2 ms·
Besides everything else going on, they left 68k because it was falling behind and couldn’t compete or speed up enough. They left the G3/G4 line when once again
by MBCook 8y ago
Besides everything else going on, they left 68k because it was falling behind and couldn’t compete or speed up enough. They left the G3/G4 line when once again they were stuck and Intel was running away.
So they went to Intel. They’re now on the same treadmill as everyone else. Can’t do better, can’t be totally stuck. But Intel isn’t progressing very fast, and they don’t seem to be focusing on the things Apple wants like ultra-low power.
But Apple’s chip division is kicking ass. The 10.5” iPad Pro is a monster, and could easily power a MacBook faster than an Intel chip. The real question is what to do on the MBP and iMac Pro.
Apple has never been keen on AMD for some reason, not sure if they have a chance on the high end. My impression is they don’t compete on low end/low power but I don’t know how accurate that is.
- robdachshund 8y agoPretty sure an ARM tablet chip is not going to beat Intel, even on the low end. Otherwise we would have moved on already. Also, apple does like AMD and uses their gpus because they have bad blood with nvidia. Apple primarily makes laptops and AMD has not been competitive until they developed Ryzen.
- godzillabrennus 8y agohttps://9to5mac.com/2017/09/22/iphone-8-geekbench-test-scores/ https://9to5mac.com/2017/09/22/iphone-8-geekbench-test-score... The iPhone 8 CPU is competitive with a Core i5
- lagadu 8y agoThat a myth; Geekbench results aren't comparable cross-platform.
- tristanj 8y agoNo, that is no longer true. Since Geekbench 3, results are comparable cross-platform.
- drakenot 8y agoFrom the linked article: "Geekbench comparisons between phones and laptops used to be pretty meaningless, as the tests were not directly comparable, but that hasn’t been the case for some time now. Founder John Poole confirmed that it is legitimate to directly compare scores across platforms" Look at these workloads[0] and tell me what doesn't look comparable across platforms? Parsing a 1.5MB HTML page, running SQLite queries, compiling code using LLVM, running Dijkstra's algorithm on a huge graph, repeatedly rendering PDFs, etc, etc. [0] https://www.geekbench.com/doc/geekbench4-cpu-workloads.pdf https://www.geekbench.com/doc/geekbench4-cpu-workloads.pdf
- 21 8y agoThat claim would be highly suspect in general, given that a desktop CPU has at least 10 times more headroom in power consumption. For such a claim to be true, you would have to expect that the phone CPU is somehow 10 times more efficient per Watt, while having the same kind of architecture (general CPU, not GPU/TPU/...).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- MBCook 8y agoIt’s perfectly possible that the iPhone CPU can’t run 4 hours straight due to heat issues in its enclosure while a desktop CPU can. But that could be fixed. Intel has not been optimizing for TDP/power draw as aggressively as Apple has. Apple started from that position and went up in performance. Intel started more in performance and had tried to keep TDP in check.
- Symmetry 8y agoIf you give the i5 it's full voltage and crank up the clock speed it'll totally beat an Apple chip. But in order to fit in a Macbook Air's power envelope you need to really throttle things back and a chip that's designed to operate in that regime has a big advantage over a chip that isn't.
- Const-me 8y agoI think he might be correct. Apple A11 has 297 GFlops CPU performance. (1) That “7th gen i5” is apparently i5-7360U. 32 FLOPs/cycle/core (2) * 2 cores * 3.50 GHz (=max turbo) = 224 GFlops. > the phone CPU is somehow 10 times more efficient per Watt Not 10 times. The i5’s TDP is just 15W. I don’t know about A11 but high-end Qualcomm chips can be up to 5-6W, just 3 times difference. > while having the same kind of architecture (general CPU, not GPU/TPU). That’s a continuum. They both CPUs, they both have SIMD that’s how they achieve that high flop/cycle, but the architecture can be quite different. A11 has 6 cores. Intel spends many transistors, and therefore energy, doing very complicated things: branch prediction, indirect branch prediction, cache synchronization between cores, speculative execution… Apple has full control over OS and software, they can probably get away with not doing some of these. Intel and AMD have to maintain compatibility with all software (including single threaded), built by all compilers and languages, that’s why they have fewer tradeoffs available to them. (1) https://forum.beyond3d.com/posts/2021926/ https://forum.beyond3d.com/posts/2021926/ (2) https://stackoverflow.com/a/15657772/126995 https://stackoverflow.com/a/15657772/126995
- leni536 8y agoVideo encoding is a pretty poor benchmark for this.
- X-Istence 8y agoI know you are wrong because Geekbench scores are showing the A-series chips to be competitive with Intel chips already.
- hrktb 8y agoCan’t they have an architecture where specialized chips deal with the most common heavy duty tasks to counteract raw CPU power ?
- wlesieutre 8y agoDon't forget the full (not i) Mac Pro, which they've committed to updating.
- stock_toaster 8y agoA Mac Pro with an epyc cpu seems like it could be pretty sweet.
- ClassyJacket 8y agoIs there actually any fundamental reason an ARM chip couldn't be made as powerful as Xeon or that it's harder than it is for x86, or is it just a matter of the (obviously expensive and time consuming) research and development not having been done yet?
- pdimitar 8y ago> The 10.5” iPad Pro is a monster, and could easily power a MacBook faster than an Intel chip. Very true. I have that exact iPad Pro (10.5") and the MacBook 12" and I can tell you that the iPad Pro is much stronger. The damn thing never stops for breath. Even trendy games with very very detailed graphics take 10 seconds to start on a bad day (usually 5-6) and they run at 60+ FPS at all times. If we are talking about everyday apps and Safari, the iPad Pro is the last tablet you will ever need in your life. It's simply perfect. > The real question is what to do on the MBP and iMac Pro. My only complaint about my other MacBook (Pro 15", 2015) are the loud fan noises, to be fair. I know Apple's thin and beautiful laptops are what people love but I'd buy some slightly bulkier MacBook if it was quiet. Speaking of which, the iMac Pro is the quietest machine of its class out there. Definitely gonna gather some cash and buy it. I don't think I'll need another desktop machine for at least 7 years, if not 10-12... Never been a fanboy in my life but I honestly can't wait to see Apple chip exclusive iPhones and MacBook. (I am mentioning iPhones because they still use Qualcomm's or Intel's radios and chips for their signals stack.)