10 ms·
FAA pushes back on Boeing exemption for 787 safety flaw
- ars 8y agoThe FAA is right not to approve this. How can Boeing think they can ship this without knowing what the bug is?
- Firerouge 8y ago6 months to a year and a half before Boeing thinks they'll have a software patch... That seems silly long
- tspike 8y agoSafety critical software is a different ballgame.
- taneq 8y agoThis isn't a matter of just tweaking some code, running your test suite and having someone buddy your check-in. Once they've identified the bug and come up with a solution they probably have to fly an airliner around for a while, deliberately trying to break it, to confirm that it worked.
- briandear 8y agoThat seems extremely quick in this sort of space. This isn’t fixing a bug in a shopping cart or some “silly” web app. This is code upon which millions of lives will ultimately depend.
- Cerium 8y agoSafety critical software has longer lead times than other software. There are often code coverage requirements, code review requirements, and extensive automated and human testing cycles. Edit: I gave you an upvote since this is an area that people should try to learn more about.
- semerda 8y agoAgreed. I would have expected 3m. I have a feeling they are also busy with a ton of other issues. The Q is whether this is top priority or not in light of all those other issues and it's chance of occurring.
- xn122 8y agoThree months is very little in software. If formal verification is required (as I hope), it is very difficult to do that under time pressure.
- tivert 8y ago> 6 months to a year and a half before Boeing thinks they'll have a software patch... That seems silly long IIRC, SQLite is flight certified...which means that they have to show that every machine code branch is tested by their test suite [1]. This stuff is not developed with the same lax processes as "move fast and break things" web apps. [1] From some Youtube talk by one of the lead SQLite developers.
- massel 8y agoI would _love_ to see that talk if you can dig it up - SQLite's stability story is fascinating.
- santix 8y agoHe mentions it here: SQLite: The Database at the Edge of the Network with Dr. Richard Hipp - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jib2AmRb_rk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jib2AmRb_rk
- technofiend 8y agoWhile working at NASA on code related to the Space Shuttle I once found a piece of Fortran that jumped into assembler. The assembler bit used a parameter to decide where to re-enter the Fortran code. Over time every exit but one was commented out. I asked "Can we just patch the software to jump from here to there instead?" and the answer was "Your six month project is to replace Fortran with 'C' and that's about how long it'll take to get a code change through the committee." People take flight safety very seriously.
- ejo4041 8y ago"Boeing’s responses to the FAA are due by 30 June." Article is a month old, response was due to FAA already but I can't find it anywhere.
- GiuseppaAcciaio 8y agoThey may have privately requested an extension to the deadline, or they may have submitted the response and the FAA are reviewing the evidence. I don't expect to see any official response until at least end of July.
- mCOLlSVIxp6c 8y agoIt looks like they had a meeting on June 12, 2018 in Des Moines, Washington (FAA Office?). Here's a direct link to the "Record of Discussion": https://www.regulations.gov/contentStreamer?documentId=FAA-2018-0186-0005&attachmentNumber=1&contentType=pdf https://www.regulations.gov/contentStreamer?documentId=FAA-2... Unfortunately it doesn't really add any new information. For those that are interested, here is the FAA's entry in the Federal Register from Boeing's Petition for Exemption: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/03/23/2018-05910/petition-for-exemption-summary-of-petition-received-the-boeing-company https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/03/23/2018-05... The documents related to that Petition for Exemption can be found on Regulations.gov by searching for Docket ID FAA-2018-0186 https://www.regulations.gov/searchResults?rpp=25&po=0&s=FAA-2018-0186&fp=true&ns=true https://www.regulations.gov/searchResults?rpp=25&po=0&s=FAA-...
- greggarious 8y agoI'm not an aviation expert, but their reasoning seems to be "it's a tiny chance and we reaaaaaallllly want to use these planes". We are talking about a known bug that could lead to deaths. This isn't some critical military aircraft or a cargo plane that without which food and goods can't be transported. The only "harm" will be to shareholders. People are more important than profits.
- jschwartzi 8y agoThey have a mitigation in the form of an automatic engine restart system. I suspect part of their risk analysis is going to call out reliability of that function. If the RR engine is failing prematurely then there's also an argument the be made for switching to the GE engine because the maintenance costs are going to be passed on to the passengers in the form of higher prices.
- NullPrefix 8y ago>They have a mitigation in the form of an automatic engine restart system. They switched to php now?
- GiuseppaAcciaio 8y agoOf course Boeing want to deliver the planes, otherwise they get hit by significant late delivery penalties. However, thanks to how the industry is regulated, Boeing don't take chances if there is a risk to passenger safety. In this case, the likelihood of a single engine shutdown due to this elusive bug + the failure of the automatic restart system + the failure of the manual restart procedures, _combined with the fact that all commercial aircraft needs to be able to operate with only one of the engines_, makes Boeing ask for the exemption. The FAA, on their part, is 100% right in demanding that Boeing show their work and is unlikely to grant such an exemption unless the risk is calculated to be negligible.
- ken 8y agoThe problem sounds to me like it's triggered by environmental conditions, not random chance: "during a step climb to a higher altitude in ice crystal icing conditions". In that case, does having two identical engines really constitute redundancy?
- InTheArena 8y agoThe FAA does a great job with general plane safety. Boeing does a great job with Safety. It's great to see this in public, so we can understand the system that leads to aviation being a unbelievably safe form of transportation, while still being responsive to the market. (See https://www.popsci.com/why-air-travel-became-so-incredibly-safe https://www.popsci.com/why-air-travel-became-so-incredibly-s...) All of that said, the modern generation of engines are so complex to hit their efficency windows, it's majorly impacting airlines. The A320-NEO engines by Pratt & Whitney have huge problems that have significantly impacted airlines and carriers, while GE is struggling with this problem. All of these are engineering problems, with a complex trade-off between efficiency (fuel), safety and cost.
- sjm-lbm 8y agoThere's also a problem with the Trent 1000, the other engine option on 787s: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-rolls-royce-hldg-trent1000/rolls-royce-says-tripling-capacity-to-fix-trent-1000-engine-problems-idUSKCN1IU2NY https://www.reuters.com/article/us-rolls-royce-hldg-trent100... Basically, the compressor is not lasting near as long as expected, and, since it's a safety-critical part, airplanes are spending a lot of time on the ground awaiting expensive inspections and repairs that weren't in anyone's maintenance schedule.
- didymospl 8y agoThere was a lot of coverage of the 787s problems in Polish media recently and it brought to light one thing regarding these engines that really frightens me. Quoting the (leaked?) memo: >The experience with General Electric Engines, which had experienced perhaps two shut downs on the Boeing 767s in over 20 years, had given the airline a sense of security so that the shut down of one engine did not cause any pressure, the probability of the failure of the second engine was rated minimal. >Rolls Royce on the other hand had taught the airline however, that this was not true. From RR bulletins it is clear that the shut down of one engine dramatically increases the likelihood of the other engine failing. This forces us to revise our approach to ETOPS. http://avherald.com/h?article=4b69e455 http://avherald.com/h?article=4b69e455
- 8y ago
- ronnier 8y ago> The GEnx-1B engine has a software bug that in one instance prompted the computer to shut down the engine during a step climb to a higher altitude in ice crystal icing conditions. > Boeing said on 4 March that GE’s fix for the shutdown problem is included in a broad software update called “B200”, and it’s not scheduled for delivery until December 2019. But GE has told FlightGlobal and the FAA that the B200 software update will be ready by the first quarter of 2019.
- sargun 8y agoHey! This is regulation at work when it's working. That's awesome. I gotta say, I'm a pretty big fan of the FAA in terms of taking their approach of to safety and regulation. This seems kinda weird though to authorize for a commercial passenger craft? I'm curious, why would they authorize such a thing?
- GiuseppaAcciaio 8y agoIndeed, the FAA have no real reason to authorize that; I would also not expect them to want to grant any exemptions on a blanket basis: usually aviation authorities make rulings on specific aircraft, based on the flight and maintenance data.
- shub 8y agoIt's entirely possible that no one at Boeing believes the FAA will grant this exemption. However, if they don't make the attempt, then when Boeing gets dinged with contract penalties or loses deals because of this problem the responsible person needs to be able to prove that they did everything possible.
- thrillgore 8y agoSomeone at Boeing or GE -- do the right thing and leak the bug details.
- gmueckl 8y agoWith safety critical software, the devil you know may sometimes be the better choice. Changing the code to fix a known problem with a known workaround may make things worse by introducing unknown bugs. So which chance do you take? Sometimes not fixing a bug is the right thing to do.
- a-dub 8y agoI think a simpler solution would be to require them to post an enormous bond that would tank the company if it came due in the result of a failure in the field. They can ask for engineering data, but that can fudged. Asking them to bet the company on it is a much surer bet, imho.