10 ms·
If you get a chance to visit a Smokejumper base, I highly recommend it. One of the things you learn is that everyone on the team is required to make all of thei
by legitster 8y ago
If you get a chance to visit a Smokejumper base, I highly recommend it. One of the things you learn is that everyone on the team is required to make all of their own equipment by hand. So all of these highly trained, ex-military guys spend days on end doing nothing but sewing clothes and packing parachutes. The reasons described:
- Cheaper than contracting out everything
- They have a better idea of the exact specifications they need for everything
- It instills a strong culture of self-reliance and trust (anyone has to be able to pack your parachute)
- It fills a lot of offseason downtime
My takeaway is that it makes a lot of sense to in-house your own tools - a lesson from outside of the software industry.
- Retric 8y agoThe San Franciso Fire Department is using wooden ladders due to an abundance of overhead power lines. Which I think is the core issue, use other peoples tools unless you have some critical and unique requirement.
- heartbreak 8y agoThey could buy wooden ladders, so I don't think that paints the whole picture.
- icegreentea2 8y agoArticle says they are one of two wooden manufacturers in California.
- Retric 8y ago> They could buy wooden ladders Can you point me to someplace selling 50' wooden ladders appropriate for firefighting?
- jdietrich 8y agohttp://alacoladder.com/fire-ladders/ http://alacoladder.com/fire-ladders/
- mkhalil 8y agoFor the right money, you can find the right ladder. It's not going to be cheap though, because you have to age the wood. I wonder if there is a way to age the wood to SF humidity/climate faster than real time. Just feels like there has to be.
- garmaine 8y agoPressure? But it’s going to be mighty expensive to build a pressure chamber that big.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoWhat pressure do they need, a length of pipe might do?
- jaggederest 8y agoNegative pressure might be more useful. Boil out the water under half an atmosphere, and replace the atmosphere with dried nitrogen and a chunk of desiccant. You'll probably damage the wood if you do that though. Now I want to try it in my vacuum chamber, but I'm not sure it'll hold vacuum for weeks/months at a time.
- madengr 8y agoSo I wonder why fiberglass ladders are not used?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- noer 8y agoHeat deteriorates fiberglass
- mdorazio 8y agoDo you have any data to detail this? Fiberglass is glass fibers + resin. Decent resin doesn't melt or become weak with normal heat, it just thermally stresses at some point (we're talking > 180C at which point a wood ladder would be on fire). Wood also has issues with heat - it expands, which can cause buckling and cracks. I'm trying to find fiberglass temperature-strength data to figure out why it's not used in fire ladders and am coming up short.
- mmagin 8y agoAs far as I can tell after some brief googling when I saw this article earlier today: 1. Fiberglass ladders tend to use polyester resin. 2. polyesters tend to have a glass transition temperature (i.e. where the polymer starts to become soft and lose its shape) in the 75 to 125C range. Wood combustion temperatures are typically about twice that. Also, incidental heat contact can char the surface of the wood and leave it mostly structurally intact.
- namibj 8y agoThe choice of resin can be accomodated, using polyamides as a matrix with suitable glass (some low-temperature types might not work), or with carbon fibers, should allow ~400°C/ 670K as a usage-limit. If it were to be coated with e.g. CVD SiO2 or something similar, it could have a pretty high reflectivity in the higher-temeperature thermal radiation range of light (where most of the radiation heat from a fire is in). The mentioned charring is a very important property in buildings, as solid (hard-)wood pillars have astonishing endurance in a full-scale fire, due to them smoldering slowly from the outside in, compared to e.g. steel framing that quickly softens throughout. One additional factor is evaporative cooling/associated covering with mostly inert water vapor due to the water contained in the wood and the water released from the cellulose fibers upon thermal decompositon.
- hinkley 8y agoI think the low yield strength of aluminum also plays a role here, as one guy mentions. But I’m surprised thermal conductivity didn’t rate a mention. There was a time when aluminum bikes were new but before the parts likely to bend were replaceable where many a bike owner had to buy a new frame due to misadventure. You can only bend aluminum once, then you’re done. When they started making cogsets with more than six gears they went with axles about half a centimeter wider, and you had a similar conversation. You can have the longer axles but you can’t change your mind after. They have to bend the stays slightly and there is no going back after that (and let me tell you, the mechanic got really quiet when they did the bend. You want to get it just right and every bike and every frame size is different. You pull until you feel the metal just start to give and just after that is your 5mm) Steel frames could often be rebent. But they’re heavier and they don’t like moisture. And their strength to weight ratio is only about the same as wood. Probably also bad options for firefighters.
- sleepydog 8y agoThere is actually a company that manufactures very high-performance bicycles out of hardwood: https://renovobikes.com/pages/why-wood https://renovobikes.com/pages/why-wood They cost a pretty penny, such that I would be afraid of losing or damaging them.
- sjg007 8y agoAlso bamboo bikes: https://booomers.com/ https://booomers.com/
- ghaff 8y agoThe other property of aluminum that is relevant for some uses (but likely not ladders for most uses) is that, unlike steel, it doesn't have a well-defined fatigue limit. Therefore, it can eventually fail after a large number of even relatively small loads that don't visibly deform the material. That's one of the main service limits on airframes.
- lsiebert 8y ago
- kwhitefoot 8y ago- a lesson from outside of the software industry. Not really, just a forgotten one. Fred Brooks described his ideal development team in The Mythical Man Month and it included a toolmaker.
- mathattack 8y agoThat was also written before there were many commercially available tools. (Still a great book!) Perhaps tool specialist is more important today?
- was_boring 8y agoI believe a toolmaker on a team is still critically important. I have yet to see a team or organization that doesn't have a suite of (often poorly maintained) custom tooling that automates things together or provides functionality critical to the business.
- hrktb 8y agoInterestingly the more critical these tools are, the less maintained they will be. They often fall in the middle of everything, and there is no set team to handle them (“everyone’s responsible”). Then as they’re critical, someone can’t just take half an hour to do a quick fix, it must be reviewed (and no one actively wants to review it, as it’s not trivial and not their job —- cf “everyone’s responsible —-). Plus anyone succesfully fixing them will be flagged as a potential maintainer when everyone else is running away. Internal tooling in software companies is a beast in its own.
- shitgoose 8y agothe toolmaking, that is being discussed here, is not generic, but very specific to the business. tool specialists today are probably even more important, because "we" (collective IT industry) became carried away with frameworks and lost ability to solve simplest problems by hand (the infamous 'leftpad' comes to mind; or was it rightpad?). writing small, targeted, fast code that solves specific business problem is the lost art now.
- BurningFrog 8y agoIt makes sense for a job where 95% of the time is spent waiting for an emergency to react to.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- enriquto 8y ago> a job where 95% of the time is spent waiting for an emergency to react to. this describes quite accurately the work of many people maintaining computer systems
- craftyguy 8y agoI must be maintaining the wrong systems, because over here 95% of the time is reacting to emergencies (some technical, but most fabricated by management)
- qop 8y agoFirst thing that came to my mind too! I've had two "Please call me, it's broke" calls just this morning!
- WJW 8y agoWhy does your manager know this before you do though?
- rurp 8y agoIt could be the case that nothing is actually broken. I have unfortunately received a number of similar calls on systems that were working exactly as specified. Random nonsense "disasters" can happen a lot in dysfunctional companies.
- sli 8y agoI would never in a million years, as a developer, give my personal phone number to a client. That's probably why. I get the same issue where I work. The client states that "everything is broken," but it often turns out that their own servers are down (or sometimes our API guys made a breaking change and I wasn't informed, but that's not common anymore). I find this stuff out when I get to work in the morning, because they certainly aren't calling me directly.
- PakG1 8y agoI remember reading in a Navy Seal's memoirs that when training to be a sniper, they were all responsible for making their own camouflage suits. The point being that when you're out in the open, you have to know how to make use of what's around you to camouflage yourself.
- JackFr 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghillie_suit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghillie_suit
- _bxg1 8y agoMy takeaway is that there are benefits to in-housing your own tools, not that everybody should. There's also a middle-ground available in the software industry: reading the code of the open-source tools you use. You can understand how your tools work without rebuilding them from scratch. Also, if you're using open-source (which most people do these days), the "cheaper" argument doesn't apply.
- hinkley 8y agoThose smoke jumpers aren’t making their own nuts and bolts, ropes, cloth, or felling their own trees. They’re making tools by assembly. Many of us work the same way. From what I understand every master craftsman has a small quantity of tools they either made themselves or at least modified to purpose. Tools with bits added on or ground off (eg, wrenches ground thin for tight spots, or magnetized). I class jigs as a separate category but I have no handy parallel for software.
- mike12345 8y agoA software equivalent to jigs, might be something like specialized project templates available in IDEs and the like.
- jmiserez 8y agoUtility functions and small self-contained libraries. Nice thing about software jigs is that copying them is free, so often they’re open-sourced.
- matwood 8y ago> From what I understand every master craftsman has a small quantity of tools they either made themselves or at least modified to purpose. I could argue editors we all use for coding are tools that we 'made' by assembly. My set of plugins and settings is different from the next person.
- ssdd 8y agoSituation here is of real world which is different from software world. Real world equipment can degrade/develop faults after use so its important to inspect them before each job(especially when risk associated are very high) which is possible only when person is familiar with equipment construction and building things yourself is the best way to get familiar with its mechanics.Whereas in software world, things don't degrade with use and we have option to automate inspection cheaply.
- igivanov 8y agoThere is one extremely good reason for packing your own parachute yourself.
- analog31 8y agoA related anecdote: There was for a long time, a history of students in certain disciplines such as physics and some areas of chemistry, making their own tools and equipment. My dad had to build an NMR as part of an analytical chemistry course. I built an exceptional amount of gear for my graduate research project. Of course there's the bit about using cheap labor. But a side result is that you have a chance of actually understanding how your tools work, which is beneficial when developing new tools or when the tools stop working.
- zrobotics 8y agoThat might have more to do with 1)students being cheap & 2)researchers often needing custom equipment that is unavaliable commercially. I know the justification given for undergrad chemists learning glassworking was the expectation that as professionals it would be a required skill.
- analog31 8y agoIt was for my dad. He was doing vacuum line work, so he pretty much had to do his own glasswork, because his requirements would change from one experiment to the next. Same as why a lot of scientists do their own programming. In my own case it was because instrumentation was the thing that I was ultimately interested in, and the expertise that I developed in grad school got me going in my career. The stuff that I built was on top of the roughly half million dollars worth of commercial equipment that I used.
- Bluestrike2 8y agoIt's called scientific glass blowing, and is a pretty interesting field that highlights some of what has to go on in the background for scientific research to progress. Some other reading: 0. https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/symbiartic/httpblogsscientificamericancomsymbiartic20110802we-blew-a-bubble-for-a-man-named-edison/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/symbiartic/httpblogssci... 1. http://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-caltech-glassblower-20160613-snap-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-caltech-glassbl... 2. https://news.usc.edu/114014/uscs-scientific-glassblower-lets-chemists-dreams-become-reality/ https://news.usc.edu/114014/uscs-scientific-glassblower-lets...
- krschultz 8y agoI do question this a little bit. One of my hobbies is racing sailboats, which doesn't have quite as exacting requirements as fighting wild fires, but it still requires specialized gear. I could not for the life of me make the splice required for a particular component on my last boat. It always looked good, but it inevitably failed after a few days of racing. When I bought one from an expert it would last for years. Craftsmanship matters and you just won't become an expert building exactly the number that you need for yourself.
- jaggederest 8y agoFor what it's worth, every rated parachutist packs their own parachute. For the reserve chute, it's always packed or repacked by an FAA certified rigger, which is an incredibly high bar by comparison. They must be repacked every 6 months. The estimate is that on average a parachute will fail one in a thousand times, mostly due to packing error, seldom due to equipment failure. Maybe 90/10 ratio. For a reserve, the expectation is that they would fail less than one in 10,000 times they are deployed. Which means that, collectively, avoidable errors should only happen one in every million or so rides on a parachute. This is less often than the real observed rate (1 per 75k or so), but errors other than packing or equipment failure are often the root cause.
- theoh 8y agoAccording to Wikipedia, it varies. Some organizations don't require the jumper to pack their own parachute. What does seem to be a common principle is that "All riggers are jumpers and can be asked at any time to jump with a parachute they have packed." or in the US military, that any rigger has packed, without knowing who. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parachute_rigger http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parachute_rigger
- jaggederest 8y agoYep. It's not really that you have to pack your own parachute, more that it's cost and convenience to do so, so it's pretty universal as far as I am aware. I'm not certified or anything but I've jumped a few times and that's what the 10k+ jumpers said at the time.