8 ms·
Inside Tesla’s Model 3 Factory
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>But relying on suppliers got Tesla into trouble with the Model X, when its engineers designed an extremely difficult-to-make “monopost” seat and an impossible-to-hit timeline. I chuckled a bit when I read this. I can relate to this a lot. For awhile I worked at a university in the mechanical engineering department machine shop. I like to think I know when I'm talking about when I say that everyone makes this mistake. They just usually stop making it by the time they've got their degree. Designing parts that deviate greatly from industry standards for marginal gain and then finding out it's impossible to build what you want in the time you have is rookie engineer mistake 101. It's always tempting at the time but it's basically never worth it in hindsight If you need a widget for your application and this particular widget isn't central to your application then use an off the shelf widget or tweak it as little as possible. Don't design a bespoke widget from the ground up. Designing your own widget from scratch consumes resources you should bet spending core aspects of the thing that you're building and has a high risk of being a time and effort black hole as you work out teething issues. Reinventing the wheel is fine, you should require that people have damn good reason or every team will want to reinvent every wheel and nothing will get done on time. edit: I want my ass to be comfortable as much as the next guy but I'd rather have an off the shelf seat and have a Tesla now than have a bespoke seat and be on a waiting list.
- vertline 8y agoI think I read somewhere with Tesla that a problem with outside suppliers is that you can't always negotiate the price down to a competitive place. Specifically if the supplier has a patent or something that gives them leverage in pricing. I'm not sure I'm wording what I mean correctly.
- walrus01 8y agoPretty much everything you just wrote is applicable to the Juicero hardware. Business model set entirely aside for a moment, its hardware is an example of what happens when some C-level decision makers let the engineering staff go wild with no real world constraints: https://blog.bolt.io/heres-why-juicero-s-press-is-so-expensive-6add74594e50 https://blog.bolt.io/heres-why-juicero-s-press-is-so-expensi... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Cp-BGQfpHQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Cp-BGQfpHQ
- zaroth 8y agoMore on the monopost seats, if you’re curious: https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-addresses-model-x-2nd-row-seat-supply-constraint/ https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-addresses-model-x-2nd-row-se...
- rainbowmverse 8y agoThey might have been preparing for their trucks. A lot of engineering time is spent on their ride quality, so I wouldn't be surprised if they use a lot of highly custom parts. If you're planning to take over trucking, working out some of the details early with your cars might make sense.
- Odenwaelder 8y agoHow do you decide on which brand of robots to use? I remember seeing videos from the Model S production line having only KUKA robots, but for the Model 3, I only see FANUC.
- dmode 8y agoI guess whoever offers better pricing, support, timelines etc
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jandrese 8y agoGiven how fast they were trying to ramp up production I wouldn't be surprised if they had to buy robots from multiple vendors becauase no single vendor was capable of building and installing the 2,000 robot arms he needed to hit that 5,000 car/week in 2 months target.
- dmode 8y agoThe bottleneck is not so much with robot manufacturers, but actually with the software implementation. There are software consultancies who will program the robot arms per Tesla specs.
- solarkraft 8y agoWith Tesla being focused on doing things in-house, shouldn't those be employees?
- darzu 8y agoDoes anyone know approx. how much one of these costs? https://www.fanucamerica.com/home/products-services/robots/fanuc-zdt-zero-down-time https://www.fanucamerica.com/home/products-services/robots/f...
- 8y ago
- fhood 8y agoI can't really judge how much insight can be gained from this article. It's a little short on details, and reads as much like a press release as a piece of journalism. That said, damn are those some incredibly cool pictures. Seriously.
- gowld 8y agoIt's PR, and it has cool pictures. No insight necessary.
- sschueller 8y agoI would love to see some videos of the Robots in action.
- kjksf 8y agoThere are some on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVCCroN7vS0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVCCroN7vS0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8_lfxPI5ObM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8_lfxPI5ObM And one with more than just factory: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KA18tusTgE4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KA18tusTgE4
- 1024core 8y agoThe first 2 videos are from 2015 and 2013, respectively. I'm guessing things have changed a bit since then?
- izacus 8y agoTesla S didn't really change since then, why do you expect a huge manufacturing plant to change drastically? It's not like you just throw all robots and conveyor belts in a bin like an iPhone. Car industry is on significantly longer cycles.
- niyazpk 8y agoElon said[1] in the shareholder meeting that the Model S has changed significantly from the older versions. I don't know the differences myself, so take it FWIW. [1] https://www.tesla.com/shareholdermeeting https://www.tesla.com/shareholdermeeting at around 01:16:00
- srcmap 8y agoThere are quite a bit of oil/grease on the floor from the latest pictures. The youtube video looks so much cleaner.
- zaroth 8y agoReally would have loved if these were animated gifs, even if just 3-5 second loops. It can be hard to parse what you’re even looking at without seeing it move.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- woodandsteel 8y agoI understand that Musk comes up with his radical innovations by starting out with first principles and then reasoning from there. I wonder what was his specific set of thought processes that lead to the radically different approach that Tesla is taking to manufacture the Model 3.
- s2g 8y ago> radically different approach that Tesla is taking to manufacture the Model 3. I thought they gave up and went back to more traditional methods?
- kitsunesoba 8y agoOnly partially, with bits and pieces being re-automated as kinks get worked out. They’ve postponed full on automation until the Model Y.
- manigandham 8y agoThat machines could build machines faster, cheaper, and better than humans. It was more about extreme evolution in that aspect, but then it allowed for a very different design in the factory itself since it didn't need to accommodate humans everywhere. In reality, it seems it might have been too much technological complexity all at once. Traditional assembly lines have decades of optimization with talent readily available. It's the inevitable bugs of any new tech approach, compounded by timeline, talent, and cash pressures.
- erikb 8y agosmart phones where a radical innovation, but how is making batteries, electric cars, or reusing rockets radical? From my understanding Musk is investing in tough challenges for prestige. The innovation, if any, comes from his engineers.
- woodandsteel 8y ago>how is making batteries, electric cars, or reusing rockets radical? No one ever made a reusable satellite-launching rocket before that landed on its tail and was cheaper than a disposable rocket. And Musk came up with the basic plan for how to do it. Nobody made an electric car before that ran off of lithium ion batteries, and no one made an electric luxury car. And Musk made up the basic plan for doing it. Or perhaps you already knew all this and are in a tight spot because you shorted a whole lot of Tesla stock.
- heisenbergs 8y agoWow. There is so much machinery that it's hard to spot the actual car parts. Would like to know how this compares to other car manufacturers. I've seen pictures from VW where there always seem to be humans around, though that may be part of PR. I also wonder when the typical Muskian move of in-housing more than is usual (ie car seats) will fall over, or whether this will remain a competitive advantage as Tesla will have more skin in the game than others.
- rootusrootus 8y agoMost established car manufacturers have the body line near 100% automated. Tesla isn't doing too bad really but they are still playing catch up. People like to talk like the existing companies are back in the stone age or something. Hardly.
- rconti 8y agoA few random comments, having toured a few auto plants and watched plenty of videos: * I'm surprised to hear Tesla is using robots to install seats. This isn't common, from what I've seen. * I toured the Tesla factory back in October, perhaps a month after touring BMW in Munich. Tesla was vastly less automated than BMW, for better or for worse. So I take the whole "Tesla is automating EVERYTHING!" with a grain of salt. * It's not uncommon for cars to have the seatbelt integrated into the seat itself. Particularly with convertibles. * A lot of this reads like a puff piece.
- danso 8y ago> So I take the whole "Tesla is automating EVERYTHING!" with a grain of salt. FTA: > Even so, Tesla says the Model 3 body line is now 95 percent automated, including the transfer, loading, and welding of parts. Apparently, there's a big difference between the "body line" assembly and the rest of the line, as people in r/teslamotors have pointed out: https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/8pim5q/inside_teslas_model_3_factory_tesla_says_the/e0bjy80/ https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/8pim5q/inside_... > When I was visiting the BMW plant in Munich a few years ago, they said the body line was automated 99%. It‘s really impressive, showed me that the real secret is not in the design of your car, but the design of your assembly line. > But keep in mind that this is only the body line. The rest of the assembly process involves quite a bit more humans.
- rconti 8y agoAh, cool, thanks. Yeah, I saw humans doing TONS of stuff at Tesla; driving forklifts around (dragging chunks of wood under the wheels and bumping into things), etc. OTOH its also possible BMW just hides that stuff from their tours :)
- bgorman 8y agoThe thing that stands out to me here is that Tesla has wasted a ton of time and money building up competency in commodity features. No consumer considers Tesla Seats to be the differentiating factor. Why on earth didn't Tesla just decide to use a more conventional seat design and outsource the work to a Seat supplier like all other car manufacturers. Kind of reminds me of Software Engineers that always want to roll their own implementation of everything... They get less done and are overconfident in their own abilities.
- adventured 8y agoIt's because Musk is a micro-manager that is easily frustrated by flaws in external solutions and more tolerant of even greater flaws internally. It's why he puts his nose into everything his companies do (eg in the article it mentions he had a role in designing the extruded aluminum base of the Model X seat, which is absurd).
- kchhina 8y agoI don’t think it is absurd. I think it shows he wants to know what goes into his cars and rockets. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve had executives above me who had never even seen the products they were representing. I admire it when an executive can roll up their sleeves and get into it without being disruptive.
- kjksf 8y agoOne possibility: that mindset of mediocrity doesn't produce excellence. Apple, for example, is famous for caring about things that rationally they shouldn't care, like the insides of their computers. And since history is written by victors and we apply post factum rationalization, no one says that Apple is wrong to care about details that are arguably irrelevant to the success. The same will happen with Tesla. If Tesla is successful then Musk will be a genius with uncompromising standard for quality. If Tesla will fail then Musk will be an idiot whose hubris, micro-management and inability to prioritize doomed the company. And reality is that neither you or me have enough information to judge this decision one way or another. You weren't there and the it was probably more complicated that what you assume based on zero data. According to reports Tesla started doing seats in-house when a contractor that was supposedly an experienced seat maker failed to produce Model X seats which contributed to 18 month delay in delivering the car.