping up, the company as a whole (and its methodologies regarding privacy) will likely remain relevant for a while yet.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Philipp__ 8y agoThat’s right, I had picked sides too... and I’ve deleted facebook.
- l5870uoo9y 8y agoI did too, but was forced back because I need their API. Their latest move is to close of much of their Event API so people are forced to use their Facebook Local app, naturally this was justified with "privacy".
- ashleyn 8y ago>We need to be willing to pick sides when there are clear moral or humanitarian issues. It's refreshing to see this. Very tired of this mealy-mouthed "free speech" refrain when we're talking about private companies. Facebook is under no legal obligation to extend white ethno-nationalists (as one relevant example) a platform or support their cause in any capacity, and should do the right thing.
- masterleep 8y agoCan we make a deal and eliminate communists and socialists as well?
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoI’m a communist and socialist. What problem do you have with that?
- masterleep 8y agoA momentary gander at the 20th century provides the answer.
- lsd5you 8y agoThat your plans could lead to the deaths of millions perhaps? i.e. You're really some kind of crypto-authoritarian, or if not a useful idiot to the authoritarians that will emerge.
- dang 8y agoPersonal attacks and ideological battle are not allowed here, so please don't do these things in HN comments. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dang 8y agoPlease keep generic ideological tangents off HN. Nothing but hellish flamewar comes of it, and it's all boring. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- oneplane 8y agoI can't read this article, that side has a bad privacy policy that requires you to accept personalisation and tracking :-/ you can turn off third party tracking but not first party tracking.
- hyperman1 8y agoYou don't, actually. Enable firefox reader mode and read the article without clicking agree. This works for a lot of these sites.
- oneplane 8y agoI know there are workarounds ;-) But the real issue is that the site has bad practises and doesn't give you an option to opt out nicely. It's basically saying "eat our crap or leave". Imagine every newspaper requiring you to sniff a turd and give a copy of your passport before you are allowed to read it... (I know, comparing buzzfeednews.com with a classical newspaper is somewhat wrong, but it's just a bad analogy)
- hyperman1 8y agoI see it more like this: * Me: Hey guard, I want to read this newspaper * Guard: I won't let you unless you sniff this turd. * Me: I rephrase my question innst ye olde English: Canst thou let reade thine newspaper. * Guard: I have no idea what you're talking about. Here is a newspaper, have fun. You are allowed make life complicated for me, but I violated no law or contract by rephrasing the question in an unexpected way. The options are: eat our crap, leave, or surprise us. BTW, This principle works very well for telesales, religious door-to-door people, and service desks. Do something unexpected and they do anything to get rid of you.
- Klover 8y agohttps://outline.com/aWVaE6 https://outline.com/aWVaE6 Here you go. Does this help?
- 8y ago
- ironjunkie 8y agoIs he still working at Facebook? This letter reads extremely weirdly. Almost like they are building a narrative inside the company to keep people entertained. Politics playing at the highest levels. (Well when you are an exec in a company full of kids that are convinced they are making the world a better place, I cannot even imagine the amount of politics you need to play to get there).
- gowld 8y agoHe quit and the article is about his exit letter.
- ironjunkie 8y agoDid he ? Last two paragraphs : > Now what? Are you staying? I honestly don’t know. > If I do leave, I promise to be open and honest. On twitter he is still listed as at Facebook, and Wikipedia is unclear.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deegles 8y agoIn response to his Recode interview, Mark says "I believe that often the best way to fight offensive bad speech is with good speech." This would be possible to test empirically. One could to to identify groups of people who express racism, flat earthism, etc and require some of them to watch an educational video and answer a quiz. Ban another portion of them from posting for a set amount of time. Afterwards, compare the rate of posting about those beliefs to a control group. Personally, I believe that unchallenged false beliefs are only reinforced over time.
- Barrin92 8y agohttp://comp.social.gatech.edu/papers/cscw18-chand-hate.pdf http://comp.social.gatech.edu/papers/cscw18-chand-hate.pdf This is an interesting study on a related issue, a ban of hate-speech subreddits on reddit. I think the authors found some remarkable things. Not only was hate-speech on the website reduced (which would be an achievement in and of itself but it could be argued that containment is not enough), but the real kicker was that they followed individuals who were displaced from hate-speech subreddits, and those individuals actually reduced the amount of hate speech they engaged in. That in my book is a really strong argument because it means that we can not just push hate-speech out of view, but combatting it actively reduces it. By destroying organised platforms, the ability to organise and normalise hate is reduced and when engaging with the public at large, attitude is changed.
- cellularmitosis 8y ago> and those individuals actually reduced the amount of hate speech they engaged in Did they reduce their amount of hate speech because they no longer had a, erm, "safe place" to express it? There's a big difference between people self-censoring due to a chilling effect, and an actual change in beliefs.
- ceras 8y agoTo add to that, the authors acknowledge a similar weakness of the study: "We note that while the ban may have worked for Reddit, from a macro-perspective, it may have also relocated the behavior onto other sites." Since in this discussion we're concerned about macro effects, I'd be careful not to over-index on this study.
- samschooler 8y agoWe need to reemphasize moral, environmental and humanitarian issues in our society. We are at a point again when the only thing that matters is money. Yes companies always support "green initiatives" and other causes... but at the end of the day this support is only there to help them turn a profit. We as consumers (and co-riders on this planet) need to put our foot down and say "this stops here." Trump pushing for cost benefit analysis of saving endangered species, Facebook invading privacy regardless of what is necessary to push ads, companies pushing internet to developing countries in hopes of getting the market for themselves under the guise of "helping" these communities. I don't have the answer, I just know if we want to grow as a society we need to learn that looking only for monetary profit is hopelessly shortsighted.
- shittyadmin 8y agoI miss businesses who didn't get involved in politics. Now it seems like everyone is pushing for them to do so and I'm sick and tired of everyone begging for their particular group to be pandered to. Even those who used to avoid it like the plague, like CloudFlare and Namecheap have caved to these sorts of political pressures in the past year.
- hypersoar 8y agoPolitics is unavoidable. All businesses and people interact with power structures in some way. Pretending that they don't isn't neutrality, but rather a passive endorsement of the way things are. Big, entrenched, successful companies often have the luxury of assuming this stance because they like the way things are. As for Facebook in particular, their goal from the beginning has been to insert themselves into everyone's conversations. It's particularly absurd to think that they can avoid politics.
- DanielBMarkham 8y agoThis is nonsense. Of course they're already picking sides with every editorial action they take. It's not like suddenly they're going to switch from being a bulletin board to a publisher. They're already a publisher. They're the first and only worldwide newspaper-tv-town-crier. They pick sides everyday. The only thing left to decide is how honest and open to be about it. The more honest and open they are, the more the jig is up and everybody says "What the hell? Why do we want one publishing company controlling the information stream for billions of people? Who the hell thought that was a good idea?" And of course they don't want to have that conversation. So more and more of this silliness of being one thing while pretending to be something else.
- notatoad 8y agoOf course they're picking sides, that's the whole point. The problem is that right now they aren't picking sides based on morality - in a failed attempt to be impartial they're picking a side based on policy or technical issues, and ignoring the morality of the side that decision puts them on. If they keep trying not to pick sides, they're going to continue to accidentaly pick the wrong side sometimes. "we have to be willing to pick sides" is not the same thing as "we have to start picking sides"
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> they're picking a side based on policy or technical issues Let's be realistic. They're picking a side based on commercial motivations.
- notatoad 8y agofrom a long enough view, every decision a business makes is commercially motivated, so simplifying a decision down to picking a side based on commercial motivations isn't really helpful. Optimizing for immediate growth, long term growth, good PR, capital outlay, or maintaining a relationship with a valuable customer are all "commercial motivations" but usually in conflict with each other. it's pretty hard to find a business decision that can be reduced down to "should we make money, or not make money?"
- olivermarks 8y agoThis feels like pre earnings FB pr to me, leveraging the 'security officer' departure for some 'we're not just relentlessly data mining at any cost' dialog...but really FB will carry on doing what they do, while apologizing and issuing mea culpas...
- mithr 8y ago> We need to be willing to pick sides when there are clear moral or humanitarian issues. This is a little depressing given Zuckerberg's recent interview in which he said, with regard to Sandy Hook or Holocaust deniers posting these things on Facebook, "I just don’t think that it is the right thing to say, 'We’re going to take someone off the platform if they get things wrong, even multiple times.'" This email was sent in March. It seems pretty clear that Stamos' hopes for a major shift in Facebook's behavior have not come to pass.
- ikeyany 8y agoConsidering Facebook is opening an office on China, Stamos' hopes are essentially being steamrolled by a tank.
- hartator 8y ago> According to the post, his departure had long been in the works following an internal reorganization that left him with fewer responsibilities, So he was basically already fired. It’s easy to take a moral stand then. Specially when it’s your department which fucked up recently.
- greymeister 8y agoSociety needs to pick a side. Do we want large private companies acting as the arbiters of public discourse?
- tempfs 8y agoYou mean like every television station and newspaper that preceded them for decades and decades now? The medium may change but the game does not. You keep the cattle ignorant, fearful and nicely divided into two groups that you can steer and pit against each other on a whim whenever it suits your agenda.
- seventhtiger 8y agoWhen you build your website you set its rules. Freedom of speech doesn't mean you get to use Facebook.
- greymeister 8y agoSo make a bakery and decide who you'll make cakes for? I don't think that businesses should operate under such simplistic standards.
- tptacek 8y agoThe way Buzzfeed wrote this headline practically guaranteed the mediocre-bordering-on-toxic thread that resulted here. That quote is taken out of context, and is not the primary message of Stamos' letter. Which is ironic, given what his letter was actually about. This is a good example of a case where the original article headline is not a good HN headline.
- fb_throwaway_99 8y agoI disagree. Given the criticisms Stamos has leveled in this memo against the executive team, the quote of the headline seems very apt to me. The memo has Stamos making points very critical of the approach of the Facebook executives (the "we") to these issues over the past several years. Much of the word count of the memo was spent on "spin" / "setting the record straight", but that is also understandable given the context, and the compensation Stamos still likely has on the table. Perhaps Facebook _does_ need to take a side (not promoting the posts of users directly advocating violence, not selling data to 3rd parties, not employing UI 'dark patterns' to encourage users to unconsciously share private information, etc.).
- krageon 8y agoFacebook has taken a side, it's just the side of dark patterns and selling all of everything it can get it's hands on. It's had this side for as long as I can remember it existing.
- diogenescynic 8y agoYouTube is no better. Alex Jones is making death threats against Mueller and neither Facebook or Google has taken it down. They’re cowards. All that money and they still can’t afford to do the right thing? What a sad reality we’ve created.
- gowld 8y agoI'm jaded by people who suddenly grow morals and speak out on the day they retire, after having not interest in those morals during their career when their opinions mattered.
- jessaustin 8y agoI wouldn't vote for Ike again, either.
- fogetti 8y agoWow. A high ranking officer putting blame on everyone... That's a shitty company culture for you. It also aligns well with the business that facebook represents. Even if he was the good guy in this story this doesn't shed any more positive light on facebook.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- drewmol 8y agoThe beauty of Facebook's position is that by having sole control of the internet middlemanning market, they can solve it without taking a position. Members of the standard hate groups can experience Freedom Loving Facebook with ultimate liberty to 'poison the well' of opinion with spiteful shouting. The 'Anti-Hategroup' Hategroups will have full authority to shout down and silence unwelcome ideoligies, slowly cleaning the internet of hate. Your Facebook, your reality. Free from the burden of internet argumemts, we can all get back to scrolling through ads.
- drewmol 8y ago"You won't believe these 10 hate groups that Marc Zuckerberg refuses to ban, donates to!" > "Facebook stands firm, bans extremist nationalist hate group: <No longer available> from platform!
- dredmorbius 8y ago"There are many amongst us who would not hesitate to build equipment to compromise the privacy of any given individual provided the price is right. These are the whores of industry. They would not hesitate building systems and devices contrary to the public interest; their only concern is the buck." Paun Baran, "On the Engineer's Responsibility in Protecting Privacy" RAND. May, 1968. https://www.rand.org/pubs/papers/P3829.html https://www.rand.org/pubs/papers/P3829.html One of many prescient insights friom that paper.