8 ms·
> People are more important than profits. That's not absolutely true. People lives have a value, around $10M for US transport. It means that if the cost of pot
by GuB-42 8y ago
> People are more important than profits.
That's not absolutely true. People lives have a value, around $10M for US transport. It means that if the cost of potentially saving one human life is more than $10M, it isn't worth it, as in, there are more important things to do with that money, including improving safety in other areas.
Now profits are important too. Companies need money. That's how they pay their employees, do R&D, stuff like that. If they don't make money, employees will get fired, and they won't be able to develop new, better and potentially safer planes. For airlines, they may be forced to make tickets more expensive or lower their standards to compensate for the costs of planes that don't fly. Talking about shareholders, you may be a shareholder too if your savings include Boeing stocks. Less profits has an avalanche of undesirable effects. Some of them affect the 1% but the majority of it make things slightly worse for the 99%.
- drb91 8y agoIt’s not at all clear flying an unsafe plane is necessary to make a profit.
- vulnan 8y agoSafe and unsafe is not a binary. Any plane is unsafe for certain values of unsafe. Any plane is safe for certain values of safe. There is always a tradeoff, and there is always an acceptable risk, whether you are Boeing or a normal person deciding whether to drive, bike, or take the bus to work.
- bobthepanda 8y agoThat's why we have regulators to determine acceptable risk. Companies left to their own devices would make the margin ridiculously small.
- drb91 8y agoAn acceptable risk for boeing is not an acceptable risk for society. This is the whole point of regulation.
- mehrdadn 8y ago> Safe and unsafe is not a binary. You could make it a reasonable binary if you define unsafe as "has known bugs that could lead to deaths", which is what the top comment was doing. Not sure if any already-in-use planes satisfy that criterion though.
- nradov 8y agoWhat about the unknown bugs that could lead to deaths? I guarantee that every modern aircraft has some. But we don't know how many.
- mehrdadn 8y ago> What about the unknown bugs that could lead to deaths? I wouldn't include that since it wouldn't be useful. In any case it clearly wasn't included in whatever definition the top commenter intended.
- slededit 8y agoYou would be incentivizing them to not look very hard as finding a bug would ground the fleet and be extremely expensive. The same way a lawyer will tell you never to see if your violating a patent lest you pay treble damages for "knowing".
- zaroth 8y agoThere are a vast number of “known bugs that could lead to deaths” in these devices. But when the bug is known to be hit only is astronomically slim scenarios, they don’t rework the entire stack to eliminate it because, well perhaps it is more likely to cause more harm than good?
- mehrdadn 8y agoMaybe it depends on what you'd call a "bug". Even a flip-flop always has a nonzero probability of failure via metastability, but I wouldn't classify every system that uses a flip-flop as "buggy". Though to be honest now I'm not really sure what a consistent and useful definition of a "bug" is, if it's even clear and noncircular. (Maybe the best definition is "has a failure mode unaccepted by the users"? Not sure.)
- yarrel 8y agoThis is a misapplication of a morally bankrupt argument. That money cannot be spent elsewhere to save lives by Boeing in an area that is regulated by the FAA at the FAA's instruction. So, yes, $10 million could be spent on education to prevent people making the argument that $10 million could be better spent on letting people be killed, thereby saving countless lives. But that's not what the question is here, and to pretend that it is represents a deeply bogus rhetorical move.
- noja 8y agoWait what? With your reasoning we could leave those Thai schoolchildren in that cave. We are not arguing that money spent on wars are wasted and that same money should be better spent on lowering heart disease, we are talking purely about increasing profit.
- drewblaisdell 8y ago> Wait what? With your reasoning we could leave those Thai schoolchildren in that cave. In order to save more lives that can be saved more cheaply, yes.
- jsmthrowaway 8y agoWell, the meme isn’t that far off. This community is starting to sound like the Soviet Union. Did everyone read that thread this morning and take it as a challenge or something? It’s not a goal to which to aspire. These are lives you’re talking about here, kids, kids that happen to be currently sharing the same planet as you. Human beings are not figures on a balance sheet, and I lament anyone’s soul that would dispute me on that point. The pillars of this community sit on billions and get hospitals named after them, but some brown kids in a cave are a theoretical exercise to think about economics? They have memories. Families. Hopes. Should we debate your worth? What’s the figure where you are no longer considered worthwhile? If I can’t meet you on something as fundamental as every life is worth saving, we simply aren’t having the same conversation, and I’ll be honest, your side gives me pause. And I see it far too often among people here who simply consider themselves pragmatic. Many throughout history have convinced themselves of their pragmatism, and we have all paid for it for centuries. What unfortunate times to live in where the scions of high tech debate the value of individual lives in a far flung part of the world. This thread should disgust.
- drewblaisdell 8y agoYou are misreading me and the poster above. I was simply explaining what he meant and why it could be seen as rational. The issue is really not as simple as you describe. Of course every life is worth saving, especially the lives of children. However, given a finite set of resources, would you rather save more or fewer children? The amount of money that goes into a long shot at saving a child with terminal cancer in the US would provide clean water and mosquito nets for many children in sub-Saharan Africa. Am I saying that we should enforce this reallocation of resources? No. But I am saying that it is complicated. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism
- mstade 8y agoSure, life’s worth about $10M – makes sense. Till it’s your life.
- msla 8y agoUnless you wrap yourself in gauze and never leave the house, you've effectively put a value on your own life that's far less than $10 million.
- nradov 8y agoSocial isolation is a risk factor for early death, so even staying in your house is dangerous.
- GuB-42 8y agoThat's statistical. A close approximation of how we value our own life would be the value of a micromort (1 in a million chance of death). According to Wikipedia people value one micromort of their own life at around $50 (inferred by how much they want to pay for safety features). So if I am average, I would probably value my life at around $50M, so yeah, you are right, though maybe not in the way you intended. Still, it is difficult to make sense of comparisons between our own perception of the value of life and how much we actually value it based on our actions. The expenses on safety when chances of death are low is only one aspect.
- owenversteeg 8y agoHuh, that wikipedia page is very interesting. Pretty weird how the UK values a mort at 1.6MM and the US at 7MM. Also, the page on Microlife is great. Wish it was longer!
- mmt 8y ago> Pretty weird how the UK values a mort at 1.6MM and the US at 7MM I think you misread. It's 2.6 and 6.2 (in millions of USD) You might also find that it's not so weird in that this valuation is not general but specific to road improvements. It could be explained by the relative prevalance of road fatalities, which would skew the relative political importance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-related_death_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r... Note that traffic fatalities per 100k of population are 2.9 for the UK and 10.6 for the US.
- mannykannot 8y agoThere is no evidence that this particular variance is being requested in order to improve safety elsewhere.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoIf they believe the 787 is, on whole, safer than the planes they're replacing, arguably the case could be made the variance is requested for the best safety for consumers. Not that I'm qualified to answer whether or not that's the case here, but it's arguably something the FAA would need to consider.
- mark-r 8y agoThey'd have a really hard time making that case given the proven track record of the existing fleet.
- ggg9990 8y agoIf it’s government money it makes sense to save $10m here to apply it there (in theory). But when it’s Boeing’s money it makes no sense at all. Boeing isn’t going to take the $10m they’re not spending and put guardrails on dangerous highways.
- Johnny555 8y agoIt's not really Boeing's money, they aren't a charity, any increase in the price of an aircraft gets passed on to airlines (and from the airlines to passengers) If unlimited safety improvements are required without regard to cost, it could drive the cost of the aircraft so high that airlines can't afford to upgrade, so they keep their older fleet in service for longer. Which works for a while, but airframes do age and need to be retired.
- nollbit 8y agoThat's only true if Boeing was the only manufacturer that builds this category of planes (they are not). Boeing has an issue in their planes that the A350 doesn't have. So if the price of 787's goes up because it needs to go from unsafe to safe, then airlines can buy A350s instead.
- bcatanzaro 8y agoOr they can buy the 787-10 with the Rolls Royce engine that is already certified. (Check out the article!) In this case, the problem is with the engine, not with the plane, and the alternative engine is already approved and in service.
- mikeash 8y agoSmaller increases in cost also result in some passengers choosing alternate modes of transportation (for example, driving) which are invariably less safe.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoIt's airline money and thus passengers' money. I'm perfectly happy to accept a higher risk if I can save a few bucks. It's like buying a used car.
- joe_the_user 8y agoNow profits are important too. Companies need money. That's how they pay their employees, do R&D, stuff like that. If they don't make money, employees will get fired, and they won't be able to develop new, better and potentially safer planes. Wow, I'd have a variety of responses to this remarkable post. Obviously, safety regulations should allow for the profitable production of planes and they clearly do, the rest should be up to the plane manufacturer. Now, profits as such aren't what creates jobs as such. Rather it's the productive use of capital - a patent troll making a mint creates zero jobs for example. Now, if a particular form of investment doesn't create jobs one place, it should be able to create them elsewhere. Guaranteeing profits in one sector has many pernicious effects, often including a lack of job growth rather than the reverse. Just as much, the profit/safety equation is more complex than "more profits, more safety spending" (to say the least). For example, if safety regulations can always be ignored for profits, plane manufacturers will build less safe planes over time. Finally, a management which responds to not being able to produce a new, unsafe design by making their present line of planes unsafe by "lowering standard" should be looking at jail time.
- skookumchuck 8y ago> if safety regulations can always be ignored for profits, plane manufacturers will build less safe planes over time. Would you fly on an airplane that had a reputation for crashing? Me neither. Crashing airplanes is very, very bad for profits.
- joe_the_user 8y agoWould you fly on an airplane that had a reputation for crashing? Me neither. Crashing airplanes is very, very bad for profits. Would you bet your life that reputation alone was enough to keep an airliner from crashing? We know right now airlines shave every possible extra cost to achieve the lowest prices because passengers are very price sensitive. Even more, right now a lot of people don't know they're flying on any number of regional airlines, some of which may have terrible reputations when they fly "United express" [1]. Consider that one of those airlines beating a passenger to get them off the plane didn't change the situation. Of course, now we have safety standards rather than just reputation preventing crashes, which seems like the appropriate thing. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Express https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Express
- everybodyknows 8y agoQuite right. Yet it's something of a taboo to speak of that reality. Boeing people in particular know well just how thin-skinned a public in deep denial can be. Back in the 2000s, a manager uttered the words "torture flights" in a private corporate meeting. Within days his words were leaked to the populist press by rivals within the bureaucracy. Boeing higher-ups dealt with the ensuing firestorm by disposing of the truth-teller.
- jessaustin 8y agoI hadn't heard of this one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohamed_v._Jeppesen_Dataplan,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohamed_v._Jeppesen_Dataplan,_....
- Taniwha 8y agoemployees are not paid from profits
- w-ll 8y agoThis has been an interesting thread, and has made me think about my own morals and beliefs. But I wanted to add that your post very much reminds me of something Jean-Baptiste Zorg [1] from The Fifth Element would say [2]. 1: http://fifth-element.wikia.com/wiki/Jean-Baptiste_Zorg http://fifth-element.wikia.com/wiki/Jean-Baptiste_Zorg 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UkFAcFtBD48 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UkFAcFtBD48