8 ms·
Facial recognition rolled out by London police sparking human rights concerns
- motohagiography 8y agoMainly what it will likely be used for is similar to how cell phone tower data is used today. It gives you a list of people in an area at a given time, which you can correlate with other information like whether they are there often or out of habit, and whether they are breaking a routine. Add ALPR camera data, and a public records graph, and using those selectors against other areas means you can narrow a list of suspects fairly quickly. Arguably, surveillance merely polarizes crime instead of reducing it, where if good people are too worried about the consequences of defending themselves, it creates an effective %100 success rate for committing crimes and an insignificant chance of eventual charges - there is little disincentive to to criminals becoming super aggressive. London is already the most surveiled city in the western world, and yet still notorious for violent street crime. Adding facial recognition to the current regime of cell towers, ALPR, cameras at every corner, cab cameras, and public transit cameras, is meaningless. What is most likely is that facial recognition will be used the way it is used everywhere else in the world - for political pacification, not crime reduction.
- sandworm101 8y agoLondon police are also addicted to cctv. A crime without footage isnt investigated. Today they only investigate motivations and wintess reliability. If the physical act cannot be confirmed with footage, it didn't happen. So we need either more cameras to catch everything, or far fewer to get cops to start investigate crime again.
- orcdork 8y ago"London [...] still notorious for violent street crime" Which I find fairly strange all things considered - the crime index (https://www.numbeo.com/crime/rankings.jsp https://www.numbeo.com/crime/rankings.jsp - admittedly this might not be the most accurate source) shows quite a gap between other similar cities like New York - a fairly common comparison. As a resident of a few years now, I definitely wouldn't say I felt London to have that kind of feel, if anything violent crime has the effect of being shocking because it is so uncommon. I find it quite disheartening to see London's relatively soft-touch approach lose out over "automated" policing, there's quite a bit of grumbling lately over the reduction in actual people on the streets, mainly over police cuts.
- fwdpropaganda 8y agoLondon has some really bad areas though.
- theoh 8y agoSome really disadvantaged areas, maybe. But not really dangerous for the HN crowd unless you go looking for trouble. There's nowhere I know of in London where I wouldn't feel safe even walking on foot, and the worst parts keep getting gentrified.
- growlist 8y agoDepends on the time of day though doesn't it?
- theoh 8y agoI used to study architecture, and about ten years ago (after drinking too much) decided to visit an architecturally famous but rough estate at night. (It was Robin Hood Gardens.) I walked around and the place was, most significantly, empty. I got hailed aggressively by some guys but a fast walk was enough to get out of there without being confronted. There is danger, all right, but I think you would probably agree that it's not the obvious, conspicuous risks that lead to violent crime. It's the places that don't seem dangerous where it happens, because those are the places where victims are present and not focusing on their safety.
- Theodores 8y agoIt is one of those glass half full things. If you have been the victim of a mugging then you will start seeing scooter-gangs everywhere, before you never noticed them and crime was only something you read about. Incidentally these guys are quite a London thing, so if you are at the traffic lights on your bike/scooter/car and you see two or more scooters with no number plates and pillion passengers then you might want to start saying your prayers. The former chancellor of the exchequer had his phone nabbed by the legendary moped gang thieves so it is not only in areas that are deprived where crime is a problem. Don't walk and text in Central London, you will only be asking for it. They wear helmets and balaclavas underneath so I do not see how facial recognition can help. Only arming the public with fully automatic assault weapons can deter these ultra-violent thugs who happen to normally be only 15 years old.
- ksrm 8y ago>and yet still notorious for violent street crime Notorious among American right-wingers, perhaps. I haven't heard this or the "no-go areas" guff from anywhere else.
- growlist 8y agoThere is evidence from the Police themselves to suggest official figures should be taken with a pinch of salt: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-25022680 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-25022680 'Almost a million crimes a year are disappearing from official figures as chief constables attempt to meet targets, a study by the police watchdog has disclosed.' https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/11236805/A-million-crimes-reported-by-public-left-out-of-police-figures.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/11236805/A-mil...
- vilmosi 8y ago> yet still notorious for violent street crime As a resident, I have to say I'm pretty surprised to hear this. Is London that different vs similar sized cities?
- sametmax 8y agoThere is a huge difference between the intent and the potential. You can also have a benevolent dictator. But if you avoid the dictator all together, you remove the incertainty. With orher signals like the brexit, porn censorship, and cctv every where, this is very disturbing. But the most important signal is how the population accepts it. It smells like a disaster in the making.
- 75dvtwin 8y agowhat is similar about Brexit and porn censorship? As far as signals of coming dictatorship in UK?
- sametmax 8y agoIsolationism and reduction of freedom.
- 75dvtwin 8y agoI would argue, that Brexit was a faint sign, that UK still have hope. Brexit was 'No' vote to thought-police, political-corruption, and selective outrage. It was a 'yes' vote for national sovereignty, and empowered diversity of opinion (where a diversity means to be 'different' compared than the 'rich /powerful/famous' line of vote) To me the early signs of Dictatorship are: a) Uniformity of thought (and, therefore, active thought police). b) The culture of Selective outrage (that then leads to selective law enforcement for your citizens). c) Paid (and therefore 'fake') victims. d) The identification if a 'single powerful enemy' that must be attacked preventively (or else everybody will get hurt) --- So a treatment that prevents Dictatorship, is to ensure that the economical, political and military power of a country (or a union) is well spread, and controlled by local votes (as much as possible), rather than representative vote It does bring 'less efficiency', but it is that type of entropy (introduced by uncertainty of diverse opinion of larger populous) -- that is necessary to prevent dictatorships.
- dominotw 8y agoI think this was used in the recent gazzete newspaper shooting to identify the perpetrator.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoIs this something that will eventually spread to every single democracy? In a vacuum it does not sound that awful. You can identify illegal actions and individuals rapidly and effectively. As democracy entails a regular shifting of individuals, it seems that the chances of any given democracy choosing to consistently reject such utility in the longrun approaches zero. Even if the vast majority oppose it, opinions quickly change after a frightful act when whatever minority seeks to act such systems can effectively leverage the fear to achieve their goal. And if the answer to this question is yes, then where does it end? Or will democracies invariably end up sacrificing any and all freedoms and rights of privacy, that can be sacrificed, in the name of security?
- SN76477 8y agoI don't know what policing is for anymore. Crime is a part of the cost of a free society. Fighting crime with such tools takes away a lot of freedom. This is a power grab, I cannot imagine it helping anyone. Maybe it will solve a few petty crimes, but it is a squeeze on freedom in my opinion.
- m12k 8y agoGenuine question: With the GDPR in effect, don't all CCTV operators in the EU more or less need to have facial recognition in order to comply with any "please show me any images you have of me and then delete them" requests? (obviously they wouldn't need to run the facial detection always, only on select faces when requested)
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> With the GDPR in effect GDPR is interpreted and enforced at the national level. I'm going to go ahead and assume the British data regulator won't rule against its own government.
- m12k 8y agoSure, how about private companies who have CCTV then? Could someone just 'ddos' a supermarket chain by getting a hundred people to all ask for their CCTV footage?
- izacus 8y agoNational security is exempt from GDPR :)
- Eridrus 8y agoThere are exceptions to this rule, e.g you obviously can't ask the bank to delete what it knows about your debts.
- A_No_Name_Mouse 8y agoThey don't. See article 11: "If the purposes for which a controller processes personal data do not or do no longer require the identification of a data subject by the controller, the controller shall not be obliged to maintain, acquire or process additional information in order to identify the data subject for the sole purpose of complying with this Regulation."
- growlist 8y agoIf the police are lacking in criminals to lock up I can suggest a few thousand in various northern cities that they've been refusing to investigate for 10-15 years.
- ionised 8y agoWhat are you referring to?
- pasbesoin 8y agoI realize it's partially rhetorical, but I keep saying to the people who are trying to shove this onto us, "You first." Police still fight wearing and using body cams. Governments are becoming more obstreperous, recalcitrant, and outright -- and arguable, illegally -- uncooperative with respect to Freedom of Information Act and other like document production procedures and requests. It seems, the powers that want this, want no aspect of this "transparency" for themselves. I'd like to see a private initiative and cameras take to tracking the elite and the "nothing to hide" people. Their actions and behavior already tell me, that they have plenty to hide. Let's see them "live their everyday life", as they've known it, in the face of relentless tracking and "accountability".
- bArray 8y agoAs a security concerned British person, this throws multiple red flags to me. 1. A Country that failed to upgrade it's NHS systems from Windows XP after 10+ billion pounds of investment and subsequently got hacked, leading to many deaths - scares me. The data they are collecting is very intimate. If it was leaked, somebody could track persons of interest (government officials, politicians, journalists, undercover police, etc), tell whether somebody is having an affair, make correlations between friends groups - tonnes of data. They could potentially figure out where you work, where you go for lunch, who you meet, who you phone - it's just too much. 2. Today it's about catching "known" criminals, tomorrow it's about predicting future criminals and sending them to state "rehabilitation" camps (just look at China), selling you data to the highest bidder (it's happened on the Council level in the past) or some other ridiculous use. Blocking websites on the internet used to be about removing exploitation of young persons, now it's used to block pirating of copyright material. 3. A right to be forgotten - if you've done nothing wrong, you shouldn't be tracked. I can understand the need to hold this sort of data for a short period of time, but after this it should be deleted. I think privacy is a fundamental freedom, along with freedom of speech, freedom to travel, etc. 4. The accuracy of facial detection, even if it's 99.99% for 70 million people, is still 7000 mistakes (at a massive simplification). It's actually worse than that, both the real accuracy of face detection and the error rate for specific people. It's also "easy" to trick. When it works it works well, but what about the person who is incorrectly detained, potentially injured for a crime they never committed? And that's not even taking into consideration that a lot of these face detection algorithms tend to be subtly racist (over trained on locals, badly trained on foreign persons). 5. Lack of oversight for such a powerful technology - to collect data on this magnitude is absolutely insane and needs multiple groups of people to keep it's use in check. Not just government based but also separate non-government groups which receive funding elsewhere. That all said, I can understand the clear benefit - remove the human element from tracking these people. But with any powerful technology we must always ask - at what cost? I think this inflicts too much on a persons basic freedoms.
- jimnotgym 8y agoWe have reached the levels of desperation whereby the police are willing to employ a technology that clearly does not work, in order to pursue a goal of policing with fewer police officers. You only have to look at the widespread increase in CCTV use in Britain. Now when you get mugged in London the police can get you a little video of your hooded attackers for posterity. Except they only have time to go through the recordings if you got murdered, otherwise you will just get a crime number.
- cpmouter 8y agoI would like to know where you get that 1) It clearly does not work (as opposed to "it has a low accuracy" which just means they will have to filter manually) and 2) They are pursuing a goal of policing with fewer police officers and 3) Having a working solution would mean they could police with fewer police officers (cameras can't detain suspects or intervene when problems arise, AND police officers don't carry a mental database of all suspects like a computer could have, so having cameras does not replace having police officers).
- barrkel 8y agoScooter crime is exploding in London and police numbers have been falling for a decade. Personally I've had 3 scooter thefts on the past year, including a bike jacking at a red light - more a robbery than theft. All these criminals wear balaclavas even if they're not wearing helmets, and they're used to using countermeasures against CCTV, so facial recognition isn't likely to make a big difference to them.
- IshKebab 8y agoThree in the past year? That's insanely unlucky. Do you carry baskets of iPhones around council estates?
- cpmouter 8y agoUnless moped crime performed by guys with balaclavas is 100% of all the crime that occurs in London, your comment is pointless. There's a way to attack this crime while reducing the number of policemen, and it's to attack the demographics of it, but of course that will get you called names :-)
- chiefalchemist 8y agoHow soon before Amazon offers "policing" via mechanical turk? That's not a joke.
- e12e 8y agoHappened 8 years ago: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-11460897 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-11460897 [ed: https://web.archive.org/web/20120229200201/http://interneteyes.co.uk/ https://web.archive.org/web/20120229200201/http://internetey... ]
- Eridrus 8y agoSo what if mechanical turk is involved? You are unlikely to arrest someone based on a mechanical turk results, since unsurprisingly you can look at photos yourself to double check. It's also pretty common to get data rated by multiple people to cross-check how certain they are, and to keep track of individuals' accuracy and exclude inaccurate raters from your tasks.
- chiefalchemist 8y ago1) Being "policed" by a Big Inc. is quite a leap of faith. 2) Surveillance as a Service? That's not a good sign.
- BerislavLopac 8y agoYou're being downvoted, but that's a pretty realistic scenario, at least from a technical perspective. I can easily imagine a system which uses facial recognition to narrow down to a choice of a few "best matches" (using police mugshots, passport or driver licence photos, or whatever they have at their disposal) and then crowdsource it via Mechanical Turk or even something like Recaptcha to select the right one.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI don't sweat the down votes. Most of the time I'm proud of them. In this case it's probably the same people who like the idea of USPS photographing their mail so they can see what they're getting, not realizing they're actually being sold surveillance as a survice. That is, they're happy about it. I'm more realistic. That scares a lot of people.
- TamDenholm 8y agoSurely someone will come up with a device that can mask your face from cameras without literally putting a mask on. I dont know what that would be or if that would be made illegal or not, because surely they couldnt make a literal halloween mask illegal. I would buy that device.
- OscarCunningham 8y agoMasks are often illegal except at halloween: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-mask_laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-mask_laws
- e12e 8y agoLike a Lazer pointer? Or, i suppose reflex face paint would work too.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoUnless there's a lot of people wearing these, it won't be too hard to track the footage of the person wearing it back to before they put it on or when they came out of their home wearing it.
- ColanR 8y agoSurprised no one has mentioned UV-emitting LEDs embedded in a hat. No visible light emitted, but looks like a spotlight to cameras & hides the face in the blinding light.
- ReverseCold 8y agoIsn't that damaging to your eyes? Also, good UV filters do exist, it would just be a bit more expensive.
- Eridrus 8y agoUV filters are pretty cheap these days, even your smartphone camera has one.
- chillydawg 8y agoMaybe highly reflective makeup in IR/UV but not visible wavelength. Apply random patterns, or perhaps specific patterns designed to confuse the nets? I don't know what wavelengths common cameras for this kind of use case operate across.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lord_ring_111 8y agoHuman rights vs protection from criminals/terrorists is a delicate balance. I am curious what are the human rights that get violated by having cameras that identify illegal activities.
- realusername 8y ago> I am curious what are the human rights that get violated by having cameras Privacy is a human right.
- chillingeffect 8y agowhy are posting from an alt/throwaway? do you not feel comfortable revealing your identity alongside your words? now you have a taste of why privacy is important.
- iovrthoughtthis 8y agoDo cameras identify illegal activities or people?
- ben_w 8y agoIn general, AI connected to the cameras can be made to do both. This one seems to just do people. Once the system is in place, expansion of use is much easier.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
- FreeTrade 8y agoIf you assume one of the main directives of British police is to frustrate radical political change and forestall revolution, none of their actions are surprising.
- claudiawerner 8y agoI don't see it as being that grand, at least not at the moment. I think we are very far from something like May '68 or Soviet revolution. A lot of theory has been dedicated to figuring out why we are in this situation in which there is a completely inactive working class with very little drive behind them; various explanations have been given, though - Marx's critique of ideology, Althusser's explanations of ISAs and RSAs, Debord's of society of the spectacle, the Frankfurt School's concentration on mass culture changing what we define as being rational (and the closing off of the "extremes", for it is no longer "reasonable" to operate outside of the "democratic" system etc.) all the way to newer ideas; I'm reading "Willing Slaves of Capital: Spinoza and Marx on Desire at the moment, which carries the following rather provocative tagline: "Why do people work for other people? This seemingly naïve question is more difficult to answer than one might at first imagine, and it lies at the heart of Lordon's Willing Slaves of Capital."
- ionised 8y agoThe Snowden leaks highlighted how the intelligence and law enforcement services in the UK surveilled the likes of the Open Rights Group, Oxfam etc. If you were part of these organisations you were labelled a 'domestic extremist'. It is already happening. Has been for a long time.
- simion314 8y agoWhat I am afraid is that we could get an even worse problem then the DNA and fingerprints issue where so called experts will put innocent people in prison. "The computer tells us that X was at the crime scene without reasonable doubt, with the AI software could measure this blurred image and the computer experts are sure that is almost impossible for the software to be wrong.
- nathanyukai 8y agoBut as long as they don't rely on this single evidence, that should be fine right? If someone's hair, fingerprints all match the ones in crime scene, even if the software only have 90% confidence, it should be good enough. Btw from a blurred image, it's fundamentally impossible to have around 100% accuracy.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoMicroscopic hair analysis is a classic example of pseudo-scientific "evidence" used to secure convictions. The FBI has washed its hands of it: FBI Testimony on Microscopic Hair Analysis Contained Errors in at least 90% of Cases in Ongoing Review https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/1996772-joint-press-statement-4-20-15-final.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/1996772-joint-press-... Ditto bite-mark analysis: https://phys.org/news/2015-05-fbi-hair-analysis-problems-reveal.html https://phys.org/news/2015-05-fbi-hair-analysis-problems-rev... Yet, this kind of "expert" testimony was accepted for years and years. People went to jail on the basis of flim-flam.
- eecc 8y agoEventually, for the sake of cost savings abd efficiency, all other means of investigation will be cut, wound down and abolished. Then you have Gilliam’s Brazil, and you won’t have any recourse because you won’t know any better either
- simion314 8y agoJudges and jury can easily be convinced, you add some other "evidence" into the mix like "The buy is listening to rock mustic or plays violent video games" maybe some racist stereotypes and you got convince ted. This things actually happen with bad DNA, fingerprints specialists, the one that will hunt me is with a fireman that testified that he is very sure a house was intentionally put on fire and the father was found guilty of killing his family)it was an accidental fire. My point is that you get some bad evidence, some bad eye witnesses or profiles and you get convicted, especially if the judge or jury gets tricked by the media in general on how good the forensic science actually is.