18 ms·
The argument of "increased collaboration" that I keep hearing is kind of negated when people have the soccer game on and you're bombarded with constant cheering
by tombert 8y ago
The argument of "increased collaboration" that I keep hearing is kind of negated when people have the soccer game on and you're bombarded with constant cheering, which is my current situation.
Even when soccer is over, you have to contend with people playing grab-ass all over the office, or jerks (like me) with annoyingly loud keyboards. The modicum of utility of me "jumping into a conversation" really goes out the window when I'm forced to wear headphones all day.
I really don't have a good way of measuring or fully quantifying how much less productive I am personally, but haven't there been a ton of studies that indicate anywhere between 1-1.5 hours a day is wasted per employee due to the open office? I assume that labor is the most expensive part of any big-ish company, so it feels like the "offices are cheaper" argument shouldn't work.
- commandlinefan 8y ago> bombarded with constant cheering At least it ends. I work in a gigantic "airplane hangar" open office with no noise barriers of any kind stretching out to infinity. Everybody around me is on conference calls all day, every day. They put their phones on speaker and then yell louder and louder to be heard over each other. One of them is even one of the Important People with an office with a door that closes... which he leaves open all the time anyway.
- WorkLifeBalance 8y agoGet any generic in-ear earphones and thread those under a pair of 3M peltor optime III ear defenders. You can listen to even fairly quiet music and you won't hear any conversations around you.
- thomk 8y agoThank you! I'm going to hunt for some 3M peltor optime III ear defenders on Amazon right now.
- Jaruzel 8y agoTbh, a good pair of 'closed back' full size headphones with noise cancellation would do just a good job (if not better musically) as wearing ear defenders over earphones.
- InitialLastName 8y ago...and probably be more comfortable. Which is something one doesn't think about until one is wearing headphones for 8 hours straight.
- your-nanny 8y agoI've used typical ear plugs plus headphones playing whitenoise.
- tomjen3 8y agoI consider a set of bluetooth headphones a part of any office now. I got a really good pair for personal use and work provided one set at work. Wouldn't be necessary if we had actual offices, but there you go.
- the_jeremy 8y agoAny passive, over-ear firearm hearing protection also works (and most are cheaper than $40).
- cimmanom 8y agoFinding over-ear gear that works well with glasses can be problematic, tho
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoLaser eye surgery is a fantastic choice as well, tbh.
- cimmanom 8y agoI've heard too many nightmare stories, even from people who went to the most reputable providers. Not gonna screw with my vision, thanks.
- pseudalopex 8y agoLaser eye surgery is a fantastic choice for many people, especially people who are nearsighted, under 40, and don't have any contraindications. It's less effective[1] and riskier[2] for farsightedness, and there's only so much it can do for presbyopia. It's also riskier for people who have autoimmune disorders, immune deficiencies, diabetes, or dry eyes. [1] https://www.la-sight.com/services/lasik/lasik-results/ https://www.la-sight.com/services/lasik/lasik-results/ [2] https://www.la-sight.com/services/lasik/lasik-explained/farsightedness-hyperopia/ https://www.la-sight.com/services/lasik/lasik-explained/fars...
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoIt's also great for correcting astigmatism. The nearsightedness that I got corrected was reasonably well managed by glasses, but my astigmatism was compensated for by my brain. I got noticeably more well-coordinated after laser eye surgery freed up visual processing ability this way, and I've heard other anecdotal evidence of this phenomena as well.
- loco5niner 8y agoI've done this. I have a whole collection of over-the-ear ear-protection. I can still hear my co-workers. It also made my tinnitus worse. Thanks though.
- telchar 8y agoYou could go the opposite route: good earplugs with good noise canceling over-ear headphones. The advantage of this over the other setup is that the minimum effective volume from music is lower, protecting against tinnitus. I had the same issues and found this setup works well for me. As an added bonus the obvious rigamarole I have to go through when a coworker taps me on the shoulder makes them more likely to send an email next time.
- kingbirdy 8y agoWhat's the difference you notice in the "earbuds + noise cancelling headphones" setup vs using the noise cancelling headphones to also play music?
- thfuran 8y agoearplugs + noise canceling headphones is better noise suppression than earplugs or noise-canceling headphones alone.
- telchar 8y agoI prefer the music to come from the headphones because my in-ear phones can be overly loud, even on the lowest volume setting on my phone. Having music coming from them hours every day had me feeling like I was damaging my hearing. With earplugs inside noise-canceling phones I still get two layers of sound isolation but have a layer of sound isolation between me and the phones, providing finer volume control so I can add just enough music to finish the job of drowning out loud people around me without hearing damage.
- loco5niner 8y agoThanks, I've tried this and it works slightly better. Can still hear noisy co-workers though. It seems the best solution is to not have loud people around.
- enraged_camel 8y agoI did this at my previous job and got in trouble for “trying to isolate myself from the team rather than making myself available.” Glad I got out of that hellhole.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoThis unfortunately doesn’t work because these types of over-ear sound blockers are extremely physically uncomfortable. I can’t get work done while wearing anything like that because it feels like my head is being squeezed. This is the big problem with headphones as a solution. You just trade sound disergonomy or physical discomfort, and it solves nothing. Like breaking your finger to distract from the pain of a gun shot wound. Combine it with the fact that managers have repeatedly told me that wearing earplugs is “rude” and it’s just more of the no-win optics that drive open plan offices in the first place.
- scaryspooky 8y agoHave you tried just closing his door for him?
- tomtheelder 8y ago> I assume that labor is the most expensive part of any big-ish company, so it feels like the "offices are cheaper" argument shouldn't work. This probably depends where you are. An open office plan might well let you use less than half of the square footage per employee, which in somewhere like Manhattan would potentially be saving you on the order of $5-10k per employee. Depending on how significant the productivity hit is, that might well be worth it.
- falcolas 8y ago$5-10k saved yearly to produce an unproductive $150,000+ employee... I don't think the scales are balanced even then. And, from personal experience, companies do it even when the cost per square foot is 1/10th of that of NY.
- stult 8y agoYeah, I'm on my phone so I can't do a full break even on this easily, but here's my rough estimate. If you're losing 1.5 hours of productive work per day, five days per week, and employees are otherwise productive 30 hours per week for 50 weeks out of the year, that's 375 hours per year out of a 1500 hour work year. That means for a $10k per employee rent savings, you lose more in wasted wages for anyone making over $40k per year. Even if we double the estimated productive hours per year, it still doesn't make sense for anyone making $100k or more.
- YouKnowBetter 8y agoThing is, it is different deparments that save and loose. The link will never be made in an organisation > 1000 people.
- bluedino 8y agoReal offices would have more furniture and such than a bunch of tables or even cubicles. Faster to deploy, wire, etc.
- bachmeier 8y ago
- antoineMoPa 8y ago"the soccer game on and you're bombarded with constant cheering, which is my current situation" You are lying, the game was yesterday. EDIT: I get the point, that was a joke.
- tombert 8y agoHa, yeah, fair point, I was just informed that it's almost over. Don't worry, there always seems to be more sports to watch. They'll probably move onto curling or something today.
- zeveb 8y ago> The argument of "increased collaboration" that I keep hearing is kind of negated when people have the soccer game on and you're bombarded with constant cheering Is there anything less professional than watching a game at work? I really don't get why people do this, and why they think it's okay. Granted, I don't like sports — but I like TV, and I wouldn't watch TV at work. I like computer games, but I wouldn't play computer games at work. It's just odd that sports fans think it's okay to distract people during work hours. At least pop off down to the pub or something.
- adrianN 8y agoDrinking alcohol at work? Taking out the Mulled Wine on Friday afternoons around Christmas is not too uncommon.
- tombert 8y agoI agree. When I suggested putting on a low-budget 50's monster movie on as background noise (e.g. Gamera, Godzilla, The Giant Claw, something that's amusing to look at for thirty seconds, laugh a bit, but not overly distracting), people act almost offended that I would waste company time like that. But if the TV has some form of ball on it, drop everything.
- beaconstudios 8y agothe important people in the office both get to dictate what's allowed, and are in my experience more likely to be extroverted/sports-watchy types. Thus they exploit their position to watch sports with the other important people and who cares what the nerds think/want.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tephra 8y agoHere's a recent story from our open office. We have a couple of mobprogramming stations with big televisions, each team has 1 or 2 of these so there are about 5 in a 20m radius from where I sit. When the first game that Sweden played all of a sudden 3 of the televisions are turned on and of course they are _not(!)_ in sync. So here I am trying to do some work with three TVs games all slightly delayed from each other, meaning one cheer turns into three. Now I work at a large newspaper and we sit 40m from the editorial staff so that adds to the background noise. To top it all of someone in the sports department thought it would be a good idea to @channel (usually reserved for "OMG the website is down what do we do!?") when some of the TVs stopped working (not really a job for the developers..). That just killed whatever positive things I used to think about open offices.
- hw 8y agocubicles wouldn't have helped in this case anyway, unless you're referring to an office where everyone has their own personal room
- chrisbennet 8y agoOMG, you need to run away from that place! Until I read that, the worst I’d ever heard was a friend who worked next to a slamming fire door. He had to wear hearing protection/ear muffs. Get this: he was the PhD physisist that did all the hard math coding for the company. He has a private office where he works now thank goodness.
- 0x445442 8y agoYeah and what kills me is how ubiquitous tellocomms are for multi-site corps. I can't tell you how many meetings I've been in where everyone was at their desk, headphones on and each was playing the mute/unmute game in order to not blast everyone else on the meeting with the surrounding noise. Then, given all that, you get the coworker two seats down Slacking you. If you're Slacking folks within 10 seconds walking distance then what's the point of being in the office at all. I think the ideal would be commuting to the office one day a week to take care of meetings which are more productive in person such as sprint planning, grooming etc.
- PietdeVries 8y agoThe thing is that this working-from-home people significantly impact the efficiency of your office. It's a trend (could be the open-office space started it) but resulted in people easily working 2 or more days from home. That implies that any desk you have is empty about 40% of the time. Or: your entire office is not being used for 40%... So when bosses realised they were throwing money away, they came up with the open office with flex-desks: no-one has a fixed place, you can sit whereever you want. And there are less desks than people. That can work out quite well (I work in such an office) but it depends greatly on ehtics or rules: no TVs with soccer games, no speaker-phone (but only headset) and rooms available for discussions or phone calls. And there is a general area (quite large) where you can drink your coffee and discuss the soccer matches or Tour de France results... For me it works, but I can imagine that without the requirements listed above it can be a cumbersome workenvironment.
- mlthoughts2018 8y ago“flexdesks” or “hot desking” is just about the most juvenile reaction to working from home I can imagine. If a company believes it will gain more from “saving money” on open plan offices or hot desking than it will from just paying more to facilitate more and better work from employees through buying the best tools (a private office is a tool like a keyboard or ergonomic chair), it’s self-evidently a company to get far, far away from. Consider “flex keyboards.” Management realizes that not all keyboards are in use all day, because people are in meetings, at lunch, etc. So nobody gets their own keyboard. You have to locate an unused keyboard at the times when you need to type. This is no different than “flex desks.” In both cases (keyboards, desks), the unit cost of providing the dedicated resource to the employee is trivial compared to far more pressing concerns, like producing working software to increase revenue, or bullshit executive compensation. Even real estate costs for private offices in dense urban areas are trivial by comparison.
- tzahola 8y ago>I'm forced to wear headphones all day. Didn't you know that you shouldn't use headphones in an open-plan office, because it prevents you from collaborating with others? /s
- phkahler 8y ago>> The argument of "increased collaboration" that I keep hearing is kind of negated... Yeah, they say it promotes more collaboration because you may overhear something where your input is relevant and join in. Or something like that. While that may be true, the increase in UNwanted distraction completely overwhelms any benefit. So then they tell us to be respectful of people around us and keep things quiet - we don't want people to overhear you. Wait wasn't that the point?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- watwut 8y agoWhat is "grab-ass all over the office"? I tried to google it to find whether it is expression, but got tons of porn as result.
- tombert 8y agoAh, sorry, it's a bit of local expression from where I grew up. People would say "grab-ass" when people are running/playing around and yelling like children at the office. It's not too uncommon for startups to have Nerf guns or something.
- tomjen3 8y agoThat does sound pretty awesome, but only in a room where you aren't working.
- watwut 8y agoGotcha, thanks. > people are running/playing around and yelling like children at the office. It's not too uncommon for startups to have Nerf guns or something. I hate this sort of environment combined with expectation to stay late. It always seems to me that if people would work instead of playing, we might not have to stay late. And that we are not working as much as we brag about, because people play a lot.
- tombert 8y agoI agree. I typically come in at about 9:15am, leave anywhere from 7pm-8pm, and it's not because I'm some great worker. It's because I need to finish up the sprint and too much crap is happening around the office. I don't know that I wouldn't work late even if I had a private office, but I do think that I'd be able to accomplish more.
- watwut 8y agoI found that when I am really working and focus on producing quickly, I get tired much sooner. As if, there us some max I can achieve during day, faster or slower. Of course then, I am tired also in the evening and that limits what I can do in the evening. (If I am too tired to code, I am also too tired to play logical game or learn something.)
- fsloth 8y agoThe increased collaboration angle is most likely bs. According to this study open offices do reduce face to face communications: http://rstb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/373/1753/20170239 http://rstb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/373/1753/2017... The only two rational factors why anyone would choose open office: 1. the floor space really is so expensive you can waste xx% of capital output of labour. 2. You inherit a dysfunctional organization or just a one you cannot trust, and want to "keep an eye" on everyone so they behave. Michael Bloomberg gave this rationale in New York. 3. Bonus round for hotdesking : You expect/have a fairly high churn rate. Why bother assigning people personal spaces since it's so much work to keep track of the facilities. Let the people find their own space. Besides, you might outsource xx% of your operations in near future so it's not like you plan on investing in long term team building. So, any linear combination 1,2 or 3 should suffice as an explanation. Any serious publication which praises open offices is likely a piece by a consultant who makes a living out of peddling said solutions and are offering political propaganda to make the employees less resistant. The most common irrational reason: You don't really have an opinion what consitutes a good working space but open offices seem to be trendy ("It's what the big boys are doing") and a consultant made you an offer to redesign your office space, so, why not.
- Florin_Andrei 8y ago> You don't really have an opinion what consitutes a good working space but open offices seem to be trendy ("It's what the big boys are doing") and a consultant made you an offer to redesign your office space, so, why not. I'm pretty sure the lemming see, lemming do explanation is one of the top actual reasons.
- fsloth 8y agoConsidering the high regard for fiduciary duty towards stock holders among corporate officers I would imagine it's stratified - company officers accept the financial rationale since it's explicitly affecting profits positively, while lower rung troopers might accept the political explanation of increased something something interaction as at least a plausible one.
- ConceptJunkie 8y agoI don't think any manager who chooses and open office plan because it's cheaper (and I'm betting that that is almost all of them) has considered, or cares about, the cost of reduced productivity. Otherwise it wouldn't be so common. But that's just my experience. I've found it's difficult to underestimate management.
- thatfrenchguy 8y agoIt's impossible to measure, and thus isn't data that is taken into consideration.
- hinkley 8y agoSabotage your employees and you don’t have to give them a raise. Win win!
- Zelphyr 8y agoMy previous employer and I had a conversation about the open office he wanted to set up in our new office space. I kept telling him it was a bad idea. He really wanted to encourage a "vibrant and collaborative environment!" I kept trying to tell him that what he perceived as vibrant and collaborative was his employees not getting any work done. Those generally weren't work conversations. They were jokes, catching up with life events, etc... Of course, he won. I wish I had this study to point to at the time. Since then I've heard they have installed what can only be described as rows of tables. They're not really desks. Just long rows of white tables where one row of employees faces another with an 8" glass divider between the two employees. You know; for privacy.
- kindatrue 8y ago>you have to contend with people playing grab-ass all over the office ??? Do you work at Sterling Cooper Draper?
- vlozko 8y agoYou forgot about Pryce!
- Spooky23 8y agoThat sounds like a workplace professionalism issue than a seating issue. If you want to watch soccer, take a vacation day.
- hw 8y agoI think it's less about increased collaboration but more about fostering culture and relationships between team members. Imagine a soccer team where everyone trains independently and only heads in to the office for video sessions. Teams with good culture, good bond between team members, often succeed (there's a particular sports team in the Oakland that is a good example).
- TimJYoung 8y agoWhat exact property of private office space prevents fostering a team culture ? At some point, people need to stop discussing and get something done, and that requires quiet, un-interrupted, work time.
- Florin_Andrei 8y ago> Imagine a soccer team where everyone trains independently and only heads in to the office for video sessions. Riiight, because soccer and office work are so similar! /s
- GordonS 8y agoIME it only fosters slowly simmering hatred of co-workers' irritating (and often noisy) foibles.
- IshKebab 8y agoAh yes the world cup - kills productivity for 6-10 hours every 4 years. Definitely worth changing office layout for.
- tombert 8y agoI think you might have missed my point; it's not about the world cup (or any ball-based sport you want to talk about) in particular. I'm complaining about the fact that <event x> can make people loud and therefore very distracting. I wouldn't suggest changing the office layout if I were only distracted by events every four years. I get distracted by events related to the open office every single day; the latest one just happened to be the World Cup when I wrote that.
- tssva 8y agoThe it is cheaper argument works because the savings are short term, easy to quantify and the person making the open office decision can easily claim credit for them while the costs are long term, hard to quantify and difficult to assign directly to the decision for an open office.