6 ms·
I kind of have to wonder what Jan Koum and Brian Acton were thinking (OK, I don't really wonder - they got paid billions of dollars, who wouldn't do it). But,
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
I kind of have to wonder what Jan Koum and Brian Acton were thinking (OK, I don't really wonder - they got paid billions of dollars, who wouldn't do it).
But, of course, if you sell a company for billions of dollars, there is the obvious expectation that within some time frame your company will earn revenue and profit to support that valuation. You can't complain "they're adding ads!" unless you have a credible solution for somehow bringing in billions of dollars otherwise, and the WhatsApp founders didn't.
- panarky 8y ago> You can't complain "they're adding ads!" FTFA Facebook promised not to put ads on WhatsApp. The terms of the acquisition agreement require accelerated vesting of incentive comp to Koum and Acton if Facebook renege on their promise.
- vxNsr 8y agoand yet: >>>Mr. Acton initiated the clause in his contract allowing for early vesting of his shares. But Facebook’s legal team threatened a fight, so Mr. Acton, already worth more than $3 billion, left it alone, according to people familiar with the matter. Turns out facebook sucks as a company.
- foolfoolz 8y agohmm, i think no. once you sell th company you only have to fulfill your acquisition agreement. in some cases that may be revenue targets but not always. do we know exactly what they needed to do to keep their jobs post acquire? i don’t think it’s obvious
- rmsaksida 8y ago> You can't complain "they're adding ads!" unless you have a credible solution for somehow bringing in billions of dollars otherwise, and the WhatsApp founders didn't What about business features? Pretty much every business in my country advertises a Whatsapp number, from large companies to mom-and-pops. People contact them over Whatsapp to ask questions, make complaints, order stuff, everything. I can't believe Facebook is unable to monetize that. It seems to me that Facebook is severely biased towards ads because they already have a platform and it's a market they obviously know well. That doesn't mean ads are the only way to make money.
- GFischer 8y agoEvery company I've worked for wants an official WhatsApp business API. And apparently that's what they proposed to Sandberg, according to the article, but the financial projections were nowhere near what ads would bring.
- mentos 8y agoHa think about all of the surface area on Facebook employees faces/arms that you could tattoo advertising on. I wonder if they have considered the financial opportunity cost there?
- Rjevski 8y agoIt’s just a matter of time. ;)
- skbly7 8y agoI think they are already working in that direction I last checked. https://www.whatsapp.com/business/ https://www.whatsapp.com/business/ I liked the business app especially for shortcuts, auto-replies and other stuffs. But yes, official APIs is deal-breaker. NOTE: Many applications and websites somehow are already using custom APIs (or something). Ex. Airlines sending booking details as WhatsApp message, flight/bus status and so on.
- GFischer 8y agoYes, the custom APIs exist but are very hacky. I work for one of the largest travel groups, I'm actually working on flight notifications, and they don't want to go there - no idea how other airlines or travel groups do it.
- debt 8y agoLotta smart people at Facebook, I imagine they've looked at this and have come to the conclusion that it's not lucrative as you think.
- 8y ago
- cookiecaper 8y agoThe ultimate goal of software companies is to control as much "platform space" as possible. This is mainly due to the way we treat virtual properties legally, and it only becomes truer as e.g. APIs are ruled copyrightable. It's not implausible to believe that a big tech co would be interested in acquiring a platform defensively and/or for control over the platform ecosystem.
- pavanky 8y agoI was happy paying a subscription fee to whatsapp when it was still a thing. I dont know if facebook has ever made money off of ads shown to me. Same goes with google and the subscription I pay for google music.
- bad_user 8y agoPeople think they generate no revenue via ads, but you do, all of you are. Best ads on Facebook are brand ads and these work on your subconscious. Unlike Google Search that shows immediate intent, you don’t have an immediate need while browsing FB. Sure there’s the occasional impulse buy for some iPhone case or jewelry you don’t need, but the big companies don’t care for your clicks. E.g. what are the default beverages people buy when organizing an event? Beer and Coke and it’s not a coincidence or because there aren’t better choices. In other words, as long as you look at ads, your buying choices get influenced by them, so you are generating revenue for pay-per-view ads, even if you never clicked on one. I don’t mind seeing ads though, as long as they are tasteful. What I mind is the tracking and in that regard Facebook is among the worst.
- georgeecollins 8y agoWhen they sold their business it was not their responsibility to make sure the buyer was getting a good deal. It was the responsibility of the buyer to honor the agreements they made as part of the purchase.