7 ms·
Nice I guess, but I wish we could get back to working on getting FASTER cores rather than more of them. Some tasks just don't multi-thread.
by TylerE 8y ago
Nice I guess, but I wish we could get back to working on getting FASTER cores rather than more of them. Some tasks just don't multi-thread.
- taspeotis 8y agoThere is some movement in the clock-speed arena [1]. [1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/12893/intels-28core-5-ghz-cpu-coming-in-q4 https://www.anandtech.com/show/12893/intels-28core-5-ghz-cpu...
- gnufied 8y agoThat is water chilled phase change cooling, no consumer is going to run a desktop with that kind of cooling. It is as pointless as liquid nitrogen based benchmarks IMO. But I think threadripper 2 should have faster clock speeds regardless. The zen+ 12nm cores that it uses are known to have higher clock speeds.
- loeg 8y agoWe've only seen early 32- and 24- core numbers. Hopefully the 16-core part gets a refresh with interesting improvements.
- fibonacci112358 8y agoThat is just Intel grabbing some attention from the Threadripper 32 core announcement. It doesn't run at 5Ghz, that was heavily overclocked using a custom cooling system hidden under the table.
- sliken 8y agoI was amused that the heroic efforts by Intel to make AMD looks bad included a 1 horse power (735 watts) pump in the cooler. So sure Intel can make 32 cores go fast, by taking a $10,000 chip (literally, it's a relabel of the Intel Xeon 8180), a giant power supply, impressive cooling, and a 735 watt pump. Still only has 75% of the memory bandwidth/memory channels of the AMD epyc. My main hope with threadripper is that they hit the lower price points that the HEDT intel chips do (I.e. $300-$500).
- loeg 8y ago> My main hope with threadripper is that they hit the lower price points that the HEDT intel chips do (I.e. $300-$500). 1900x sells for ~$450. It's just the 8 core part, though — might as well grab the Ryzen 8 core for way less cost instead unless you need the memory b/w or PCIe lanes.
- sliken 8y agoYeah, that's the one I have my eye on. Was hoping for something more competitive with the i7-7800x or so (6 core, 12 threads, 4 memory channels, 4 GHz, and $390 list).
- loeg 8y agoThey're pretty similar, but I think 1900x is slightly higher end. (And arguably, better value if you can utilize all the cores.) i7-7800x (Skylake-X) is a sort-of last gen part (Kabylake-X briefly existed in the form of i7-7740X, although only in a 4-core SKU); 4 GHz is its maximum turbo clock (may be only single core); base clock is 3.5. 1900x is current gen, although about to become last-gen; its base clock is 3.8, 4.0 turbo (single core). Same number of memory channels. 33% more cores. AMD's IPC lags Intel a little bit, but not by 25%. Is it worth the $60 (15%) premium? Maybe. When TR2's version of 1900x comes out, TR1 1900x may experience a nice price drop, making it (even) more competitive/affordable.
- aarongolliver 8y agoThe 40th anniversary of 8086 is just attention grabbing from Intel? Not every move from Intel has to be a reaction to competitors...
- glenneroo 8y agoNowhere in the linked article is there any mention of 40th anniversary. The title is simply "Intel’s 28-Core 5 GHz CPU: Coming in Q4" and the first line of the article is "...the launch of Intel’s first 5 GHz processor, the 6-core Core i7-8086K, Intel today also showcased a 28-core single socket machine also running at 5 GHz." A bit of Googling verifies that you are at least partially correct: "Intel announced that it is releasing the Core i7-8086K, a special edition processor that commemorates the 40th anniversary of the 8086..." and "...reports speculated that Intel would only produce 50,000 units. Our sources have confirmed that this is a limited-edition chip, so Intel isn't positioning it against AMD's competing Ryzen processors."
- deepnotderp 8y ago> Nice I guess, but I wish we could get back to working on getting FASTER cores rather than more of them. Absolutely. I can double the speed* for a ~10-15X increase in power. But then you won't buy my core ;) *In theory a massive ROB could do this, frontend bottlenecks notwithstanding.
- DSingularity 8y agoYeah, but good luck renaming registers fast enough. The breakthrough has to come from software. Might need to reimagine our programming/system model altogether.
- kbenson 8y agoI was under the impression there was still some advances here, even given the lack of movement in clock speeds. That is, basically being able to pipeline better and service specific operations in fewer cycles or with less latency. I just did a little googling, and came across the Intel Optimation Reference Manual[1], and in Appendix C you can see how latency and throughput changed for architectures over time (e.g. table C-4). Being able to assess all the implications of these is beyond me currently, but if an operation goes from 5 clock cycles to 4 (or it ties up certain transisters less for other ops at the same time, my understanding is this stuff is super complex), that could be a huge boost for specific actions. 1: https://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents/manuals/64-ia-32-architectures-optimization-manual.pdf https://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents...
- dahart 8y ago> I wish we could get back to working on getting FASTER cores rather than more of them. Some tasks just don't multi-thread. Out of curiosity, are you working on tasks that don't parallelize? There are some for sure, but maybe more that do parallelize, just not trivially or easily? It seems like some people have wanted faster CPUs rather than more parallelism for as long as I can remember... decades. I'm wondering out loud if your wish has ever not been true. I suspect we're stuck with getting more cores until there's a new fundamental breakthrough in physics. We're hitting the wall with CPU speeds, which is why GPUs have been seeing all the growth recently. So I just went looking and found a CS term for hard to parallelize I hadn't heard before: P-complete. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P-complete https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P-complete Are you working on stuff related to or dependent on any of these examples?
- deepnotderp 8y agoI'm pretty sure OoO execution (which is how single threaded execution is improved in modern CPU cores) won't help with P- complete problems.
- DSingularity 8y agoNo not really. One of the biggest attractions of OoO is that it helps you find parallelism at the instruction level. So OoO as an architectural technique is one of the most helpful to problems hard to parallelize. The problem is there is a limited window of instructions where it can be applied. Trying to make one massive processor to find huge amounts of instruction level parallelism is just too hard.
- kingosticks 8y agoRecently on here[0], Arm claimed for every 7% extra resources they put towards increasing the RoB they got 1% performance. Past a certain point it's not worth it. That was their justification for having half the window of rival Samsung chips. [0] https://www.anandtech.com/show/12785/arm-cortex-a76-cpu-unveiled-7nm-powerhouse https://www.anandtech.com/show/12785/arm-cortex-a76-cpu-unve...
- sosborn 8y agoWhat makes you think people aren’t working on it?
- deepnotderp 8y agoLook at paper topics at major computer architecture conferences like ISCA. There's been a clear shift from single thread architecture research to parallel and low power single thread core research. Not a complete shift of course, but the trend is clear.
- pjmlp 8y agoSure they do. My computer has 130 processes on average, even if they are single threaded, they get all nicely distributed across all cores. We are not in MS-DOS where a single application owns the hardware while it runs.
- oldcynic 8y agoSO many comments missing the entire point in reply to this! It's like none have noticed all processors, even gaming centric ones, come with a bunch of cores these days. Athlon dual core is not exactly a recent innovation, it's archaeology. So all the trivia and "yeah but..." + Gaming and a few other tasks mostly do not benefit from more cores and tend to be extremely GHz dependent. Thanks to massive GPU parallelisation we're left mainly CPU bound. + Even gaming pitched "Extreme" SKUs are disappointing from a GHz PoV + We haven't been in MS-DOS mode or had problems serving 120 OS background processes for a very, very long time indeed. + Power and heat have still gone wildly up despite the switch to cores not GHz So, processor manufacturers hopped off the GHz race for well known reasons. We're now a decade on from that and GHz is about the same like they have stopped thinking about GHz entirely. It's not unreasonable to have hoped to have hit 5GHz without wildly unrepresentative cheats hidden under the desk, or that they would have kept at least a few percent of their research chasing some more Hz as well as cores.
- Piezoid 8y agoI will keep my dual X5690 machine for few more years I guess. The increase IPC of modern CPU is only 33% compared to theses old Xeons. Although, power consumption is another factor to consider...
- sliken 8y agoSure, we can all wish that physics were to bend to our 'reasonable' expectations. The reality of it is: 1) increasing the clock rate is hard past 3 GHz or so. The memory wall doesn't get any easier, so IPC drops as clock rate increases. Also heat becomes more of an issue. 2) increasing pipeline length (to make it easier to hit higher clocks) has increasing penalties for each branch misprediction. So IPC drops significantly and you end up back where we are today (high IPC, but low clock). 3) shrinking chips to increase the clock rate no longer works. Generally the insulation layer is so thin that making it thinner results in more leaking. 4) Ever increasingly smart cores (to get higher IPC), makes it ever harder to increase the clock. It's actually pretty amazing what happens in 1/3rd of a ns. Voltage changes in silicon actually move quite slowly (relatively to the speed of light) in silicon. Things like looking at a queue of 80 instructions, figuring out which ones have no pending dependencies, and issuing them to the right unit is pretty impressive for 0.33 ns. Moving to 0.2ns makes it worse. So could AMD, Intel, or anyone with a decent CPU team design a 5 GHz cpu... sure, no problem. Would it be any faster for general purpose code running on today's 3 GHz CPUs, unlikely. Personally for my desktop use I don't care about best case performance (0% cache misses), or even average case performance (which is generally way more than I need). I care about worst case performance. Stutters, hangs, lagginess, etc. Linux, enough ram (32GB in my case), GTX 1070, and a M2 for /home. So I welcome the additional cores. Plex transcoding, compressing family videos, making new icons for 10,000 photos, large parallel compiles, etc. Hell sometimes I game while the kids are watching plex streaming and neither of us notice. Thank god for M.2 which killed off the rather serious bottlenecks with SATA.
- sliken 8y agoThe laws of physics are intruding. Clock rate doubling without prohibitive cost, power, and heat have gone. At 3 GHz electrons don't go very far in 1/3rd of a NS. Chips are getting physically bigger (look at the Epyc). Easy increases in IPC are gone. There's an embarrassing number of transistors available, but few uses for them actually increase performance on things consumers care about. Even GPUs are starting to peter out with lengthening product cycles, smaller improvements, and the increasing tendency to just rename the previous generation with a new name, as if it was actually significantly improved. So CPUs have peaked, most of the low hanging fruit has already been taken. Most easily shown by pretty much all the popular CPUs from the previous generation maxed out at 95 watts or so (desktop or server), but are at 180 watts in the current generation. This happened years ago for desktops, but is hitting laptops (last year), and smart phones (this year or so). GPUs are about half way there, improvements are harder. No more annual updates with 2x the performance on most common use cases. Feature improvements are getting more obscure, gaming sites are using 16x zoom to show the improvements. GTX1170 is rumored to be 50% faster than the GTX1070... from 2 years ago. Specific use ASICs for mining, AI, and similarly narrow use cases are still early in their development. Multiple vendors are showing 2x improvements with each generation, even crazy things like including said chips in consumer devices with tiny power budgets. So basically a core twice as fast isn't happening, it's not because anyone is lazy. There's tons of room for improvement in specific use cases where today's silicon is crazy inefficient. Things like machine learning, software device radios, vision specific processing, and related are seeing rapid improvements.
- merinowool 8y agoI think it is not happening because it doesn't have to. Current CPUs are more than fine for home user and HEDT market is too small to excuse huge spending for research. I think once electron apps will become more popular home users will get power hungry again and that will kick off another cpu revolution.
- muxr 8y agoIt's not happening because it's hard to do. Extracting instruction level parallelism is difficult(which is how CPUs gain IPC) and then also the cores have to be wider with exponential complexity. ie. At the point you have to sacrifice 50% of CPU's power efficiency for 5% IPC gain, it's no longer worth it.
- tutanchamun 8y agoI remember reading a article here on hn about inverse hyper threading (I don't remember the correct term) where multiple cores would work together to increase single threaded performance (if some cores are idle). I believe some company (not a major player like AMD, Intel or Samsung etc.) claimed they would have solved major problems with previous implementations of this idea or something along those lines. Sounds interesting but is that even possible? Seems like it would have been the perfect fit for AMDs Bulldozer back then due to the chips worse single threaded performance and it's unused multi threaded performance in mainstream software.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoOr we could just write more efficient software?
- jcranmer 8y agoHow? We can't make cores higher frequency, because the power consumption (and heat dissipation) is prohibitive. Doing more per cycle? It's hard to see how more work could be squeezed out of most operations (maybe fdiv or div could be shrunk a few cycles), so you're left with introducing niche instructions or wider, more complex SIMD instructions. Spending more of your time being productive? This requires more accurate branch prediction and other speculative execution, but everyone's freaking out and trying to rip out speculative execution because of a bug that lets you read memory you already have access to. You might be able to squeeze out more performance, but you're looking at 10% gains, not 2× gains.