8 ms·
The only way I can understand how widespread this is, is that a majority of the powerful string-pullers in the world are participating in the scam. If a compan
by BLKNSLVR 8y ago
The only way I can understand how widespread this is, is that a majority of the powerful string-pullers in the world are participating in the scam.
If a company has an international ownership structure that's complex enough that makes it difficult or impossible to follow the trail of ownership / leadership / directorship, then the company shouldn't be allowed to operate.
All the fuss and bluster in various countries about multi-nationals dodging their local tax responsibilities, and yet this is allowed to go on. There were a couple of such companies that have Australian Government contracts that were revealed to have opaque international ownership.
In the current environment of growing suspicion about foreign ownership and its relationship to national security, you'd think these issues would be a priority. How do you curtail foreign ownership and Chinese / Russian influence if you can't work out who's ultimately responsible? Maybe that's just talk to distract us non-string-pullers?
- Iv 8y agoI found it pretty illuminating, in another leak, the Paradise papers, to see that the Queen of England, who is also the head of the state in Bermuda, where this leaked came from, had huge investments in off-shore companies: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/11/05/paradise-papers-queen-bono-kept-money-offshore-funds-leaked/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/11/05/paradise-papers-... It is no secret that Juncker, the head of the European Commission, was the leader of Luxembourg when it established itself as a tax haven power house, and blocked any serious EU reform to curb tax evasion. The various leaders of the world are the first to use these services. Theses funds allow them to finance campaigns, bribe officials, and maintain the statu quo. Of course they use political power to maintain this situation. I don't often say nice things about GWB's administration but one thing that came out of their terrorist paranoia was that they managed to basically kill the tax haven status of Switzerland, where some funds transited. But it took all the weight of the USA while it was in berserk mode to shut down such a thing. There is dozen more to go.
- wahern 8y ago> I don't often say nice things about GWB's administration but one thing that came out of their terrorist paranoia was that they managed to basically kill the tax haven status of Switzerland That seems like it could have been a counter-productive strategy. Better that your enemies use a well-understood banking system with [theoretically] reliable and consistent bookkeeping than for those transactions to shift to a more disperse, more chaotic international system. Even if Swiss accounts were nominally secret, AFAIU the CIA and NSA had developed a fairly reliable system for snooping around. There's a reason New York and London continue to be world leaders in processing financial transactions--the governments have been intentionally tolerant of shady characters, shady businesses, and shady nations as long as the transactions nominally followed the law. Among other benefits, that puts you in a good position to keep track of the bad guys and, when it really counts, to take them down. If you police too heavily all that activity goes somewhere else. But it does leave you open to accusations of aiding & abetting bad behavior. There's a limit to what can be politically and legally tolerated in New York and London. But you can structure the international system to channel those intolerable transactions to the least worse alternatives. Like so much with the War on Terror, the better approach would be to improve HUMINT and investigatory resources, rather than pushing the activity further underground and playing a game of whack-a-mole.
- everdev 8y agoI don't think it takes long for word to spread. Once privacy is comprised your window of opportunity probably closes pretty quickly. Even a hint of government access to Swiss accounts probably sent all nefarious accounts somewhere else.
- wahern 8y agoSwiss banks were still used for the 1MDB operation, which involved Saudi Arabian intermediaries who 1) presumably understood the limits to Swiss secrecy and 2) probably ran in the same circles as those associated with militant organizations. And that began after the Bush administration. Moving transactions to other systems is also risky for the bad guys, in terms of higher transaction costs and less predictability regarding the degree of confidentiality. It's like in computer security--you can't defend against an omnipotent attacker, rather you have to make some assumptions about your visibility and desirability as a target vs the strength of defenses. Choosing to go with some new, untested service may make you invisible or may leave you a sitting duck; how can you know? Moreover, while organizations like Al Qaeda would have steered absolutely clear of the normal system, they benefit when more money moves via the darkest channels. They benefit from improved consistency, reliability, liquidity, and cover traffic.
- codeisawesome 8y ago“All the weight of the USA while it was in ‘berserk mode’” is very evocative phrasing.
- charlesdm 8y agoThe UK Queen (or her managers) invested in an offshore fund, which for UK tax purposes was tax transparent. That meant the fund itself did not pay taxes, but tax was paid "in personal name" on any gains. This results in an outcome which would've been exactly the same as if she had directly made the investments in her personal name. Meaning: a whole lot of talk about nothing by people who are clueless about tax matters. These kinds of arrangements are not the problem. Neither is Emma Watson purchasing a property through an offshore company for privacy reasons. The problem is autocrats siphoning off billions from their local economy and hiding it through layers of shell corporations across the world, which are not limited to just companies based in offshore tax havens.
- mikekchar 8y agoDoes the UK queen pay taxes in the UK? I'm pretty sure the royal family was exempt at one point, but I haven't followed it for a long time. I think they actually receive funds from the tax payer.
- jhayward 8y agoShe voluntarily pays taxes on her personal income, although as Sovereign she is constitutionally exempt. She also donates all of the income from Crown holdings to government, as I recall. Most of the complainers about the royal family being taxpayer supported don't realize what a bargain the UK gets, they make a lot of money from HMTQ.
- jacobush 8y agoAlthough I expect some of them complain because they want the whole institution of monarchy abolished. Personally, I find it quite interesting how several European monarchies within themselves managed to "strike a bargain" between old vested interests (the Crown) and commoners such that probably revolution was averted - and that this "power balance" lives on to this day.
- bmer 8y agoWhere are you getting this from? Here's an article, from a reputable news organization: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jun/28/royal-family-value-for-money-not-worth-tuppence https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jun/28/royal-... More recently: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jul/19/queen-spend-mushrooming-pay-revenue-estate https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jul/19/queen-...
- api 8y agoA term I've heard in the last decade that describes this situation is "superclass." There exists a global class of politically powerful super rich that are beyond rich in the conventional sense and are more like planetary royalty. In that sense we already do kind of have a global government, and it is not a democracy.
- germinalphrase 8y agoWhen I actually try to think about it - I’m not sure I have a robust understanding of what these people are like. Celebrities? Sure. Trust fund slackers? Yep. Superclass...Maybe? Edit: not suggesting that celebrities are part of the superclass but that I understand the general lifestyle associated with celebrities (I was previously employed in the film industry). On the other hand, I really don’t understand the lifestyle and social environment of this ‘superclass’. Perhaps, I simply lack the imagination to conceptualize what it would be like to possess a billion dollars. Perhaps, it’s just too divorced from my own reality.
- creaghpatr 8y agoMost celebrities aren't. Maybe a handful, but having a net worth of say $25M is a drop in the bucket compared to 11/12 figure individuals- the marginal advantages at that point must be very abstract.
- api 8y agoWhen you approach billionaire money probably ceases to exist in any tangible sense. You could afford literally any apex product of the entire human species to the extent that you could experience it subjectively. At that point it starts to become about power. This is probably made all the more true by the fact that we don't live in anything approaching a libertarian/voluntarist world. Getting that rich means you are now a 'player' among other power players whether you like it or not, and other power players don't always play fair. Basically you probably are forced to become some kind of oligarch or politician or give some of your money away to stay below a certain threshold. But I've never been up there so I don't really know. I'm only observing from afar.
- pembrook 8y agoMeanwhile, the IRS and the US government are more worried about shaking down middle-class expats with the absurd reporting requirements of FATCA and the only double-taxation system in the world. The IRS & treasury department obviously have the power to get international governments to cooperate, but choose to focus their power on Johnny-salaryman instead of international money launderers. As usual, the rich and powerful have ways around this (ie. holding assets in offshore corporations) while the little guy with no powerful connections gets screwed for his meager salary.
- rahimnathwani 8y ago"the only double-taxation system in the world" Care to elaborate on this point? The US (like most other developed nations) has tax treaties with many other countries, partly to ensure that its citizens are not taxed twice on the same income. A list of such treaties is available here: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/international-businesses/united-states-income-tax-treaties-a-to-z https://www.irs.gov/businesses/international-businesses/unit... For most US citizens living abroad, the practical outcome is that you don't pay 'double tax', but you pay the higher of {where you live, USA} taxes. (There's an alternative option that results in lower taxes, but only works for those earning less than ~$100k/year.)
- codeisawesome 8y agoPay the higher to the respective country or to the US? I have friends who make less than $100k but pay both US and expat host country taxes that would benefit from this.
- rahimnathwani 8y agoI am an accountant, but I am not your accountant, and what follows is NOT advice: The US government offers its overseas resident citizens two schemes to ensure they don't pay what you referred to as 'double tax'. You can choose only one or the other, not both. A) FEIE (Foreign Earned Income Exclusion): https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/foreign-earned-income-exclusion https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/fore... For your friends who make less than $100k, this may mean they owe zero US Federal tax. B) FTC (Foreign Tax Credit): https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/foreign-tax-credit https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/fore... Instead of A, you can calculate your US taxes as normal (i.e. as if you were living in the US), but then deduct the amount of any tax you paid in your country of residence. If you live in a high-tax country (e.g. UK), then IIUC your tax bill after deducting tax paid in your country of residence would be zero, i.e. you would not pay any taxes to the IRS.
- eurticket 8y agoSounds like a logical approach — no trail, no business. But I would imagine this is the system, the very people hiding behind these shells, are willing to hold in place and have the perfect power/influence/capital to keep it, which doesn't make it a priority.