6 ms·
Can They Make Government Jobs as Cool as Google and Goldman?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Eridrus 8y agoSeems unlikely. There's no appetite to pay people as well as Google/Goldman. Even much of HN isn't willing to accept how much Engineers get paid there. But it doesn't need to be as cool as Google/Goldman, it just needs to be well run.
- captainbland 8y agoProbably not. At best they might make them kind of 'MAGA' edgy.
- gaius 8y agoThere absolutely are government jobs that are super-cool, Navy SEAL for example. It’s not the inherent government-ness that makes these other jobs un-cool, it’s something else
- goldminer88 8y agoWhile being a Navy SEAL would be interesting or cool by any standard, its not exactly a position with low barriers to entry. The point of the article is questioning if its possible to have government jobs that are attainable by the everyman.
- mantas 8y agoGoogle software engineer does not have low barriers either. You've to train pretty hard for either. And both jobs seem like magic for general population.
- moccachino 8y agoWhat makes being a Navy SEAL cool is: 1) that they endured the training, unimaginably impressive 2) special forces military, always cool The only special thing about a Google engineer is that they get paid well and have a probably nice work environment. Which actually is nothing special. Most people would admire a Navy SEAL, be glad that they do their job but never ever want to be one, except for 5 minutes in their imagination. Almost no-one admires a Google engineer but most people would probably want to be one or at least have their working compensation/environment.
- mantas 8y agoYet both jobs have rather high barriers of entry and are not really "attainable by the everyman".
- empath75 8y agoNot working for this administration. I just quit a DHS contract a few months ago because I didn’t want to have anything to do with what they were doing.
- billsmithaustin 8y agoI’m sorry your experience with the federal government was so bad. The article was more focused on government at the local and state level.
- JasonFruit 8y agoThank you for having principles.
- dsr_ 8y agoThose aren't cool companies, those are just paid a lot. Cool is working on something that you, personally, find important -- and making progress. The biggest barrier to that in government is being allowed to make progress, partially because the existing processes have a large inertia, and partially because the cost of failure is so high.
- christophilus 8y agoThis was my thought, as well. I've never in my life heard of this purported Goldman and cool association.
- Kaliveho 8y agoYeah. Goldman, cool? Yeah right. These are only cool for the general public I think.
- goatherders 8y agoYou dont work on Wall Street.
- kasey_junk 8y agoI have. Goldman didn’t have a reputation for cool. They had a reputation for being a good stepping stone to something else. Ditto in tech. It’s been a long time since Google had a reputation for cool. They have a reputation for paying well & being good on the resume.
- alistairSH 8y agoThat was my thought. In college (albeit 20 years ago now), Goldman (and similar Wall St) jobs were only cool because of the money involved. The actual work, and lack of life balance, wasn't cool. It was just something to do for a few years while you saved a pile of cash, and before going back for an MBA or something else.
- lowken10 8y agoYou know what's a cool job? Working at a great job doing interesting work... and having a schedule where I leave at 2:30 PM and pick my kids up from school. Then I get to spend the evening with my kids, playing with them, going to the pool with them, doing homework with them, reading with them, etc. That's a cool job!!!
- amelius 8y agoThose companies are so big that they are just like the government, except they have only one indicator of success which is financial.
- skc 8y agoI think this is the first time I've ever seen someone use Goldman as an example of a "cool" company. When did that happen?
- Tade0 8y agoSame here. I used to work with a guy who was employed at the London HQ. He had some great stories to tell but his experience there was anything but "cool".
- gaius 8y agoBoth Google and Goldman are “springboard” companies, 2-3 years at either and you are basically guaranteed an interview anywhere you want, possibly for the rest of your career. Cool might not be the right word, but there is a reason why people clamour to get in, not just the money
- ionforce 8y agoTo whom does a stint at Goldman hold cachet?
- what-the-grump 8y agoAll of finance in NYC at the very least.
- alistairSH 8y agoMuch of the finance industry in the US. Do a few years at Goldman (or any other well-known employer on Wall St), get an MBA, and work wherever you want for the next 30 years. I know quite a few who have followed this plan. Every industry has companies like this. Apple and Google in software, PWC in accounting, BoozAllen in consulting, etc.
- gaius 8y agoRight. It may not be everyone’s cup of tea but a stint at Goldman would be looked on favourably by any of the Fortune 500.
- elgenie 8y agoThe article doesn't mention "coolness" at all. All that's mentioned is on-campus recruiting of graduating seniors at selective schools, which Goldman/Google/McKinsey certainly work hard at. In terms of the universal measure of coolness known as "tastiness of food provided at on-campus info sessions", I recall those companies rating highly. And Betteridge's Law of Headlines applies here.
- qaq 8y agoIt seems government has not issues attracting Goldman talent even most senior people :).
- sailfast 8y agoReaders will note the article is about state and local government jobs. Everyone should try to work in government at some point to understand why things so relevant to your life happen the way they do, and to be better citizens. State and local has huge challenges in terms of funding and potentially old infrastructure, but also incredible opportunities to change lives with simple improvements in processes that haven’t gotten the love they deserve. Wage increases would help, but two year “tours” with other benefits might at least help folks understand why the mission is so important and maybe bust up some staid organization with some new energy. Good luck to these folks - they’ll need it.
- wolfgke 8y ago> Everyone should try to work in government at some point to understand why things so relevant to your life happen the way they do, and to be better citizens. I disagree: Working in something government related makes you deeply hate the government. To give some background: When I get involved into political discussions (which I rather avoid for good reasons), people very often tell me privately afterwards that I gave really good arguments for my points of discussion, but my arguments and political direction are so different from anything they have heard so far and could hardly be more different from any party program of any party they heard of (needless to say that I do not feel in any sense represented by any party in Germany). So they privately do agree with many points that I introduce, but openly state to me that they are not be able to defend these arguments in public because they are so different from the current political agenda. To me this is deeply frustrating. > State and local has huge challenges in terms of funding and potentially old infrastructure, but also incredible opportunities to change lives with simple improvements in processes that haven’t gotten the love they deserve. This is exactly what government is not about. It is obeying some strange set of laws perfectly instead of doing what really makes sense.
- alistairSH 8y agoI don't disagree, but working as a bureaucrat is not the same as having a political debate. Most bureaucrats are doing work that needs done regardless of political alignment (of the employee, or of the current administration). Leading the police department, sanitation department, etc - none are strictly political positions.
- code4tee 8y agoI think Goldman was seen as a “cool” place to work maybe like 12+ years ago before the crash. Now, not so much.
- aikinai 8y agoThis sounds like one of those things that's impossible to replicate since it so heavily depends on existing culture, but it's interesting to note that in Japan government work is seen as quite cool and it's a top choice for many of the most successful job seekers.
- adrian_mrd 8y agoShort answer: no. Long answer: no, with comments! This is because government is inherently risk-averse and attracts many working types who are more attracted by stability, consistency and a ‘safe’ job. Obviously governments are varied beasts and there are some ‘funky’, innovative, exciting departments, although in my experience they are very much exceptions. Making and enforcing rules is safe territory - in terms of being somewhat of a known state, working at exciting companies can be very much the opposite. But as some commentators have stated, cool is very much an individual angle.
- nashashmi 8y agoFurther government is a place where loyalty trumps responsibility, ideas, and passion for the measly end goal of climbing the ladder, securing your rank, and succeeding when you shouldn't.
- coderdude 8y agoWhat's with all these government employees with all this loyalty?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- noxToken 8y ago> This is because government is inherently risk-averse and attracts many working types who are more attracted by stability, consistency and a ‘safe’ job. Obviously governments are varied beasts and there are some ‘funky’, innovative, exciting departments, although in my experience they are very much exceptions. It's funny how true this is while some government jobs immediately spit in the face of these practices. More specifically, a lot of O-1 and O-2 officers are so far up their own ass that they don't realize that the stability exists because the technical side of some jobs have such a well established routine. Yes sir. We understand that you have a college degree in chemistry. We know that according to your analysis, we should do A, B, and C. But have you considered that the software we have for mapping out RF propagation has (quite literally) never failed us? Have you considered that the people who wrote this software both have a degree in the field and refined it based on real-world analysis? Also, have you considered that having us set up a re-transmission site in the middle of a firing range is bad for the equipment and bad for my chances of living to see 21? You would think that last one would be common sense, but waking up to friendly fire (explosions) at 6AM is terrifying.
- ToFab123 8y agoThere is nothing cool about Goldman. That company have created more havoc in ordinary people economy than any other private company ever had. IMHO Goldman is the definition of scumbags. "cool" is defiantly not the word that comes to my mind when I hear that name
- goatherders 8y agoGoldman is a public company. Facebook, Apple and tons of other idolized companies have generated as much malfeasance around the world. And Goldman is cool in circles where people like to make lots and lots of money.
- booleandilemma 8y agoA worked with an ex-Goldman employee and she was the most backstabbing person I have ever met. The experience made me wonder if they select for that.
- nimbius 8y agough, hard to imagine. As a former motor pool mechanic for a small county in Ohio, the government has some serious work to do before it will ever compete with google, and its all in management. Ive endured some truly idiotic days at government...including - Racking up 8 industry certifications, fully paid, only to have all my ideas shot down because they didnt come from a manager with a degree in philosophy. - Buying an expensive flush computer system for a type of truck that we already outsourced transmission flushes for, and that was being phased out in favour of something cheaper from International Harvester. - Refusing...and i mean absolutely refusing...to fix any salt spreader hardware because meyer (the manufacturer) insisted everything would last 40k miles. - trying to explain we dont measure in miles, we measure in engine hours. all reports still list miles. - watching the city basically sell off 5 salt spreading trucks because a lawsuit after one failed made them all 'a liability' - replacing a fleet of Kodiak 4x4 HD salt spreaders with used Ford F250's from a construction fleet. - watching these all fail miserably after the first major snow storm. - Borrowing...then buying and poorly repainting...trucks for salt spreading from the National Guard. - Getting dinged on my performance review EVERY YEAR because management wouldnt buy parts I needed to make the sheriffs new mine resistant armored vehicle work.
- alistairSH 8y agoYou're comparing apples and oranges. So is the original article. The government equivalent of Google would be working for an interesting branch (CIA, NSA, NRL, etc) of the federal government. Not working on trucks for the town. And, as a DC local, I can tell you that there are plenty of applicants for federal jobs. People want the jobs - they pay reasonably well (not Google level, but comfortably upper-middle-class, with stable benefits). A huge number of my peers from high school and college work for Uncle Sam. Almost all of them have post-graduate degrees, love their jobs, and are definitely smart enough and ambitious enough to pick and choose their employer.
- renox 8y ago> - Getting dinged on my performance review EVERY YEAR because management wouldnt buy parts I needed to make the sheriffs new mine resistant armored vehicle work. Well I kind of understand the management here: why do the sheriff needs a mine resistant armored vehicle in Ohio? That said of course this should not have an impact on your performance review..
- drngdds 8y agoCan they pay as much as Google and Goldman? No? Then no.
- bitL 8y agoProbably, but they have to wait until Google and Goldman deteriorate to the Government jobs-level first.
- lesss365 8y agoWhen NYC gov upgrades from Windows 2008, and a way too cumbersome and outdated CMS for their sites, then we'll know they're taking the steps towards maybe not "cool", but towards bearable systems/workflows to deal with, and as a result making them more attractive as an employer
- lbriner 8y agoA point that hasn't been made is that measuring success and value is generally easy in a simple commercial company like Google. If you are a part of something that makes $1B a year, you are probably worth your wages and all the cool tech and offices you need. Clearing snow or getting rid of garbage has no obvious financial value even though it is necessary. So answering the question, should Sanitation be run by a clever person on $200K per year or a normal person on $40K is harder.
- alistairSH 8y agoThere's a reasonable middle ground, no? Should the manager of a city's sanitation department draw a Goldman/Google-level salary? Perhaps not. But, the person is probably managing tens or hundreds of employees, a fleet of vehicles, and depending on how the city is organized, they're also managing some complex "industrial" facilities(water treatment, etc). I don't think a six-figure salary is unreasonable for that. Heck, given the impact on my life if sanitation goes to shit, I'll happily pay my share of taxes to support a salary that draws somebody who will get the job done. Ditto for the leaders of many of the other city/county services.
- delinka 8y agoCan they? Sure. Will they? Doubtful. The problem is slowness due to bureaucracy. When you can't even experiment on 'company' equipment without formulating a plan and having it approved by a few levels of management, it becomes a pain to advance not only your department/organization, but also to advance your own knowledge.
- lbriner 8y agoGovernment employs a massive number of people compared to Google. There simply aren't that many amazing people to fill a government, even if a specific job looked cool, the clever person would soon leave out of frustration that others don't know what they're doing. At Google, even if you don't like the management, they have (generally) proved their worth and ability. If your cool jobs couldn't attract the clever people I assume the OP was alluding to, then it isn't worth the hassle? Governments also have to work with many outside agencies, suppliers and consumers, I guess many more than people like Goldman do. Unless the whole network is run well, frustration is crouching at the door.
- jdietrich 8y agoYes. We did it in the UK. The Government Digital Service is essentially a startup within the government, providing services for other government departments. Since 2011, a relatively small team have completely transformed the government's online presence. Government services are now digital by default and open by default; GDS maintains over 1,100 repos on GitHub. It helps that tech salaries are generally lower in the UK, but it's mainly about attitude. GDS enjoy a very high level of autonomy and are free to use modern tools and methodologies. Working at GDS is legitimately cool. https://gds.blog.gov.uk/about/ https://gds.blog.gov.uk/about/ https://github.com/alphagov https://github.com/alphagov
- typon 8y agoWhat kind of a square thinks working at Goldman is cool?