10 ms·
> “Nobody had found any direct evidence for production of bread, so the fact that bread predates agriculture is kind of stunning,” says Tobias Richter, a Univer
by mirimir 8y ago
> “Nobody had found any direct evidence for production of bread, so the fact that bread predates agriculture is kind of stunning,” says Tobias Richter, a University of Copenhagen archaeologist who co-authored the paper. “Because making bread is quite labor-intensive, and you don’t necessarily get a huge return for it. So it doesn’t seem like an economical thing to do.” That’s because breadmaking doesn’t just involve baking: Back then, it would have also involved kneading, grinding cereals into fine grains, and dehusking plants.
But why would agriculture have developed, if people were't cooking the stuff? It's true that making bread involves more work than just boiling grain. But bread also serves as ready-to-eat storage. As does beer. And I can imagine how both developed more-or-less accidentally from leftover boiled grain.
- Isamu 8y ago> “Nobody had found any direct evidence for production of bread I think it is clear with this "flatbread" that we are seeing evidence for proto-pizza delivery. They may yet turn up what amount to coupons, perhaps as notches on sticks, or perhaps a receipt or change.
- rch 8y agoHow Beer Gave Us Civilization https://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/17/opinion/sunday/how-beer-gave-us-civilization.html https://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/17/opinion/sunday/how-beer-g...
- mirimir 8y agoThat's a great article, for sure. But back in the day, it's arguable that beer was mainly for grain preservation. It's very hard to get wasted on low-EtOH beer. Which is what early beers would have been.
- lostlogin 8y agoChicha in Peru seems to be up to about 3%, which isn’t strong but presumably you could get drunk without too much suffering.
- jacobush 8y agoEspecially if I have been off the stuff for a time, I get a real buzz from 3%. Given that they may have had it on an empty stomach too, I'd say, 3% is quite enough to be psychoactive.
- mrob 8y agoWhat evidence do you have for low alcohol content of early beers? Modern beers fermented with wild yeast[0] have roughly the same ABV as beers fermented with selectively bred yeast, and it's rare for modern beers to aim for the highest ABV the yeast is capable of fermenting. ABV is more commonly a consequence of how much you choose to dilute the wort. Higher ABV requires less fuel for heating the water, and results in a product that keeps better, so why wouldn't some early brewers produce it? [0] https://www.beeradvocate.com/beer/style/50/ https://www.beeradvocate.com/beer/style/50/
- soundwave106 8y agoAccording to one site I ran into (https://www.ancient.eu/article/1033/beer-in-ancient-egypt/ https://www.ancient.eu/article/1033/beer-in-ancient-egypt/), Egyptian beer was classified by strength or flavor. The typical "everyday" Egyptian beer would be roughly the same as typical sessionable beer today, 3-4%. Higher strength beers definitely existed, particularly for religious festivals or ceremonies. The article unfortunately didn't go into details, but this makes sense to me. It is actually pretty easy to make a strong mead (a more ancient alcoholic beverage than beer, and also present in Egypt) and a few references indicate that Egyptians fortified beer with honey or dates sometimes (which would serve mostly to increase ABV, in addition to adding a little flavor). (https://www.homebrewersassociation.org/zymurgy/pharaoh-ale-brewing-a-replica-of-an-ancient-egyptian-beer/ https://www.homebrewersassociation.org/zymurgy/pharaoh-ale-b...). So they certainly were capable of brewing stronger stuff; I have doubts that they went for the low-intoxicant "session beer" all the time.
- stevenwoo 8y agoThe bread as described in the article was made from relatively finely ground grain, so unlikely to be accidental, and the article references finds of similar flatbreads from just a few thousand years later at different locations.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y ago@mirimir wrote "And I can imagine how both developed more-or-less accidentally from leftover boiled grain." Not that this particular example was an accident from leftover boiled grain.
- mirimir 8y agoI'm not arguing that this bread was accidental, but that people may have noticed that partially burned leftover gruel was tasty. Also, it's arguably easier to grind leftover gruel than dry grain. Because it somewhat holds together. I know from wet grinding homemade black powder, but it's the same idea. Except for the not-exploding part, anyway :)
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoSomeone probably sent their toddler to go rub grain between two rocks to keep the toddler out of their hair while they butchered a goat or something.
- redtexture 8y agoMore likely, there were already thousands of years of experience with boiled grains and related processing of grains to experiment with, and notice the results of, including fermentation, baking, and other heat-related consequences of particulate and processed wheat grain. Just like the experience of fermented milk / yoghurt / cheese -- thousands of years of experience with the possibilities. Refrigeration is not comfortable to tent-dwelling nomads.
- mirimir 8y agoOatmeal fried with lots of butter, plus fruit and honey or maple syrup, is very tasty.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoBecause making bread is quite labor-intensive It's important to remember there is no evidence to suggest our 14,400 year-ago-ancestors had office / factory / workshop jobs to go to for 60 hours a week. Probably very little in the way of school or universities assignments to hand in by Friday. And they likely didn't have to pick up the dry cleaning or the kids on their way home. I'm going to propose that, probably, everything the ancients did was labour intensive. Predominately due to not having invented the powered machine yet.
- wavefunction 8y agoYou can gut and dress an animal quickly if you're practiced. Snares and stake traps paired with flushing animals doesn't take a lot of 'intensive labor.' We even have the ruins of catch traps in central Asia and other places that would have industrialized animal slaughter before agriculture was ever a thing. Agriculture was likely a required response to human degradation of formerly productive areas for hunter-gatherers due to over-taking of natural resources.
- civilitty 8y agoHunting was a predominantly male activity, though. If tribal structures got more efficient at child rearing "at scale" over time, more and more labor could be invested by the rest of the tribe into making food stuffs, tools, etc. beyond the usual options necessary for survival. This would allow them, for example, to develop food that lasts longer and makes it less risky for the hunters to go out longer - a helpful trait to survive natural variability in animal supply but one that requires free resources for experimentation and production.
- justinator 8y ago> Hunting was a predominantly male activity, though. Oh?
- King-Aaron 8y ago> Oh? If you have any information that goes against civilitty's comment there, I'd be interested to read it. I was always under the impression that in most hunter/gatherer cultures the men were primarily involved in the hunting.
- bane 8y agoYears ago I watched a documentary about Sago production in Papau New Guinea. It comes from a Palm tree that's cut down before the fruit ripens (otherwise all of the valuable starch gets used up ripening the fruit). The starch is contained in the core of the tree. A single tree can yield hundreds of pounds of starch, but getting it out of the tree and processed to get rid of the wood pulp and such is incredibly labor intensive. The starch is then cooked into various kinds of pancakes and other dishes to eat. Traditionally (and for all I know) the trees weren't farmed. Somebody just walked around until they found a suitable tree and then cut it down. So...hunting and gathering. But IIR, people track the growth of individual trees to make sure they're harvested at the right age, but they aren't specifically planted or cultivated in a "farm" sense. It's not a terribly different notion from what's being written about here I think. I would guess that humans have found starches of various kinds throughout their environment, extracted and processed them, and then made simple flatbreads or pancakes almost everywhere. It doesn't even have to be obvious. The line from palm tree to sago is not clear at all. Why even consider eating the core of a tree? Why invent a long, multi-part, labor intensive process to make it more edible? Nobody really knows how it started. But I think the important point I got from this was that agriculture is not a clean cut-off. You aren't digging out root vegetables one day and then planting wheat the next. There must be some kind of transition period that depends on the local plant life and many of the things that we think of as indicative of post cut-off agriculture societies probably aren't that at all. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CfGxm8canXg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CfGxm8canXg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VomE4GN9Z6I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VomE4GN9Z6I
- yesiamyourdad 8y agoWell, if you're starving, you'll try anything. If you survive, hey, that worked, let's do it again! People seem to lose sight of that fact: when you're faced with death, you'll try anything.
- jopsen 8y agoAnd we keep forgetting just how common starving to death must have been in prehistoric tribes..
- bayesian_horse 8y agoI don't believe bread is that much easier to store than grain. Easier to carry maybe. The problem about grain before agriculture was to collect it. The right conditions to make that feasible existed only in certain regions.
- vfc1 8y agoIndeed, they must have known that they could make bread out of wild grains before they even learned how to seed and harvest crops, otherwise, why would they have done in the first place? Wild grain would probably grow in the same place year after year, and the tribe would go back to harvest it even though they did not plant it themselves intentionally or irrigated the soil.
- weberc2 8y ago> But why would agriculture have developed, if people were't cooking the stuff? This was my intuition as well. And IIRC, wheat was naturally plentiful in at least some parts of the fertile crescent, such that people could bake bread without needing to farm it. In such places, heavy grinding stones and other artifacts were found which suggested that people had settled (they were far too heavy to be picked up and moved from place to place) because the region was so abundant.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThat surprised me really - aside from not knowing how bread sounds ideal to gatherers for condensing their finding into transportable and preserved bread. And they both do have a lot of time to kill too. The tools sound like a real obstacle given how fanatically low possession hunter gatherers are - doing things like flint knapping on demand tools instead of specialized tools. Perhaps gatherer divergence - they would need just a pot and maybe a vegetation cutter at most to be useful for gathering and cooking while hunters could need just things to kill and butcher their kills. Wood and stone both being grabbed in situ.