24 ms·
Federal Reserve chair says decline in workers' share of profits 'very troubling'
- sharemywin 8y agoyou erode worker bargaining power for 30 years and you wonder why they're share of profits is going down. go figure.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoTo be fair, the Federal Reserve is not responsible for labor law and the like. They are clearly very late in their response, but it's notable that a non-political organization felt the need to comment.
- noobermin 8y agoI don't think that the person you're replying to is implying its the Fed's fault as an organization. It is the function of people in power (both politically and in the economy) since the 80s having eroded worker's abilities to push back, so it's more an indictment of the system, not individuals strictly.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoThe comment was massively down voted when I saw it, so I have to assume the reason was because people interpreted the comment as I laid it out. Though now it is out of the light grey
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 8y ago"Job Insecurity of Workers Is a Big Factor in Fed Policy" https://web.archive.org/web/20100304170139/https://www.nytimes.com/1997/02/27/business/job-insecurity-of-workers-is-a-big-factor-in-fed-policy.html https://web.archive.org/web/20100304170139/https://www.nytim... The Fed has an interest, and influence, on labour conditions, if not direct legislative input. Unemployment is the other of its dual mandates. (Though, and crucially, not wage levels.)
- walru 8y agoThe Fed is responsible for the savings rate of the average American, which is to say, it's absolutely worthless to stick your money in the bank and watch it grow, which would help starve off what they're talking about here.
- Y_Y 8y agoI think "starving off" might be exactly what they have in mind.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- walshemj 8y agoYou know that high interest rates for savings go in had with high inflation cash never beat's inflation.
- kolpa 8y agoThe average American has no particular reason to stick with a "savings account". They could buy equities and ETFs that are as simple as savings accounts.
- gbacon 8y agoYou are responsible for your rate of savings. I am responsible for mine.
- pjmorris 8y agoThe Fed is responsible for QE, including about two Trillion in purchases of Mortgage-Backed Securities [0], which has the effect of making housing more expensive than it would otherwise be. If you're a home owner or debt owner, that's good for you. If you pay rent or a mortage, that's wage suppression. [0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MBST https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MBST
- pjmorris 8y agoI am interested in the views of those who downvote this comment. My facts are conventional, I'm guessing that my perspective is controversial.
- moistoreos 8y agoI must agree. This smells like a strong case of "no shit-sherlock".
- ams6110 8y agoPeople need to be taught about investing and the time value of money from an early age. If you invest in some low-cost index funds, you share in the profits. And if you start early, it doesn't have to be a big sacrifice.
- pradn 8y agoMany people barely have enough to live on, let alone invest. If wages were higher in real terms, they're lives would be better. Plus, investing is risky. Not everyone has the ability to weather business downturns without tapping into savings.
- noobermin 8y agoBTW, this isn't a moral argument (at least it need not be), practically people cannot invest in anything and yield an actually substantial return. Almost half(E) people in the US cannot weather a $400 emergency without going into debt, how could they possibly have enough money to invest for either themselves or their children? This arguably would be only valuable for people in the middle class to upper middle class. EDIT: the statistic is 46%[0]. Okay, it's not "most" people but it's a good fraction. I wouldn't be surprised that >50% can't weather a $1000 emergency. [0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/05/25/the-shocking-number-of-americans-who-cant-cover-a-400-expense/?utm_term=.4c3fc8e745a5 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/05/25/the-s...
- joyeuse6701 8y agoIf one has internet, one can invest in oneself through education in very tangible lucrative ways. Never before has access to so much knowledge been available from MIT courses to marketing books, much of which is free.
- iamdave 8y agoNever before has access to so much knowledge been available from MIT courses to marketing books Sure, but do these mooc/online courseware platforms teach one how to apply these new tangential skills and translate them into CV language and personal development actions that will get them hired? Especially if one is not already mentally inclined to join a 21st century workforce? I'm asking this coming from the perspective of someone born in rural South Carolina (in a portion of the United States known as 'The Bible Belt') who is an entirely self-taught programmer, versed in a couple of languages-and realized I had to go to an entirely different part of the world to even make use of what I had learned. So my mind is going out to those people who don't live in dense urban areas and are maybe looking for a relatively 'future-proof' job that may as well be asking the to learn an alien language. It was only by circumstance alone that I got exposed to the kind of entrepreneurial thinking needed for me to realize early on: I'm not gonna do jack shit with these computer skills, there's no market here, I live in a town that used to be a booming textile center and is now an economically depressed shithole (I say that lovingly, it's my economically depressed shithole), and has been for the last 30 years-forcing me to pack up and leave. Do you think a substantial number of people who have internet have the same circumstances I did to know "I have this skill now, thanks to an online course, and now I need to follow up on it by making this sacrifice to put myself in a position where these new skills will get me hired. I need to be having these discussions with recruiters and hiring mangers, and doing these things to stand out"? Or even have the resources to pack up and plant their butt in a different part of the country? Personally, I don't know if all of these code camps and online training programs do more than say "Here's a wrench, here's how to use it, good luck with your future as a wrench turner". Can anyone speak to career development as an extension of this wealth of online knowledge? I just have hesitations of what utility these programs offer beyond here's how to do x with n.
- patagonia 8y agoUnfortunately the laws and regulations in place facilitating this trend are put in place, for the most part, by elected representatives. For one thing, we need to change “first past the post” election results to decrease the polarizing results that have been shaping our politics as of late. I’m just saying, this isn’t a conspiracy by one party or group. To an extent, it’s the country we voted for.
- Buttons840 8y agoI donate to http://www.fairvote.org http://www.fairvote.org . If anyone knows of other activist groups supporting better voting systems, I'd like to know about them.
- munk-a 8y agoI don't know a better one but I'm sad to see the organization doesn't support leveling seats for volume positions (i.e. house members & senators) there are some complex voting systems that appear to be theoretically more representative than IRV but for single position elections (governor, president, DA, etc...) IRV seems like a good balance between complexity and fairness.
- knuththetruth 8y agoThis is a strange take when the wealthy actively conspire through bought-and-sold politicians to discredit, undermine, and destroy labor organization, the only thing in history with a proven track record of winning concessions for workers(in aggregate). Maybe there’s not a “conspiracy,” but there’s certainly a class war.
- patagonia 8y agoI agree class issues are at play. But our “class system” is not determined by blood lines. The constituents of a a given class are fluid. Which leads me to believe it is a combination of human nature and relative participation of the various classes. Blaming “the rich” when voting turnout is so low and election participation is low is a non starter for me.
- kvakvs 8y agoCannot read due to EU wall.
- rjvbk 8y agoJust prepend https://outline.com/ https://outline.com/ to the URL. https://outline.com/http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-federal-reserve-powell-20180717-story.html https://outline.com/http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-fe...
- oflannabhra 8y agoPowell also spoke to this in a recent interview with Marketplace[0] >Ryssdal: I want to get to the regulatory part of your job, which you address right there in a second, but I want to first talk about some of the things that came out of the financial crisis that we're still dealing with. And maybe the most relevant for consumers in this economy is the idea that wages now for a decade or more really have been stuck. And the question is: As you consider your dual mandates of price stability and maximum employment, where are wages on your list of things to worry about? And what really power do you have? >Powell: So wages were low, and that was understandable after the financial crisis because unemployment was extremely high. Unemployment was 10 percent in 2009. As unemployment has declined — now all the way down to 4 percent, the lowest it's been in 20 years — we would have expected wages to move up fairly significantly. We now just in the last year or so, we have seen wages move up. >Ryssdal: A hair, right? >Powell: We look at a range of — there's no one wage indicator. We tend to look at sort of the four big ones in particular. And if you look back to five years ago, they were all in the low twos — this is annual rate of increase — and now they're all close to three. So there's been this very gradual move up. I think, you know, part of that is that wages should reflect inflation plus productivity. So if you're delivering more output per hour, it should be reflected. Productivity has been very low. But there is still a bit of a puzzle in that we're hearing about labor shortages now all over the country in many, many different occupations in different geographies. And one would have expected, I would have expected, that wages would move up a little bit more. So I think we don't directly look so much at wages as we do price inflation, but I think we're looking very carefully at maximum employment, and that is one of the things that pushes up wages and price inflation. >Ryssdal: Right. But why are they stuck? Is it just that we're not producing enough widgets per hour? Is it robots? I mean, what is going on? Because that's the thing that people want to know about. >Powell: So, one big part of the explanation is certainly that inflation has been low and productivity has been low. So productivity just means how much your output per hour increases. And that's what you should expect as a worker to get paid for, is enough to cover inflation plus how much did your output go. So if you take that at the aggregate national level, if you add those two up, that's actually pretty consistent with what's been happening with wages. So again, there's no — I wouldn't call it a mystery, but I would say that it's a bit of a puzzle given how tight labor markets appear to be. And what we're hearing from employers really is that they can't find workers, and you're wondering, well, why aren’t wages going up faster? >Ryssdal: Why aren’t they paying them, right? >Powell: It’s a good question. It’s a good question. We don't really have the answer to that question. >Ryssdal: Which is a little troubling, if you're the guy running the economy. >Powell: I don't think of myself as the guy running the economy. You know the economy is a $20 trillion economy. [0] - https://www.marketplace.org/2018/07/12/economy/powell-transcript https://www.marketplace.org/2018/07/12/economy/powell-transc...
- legitster 8y agoTo me it is pretty ridiculous how much labor is taxed, and how little capital is taxed. Especially if we are worried about automation and lack of productivity growth, it seems so counter-intuitive that we are completely stuck to a tax system that devalues workers.
- jiveturkey 8y agodefine "we".
- toomuchtodo 8y ago> define "we". People who want to avoid violent revolution, which historically has occurred when inequality has reached a certain threshold. https://www.marketwatch.com/story/want-to-level-income-inequality-so-far-only-war-and-disease-have-worked-2017-09-18 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/want-to-level-income-inequ... https://www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2017/03/02/the-lessons-of-violence-and-inequality-through-the-ages https://www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2017/03/02/the-less...
- astrodust 8y agoEither you fix the system or the system fixes you. When you grind people down so much that tens of millions have nothing left to lose, watch out.
- munk-a 8y agoThis is correct but it's also rewording the parent comment. There is reason to be legitimately concerned that things might be on fire in a year or two, it would be very good for the US government to take actions to prevent that for the benefit of the people who are being ground down and, for bonus points, it would be in the best interest of the people grinding others down!
- acct1771 8y ago
- gboudrias 8y agoWho could've seen it coming except all social sciences and literally mathematics... What I'm saying is, how are they just now "troubled"? This is all but inevitable barring drastic measures to enforce the opposite trend, at which point it's no longer any recognizable sort of capitalism. Honestly it just seems like a bunch of people receiving numbers they expected and pretending to be surprised.
- israelisreal 8y agoMy daughter is going into the Air Force, getting her degree at night for nothing in 2.5 years, going back in as an officer, effectively doubling her income all the while not paying for food, lodging, medical/dental. She plans on doing 20. She'll likely marry an Air Force officer, and two people retiring at 39/40 YO will have a combined retirement of just under 100k (today's money), all the while not wasting precious money on medical/dental. She'll be young enough to have a second career in her chosen field and if the legislators don't screw up SS, she'll have three retirement incomes.
- isostatic 8y agoAll paid for by those who don't go into the military–industrial complex, but instead pay enormous taxes to fund it. The kid fixing broken windows does well too. The U.S. accounts for 35% of the world's defence spending, more than twice that of Russia and China together.
- israelisreal 8y agoYou are paying for it by your service, which only 1% of the population serves. I have nothing but respect for the military and those who serve. People need to stand behind the troops or in front of them. People sleep well at night because of the military and their sacrifice.
- bluntfang 8y agoexcept for all those people in poverty who don't sleep or eat well.
- adamwong246 8y agodon't forget the collateral damage caused by those troops. Americans might get to sleep well and eat well, but those yemeni weddings guests who got droned get neither.
- s73v3r_ 8y ago
- csense 8y ago40-50 years ago, a young person fresh out of high school could get a job that allowed them to live the middle class life -- own a house and support a family with only one spouse needing to work. Nowadays even college graduates struggle to achieve "liftoff." Globalization has led to a race-to-the-bottom situation where jobs flow across borders, to the places where desperate poverty allows wages to be as low as possible, and the greatest degree of worker exploitation is allowed. Which is great for those people being lifted out of poverty. And it's great for companies who can more freely exploit workers, and maximize their profits. And it's great for consumers, who get lots of cheap new stuff. But it totally wrecked our economy's ability to provide a good standard of living for the ordinary person. Those chickens finally came home to roost in the last US presidential election. There's a lot I don't like about Trump, but I think his tariffs really will make America great again (if they aren't just repealed by the next administration). Because we're finally doing something about this situation.
- ashleyn 8y agoWe're doing something, but is it a competent response? Done the wrong way, tariffs just cause everyone to lose. Trump is a symptom of the problem and that's a big part of the reason he happened, but he's not particularly a good solution to it.
- israelisreal 8y agoI agree. I remember those days. At 50, I've been in IT now for 3 decades. The pay in IT has decreased as well. My dad pulled a family of four along on his salary and we were comfortable, but not rich. I lacked nothing. However... when I turned 10, I came home one day from school and there was a brand new mower sitting in the driveway with a gas can and a rope. My dad said, "Son, canvas the neighborhood and charge $5-10 (size) a lawn. That money is yours. Save a dollar for every 10 for gasoline." I was making about $250 a month. This taught me to get off my own butt and make it on my own, which I have. I paid my own way through college (impossible now), bought my own car, married a woman who did the same. We are largely debt free (mortgage), but will be free soon. Except for property tax, we owe no man anything, and this is the way it should be. Pull yourself up by your own bootstraps. Big daddy government is not the answer and technically owes you nothing. As Gerald Ford once said, "A government big enough to give you everything is big enough to take it all away." Sadly, this young generation has embraced the notion of entitlement. No one is owed anything except human dignity. Americans have lost the sense of doing it on their own. Te military is a great choice for kids who cannot afford college. I'm not babying my kids. They will need to make it on their own. My dad did it, I did it, my wife did. None of us were rich, and by today's standards, we would have been considered poor.
- methodover 8y agoThe allocation of profits in startups, at least, feels... problematic. I was the #2 engineer hire when I was hired five years ago. Since then, we haven't become super successful -- yet -- but we're at least at breakeven. We have three engineers and we're working on a huge new project that hopefully will really grow the company. I have 1.8% equity. Sometimes when I'm working late or working on the weekend, which is often, I wonder: Is this really worth it? I'm totally fine with taking a pay cut to build something new, in order to have the chance at making life changing money. But at the equity I have, we'd need to be quite successful in order to get that. The VCs who funded our seed and series A (the only funds we've raised) will see the lion's share of the profits. Emotionally, that feels odd. We've thrown a significant percentage of our lives, and they've only thrown in money -- and a pretty small amount of it, really. I know it's supposed to make sense from a financial perspective or whatever, but emotionally it doesn't feel fair. But hey I guess it worked, I have what feels like a small percentage and yet I'm throwing everything I have at this company. I'm likely an outlier, though. I suspect that if VCs and founders gave employees a bigger piece of the pie, they'd have a much more motivated workforce.
- pembrook 8y agoThat's not what the Fed chair is talking about. Nobody is concerned about wages in tech. Tech is one of the few industries that has the opposite of a stagnant wage growth problem.
- tdb7893 8y agoWe are paid a lot but I heard somewhere that even though we should have crazy bargaining power we still are capturing less of the profits than would be expected so tech isn't fully immune to it (especially if you aren't working at one of the more famous tech companies)
- jsoc815 8y ago>We are paid a lot... even though we should have crazy bargaining power... While you are likely correct, what pembrook says is mostly true. The tech scene is often used by economists and the like as a cudgel against any talk that U.S. wages and the general economy are lackluster. (To be clear, I am basing this on actual discussions I have had, not theory and/or scholarly papers.)
- jrjarrett 8y agoShocking. SHOCKING, I say. The recent tax cuts were touted to generate big raises for American workers. A few companies made some news with one-time payouts, but then the rest of that is just being funneled to shareholders. If a government creates laws that incent shareholder givebacks, you wonder why workers' share of profits aren't increasing?
- bluGill 8y agoThe recent tax cuts will take a few years to filter though the economy to workers - at best. Thus it is incorrect use results to judge any policy until many years have passed. This is the nature of most things that the government does, and why it is really hard to figure out what is best. There are ways to make judgement that are not based on results, but they always subject to their own biases.
- kingnothing 8y agoTrickle down economics doesn't work.
- nv-vn 8y agoYes, but nobody really believes in trickle down economics. The entire name of "trickle down economics" came from people who were against supply-side economics and named it based on their (mis)understanding of the theory. Around half of economists today seem to be on the supply-side side (notably, the Chicago School and the less mainstream Austrian School).
- kimdotcom 8y agoRonnie?
- gbacon 8y agoBecome a shareholder. Save and invest more.
- kolpa 8y ago
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoHow can this be fixed? If businesses increase salaries they will likely not meet their quarterly which means investors will punish them. Too many quarters like this and the C-Team gets replaced. This is a sad, pathetic treadmill we are on. I strongly feel we need to go back to annual reporting.
- vturner 8y agoWhy doesn't the stock market act as a balancing system to low wages? Lowering wages implies higher efficiency thus resulting in higher profits which ultimately end up in "investors" pockets. Why are these "investors" not the common American "worker" whose wages are low? Why has the market not created such an instrument to supplement the "worker" who has low wages but could ultimately profit from the ever-increasingly efficient economy? This is an honest question whose answer I ponder. Why doesn't the stock market act as a great redistributor of capitalistic wealth?
- malcolmgreaves 8y agoBecause you need lots of captial in order to buy enough stock to make a substantial life improving financial gain. The short term gains, fluctuations, etc. can easily wipe out the capital gains that one is able to make on a worker's take home pay.
- padobson 8y agoI feel like unions really missed the boat on this one. Maybe I don't know union history well enough, but it seems like the UAW should have made large equity stakes in Ford, GM and Chrysler (or the equivalent historical companies) important priorities in their heyday.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Why are these "investors" not the common American "worker" whose wages are low? Because workers don't have money to buy stock, so they don't get the gains from stock appreciation. And because workers are taxed vastly more heavily than investors at the same income level, people who don't stay out living off investments rather than wage labor are, even if m with the same pre-tax income, greatly disadvantaged at accumulating the resources to become others of capital sufficient for their own support (the lucky worker manages to accumulate enough for a modest but decent retirement by the time they are incapable of further wage labor, but many do not.) It's a lot easier for a modestly wealthy capitalist to become a very wealthy capitalist than for a worker to become even a self-sufficient capitalist. > Why has the market not created such an instrument to supplement the "worker" who has low wages but could ultimately profit from the ever-increasingly efficient economy? Because that would involve the people who have disproportionate political and economic power handing over the tools of accumulation of that power to the people they spent considerable effort denying it to in order to accumulate it themselves. > Why doesn't the stock market act as a great redistributor of capitalistic wealth? Because that (at least, in the direction of redistribution you propose) is literally the exact opposite of its purpose.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- LarryDarrell 8y ago[Deleted]
- kolpa 8y agoPlease don't toss around stereotyping caricatures.
- Crontab 8y agoI think one of the biggest issues in Corporate America is that the pay of upper management is totally divorced from the pay of the common worker. Furthermore, upper manager is often incentivized to fuck over workers because of their preferred stock options. I am sure it has always been this way but I don't know if it has always been this unbalanced.
- ghosterrific 8y agoThe Fed pointing fingers after causing all the recessions and stealing from us via inflation. Something must be brewing, thst WE do not yet know about for the Fed to start blaming private enterprise. Prepare accordingly