9 ms·
Utah voting system fending off 1B hacking attempts per day
- ChuckMcM 8y agoIt is an interesting data point, and it makes me wonder if we can use this as a side channel attack to figure out who the hackers "like" and who they "don't like" running for office. Might give us more insight into the hacker's goals.
- drfuchs 8y agoTitle should say “fending off”.
- dang 8y agoFixed now.
- Blackstone4 8y agoWhat are they including in the metrics? Are they including SSH port scanning and attempts on port 22?
- raverbashing 8y agoAnd attempted accesses to /wp-admin.php ? (you get those regardless of the technology on the backend, a lot of malicious vuln. scanners around test for that)
- lihaciudaniel 8y agoI think Drupal would be better for government websites.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoI think the point was that you get attempts on /wp-admin.php even if you're not running wordpress at all. I mean, my personal blog is a static collection of HTML pages and I still see /wp-admin.php in logs. In fact, I've long wondered whether this isn't a great opportunity; I'd like to make a script that went through logs and got every IP trying to access such a path, and adds those IPs to a blacklist that gets dropped at the firewall. Not even a honeypot (since they try even when there's nothing there at all), but still a way to catch (really stupid) bad actors / compromised systems.
- tetha 8y agoThat's called fail2ban, and you're describing a custom filter.
- hueving 8y agoCareful, because of nat that's also a way to ban potential legit users.
- mcny 8y agoI started commenting but I deleted everything half way because I hadn't thought about public WiFi access points. I remember we used to do temporary IP bans on the English Wikipedia if there was too much abuse but it was only for editing. 4chan bans are also for posting afaik. I don't know of a blanket refusal to connect ban for a web server. Would it be ok to ban an entire IP just because someone from that IP has a compromised machine? I remember this argument that if there is obviously malicious traffic coming from an IP address, the right solution is to block traffic at the next stop, usually the ISP supplying Internet access to that connection. Failing that, the back end should disconnect the ISP and failing that, the other peers should disconnect from the malicious peer. But I don't know how practical it is...
- civility 8y agoMy guess is they're including requests for / A billion "hacks" per day seems a bit far fetched. At that point, it's either a visible act of war (if external to the US) or the FBI would be much more involved (if internal). Both of those would be much larger news.
- dylanhassinger 8y agoRussia/NKO/China have been at digital war with USA for years
- saagarjha 8y agoSure, but that doesn’t change the fact that this is likely just people going through a dictionary trying to guess the password, rather than a cyberattack by a nation-state.
- wavefunction 8y ago>people going through a dictionary trying to guess the password, rather than a cyberattack by a nation-state. Russia allows its cyber-criminals free-reign when it comes to the rest of the world, as long as they're not interfering with official interests. Consider the difference in Letters of Marque vs the Admiralty in British history.
- orbitingpluto 8y agoWouldn't it be a good estimator to include ANY connections coming outside of Utah? I hope that whoever is attempting to hack the Utah voting system has no nefarious purpose greater than changing "Mitt" to "Mittens.
- CleanCodeCraft 8y agoOr outside the United States. You would think that they could somehow use geo-fencing that correspond to the districts that are under consideration. Rather than going back to paper counting some form of key-based two-way encryption that verifies voters within the state would be useful and more secure.
- tzahola 8y agoProbably the data on these “hacking attempts” was compiled by the same people who reported healthcare.gov being 500 million lines of code.
- xeeeeeeeeeeenu 8y agoWhat does "hacking attempt" even mean? I smell FUD.
- User23 8y agoSadly I smell FUD virtually every time a security engineer opens his mouth. Yes there are some great ones, but I’ve never worked with one directly. Part of my skepticism is rooted in the prevalent ignorance of basic computing theory. If you can’t define the operational semantics of a system then you can’t rigorously convince yourself or anyone else that it is “secure.”
- andrewflnr 8y agoHonestly, a lot of systems have enough low-hanging fruit that formalizing the semantics is probably not worth it. Can people outside this small list get a shell on your server? Then it's not secure. Let's start there.
- User23 8y agoThat’s a well said example and actually very easy to establish formally by complementation. I don't really care if Hoare notation, the predicate calculus, or even English is the language of choice, so long as the argument is rigorous. That said we all know how difficult avoiding ambiguity is in English, so I wouldn’t choose it except for the broad strokes.
- throwawayjava 8y ago> If you can’t define the operational semantics of a system then you can’t rigorously convince yourself or anyone else that it is “secure.” Well. This means no one can provide any security guarantee for any remotely realistic system because no modern stack has a completely understood&formalized operational semantics. But I definitely know that some systems are much more secure than others! So this seems like a situation where perfect is very much the enemy of "1000x better than it could've been". Furthermore, formalization is "above and beyond" best practice, so you're unlikely to be accused of negligence if you do "better than best practice but still not formalized". Finally, the original claim is not true. There are many systems with non-operational semantics that are useful for proving security properties. And sometimes no semantics is needed at all for large swaths of the system. Sandboxing is an excellent example of the latter. For some very reasonable attacker models, you need an operational semantics for the sandbox but don't need an operational semantics for whatever's running inside the sandbox in order to provide fairly strong security guarantees.
- tedunangst 8y ago11500 per second.
- TomK32 8y agomodems are getting faster and faster...
- king_nothing 8y agoIf they have such hacking attempts, console access should be gated by a jumpbox that SSH/ipsec secured by SPA portknocking. For external services, have transparent proxies with deep SPI/IPS and IP acls out in front.
- danielhlockard 8y agoPort knocking is security by obscurity. How about a VPN like a real company.
- azinman2 8y agoGoogle famously ditched VPNs because you can’t trust the inside networks either. https://www.blog.google/products/google-cloud/how-use-beyondcorp-ditch-your-vpn-improve-security-and-go-cloud/amp/ https://www.blog.google/products/google-cloud/how-use-beyond...
- gray_-_wolf 8y agoSure but it still adds another layer.
- aw3c2 8y agoOf course 1,4 billion chinese hackers plus + 150 million russian hackers can pull of less than one hack attempt per day!!!!!!! sigh.
- jlmorton 8y agoIf there is no online voting, why is the system even connected to the Internet? What exactly are the attacks against? The voter registration site? The election results site?
- bschilke 8y agoFrom what I understand the greatest vulnerability is modification of voter registration data. If you show up to vote and they don't have you in that district's voter rolls because your address was changed to another state, your vote has just been taken away.
- zaroth 8y agoThere’s such a thing as a provisional ballot. For all the studies that show voter fraud is not prevalent and a complete non-issue, we can say even more certainly that “election hacking” is an even more egregious smoke screen.
- jlmorton 8y agoIf this is the case, it begs the question why voter registration data is directly connected to the Internet. Yes, we want to allow online registrations and modifications, but surely we could have a batch process to make changes to the canonical source, with a signed log of changes.
- hrktb 8y agoCould you clarify how you would see these batch data transfered outside of the internet ? We are speaking of dispatching that data to every single voting stations, set in schools, small town offices, etc. Most "secure" solutions (private lines, central update and physical dispatch of the machines days before the elections, etc) seem difficult and/or crazy costly to me.
- krrrh 8y agoHow can the cost of securing these systems be less than the cost of using a fully paper system?
- fooker 8y agoYou can use the same argument for banks.
- greglindahl 8y agoThe number of transactions in voting and at banks are pretty wildly different.
- fooker 8y agoIt doesn't have to be. If online voting ever becomes widespread, there is a reasonable chance there will be more votes and referendums.
- pessimizer 8y agoThere would be a absurd cognitive overhead for people to have to study and prepare an opinion for as many votes as they have financial transactions. Every other productive activity in the US would grind to a halt.
- fooker 8y agoWhy would polls like : Do you want a bridge built here? Yes, No, Don't Care. be a cognitive overhead?
- danso 8y agoThe California voting guide for June 2018 is 96 pages long: http://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/pdf/complete-vig.pdf http://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/pdf/complete-vig.pdf The info associated with each ballot measure is considerably more extensive than you seem to realize.
- erentz 8y agoThat number is insanely high. Are they talking about all voting machines being connected to the internet? Or is it some back office set of systems? For the life I me I don’t know why voting machines and voting systems need to be connected to the internet. It’s just a flat out unnecessary risk. That’s not to say that they shouldn’t be built so secure you could connect them to the internet. But nothing is perfect and unnecessary risks should be avoided with such an important system. Which is probably why we should be using paper ballots and scanners with results called in from the regional counting centers. And manual count available then as much as needed or desired post election night for verification. This rush to electronic voting boggles my mind.
- propman 8y agoPaper ballots, no machines and especially no machines connected to the internet...if we were able to get that crazy bug into Iranian nuclear reactors without direct transfer from Internet, then you can bet North Korea, Russia, Israel, and China will pour billions to do the same thing. Voting ID cards too, though I admit I don’t know enough about that. Even if it costs billions to get it done, confidence in fair and free elections is the cornerstone of our democracy.
- jadedhacker 8y agoThe first is a good idea, but the second is not. Voter ID cards are historically used to make it harder to vote and thus compromise elections. In person fraud is very uncommon, and it would be very difficult for a foreign government to pull off a large scale interference without being detected. After all, we struggle to get people to show up to vote once already! The idea of mass ballot fraud seems difficult to countenance without literally paying masses of people to vote (which I believe is extremely illegal). EDIT: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/597 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/597 EDIT 2: If you want to see real foreign interference, check out that time that Bill Clinton publicly aided the election of Boris Yeltsin. https://www.nytimes.com/1996/02/23/world/russia-and-imf-agree-on-a-loan-for-10.2-billion.html https://www.nytimes.com/1996/02/23/world/russia-and-imf-agre...
- erentz 8y agoRight. The hysteria around double or fraudulent voting is crazy. You’d need thousands of people doing it in most districts to have any impact, and that would get obvious really bloody quickly. I think this is a pretty good example of what I find to be the typical of an American practice of cutting off their own nose to spite their face. [1] Americans absolutely hate the idea of freeloaders or someone getting something they don’t deserve that they would rather make everything in life more complicated, less efficient, and harder on everyone (including themselves) than allow a little bit of inefficiency in the system to be accepted as the trade off. In this case it’s the hysteria around a few cases of voter fraud out of hundreds of millions, so they’d prefer to see a system enacted in which tens of millions of voters will be disenfranchised. Silly and out of proportion. [1] this doesn’t seem to be the saying I want for this situation but I couldn’t think of a more appropriate one.
- perlgeek 8y agoIf this were true, and the error rate in defending was only 0.00001%, it would still be hacked several times a day. What's the lowest error rate you have ever seen in a practical security product?
- amelius 8y agoBut what if all the hacking attempts are coming from basically the same software, trying the same thing over and over again?
- zemnmez 8y agoto put this in perspective, this is one-quarter of Google's global search traffic, in hack attempts. 'hack attempts' are always bullshit but this is especially impressive
- not_kurt_godel 8y agoGoogle isn't going to count port scanning and other such malicious activity in their global search traffic metrics. It's very possible that such traffic is more prevalent than legitimate search traffic by orders of magnitude. I have personally operationally managed sites which are only very moderately high profile and yet still receive a constant stream of malicious requests from foreign IPs pretty much 24/7 even with aggressive, proactive & reactive firewalling in place. The costs to execute such tasks are negligible for a nation-state. To be honest I'd be more inclined to believe the numbers are real and that you're posting this comment as an agent of a belligerent nation-state trying to spread mininformation than the other way around (though I sincerely do hope you are posting in good faith and are just naive).
- chiefalchemist 8y agoFrankly, 18 feels low. I would expect the number to be 10x or even 100x that.
- woogley 8y ago1B (one billion), not 18
- chiefalchemist 8y agoOH. Oops. Where are my reading glasses :)
- gault8121 8y agoIt's 1 billion.
- chungy 8y agoI made the same error in reading the link text (which is not representative of the article linked to). It's rather a dumb way to abbreviate one billion.
- tlrobinson 8y ago"1B hacking attempts" is, of course, incredibly vague. It could be 100 sophisticated groups using their 1B 0-days, or one dude running a script on repeat.
- g0dg0d 8y agoWhy would a voting system even need to be online?
- azernik 8y agoDepends what you mean by "voting system". Individual voting machines rarely are - they're usually air-gapped, read the ballot from a physical memory card transported by sneakernet from administrative offices, and write vote totals back to those cards for sneakernet transmission to same offices. However, those central locations use a lot of internet-connected machines, mostly to communicate their numbers to outside systems. The computers that program the ballot descriptions pre-election (a vector for attacking voting machines) are also usually internet-connected - they're plain old desktop workstations of some elections official. Air-gapping those systems is probably doable, at a minor loss of convenience, but there is a reason they're internet-connected.
- _bxg1 8y agoGeez, just like... Give the voting software its own isolated network, and for external reporting force somebody to dump the results to a flash drive before uploading them to the web. I'm not even a security expert, but maybe I could get a job as one working for the US government.
- foota 8y agoTranslation: 1 billion Brute Force ssh attempts rejected
- 086421357909764 8y agoSo much this, yes i'm sure people were attempting to scan it up but I guarantee you could show the same for almost every network out there. I understand the fear mongering to a degree but its projecting things in the wrong place and it's almost like crying wolf.
- ddingus 8y agoVote by mail works, is efficient and easy. Autoregister on State ID or Drivers License. Online party management. Signature validation, collected at registration. Voters can mail it, use a drop, or vote in person at an elections office. My favorite is voting parties. Everyone brings ballots, talk abot the options, vote, eat, smoke, drink, done.
- _bxg1 8y ago...how are these systems not airgapped?
- prolikewh0a 8y agoSo the status quo can stay in power.
- cmurf 8y agoI encourage all citizens who typically do not vote, to vote your conscience, and then lie. Already no one expects you to vote anyway, so just lie per their expectations and say you didn't vote. That way you don't have to justify or argue your choice any differently than you have in the past. Yes it's a bit chicken s* but so f'n what? You don't actually owe anyone an explanation anyway, but you're entitled to vote. So just get on with it, and lie. Everyone is lying about something or other anyway and this kind of lie is pretty benign. And it's in the public good that you vote even if you don't like arguing about why you voted the way you did.
- ilovetux 8y agoI don't get it. If these systems are not air-gapped then that is gross negligence. There is absolutely no reason that these systems are exposed to the internet.
- pietroglyph 8y agoIs there any reason for a voting system to ever be connected to the internet? (I assume this system is, because I can't think of any other attack vectors that enable the reported volume of "hacking attempts".)
- masonic 8y agoWhy is their voting system (as opposed to voter registration) even publicly accessible outside of election cycles?