17 ms·
How Peppa Pig became a video nightmare for children
- matte_black 8y agoLetting a child wander around the Internet without adult supervision is something akin to child neglect. Way too much clickbait, way too much malevolent content.
- koolba 8y agoTitle aside that’s a fair point. One wrong click can lead to months of nightmares for a young child.
- anonymfus 8y agoIs not an age when adult supervision is harmful as a violation of child's rights for privacy lower than age when such content is harmful?
- PretzelFisch 8y agoI think there is a level of undo trust to apps called youtube for kids. It sure gives the impression that its filtered and curated.
- laumars 8y agoIts easy to blame the parents but the problem is some of these shock videos are designed to look like innocent kids videos (eg a Peppa Pig clip) and it's not until the "shock" part has already happened that even the adult is aware of the true nature of the content. Sure, there are some which are easily identified by the title or an obviously unofficial animation style, but if all of them were like that then I suspect YouTube would have had an easier job training their AI to detect and remove such content.
- tyfon 8y agoWatching Peppa Pig on youtube is pirating anyway so it should not be that hard to remove. And it's very easy to blame the parents, since it is their responsibility. I don't let my kids watch youtube at all.
- laumars 8y ago3 year olds don't understand copyright law and frankly I'm not about to try and explain it to them when I'm sat in a restaurant or queuing to get his hair cut. If watching something on YouTube (on my phone with the sound muted) pacifies my kids which make everyone's experience more tolerable then I wouldn't class that as bad parenting. But I guess the problem with appeasing judgemental individuals is you're damned whatever you do. However for what it's worth, almost everything we watch on YouTube with the kids we do also have on DVD.
- lopmotr 8y agoI think he means the parent should recognize that it's pirated. But regardless, there's a simple feedback loop that surely works to solve this problem. If you personally find your kids watching something you don't want them to, then you're going to stop letting them watch it. If you don't mind, then you might carry on. In either case, they watch what you approve and there's no problem.
- laumars 8y agoYou're just reiterating the original point that started this fork. While i agree with you that any responsible parent would do as you described, some of these shock videos aren't obviously shock videos until after the shock event has already happened. This in fact happened to a good friend of mine who is a very responsible parent however right at the end of a cartoon there was a loud scream with a guy wearing a zombie mask. I'm sure it was done as a laugh but it took my friends kid a couple of years to get over it. Before that event happened neither he nor I had ever heard of these kinds of pranks on YouTube before. Just as most other parents wouldn't have. Sure you could blame the parents complacency or whatever but where do you draw the line? What happens if someone causes a scene that scares my kid when we are at a restaurant? Or walking him to school? You can't predicte the actions of every arsehole in communal spaces so blaming this stuff on the parents is more than a little unfair then society owes a little responsibility for its own actions as well. But as I also said before, if these shock videos were just bad knock offs etc that a quick watch when the kids aren't around highlights their content, then I suspect YouTube would have found it easier to train their AI. The problem is some of those videos even get past parent moderation as well (such as the one I described above) and thus don't become apparent as a shock video until the damage has already been done.
- rvanmil 8y agoAgreed. Except it is extremely common for parents to let their kids watch YouTube unsupervised (and when I mention the problems they don’t want to hear it; “nah it’s fine, they won’t click weird stuff...”), so this does beg the question whether YouTube should be responsible too (I think they should). That said, YouTube is banned in our house because of this and Netflix is way superior anyway.
- jimmaswell 8y agoThis is odd to hear since that "free roam" idea of letting them wander for miles unsupervised is all the rage on here. I'd say that's much more reckless than letting them use the internet. Unsupervised computer use at a young age was nothing but a positive for me, yet being left unsupervised with an irresponsible neighbor's dumb kids left me with a crushed wrist and internal bruising from a bicycle accident and the beginning of lifelong weight problems from the subsequent aversion to such activity.
- maxsilver 8y ago> This is odd to hear since that "free roam" idea of letting them wander for miles unsupervised is all the rage on here. I'd say that's much more reckless than letting them use the internet. I wouldn't. The real world has laws and rules, and people to enforce them. The internet (in all practical situations) is lawless and completly unpoliced. That's not inherently a bad thing (I like having an open internet). But it's not something I'd ever expose a child to. I'd easily let my own child wander the neighborhood unsupervised, long before I'll let my child wander the open internet unsupervised.
- bonniemuffin 8y agoI don't know how old you are, but the internet (and before that, BBSs) used to be a much more friendly place than it is today. When I was in high school circa 1996-8, my parents would drop me off to meet random people I had met online, and it was totally no big deal. Nowadays I can't imagine anyone doing that -- the dark corners of the internet have gotten a lot darker over the years.
- lopmotr 8y agoI had similar experiences. Though I did find out later that one of the people I met on BBSs had some history of child porn or sex abuse and met lots of teenage boys that way. He later went to prison for molesting another one. It might be more that parents were more tolerant of risks than that things were safer. Cars didn't have airbags either.
- 8y ago
- DoreenMichele 8y agoAt the risk of being wildly misunderstood: My kids got help to find kid-friendly things but were essentially free to do pretty much as they pleased online. They were given two tongue-in-cheek guidelines: No porn and no learning how to make bombs. I think the key is to assume they are good kids who need some help finding what interests them, not bad kids who need a parent jail keeper preventing them from doing bad things. Having said that, I was fortunate to be stationed in Germany when they were really little with access to only one American TV channel. I had lots of videos for them, not to control content but to give them entertainment. Still, content control was largely baked into the situation. So I am somewhat self conscious that what worked back in the day may not work now and other disclaimers. Edit: I will also add that when they were little, we had one computer in a public space. Individual computers in private spaces came much later.
- awat 8y ago[Deleted]
- blowski 8y agoThe introduction of the article says: > James Bridle’s essay on disturbing YouTube content aimed at children went viral last year. The first paragraph includes a link to an article from that time. The point of the article is “has Google done anything about it since last year?”.
- gaius 8y agoI was watching videos from the last CppCon and kept getting Peppa Pig recommendations as the next thing to watch. There is definitely something weird going on and YouTube must be complicit.
- teamonkey 8y agoImagine the inverse was true. Some kid happily watching Peppa Pig then, suddenly, a nightmarish video of someone debugging a project that liberally uses deeply-nested templates
- watmough 8y agoFinally something that traumatizes me, as much as my children. In all seriousness though, my daughters moved into the same room for about a month in response to the 'Killer Clown' (pennywise etc.) stories that were doing the rounds in their elementary school. And just to emphasize how scary stories and TV can be, I'm only now getting over my deep unease whenever I think of the scarier parts of City of Death, and Sapphire and Steel.
- ben_w 8y agoIt’s fascinating how differently different people react to any given content. Myself, I found The Taming Of The Shrew to be appalling, but not as appalling as the fact everyone else in the audience was laughing to it. Likewise BDSM. Some friends of mine invited me into forums about it for dating, and I found I could not distinguish what I saw from actual abuse — I instead need to rely on the fact that I knew some of the people and they told me they had enjoyed what was done to them. It’s like The Dress, I suppose, only disturbing/fine instead of black and blue or white and gold.
- booleandilemma 8y agoWho’s making these weird videos? Has anyone taken credit?
- doh 8y agoI never though of this question before, so I went down the rabbit hole to find the answer. I started by checking the ownership of the videos on YouTube (through Content ID). All recent videos are claimed by emails on a domain entonegroup.com. The domain itself yields nothing as it's registered with an extra privacy option. However the email leads to a lady that works for Entertainment One that also advertises [0] the ownership of the content. I also checked the earliest videos of Peppa and it seems like they were produced by a different individuals, which would suggest that, at least this show, was acquired by Entertainment One. [0] https://www.entertainmentone.com/ https://www.entertainmentone.com/
- notamy 8y agoYour [0] link 404s for me.
- doh 8y agoI changed it back to the home page. I grabbed the link from their homepage where you can see Peppa Pig, but it doesn't seem to be working directly.
- vpribish 8y agohere's a working one, they aren't hiding it https://www.entertainmentone.com/home/EN/peppa-pig https://www.entertainmentone.com/home/EN/peppa-pig
- notamy 8y agoThis also 404s; like the sibling comment says, it works from the homepage but not if you try to go to it directly.
- knuththetruth 8y agoOne of the greatest successes of companies like Google is transferring all of the negative externalities of their systems onto the public using some fiction about technology “going awry” of its own accord.
- Rjevski 8y agoI don't see why Youtube doesn't just start charging per-upload to fund the human review process. I understand that at the beginning it makes sense to make uploads free to gain market share, but now they've reached monopoly so that's no longer needed. Charging something like $1 for uploads would allow to pay human reviewers, would cut down on mis-labeled content (since humans are reviewing) and inappropriate/advertiser-unfriendly content (since the creators would be reluctant to pay if they know it'll most likely get rejected, and if they try anyway the human would catch it). $1 is also affordable enough not to hinder legitimate usage. Seems like a win to me.
- gaius 8y agoThey say 400 hrs/min of uploads is too much to police. But not too much to find the most profitable ad to run on it. That is why YouTube are clearly turning a blind eye.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoFor general YouTube? Sure. For the advertised as curated and safe YouTube Kids? Absolutely not. There is zero excuse for not having a human vetting what they show on there.
- sbhn 8y agoI think YouTube needs to be censored and filtered until it resembles the evening news where you can see concerned politicians rescuing you from attack and justifying the stuff that creates division, destabilisation and refugees. Edit: and police shootings
- jameslk 8y agoThis is just the usual internet trolling that occurs everywhere. There's probably campaigns on various forums (e.g. 4chan) to see how many of these videos can be snuck through the filters. I'm actually surprised that Google has done as good of a job to moderate it in their children's app (if their reported 30-day 0.005% flagging rate is correct[0]). 0. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/04/business/media/youtube-kids-paw-patrol.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/04/business/media/youtube-ki...
- s73v3r_ 8y agoDon't excuse things as trolling.
- jameslk 8y agoIt is trolling, and this article is just painting an alarmist narrative. Google clearly did something about the issue of how to create a filtered experience for children, by creating YouTube Kids. Most of the article is just pointing to "weirdness" in videos on YouTube proper, which should surprise no one.
- astura 8y agoThese videos were appearing on YouTube Kids.
- myWindoonn 8y agoI've been on 4chan for over a decade now. It isn't 4chan trolling and there's no concerted campaign that I can find on any board. (Do you have a link or other evidence to contradict this? We'd love to see it!) The investigations that have been carried out so far seem to point to individual small film studios who produce the content because it seems to be an acceptable business model for them, and of course YT's own recommendation algorithms for being unable to distinguish between kid-okay and not-kid-okay content.
- jameslk 8y ago
- rossdavidh 8y agoDecent job of pointing out that many similar problems exist in different areas. They could also have mentioned Microsoft's attempt at a self-teaching chatbot that went full fascist in a surprisingly short amount of time. Much of it illustrates how surprisingly difficult it is to get algorithms to replace human judgement, and how easy it is to think you've done it when you haven't. We look at instances of humans making poor judgements and tend to think , "an algorithm could improve on that". It turns out, human judgement does better than you think, compared to the task of automating that in an algorithm. Self-driving cars, I am looking at you.
- joe_the_user 8y agoHaving watched a few of these videos, it's not that they have a message but they're a contentless stream of semi-dramatic events (of the events violent). Something that would only entertain a 2 year old. But naturally they are aim at 2 years olds (or there-abouts). This is also a natural result of parents using video as a baby-sitter for kids too young to really have any judgment of their own. So we have parent who won't exercise judgment, kids who can't and youtube which is expected to do so. This goes naturally with the recent item about large corporations discriminating against pregnant women. If society isn't offering parents any extra time to take care of their kids, parents fall back in automated methods. We're finding downsides to such automation but that doesn't stop it, given that society isn't offering any time for alternatives.
- lopmotr 8y agoNo, humans don't do better. What you probably mean is you're personally good at applying your own judgement that's arbitrarily based on your own culture and experiences regardless of whether that's good or bad. But would you trust all other humans with that task? Isis was composed of humans but they taught schoolchildren to kill people. I grew being read the bible at school and had to hear stories about entrails being spilled on the ground, hands being cut off, and a father attempting to murder his son in a fit of mental illness. Humans told me those stories. These complaints are just parents being parents and hunting for anything to worry about for their children. The anecdotes about being afraid of the dark, crying and violence obviously cannot be attributed to some particular thing they watched. Even scientists can't work out the causes of child behavior with much reliability.
- sigfubar 8y agoThe YouTube problem is solved very easily: use the firewall to shitcan the whole site. Require mandatory VPN through same firewall for all mobile devices. Done. At the very least, my child never gets to see any of this crap.
- foobarbazetc 8y agoSure, but the bigger problem is that Google makes an app targeted at kids (“YouTube Kids”) which is supposed to only show age appropriate material. It’s a huge problem that Google is just blaming on “algorithms”. Meanwhile little 2 year old Johnny gets to see Peppa Pig killed in a variety of ways. It’s not only the overt violence either. There’s some really weird sort of cult programming stuff that slips past the filter because they put it at the very end of an otherwise normal clip. But yeah, just delete it. Plenty of quality apps for kids.
- cornholio 8y agoI believe there is a technical solution to this that does not involve sanitizing the whole Internet to the level of broadcast TV (good luck with that). A "Child mode" flag would be set system wide when the device is configured by the parent to be used by a child. This should enforce a top down policy that only allows installing child safe apps or apps that propagate and enforce a similar policy. For example, Chrome would be installed but would only allow access to sites that respect the child safe flag. Youtube would load but only run videos and suggestions form a carefully curated set of publishers that respect the age. Etcetera. Compared with previous approaches that failed due to lack of adoption (RASCi, ICRA) this system would provide a strong incentive for app and site owners to properly support the age flag, else they are simply invisible in the children market. A strong initial effort would be required from Google/Microsoft to bootstrap the initial whitelists.
- prepend 8y agoThis approach is contrary to youtube’s Business model. They’d rather just block kids. Which makes kids (and parents) just pretend to be 18. Goog just needs to give up and partner with pbs or something to make kids videos a charity.
- matthewrudy 8y agoThere already is a YouTube Kids that has a similar set of features. https://www.youtube.com/yt/kids/ https://www.youtube.com/yt/kids/
- acqq 8y agoAnd the "weird" videos from the article seem to still exist there too, the way I understand the article (I haven't checked myself, it was disturbing experience the last time).
- prepend 8y agoThis tool claims to have those features, but does not. The article covers this. It’s actually kind of worse, because it lulls parents into thinking it’s safe. And it’s even harder to police since adults never use it and the UI is different than the YouTube parents expect.
- mattsfrey 8y agoHere's an idea, don't give impressionable young children unrestricted internet access if you're worried about this kind of stuff.
- prepend 8y agoMy partner and I did this a few years ago. Our kids ranged from 5-10. It wasn’t that big of a deal but the social pressure has risen more and more each year due to advertising “watch on YouTube,” classmates having YouTube, elementary schools requiring YouTube projects, complaints that other parents allow and such. But the strangest thing is the reaction from friends who have kids the same age that we’re being prudes or technophiles. I shared a few of these articles with a friend whose 9 year old had a YouTube channel with a few cute videos but spends about 4-6 hours per day watching. They denied the author. Screen caps showed videos like the ones referenced in the right list and recommended and they still said it wasn’t a big deal. Really weird reaction from people I know well. Makes me wonder if I’m getting all Tipper Gore in my old age and this is the new form of heavy metal panic.
- mattsfrey 8y agoYeah there is a generational gap that largely doesn't connect with me as a non-parent and somebody who didn't have internet until adolescence, and there was no youtube etc back then. I just will always generally scoff at calls for more censorship, "curation" etc on what is basically a large public medium of expression on account of "concern for the children", to me kids are the parents responsibility.
- s_kilk 8y ago> Youtube would load but only run videos and suggestions form a carefully curated set of publishers that respect the age. I suspect they're deep, deep down in a pit of denial because to admit that this is a problem would be an existential threat to them and their way of parenting.
- cthalupa 8y ago>Makes me wonder if I’m getting all Tipper Gore in my old age and this is the new form of heavy metal panic. In general, I don't think so. There's a pretty clear value proposition in things like heavy metal, D&D, and similar Tipper Gore-esque hysterias. There's really not much value in these things - algorithmically generated random content that is designed to trigger the same response over and over again. But maybe a little on the 9 year old. I think the biggest fear here is the impact it has on really young children, and kids that are likely to get sucked into this are probably closer to the <5-6 year old range. At 9 the kid should have a much better understanding of reality and how the world works, and should be less likely to get sucked into watching these for any great length of time. They're also less likely to come away from it with their view of reality being impacted - they can see and parse what actually goes on well enough to know this shit is super weird. I think for older children it's something to be aware of, and if you see it impacting their behavior, then certainly, take steps to handle it. And I imagine that some amount of older kids are going to react negatively to it as well.
- coolspot 8y agoPeople of ElsaGate tracking and report these videos: https://reddit.com/r/ElsaGate https://reddit.com/r/ElsaGate
- new_age_garbage 8y agoEngineering problem aside: Stop and think about this for a second. YouTube is hosting videos designed for child abuse and doing nothing about it.
- mchahn 8y agoThe article did nothing to explain the motivation for making sick videos instead of bland knockoffs. I know my grandchildren will watch anything. Surely a sick video won't gather more views than a bland one. Maybe the number that are sick is small and not typical.
- oflannabhra 8y agoI actually think children would be more likely to select an abusive video to watch than a bland one. Child psychology is incredibly complex, and I am nowhere near an expert, but out of anecdotal experience, children are both terrified and fascinated by their fears. There is an almost obsessive tendency that comes from a minor trauma: for example, a child being startled by a vacuum might then cry every time he sees a vacuum, and ask to see the vacuum. Note that I don’t think this absolves parents or anyone at YouTube. I think they are both morally obligated to protect children from videos such as this.
- anigbrowl 8y agoSurely a sick video won't gather more views than a bland one. Of course it will. That's why there's a market for horror movies, but there's no real market for avowedly dull movies.
- ricardobeat 8y agoThere are thousands upon thousands of them (though many have been recently removed). Especially the 3D ones. And they have staggering view counts in the hundreds of millions, due to the compounding effect of quantity, shock factor and recommendation algorithms.
- JetSpiegel 8y agoFord is creating vans for paedophiles to abuse kids in and do nothing about it! Home Depot is selling construction materials for paedophiles to build basements to abuse kids! This works with many companies.
- acd 8y agoOne thing to think about is that its called a TV-program. Just like a Computer program a TV program is a content that can change the mind. Young brains do not have filters of what is good and bad.
- dpeck 8y agoUnpopular opinion: pay for the content you want and know that it is what it is, either iTunes, Kindle free time, etc.
- myWindoonn 8y agoAnother unpopular opinion: Parents should not let their children watch something that they have not themselves watched and approved. Edit: This isn't smugness. Do you think it's also smug to not run untrusted binaries? To not copy-and-paste from Stack Overflow into production? To say "thank you," or "yes, I've got it," when taking a blade from somebody else? To not run with scissors is my opinion, not because of smugness, but because I care about safety.
- skywhopper 8y agoYour brilliant insight is addressed in the article. It's fun to feel smug and say "just don't do X, duhhhh", but you are just ignoring the problem. "Just don't let your kids play with matches, duuuhhhh." Brilliant solution! Unfortunately your city is burning down around you.
- Avamander 8y agoWhat you just said is like saying: ""Brush your teeth" is a bad advice when you already have cavities". "Don't do X" is not ignoring the problem, it's literally the only way to avoid Y negative effect caused by X.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jstarfish 8y agoKids shows are pretty inane. Sesame Street (and Spongebob, if you can stand it) at least throw bones to the adult audience every now and then, but there's nothing in an episode of PJ Masks to keep me engaged. That said, parents that unleash their kids on YouTube make about as much sense as encouraging them to go play in a dumpster. Its all fun and games until the obscenity surfaces and the feedback loop begins.
- jacquesm 8y agoBack in the day, before WikiPedia was even born I made a small website called "Adalyn". The website pretended to be a very curious girl that you could teach stuff. Everytime some term would be used it would ask you to explain that term, adding it to the list of definitions. And so on, it got quite clever within a week or so. Then the jerks discovered the site and within hours it was nothing but a huge perverted caricature of what it was intended to be. The internet has - and will always have - a number of assholes whose only joy it is to make others miserable in whatever way they can. So from that day on I always design whatever I make with abuse in mind from day one. It still doesn't always work, but for the most part that seems to be the only reasonable way to put stuff together for public consumption. It's frustrating, but it's reality.
- skywhopper 8y agoAdd in the opportunity for profit and algorithms that can generate content, and you get a magic spiral of abusive and exploitative content that rewards the worst impulses.
- sangnoir 8y ago> Then the jerks discovered the site and within hours it was nothing but a huge perverted caricature of what it was intended to be. It was a lesson Microsoft learnt the hard way, a decade+ later with its AI twitter bot (Tay)[1] 1. https://www.theverge.com/2016/3/24/11297050/tay-microsoft-chatbot-racist https://www.theverge.com/2016/3/24/11297050/tay-microsoft-ch...
- bonesss 8y agoIt almost makes you wonder if bot-programmers and their related marketing team have never seen a bathroom wall before... Anonymity paired with a publishing channel seem to bring out a certain kind of creativity...
- dictum 8y agoAn atemporal kind of creativity. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13976155 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13976155
- sireat 8y agoHuman curation / whitelist is the answer but Google being human averse is not going to pay for that and keep hoping for AI answer. I remember there was a second party website of human curated youtube videos for kids some 4-5 years ago, Kideos . It worked really well at the time (for my first kid) but site seems to be broken now.
- jenkstom 8y agoMaybe this is just how the economy will work in the future. Paying for curated content - even just selections of free content. It's not a bad model at all.
- anigbrowl 8y agoTake YouTube’s recommendation system for starters That's going to be their downfall, since its priority seems to be to connect people to the worst of the site as firmly as possible. A year or two ago I became curious about the flat earthers and watched 2 videos to try and figure out if there was any sort of deeper meaning to their superficially ridiculous claims (spoiler: there isn't). YT kept shoving flat earth videos at me for weeks like some sort of ontological crack dealer.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoI assumed that the flat earth thing was supposed to be some elaborate troll / in-joke that I just didn't get. You're saying it isn't?
- skywhopper 8y agoNo. The more this stuff is out there, the more people are genuinely believing it. Check out this article from a couple of weeks ago: https://www.newyorker.com/science/elements/looking-for-life-on-a-flat-earth https://www.newyorker.com/science/elements/looking-for-life-...
- mbroncano 8y agoGreat article, thanks
- antpls 8y agoThat didn't prove anything sufficient enough to answer a categorical "No". For most people, it points to the fact that knowing the shape of Earth is irrevelant and far away of their everyday problems. If it doesn't make any economical sense to say the "Earth is a sphere", then people can say what they like.
- carapace 8y agoOf course it is. One that's thousands of years old at least, a true classic.
- 8y ago
- sexydefinesher 8y agoIt's weird that the creators of these videos haven't been found yet, at least the live-action actors should have been doxxed by now.
- noonespecial 8y agoIt was My Little Pony for my daughter. That was the day we learned about "trolls" on the internet. I wish this were a better world and that this was unnecessary but in retrospect it was a sweet bonding moment we still laugh about years later. Kids are resilient as long as you are there to help them make sense of it. And you have too. The internet and it's trolls aren't going anywhere. In the end, goatse comes for us all...
- schappim 8y agoI think you mean Gabriella Goat[1]. 1. http://peppapig.wikia.com/wiki/Gabriella_Goat http://peppapig.wikia.com/wiki/Gabriella_Goat
- jackvalentine 8y agoChamp he really, really doesn’t.
- schappim 8y ago:-)
- noonespecial 8y agoI think someone just experienced the 8 stages... http://raincoaster.com/2007/08/27/photoessay-o-the-day-the-eight-phases-of-goatse/ http://raincoaster.com/2007/08/27/photoessay-o-the-day-the-e...
- schappim 8y agoOh dear god why!!!!!!
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSo, YouTube can quickly and efficiently get entire movies removed for copyright violation, thus protecting the almighty profit margin of BigCo, but is incapable of safeguarding our kids. Because? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- mmt 8y agoEasy, because it's actually BigCo paying for someone to ask for that removal.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoBut parents likely ask too. The previous article on this topic asked. Asking doesn't appear, per se, to be the explanation.
- mmt 8y agoI didn't mean asking for a solution, I meant, more specifically, "asking" (really demanding) that certain videos be taken down, such as with a DMCA takedown request. Are you saying that Youtube has spent their own resources to make it easier for BigCo, beyond that legal obligation?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI am more suggesting that this is a fundamental problem in the world where we have "might makes right" rather than "might for right." People can exist without companies. Companies cannot exist without people. Companies should serve people, not the other way around. Something has gone very wrong that it works this way. Given that people created these companies, people run these companies, people created the laws and court system used to justify this shit and on and on... Somewhere, we lost our way and forgot that all of these things should serve the common good for humanity. These systems became bastardized and we sit around lamenting that this is just how it is and we are too powerless to stop it. We have become the slaves of things we invented to serve us and we loudly proclaim that this is the new natural order and there is nothing to be done about it.
- rubyfan 8y agoAfter about 2 months of endless “Johnny Johnny” and “Finger Family” videos which were bad enough, a video came up that used the MF word. My wife reacted appropriately and just deleted the YouTube app. Problem solved, no chance encounters with the bad content and more sanity for mom and dad. In retrospect I wish we would have done it sooner.
- sremani 8y agoStep 1. Delete YouTube or YouTube Kids Step 2. Install PBS Kids and Duck Duck Moose Do not let any un-curated automagic near kids. Its not worth the headache!
- freehunter 8y agoI say this as someone who is not a parent, but it amazes me the things parents let their kids do. I cringe when I see my siblings give their kids their $600 phones to play with when they're still in the age where "throw something on the floor and make an adult pick it up" is the most fun game you can play. But that's just a piece of property... just putting on YouTube and letting kids explore the Internet has potential to be far worse. I know the fucked up things I saw on the Internet as a kid, and I know it hasn't gotten any better since then. YouTube is not a safe space and it blows my mind that otherwise responsible adults treat it as such. Again I'm not a parent so maybe I can't understand it through that lens, but from an outsider's view it's awful. There's just so many hours of misery on YouTube that even adults don't need to see.
- bscphil 8y ago100% agree with you. The problem is not just that parents are setting their kids in front of a wide open medium filled with abusive content, it's that they're letting their kids watch hours upon hours of mindless entertainment in the first place. I realize this is kind of a third rail at the moment, but hear me out. The fact is that parents got by for thousands of years without having electronic child sitting devices. The time children waste on glowing screens could be more productively spent learning (remember books?), socializing with their peers, or enjoying healthy exercise. If a child absolutely has to have an hour a day in front of a screen, at the least give them something worthwhile like Mr. Rogers' reruns to watch. Who knows what the long term effects of 3 hours of the same nursery rhyme a day will have on their mental health. At the very least I think extreme caution is warranted; it's easier to let the screens do the baby-sitting, but raising a kid has never been easy.
- freehunter 8y ago
- Twisell 8y agoElephant in the room being that peppa pig is not a copyright free content... There is no risk at all to put your kid in front of a peppa pig list of episodes on Netflix or another legal video plateform. But YouTube can’t efficiently curate or filter content like peppa pig because it’s not legal and the only appropriate action following law would be removal. And that’s their main problem they actually needs illegal kids cartoon to be posted because it’s what people that put kid in front of YouTube are seeking. And Alphabet have paying customers that ask to place their ads in front of kids...
- EA 8y agoPeppa Pig and other cartoons have official channels with free episodes on YouTube.
- olfactory 8y agoThe root cause of this problem is that YouTube does not offer a whitelist only option for parents.
- bsg75 8y agoAn oddity of the current day and age is that people let children on a service like YT without supervision. As a child, my parents vetted anything I watched that was not a broadcast children's TV show. Adult themes and violence were filtered until an age that was considered safe. This was also a time when the TV schedule could be known in advance. There was no on-demand anything - pre-VCR. I can't imagine handing a child the loaded gun of the internet and letting them point it at their developing heads.
- msl09 8y agoMost of my coworkers work two shifts, most of them got a second job when they realized that it was impossible to raise their children with their previous income. At some moments they are so tired that they relegate child rearing to technology, none of them chose that willingly.
- nomocrypto 8y agoI argue that having children is 100% a conscious decision (well, unprotected sex is) and if you can’t afford to actually raise your children, you are not in a position to have them. Seriously, why does nobody do the math and make a budget BEFORE having children? I know the answer: lots of babies are accidents and abortion is still seen as wrong by a lot of people. If you don’t have the means to raise children (financially or time-wise), don’t have them.
- msl09 8y agoSome people don't live in countries where abortion is legal, as it's the case for my friends. It's also important to know the huge influence of culture and peer pressure on having kids. I got physically upset when I went to parties with friends and couples were told non-stop that they needed to have kids, "it's wonderful", "I didn't know what it meant to be a woman before then", "your biological clock is ticking", and of course there's peer pressure back at home as moms tell their children that "they need grandchildren", "soon they will be too old to help with raising them". Ignoring that pressure sometimes means alienation in most social occasions as your friends and siblings only have interest in "parents talk" that you cannot engage in.
- golemiprague 8y agoTried all kind of solutions to block or monitor my kids access, there is no one good solution which deals with content, overall time on screens, money spending and all the other things you would want to prevent your kids from doing. Seems to me like companies are encouraging this mayhem instead of setting one standard to manage the whole thing.
- unclebucknasty 8y ago>Whether these videos are deliberately malicious, “merely” trolling, or the emergent effect of complex systems, isn’t the point. That's an extraordinarily naive statement and it's baffling that the author even questions the obvious intent and, worse, reaches the conclusion that intent isn't important here. He then goes on to say the problem is with the platforms, algorithms, etc. While these have their issues, I think he overweights them by a good bit, and they are secondary to this particular subject. That is, if the algorithms weren't being abused, then they would be just fine for their intended purpose. The problem here is that the content they are working on is problematic to say the least. Specifically, someone is clearly and deliberately targeting children with disturbing videos that promote extreme violence associated with themes and characters they think to benevolent and loving. He then completely acknowledges this in the following nugget: >Previously happy and well-adjusted children became frightened of the dark, prone to fits of crying, or displayed violent behaviour and talked about self-harm – all classic symptoms of abuse. So, the harm is specific and clear. How can he then dismiss this as possible happenstance of secondary importance? We also live in a culture where people are being radicalized online and children are now being murdered in schools en masse, frequently by other (slightly older) children. Does the author not see a thread here? Now, broaden the context further to consider the armies of troll-bots, etc. on our platforms that we know are being weaponized against us to incite anger, division, etc. There can be no other conclusion except that we are under a sustained attack to divide and destroy our society, and now children are being included on the target list. This is not some randomly generated content to game platform algorithms for ad revenue that just happens to be disturbing. It is specifically effective in damaging children and is rooted in a very particular line of psychological attack.
- plasma 8y agoLego Universe from memory had "content moderators" constantly looking at the world players created to remove inappropriate content (as LEGO is aimed at children), https://www.geek.com/games/penis-detection-derailed-the-lego-universe-mmo-1624034/ https://www.geek.com/games/penis-detection-derailed-the-lego... which caused it in the end to be shutdown
- vivekd 8y ago>Previously happy and well-adjusted children became frightened of the dark, prone to fits of crying, or displayed violent behaviour and talked about self-harm I'm all for keeping kids away from mature content, and I think parents should monitor their children online. . . but I thought kids were more resilient than this. I don't have kids, but it's hard for me to imagine them displaying violence and self harm because of some disturbing video.
- ricardobeat 8y agoYou’re just underestimating how disturbing these are, even for adults. Violence, rape, cannibalism, gore, in the creepiest form possible, involving either your favourite cartoon characters or adults dressed in ragged Spider-Man costumes. EDIT: a few samples here https://www.reddit.com/r/ElsaGate/comments/6o6baf/what_is_elsagate/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ElsaGate/comments/6o6baf/what_is_el...
- megy 8y agoThis is one of the great things about youtube, that alongside Disney videos you have home made videos. But it doesn't work for kids. Should youtube change? Or parents reliance upon it.
- iincuser 8y agoAs a parent in the IT world for the past 15yrs (with a background in networks, servers, etc) I find it difficult to reasonably block YouTube from my pre-teen kids. I can delete from their devices, I can set parental controls, etc but somehow they were always able to find some kind of way to watch it. I finally had to tie all smart TVs and devices to a local dns server in my home and filter all in/out traffic as a last resort. Most parents don’t have the slightest clue how to do something like this and I see my kids friends with pretty much open access to the internet and YouTube and it’s very disconcerting.. plus I’ve seen some of the “kid friendly” crap on YouTube, like catching my kids watching adults giving product reviews of toys (basically marketing to them about why they would want the toy) that is marked as kid safe. It’s hours and hours of let’s look at this toy, let’s talk about what it does and why you “need” it. It’s utterly absurd and a form of predatory marketing. I know there are some positive things about YouTube like when I can lookup a quick instructional video on how to do something but in whole, I’d rather see YouTube just completely shutdown.
- yurishimo 8y agoShutdown for who? I don’t think anyone wants to see YouTube actually go away entirely. I agree that better filtering of advertising to kids is needed though.
- dingleberry 8y agowhy isn't there kids.youtube.com ? why youtube kids must app-only ?
- samat 8y agoReady to be downvoted to hell, but I’d rather not force feed by kids with hours of unsupervised video. Any video at all
- arcturus17 8y agoNot too much of a conspiracy theorist, but what are the chances that part of this is organized by Chinese, North Korean or Russian government agencies? The incentives are there - disrupt one of the West's biggest platforms, cause social upheaval - and with just a bit of funding an effort like this could go a long way. Is this option not being considered and investigated?
- pndy 8y agoRight, because every single problem people face nowadays is coming from the outside, from "these evil countries".
- arcturus17 8y agoHave you read the article and studied the issue at large, or are you just here to contribute your snark? There is good evidence that a lot of this content is produced in China. My question is whether this is state-endorsed.
- tboyd47 8y agoThe topic of grotesquely inappropriate kids videos on YouTube (aka "Elsagate" videos) comes up on HN and offline every so often. I've noticed that people's opinions on it tend to fall into one or two categories: they either get self-righteous about how their child doesn't have to see them because of their supreme parenting skills, or they start waxing philosophical about the limits of AI or importance of human curation in online communities or something like that. What's missed in these discussions is the pure oddness of these videos. And I don't mean odd as in quirky and funny. I mean odd as in uncategorized - meaning that there's no conceivable way for some of these videos to emerge logically as a function of society. And the sheer effort put into them and endless variety seems to imply some sort of underground economy or industry behind them. A lot of children's media is edgy and experimental in ways that adults deem inappropriate, and it's been that way for decades. Remember Ren and Stimpy? There's a lot in that that would make today's parents really uncomfortable. And nowadays, kids' movies (like Shrek) will usually have some inappropriate humor encoded in it to keep the adults happy. But it's all just entertainment and the themes are all familiar. You can kind of imagine how it played out. The writer of a kids' show had a slightly-edgier-than-usual idea for a gag and thought it would fly under the company's radar, and happened to be right that time. Maybe I'm just naive about the state of video technology or the depravity of ordinary people, but I can't possibly imagine the type of mind that dreams this stuff up or the company that provides the resources and manpower for such a project. I get that they're done to farm clicks from 2-year-olds, but that doesn't explain the content of the videos. Stuff like Elsa becoming pregnant and receiving an abortion via Spiderman injecting her with a giant hypodermic needle, or Minnie Mouse blacking out after her friend spikes her cocktail with pills and waking up chained to a bed? The cruelty and inhumanity depicted in these videos using children's characters go way, way beyond the realm of goofy pranks and immature comedy. They indicate an intimate familiarity with the criminal world.
- dictum 8y agoThe more things change... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_nasty https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_nasty
- carrja99 8y agoYoutube could solve this whole problem by letting people simply whitelist the channels they want to be viewed and blacklist everything else.