15 ms·
Justice Dept. Seizes Times Reporter’s Email/Phone Records in Leak Investigation
- forapurpose 8y agoThe Executive Branch is going after both the press and the Congress, and the article doesn't convey anyone putting up too much of a fight. Unless I missed something, I only see statements of concern or principle, from 'we'll see if this is bad' to "we're deeply troubled" > “Freedom of the press is a cornerstone of democracy, and communications between journalists and their sources demand protection,” said Eileen Murphy, a Times spokeswoman. > Ms. Watkins’s personal lawyer, Mark J. MacDougall, said: “It’s always disconcerting when a journalist’s telephone records are obtained by the Justice Department — through a grand jury subpoena or other legal process. Whether it was really necessary here will depend on the nature of the investigation and the scope of any charges.” > Ben Smith, the editor in chief of BuzzFeed News, said in a statement, “We’re deeply troubled by what looks like a case of law enforcement interfering with a reporter’s constitutional right to gather information about her own government.”
- drawnwren 8y agoThis really isn't that surprising. If, by reporting you are directly involved in a crime - you're gonna have a bad time. We can argue all day about whether information should be classified, but the fact remains that disclosing classified information is illegal in the US. Had the reporter engaged in murder or theft while reporting, would there be any outrage? I admit it's a bit odd, because it isn't a crime for the reporter -- but they are definitely involved in the commission of a crime.
- forapurpose 8y ago> the fact remains that disclosing classified information is illegal in the US It's not as simple as that; a few points: 1. The Constitution's protection of freedom of the press can outweigh any laws on classification, though the courts haven't said that. 2. The unauthorized release of classified information has many times been important for democracy to function, for government to be held accountable, and that is exactly the role and function of the press. 3. The classification of information is believed by many to be excessive. Much that is classified is not dangerous and doesn't need to be classified. I've read several examples of information classified to cover up government activities. 4. Classification obviously could be used to intentionally reduce accountability to the public. It's not hard to imagine a scenario where the President commits a crime, and it's covered up by classification. Arguably, this happened with NSA spying and CIA torture. 5. Until the Obama administration, Presidents did not prosecute leaks regularly, indicating that they were not viewed as dangerous. Generally, not nearly all laws are enforced; 'it's illegal' is not a threshold, or it seems almost everyone could be prosecuted for something. > Had the reporter engaged in murder or theft while reporting, would there be any outrage? Not comparable.
- olliej 8y agoWell that’s not at all disconcerting.
- JumpCrisscross 8y agoIs there a material downside to the Times switching external e-mails to E2E encrypted and to be deleted after N months?
- tedunangst 8y agoDon't forget step two, blacklist all buzzfeed writers from being hired.
- wmf 8y agoJohnny can't encrypt so their sources would probably still send them unencrypted email.
- WindowsFon4life 8y agoMore of the same from the last 9 years.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoSort of. But I think it’s important to note how many people were applauding the seizure of communications when the target was Trump’s lawyer...
- arosier 8y agoTimes, let me introduce you to ProtonMail.
- huy-nguyen 8y agoWho in their right mind would communicate confidential info to a reporter via email and what kind of reporter would allow their sources to do that? The minimum acceptable way to do this is end-to-end encrypted messages via Signal or GPG-encrypted emails via a service in a jurisdiction beyond the FBI’s reach (e.g ProtonMail).
- olliej 8y agohere’s the problem with saying things like “use proton mail” it deflects from the problem (warrantless search of email for 7 years) and instead attacks the use of email. Note that what was used shouldn’t matter from the POV warrant vs no warrant. Follow on with: there is no claim that there was anything found in those emails. All we have is an acknowledgement that the government is undertaking warrantless surveillance of a reporter,. It doesn’t have to find anything, it just needs to be threatening enough to ensure that no one talks again. Hence “chilling effect on journalism”
- olliej 8y agoApologies for terrible editing in the above message. Typing on my phone with beta software. There are some issues :)
- uabstraction 8y agoThe Times provides the information necessary to do just this right on their tips page, including instructions for PGP, WhatsApp, Signal, and SecureDrop. One would hope that serious whistleblowers would heed these instructions.
- zer00eyz 8y agoEveryone needs these directions, they need to be clear and followable to the letter with ease. It doesn't matter how competent you are, if your blowing the whistle then you not want the slightest chance of making a mistake - got to be a high stress situation, someone holding your hand through a critical portion makes sense to me.
- 8y ago
- eli 8y agoThe indictment talked mostly about using Signal so the comments here making fun of using email seem unfair.
- tptacek 8y agoIf, as seems likely, the messages were revealed because they weren't auto-deleted, then the flak email takes is especially well deserved. People are bad at deleting IM messages (even with apps like Signal that will auto-delete them if you ask). But scrubbing an email conversation is actually challenging, and people are notoriously bad at it. Email gets archived, and email replies and threads repeatedly quote and repeat fragments of the conversation; we've all read email "discussions" that were a single message with a long quote history in it.
- statictype 8y ago>we've all read email "discussions" that were a single message with a long quote history in it. Those emails are notorious for leaking information - especially when you loop someone external in and forget to scrub the long 3 month-long trail at the bottom.
- notveryrational 8y agoAnyone know what she was reporting on that caused the Justice Department to censor the coverage?
- iends 8y agoEven The Intercept got it their disclosure wrong once, and these guys are probably the experts: https://blog.erratasec.com/2017/06/how-intercept-outed-reality-winner.html https://blog.erratasec.com/2017/06/how-intercept-outed-reali... But unencrypted email certainly isn't the right way to go if you're leaking.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cf498 8y agoThey screwed over Winners by being unjustifiably incompetent and reckless or simply malicious. Thats not the behavior of any sort of "experts". Even more so when you look at the history of the reporter in question when it comes to the safety of his sources.
- marmshallow 8y agoDoes using gmail count as unencrypted?
- craftyguy 8y agoMost definitely.
- maxlybbert 8y agoGeneral Patraeus was caught leaking through Gmail. And, amusingly, they didn’t actually send the emails, they just shared an account and wrote draft emails for the other side to read. Granted, sharing an account with a co-writer turned out to be suspicious behavior, but apparently the government was able to get access to the draft emails that were under Google’s control (and I haven’t heard of any changes to Gmail that would make it more secure now).
- mirimir 8y ago> "Freedom of the press is a cornerstone of democracy," Ms. Murphy said. "This decision by the Justice Department will endanger reporters’ ability to promise confidentiality to their sources and, ultimately, undermine the ability of a free press to shine a much-needed light on government actions. That should be a grave concern to anyone who cares about an informed citizenry." Sure. But Ms. Watkins could have used better OPSEC, and trained her sources to do the same. Edit: You can't "promise confidentiality" if you're depending entirely on the behavior of third parties.
- emidln 8y agoAnd government officers could not blatantly violate their oaths to defend the Constitution.
- oh_sigh 8y agoThe thing about the Constitution is that until it gets to the USSC, everyone gets to have their own interpretation of it. People on the left were screaming that GWB was violating the constitution. People on the right were screaming that Obama was violating the constitution. Globalists et al are screaming that Trump is violating the constitution. But it literally means nothing until the highest court rules on it.
- baybal2 8y agoI have no idea what why you are getting downvoted. You speak truth: >People on the left were screaming that GWB was violating the constitution. People on the right were screaming that Obama was violating the constitution. Globalists et al are screaming that Trump is violating the constitution. But it literally means nothing until the highest court rules on it. Best to say it was the US highest court that has violated the constitution during all three administrations.
- geofft 8y agoIt also means nothing when the highest court rules on it, unless lower courts and lower law enforcement agencies pay attention. The Supreme Court has a few police officers, but they just protect the court building and the people in it; they can't enforce the Constitution themselves. The only thing the Supreme Court can do is tell other people what the Constitution says. So, the Supreme Court only has power as long as people respect the Constitution in the first place. (I don't understand your point about the left and right; it's certainly possible that all of Bush, Obama, and Trump violated the Constitution. The article specifically calls out the Trump administration for "continu[ing] the aggressive tactics employed under President Obama." It's not true that Democrats and Republicans are the same, but it's also not true that they're dualistic opposites, where every virtue and every vice belongs to exactly one. Sometimes they both possess the same vice.)
- res0nat0r 8y agoAny idea how the DOJ got their Signal communications? I've never used the app, but did he just not delete his messages or something stupid like that? https://twitter.com/mattdpearce/status/1004913094772944896 https://twitter.com/mattdpearce/status/1004913094772944896
- tptacek 8y agoThe most likely explanation would be that he simply didn't delete his messages, or have auto-delete enabled; or, perhaps, he had the auto-delete window for these particular contacts set too long.
- tuxxy 8y agoMost definitely this. Bad messenger OPSEC is a real problem, still. Just recently Paul Manafort backed up his encrypted WhatsApp messages to iCloud, for example. Many users of these apps don't realize that they are opening themselves up to security issues by performing certain behaviors. Are there any guides to good messenger OPSEC available for the general public (or even at-risk people like journalists or politicians?)
- OrwellianChild 8y agoThis is the one I see circulating the most. Links to Signal setup are in the body and include auto-deleting messages. https://techsolidarity.org/resources/basic_security.htm https://techsolidarity.org/resources/basic_security.htm
- plorg 8y agoWhile it may be true that Manafort incidentally backed up WhatsApp or Signal messages to iCloud, the FBI supporting statement in the motion to revoke parole indicates that the messages cited were preserved by the receiving party and voluntarily turned over to the FBI.
- nitrohorse 8y agoThese guides come to mind: * https://ssd.eff.org/en/module/how-use-signal-ios https://ssd.eff.org/en/module/how-use-signal-ios * https://yawnbox.com/static/iPhone-opsec-guide.html https://yawnbox.com/static/iPhone-opsec-guide.html * https://blog.filippo.io/securing-a-travel-iphone/ https://blog.filippo.io/securing-a-travel-iphone/
- loteck 8y agoUsing any electronic text messaging as a means to communicate state secrets strikes me as lazy, regardless of encryption. Data, metadata and breadcrumbs are left littered amongst an unknowable number of endpoints and 3rd party servers, permanently. Leaking state secrets isn't supposed to be easy and convenient; there's not an app for that.
- wmil 8y agoA staffer working for the Senate Intelligence Committee was dating a reporter who was writing stories based on exclusive intelligence leaks. They weren't exactly being super careful.
- mirimir 8y agoI wonder what they were thinking. I mean, maybe something like "I'm a reporter, so they can't ask about my sources." I'm reminded of David Petraeus and Paula Broadwell.
- creaghpatr 8y agoI bet they watched House of Cards and thought, hey it works for Zoe Barnes... Edit: I hope she does not have the same character arc of Zoe Barnes, which I won't spoil.
- oh_sigh 8y agoPretty cheeky to be the director of security and be leaking to a reporter that you're fucking. What is the correct way for the USG to behave in this manner? Some people are upset that they seized her communications, but what other choice is there? Just let leaks go unpunished? Or should senate aides et al sign a 'no privacy' agreement, where the USG can do whatever they want to intercept their communications at all points?
- beezle 8y agoReally depends what is "leaked" doesn't it? The only leak I am aware of that breaks a law would be passing classified documents (uncertain if the law specifically extends to discussions at which classified material may be used). Are you suggesting leaking details of something like the EPA heads abuses of position should be prosecutable?
- jonstewart 8y agoThey could have just revoked his security clearance, forcing him to resign. Think about the resources being expended on criminal prosecution of lying to the FBI.
- cycrutchfield 8y agoIt's meant to act as a deterrent. Nail one leaker to the wall, and others will be more reticent to leak.
- geofft 8y agoApparently this reporter was at BuzzFeed (not NYTimes) at the time of the messages. https://twitter.com/BuzzFeedBen/status/1004904034132725760 https://twitter.com/BuzzFeedBen/status/1004904034132725760
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Alex3917 8y agoOf course this is assuming the NYT didn't voluntarily give up the source and then ask the government to send them this letter. Given the NYT's history with whistleblowers, I have trouble seeing how anyone is taking this story at face value.
- jasonlotito 8y agoWhile the reporter works for NYTimes now, she was working at Buzzfeed at the time. It wasn't a NYTimes source.
- Alex3917 8y agoThat actually makes more sense. Still though, it's pathetic that the NYT pretended like they were going to publish the story about mass illegal wiretapping by the NSA and then buried it to get Bush re-elected, and now are complaining about the government reading their reporter's emails. As if this isn't completely deserved.
- rdtsc 8y agoLink to the indictment: https://www.justice.gov/usao-dc/press-release/file/1069836/download https://www.justice.gov/usao-dc/press-release/file/1069836/d... > The former aide, James A. Wolfe, 57, was charged with lying repeatedly to investigators about his contacts with three reporters. According to the authorities, Mr. Wolfe made false statements to the F.B.I. about providing two of them with private information related to the committee’s work. They did not say whether it was classified. Ah interesting. They definitely have metadata but they don't have (or don't admit to having) all the data. So they know who talked to who and when and caught him in a lie which can end up badly. But it seems they don't know the content so they can't say "on this day, in this message you divulged this classified information". They disclose a few Signal messages but they were simple like "Great job" or "I am glad I made your career" etc. Lying to FBI is not good but disclosing classified information is even worse. It seems in this case he is only charged with lying. I wonder had he refused to talk to the investigators what would have happened? Given he was an employee with clearance, did he even have a choice in saying "I am not answering your questions, talk to my lawyer"... > Under Mr. Obama, the Justice Department prosecuted more leak cases than all previous administrations combined. I wonder if there were simply more leaks because there were more dissenters, more media channels, more disappointed employees or those in charge ordered more resources allocated on finding and stopping the leaks. It is scary that they are going after and collecting all of reporter's communication going back for years. I can imagine that would be very scary.
- captain_perl 8y ago> I wonder if there were simply more leaks because there were more ... No, Obama had a personal thing against leakers. None was too many for him. I followed it in the news, but couldn't tell if it was motivate by being a lawyer, so some kind of omerta. OTOH, previous administrations used leaks as trial balloons, so had a more balanced approach. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/oct/10/obama-leaks-aggressive-nixon-report-prosecution https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/oct/10/obama-leaks-ag...
- mistermann 8y agoReally? I'm not really a news junkie, but I can't recall a single time hearing anything about Obama having a dispute with anyone, whereas I've heard stories about Trump virtually every day for the last year. Maybe he's even worse than they say?
- snacktaster 8y agoReminder to NOT use any 3rd-party VPN service if you truly value your privacy. ProtonVPN, PureVPN, Private Internet Access, etc. Do not use those services if you're intending to do some "shady shit". I know first hand that Google has a (semi)-automated web-based process for law enforcement to submit their subpoenas and get the entire access history of a particular Google/Gmail account. They don't get access to the contents of the account, but they get to see IP addresses and user agents that accessed that account in the last N days. A warrant to see the contents of the accounts would be trivial if the investigators wanted to pursue it.
- yourduskquibble 8y agoSo a better option would be to use your Comcast / AT&T / Verizon connection to leak data to the press? Everything on the internet (and really in life) is a chain of trust - there are going to be weak links however far down the rabbit hole you go.
- kinsomo 8y ago> So a better option would be to use your Comcast / AT&T / Verizon connection to leak data to the press? A better option is to use technology that might be better able to provide some verifiable anonymity guarantees, like Tor.
- mirimir 8y agoTrue. But Tor has pwned people too. Most recently, there was the bug that CMU researchers exploited, and then shared with the FBI. Also, many users of Tor browser have been pwned by phone-home malware, which leaked their ISP-assigned IP addresses. Hitting Tor through nested VPN chains would have protected them.
- kinsomo 8y ago> True. But Tor has pwned people too. Most recently, there was the bug that CMU researchers exploited, and then shared with the FBI. Also, many users of Tor browser have been pwned by phone-home malware, which leaked their ISP-assigned IP addresses. Hitting Tor through nested VPN chains would have protected them. It's better, as in closer to trust-no-one, but of course it's not perfect. Especially when we're talking about endpoint security concerns.
- zeth___ 8y agoFreedom of speech does not mean freedom from consequences turns out to be a really shitty idea when it happens to people you agree with.
- jurassic 8y agoMaybe I'm overlooking something here, but I don't know why leakers don't just use a forever stamp and drop something in the mail. Securing electronic communications seems freakishly hard by comparison. Is there some reason that is an obviously bad idea?
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoThere's a significant amount of physical evidence from that. You'd have to make sure it's clean of any fingerprints and DNA (hair) for one. Plus printers will typically inject watermarks into the document. Handwriting is definitely a thing to be analyzed. And the location which you mail stuff from leaks another few bits of information. It's probably a better idea than email, but not by all that much.
- shalmanese 8y agoThat's how Reality Winner leaked and she got caught via printer microdots.
- graylights 8y agosource? She printed it on a work printer. They had a short list of everyone that accessed the file. Microdots were both unnecessary and useless towards finding who did it. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-06-08/accused-leaker-is-indicted-for-disclosing-classified-report https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-06-08/accused-l...
- ipsin 8y agoUsing the postal service might be lower-risk, but it's not risk free. If you try that, don't forget about the Mail Covers [1] program. If you're mailing a reporter at the NY Times, you're at risk if you use your own handwriting. You might also be at risk if you use a printed label [2]. There's also the risk that your mail will be intercepted, and I wouldn't be too shocked to discover that government agencies were selectively (or not-so-selectively) reading our mail [3]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mail_cover https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mail_cover [2]https://www.eff.org/pages/list-printers-which-do-or-do-not-display-tracking-dots https://www.eff.org/pages/list-printers-which-do-or-do-not-d... [3] https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/53dk3n/this-camera-can-read-a-book-without-opening-it https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/53dk3n/this-camer...
- cm2187 8y agoInteresting to see this shortly after the release of the movie The Post. Obama attempted something similar. Basically Nixon had more respect for the independence of the press than current administrations.
- nautilus12 8y agoIm surprised that majority of the comments are about how they are dissapointed about their carelessness and not noting that leaking classified information is bad regardless of your ultimate aim. This is exactly what we should expect to happen when people leak classified information regardless of your ultimate motivation
- cpmouter 8y agoMany people here have some edgy anarchist vibe to them. Fight the power, brother.
- sametmax 8y agoThis assumes the people classifying the information are the good guys. It's not an easy problem to solve.
- Clubber 8y agoDan Carlin had a podcast about this. He said something to the effect of, "what if you had a stamp and every time you stamped something, your boss would never find out about it. How long do you think it would take before you start putting the stamp on your mistakes?" What he was trying to get at is, how does a democracy function properly when it has no idea what it's leadership is doing, because the leadership makes everything secret and classified? It's a good question and I don't really have an answer.
- nautilus12 8y agoOn the reverse side of that, how can a government function when everybody feels like they are privy to know everything about its operations. Its like having a meeting with too many people in the room. Nothing ever gets done. Democracy functions in that we have a democratic process to elect those who represent us, and at some level we need to trust them with certain elements of operations because everyone knowing everything could cause harm in some cases. If we dont trust who we elect to office then thats a seperate issue that we need to tackle on its own.
- 8y ago
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoSend a letter.
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoI would leak printed documents - preferably not with a Laserjet - by sending them, not sent from my hometown but random (does this make it less secure? pattern detection? gas stations linked to my VISA?) towns. And make sure - difficult (re-OCR to text? high contrast?) - they are not marked (dot-marked, whitespace-marked, font-marked, ...) to me. I'd prefer that way to any long chain of online trusted systems of which only one needs to leak. To me digital OpSec feels more difficult to maintain. Add a printed PGP key and the reporter can post more questions online on their homepage (could the NSA detect cut&paste? JS-events with injected JS?).
- zaroth 8y agoJames Wolfe, 57, Director of Security of the Senate Intelligence Committee for 29 years... leaks intel on Carter Page to his “girlfriend” (she was 21 years old at the time) at BuzzFeed, who publishes a huge scoop and lands a job at the NYT.... [1] Sounds like a script from House of Cards. [1] - https://www.nytco.com/ali-watkins-joining-washington-bureau/ https://www.nytco.com/ali-watkins-joining-washington-bureau/
- zaroth 8y agoAnd just wow.... this tweet from her in 2013: https://twitter.com/aliwatkins/status/347800186195701760?s=21 https://twitter.com/aliwatkins/status/347800186195701760?s=2...