6 ms·
An Ex-Porter of AAA Games to Linux Talks about the Future of Linux Gaming
- preinheimer 8y agoIt's interesting to hear about the dynamics between the porting company and the original developer. As a mac user I'll agree with the statement "mac users are happy to pay for their port". I'm perfectly happy to pay for whatever is coming to mac, it just needs to work properly. When I do pay and the performance is crap I don't want to spend hours digging through forums while people point fingers at each other.
- nottorp 8y agoDunno, as a mac user I only buy cross platform games lately. I.e. those that have at least win/mac (preferably linux too) available in GoG or Steam. I would never consider buying just a Mac or just a Linux version. However, most AAA games are made with consoles in mind, so if i do want to play one, i'll get it for my PS4. It happens pretty rarely lately, though. Huge backlog of Mac indies to play, sorry AAA companies. About the Witcher 2, the performance on Mac (and I guess on Linux too) was crap on launch. And that's what most people who bought the game saw, because they didn't expect the ports and bought when the Windows version launched and dual booted. Whatever they improved, it was too late, everyone had finished the game by now. As for Witcher 3, I bought it but I only got like 1/3 of the way through it. Why? Because it only runs on Windows (I haven't tried Wine lately, so this may have changed) and rebooting to play a game is disruptive to all the stuff I run on the Mac OS side of things. That doesn't bode well for my chances of rushing in and preordering Cyberpunk, sorry CD PROJEKT. Edit: please no one explain to me how Macs don't have the hardware to run games, I hackintosh, have a proper video card and stuff like the ports of the Metro games work just fine(tm).
- ekianjo 8y ago> Because it only runs on Windows I finished Witcher 3 on Linux using DXVK. Not sure if it works on Mac (probably not), and it's not 100% perfect yet, but it is pretty good performance wise already.
- nottorp 8y agoDXVK seems to be Linux only. Might as well reboot to Windows then for less hassle. Problem is: out of sight, out of mind. I've kinda lost interest. Pretty sad, considering how enthusiastic I was on launch.
- sn0v 8y agoDo you have any Mac indie games to recommend? Ones that you've particularly enjoyed? Been outta the scene for a bit. TIA!
- nottorp 8y agoMost of the indies covered positively by the gaming press are cross platform so there are a bazillion options. Don't look at "mac gaming" sites. Look on the mainstream sites that favor indies (i read rockpapershotgun regularly, for example) and check if they have mac versions on Steam and GoG. Do not bother with the Mac app store, it's worthless for gaming.
- tapoxi 8y agoIt looks to me like Valve has been missing the boat constantly. They completely screwed up SteamOS/Steam Machines, haven't shipped a game in years, their current games have been essentially under maintenance mode, competitors have built their own storefronts/launchers that have caught up to Steam, they didn't react to obvious gaps with communication (Discord) and streaming (Twitch). They shipped SteamVR with HTC, which is cool! But you need a powerful PC, $800, and plenty of free space. There's no competition to the $200 Oculus Go. I guess the flat management structure isn't all that its cracked up to be.
- mepian 8y ago>haven't shipped a game in years The Lab was released in 2016, Artifact recently went to beta.
- tarboreus 8y agoI think the point stands.
- rcxdude 8y agoThe Lab is a VR demo, I would not call it a game.
- larrik 8y agoThat's technically "years".
- mepian 8y agoTwo years is not a large gap for a game company that employs ~300 people and allocates some employees to the development of hardware and Steam. Valve is not as big as Sony or even Nintendo, and a lot of people don't seem to be aware of that.
- cwyers 8y agoThe last game before Artifact other than some F2P stuff that they farmed out to places like Nexon (and The Lab, which was a pack-in tech demo) was Dota 2, which hit beta in 2011. Seven years is a large gap for a game company.
- onli 8y ago> What is especially ridiculous is that we keep seeing folks, in 2017 and 2018, repeating the same nonsense “Witcher 2 runs like crap”, which is completely false and a blatant lie at this point in time. The long tail of stupidity. Witcher 2 did indeed run bad on Linux the last time I looked at it, and that was many months after its release. It wasn't at 2 FPS anymore, but still only barely playable. I bet it still runs badly, I think my last test wasn't that long ago, but given the driver improvements since then I might be wrong. All that on a system where the game ran fine on Windows. I know nothing about whether the criticism was too heated, but if a linux port is released and does not run properly on user's systems, then complaints are to be expected.
- setzer22 8y agoI completely agree. There's something wrong with that port. With a machine that can run The Witcher 3 on high settings (on Windows), Witcher 2's port for Linux barely gets to 30fps on medium-low settings.
- ekianjo 8y agoI have a 970 and Witcher 2 runs constantly above 60fps on ultra settings. You sure you have tried it after the port was improved?
- onli 8y agoI think that goes to me as well... I dug a bit into my blog archive. My first try with Witcher 2 on Linux was just a month after its Linux release, I wrote down that the recommended fglrx driver worked worse than the free mesa driver, which in 2014 was a new experience. I was happy to see that I did not bash the developers at all, I was just a little bit disappointed, but happy about the improvements of Mesa. I also wrote that, at least at that time, only Nvidia was officially supported. I guess that explains why your experience was (is?) so much better. Also, the 970 is a very strong gpu for a game released 2014 on Linux and 2011(!) on Windows. But I definitely played it again not too long ago (trying to get all the achievements) and I stand to the statement that performance was bad, but I did not write down when that was exactly. But didn't I make some screenshots? Yes, with Steam, and the details reveal that playthrough was in 2017! But that was also with a Radeon (but a stronger one than the first try, I upgraded in the meantime). To be fair, I will download now and check the current FPS, but even it worked great now, the bad performance in 2017 makes clear that the vitriol expressed in the interview is wrong. They never made the game run great, at least not with AMD, and from what I read also Nvidia performance remained bad when compared to the Windows version.
- BanazirGalbasi 8y ago> The Linux bridges have been burnt for CDPR This phrase made me sad, but it's an understandable statement. The article mentions several times that the Linux community in general was very toxic when it didn't get its way, and this isn't the first time I've heard the sentiment. It seems to me that the sense of elitism that Linux-users (including myself) generally carry can be enough to turn people off from trying to assist us from outside the community, and I don't think I'm the only one who has come to that conclusion.
- TheCapeGreek 8y agoI've seen it too. I use macOS at work, troubleshoot my gf's Windows laptop and use Mint as my daily driver. I'm far from the elitist camp. But the sentiment against Linux is surprisingly large. I posted 2 reviews for Overlord and Overlord 2 just to warn Linux users that a camera bug that makes the game incredibly annoying to play is still present and I was met with comments that I shouldn't be bothering to play on Linux. If the developer offers that support, should I not report issues with the port? I don't follow that logic. I didn't pass any judgement on the game itself, but couldn't really give a positive recommendation. For now, I value the lack of Linux ports for some items because I know the barrier to get it working on Wine (not always doable) will limit me and force me to get back to other, more valuable pursuits. Can't just game all the time as much as I'd like to at times.
- Yizahi 8y ago> Linux wasn’t really ready either, with the poor AMD driver situation amongst other things. AMD APU’s would have been the ideal platform for a console Is there any practical difference for applications whether GPU is outside or on the CPU chip? Any major difference in drivers?
- pjmlp 8y agoLots of them, because it affects how data flows between CPU and GPU. For example, dedicated GPUs usually can't make use of shared memory. On the other hand, shared memory has slower access rate, meaning integrated GPU with it cannot be as faster. This is just one difference, there are others.