6 ms·
You mean like arresting people when they say something the gov't doesn't like? [1] I'll take a pass, thank you. [1]https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/arres
by refurb 8y ago
You mean like arresting people when they say something the gov't doesn't like? [1] I'll take a pass, thank you.
[1]https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/arrests-for-offensive-facebook-and-twitter-posts-soar-in-london-a7064246.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/arrests-for-offensive-...
- jboles 8y agoI'll gladly take that, and a government that generally tries to look after its citizens, over one that is downright hostile to and steals from citizens.
- orf 8y agoCouple of thousand fines in a city of 8,700,000 seems sensible to me. Not everyone values free speech quite as highly as the USA. It's important, sure, but it's not live or die. There are limits and spreading vile hate speech is one of them. I also like the complete focus on the free speech aspect, completely ignoring the "we actually deal with racists here" aspect. How narrow minded.
- core-questions 8y agoLet's keep in mind here that there are many definitions of hate speech. In Canada, it's carefully defined as speech that actually incites people to a criminal act - so racism or other "vile speech" on its own doesn't qualify, you have to be actively making a credible threat or incitement to have others commit real actions.
- seibelj 8y ago“Vile hate speech” can cut both ways unfortunately. Both of us agree that racism is a bad thing. But the American South during Jim Crow declared progressive speech as “hate speech” and tried to ban it.[0] So it’s better to not empower the government to decide what is hate and what isn’t, or you may elect a government that decides what you say is hate speech. [0] “As we have seen, during the days of slavery and later segregation, laws suppressing free speech were often aimed at abolitionists and civil rights advocates, not at slave owners or Jim Crow advocates. This reflected social and political power in local states and communities where attitudes towards race were very different than today.“ https://www.hoover.org/research/harm-hate-speech-laws https://www.hoover.org/research/harm-hate-speech-laws
- orf 8y ago> So it’s better to not empower the government to decide what is hate and what isn’t The government cannot just arbitrarily expand hate speech to include something which is patently not hate speech. The courts would not uphold it, neither would the judiciary or the public at large.
- abstrakraft 8y ago10 years ago, I would have argued the same about the gov't just arbitrarily expanding asset seizure laws, but here we are.
- stordoff 8y agoIf they made it law (which strictly speaking requires parliament, not the government), the courts _would_ uphold it.
- steve_musk 8y agoUnless you get an extreme president who stacks the courts with extreme judges...
- mlazos 8y agoSo I would agree except judges are even elected in some places in the south. The judiciary is not always insular.
- refurb 8y agoCouple of thousand fines in a city of 8,700,000 seems sensible to me. As someone who values free speech, even one fine is abhorrent.
- orf 8y agoDo you speak for all people who value free speech?
- DuskStar 8y agoI think that by his (and my) definition of "people who value free speech", yes he does - because that is a part of the definition. Everyone values speech they like. Valuing Free Speech means valuing the speech you don't like, too.
- iforgotpassword 8y agoI can't wrap my head around how you can see it as positive that these kind of actions would go unpunished, in the name of "freedom". If I were harassed and bullied I'd not feel very free, but rather anxious, threatened, depressed. I'm quite happy my government takes measures to assure a certain level of personal safety, both physical and psychological.
- wetpaws 8y agoI would prefer being harrased and bullied rather than having to live in a country that has a legal power to punish me for what I say.
- orf 8y ago> to punish me for what I say. But doesn't, unless you say something reprehensible that the society you live in agrees that you stepped way over the line.
- wetpaws 8y agoI don't give a damnt about what society like or don't like. Tomorrow special sjw snowflakes could say that breathing or saying "hello" is harrasment.
- arcticbull 8y agoYou can absolutely get punished for what you say in the US -- freedom of speech was long ago recognized as anything but absolute. You can't yell fire in a crowded theater. Obscenity (as defined in Miller v. California) is not protected by the constitution. You can't lie under oath. You can't deliberately tell lies about people (Libel). The First Amendment doesn’t protect the speech of people plotting to overthrow the government (Dennis v. United States). House Bill 347 authorized Secret Service agents to arrest anyone protesting in the president’s or vice president’s proximity. The only difference is they've chosen to draw the line somewhere just offset from what you're used to. There's still a line in these here United States. And it's really not that different, is it?
- celticninja 8y agoBut that's not criticising the government, you could call the government a bunch of cunts and no one is coming to arrest you. But if you harass an individual then that individual can use the government to prevent further harassment. This sort of malicious communication was illegal before the intern but now it is easier to commit it as you don't need to know where someone lives to send a letter, you can tweet them without leaving the house. In the past I imagine you had to do something pretty bad to get lots and lots of hate mail (takes a bit of effort to write the letter and send it ) but these days you could wear the wrong colour shirt and end up on the internets shit list and have your inbox or Twitter feed deluged in seconds.