36 ms·
America’s Teens Are Choosing YouTube Over Facebook
- seccess 8y agoI'm pretty surprised Twitch isn't mentioned in that list. I'm curious where it would stack up.
- karimdag 8y agoI'm a "millennial", so I think I speak millennial pretty well. Twitch is a very niche product: THE go-to place for the gaming community, it's also trying to break into mainstream live-streaming but that's Instagram's territory.
- genzbruh 8y agoThis article is about teens Millennials aren't teens anymore
- arwineap 8y agoWhich is super interesting because twitch was justin.tv's pivot FROM mainstream live-streaming into the niche game streaming market
- karimdag 8y agoYeah, I know ! Thing is, I think Justin is ahead of his time (he did it with Justin.tv and Whale).
- YorakHunt 8y agoYeah but as more and more podcasters and talk show type youtubers start livestreaming on twitch to diversify income it'll get some more mainstream appeal.
- jacksmith21006 8y agoTwitch is tiny compared to YT and growing slower.
- ausjke 8y agoThen youtube should have a better age-based filtering mechanism for all its videos.
- asdsa5325 8y agoIt seems like all content would be fine for them, what would you filter out for teenagers?
- ausjke 8y agowhat about pre-teens or even younger ones, there are a lot video content at youtube that are not kids-friendly, try to search for some sex/violent videos you will be surprised. I have a friend working at youtube, she said so far the only safe way to "filter" video for kids is with human eyes.
- Rjevski 8y agoIs there actual evidence that such content causes harm, or is this the usual “think of the children” FUD ? I know it’s a sample size of one, but being exposed to violent & explicit content as a kid doesn’t seem to have ruined my life in any way. Finally, any kind of “filter” would be ineffective; as kids will still find ways of exchanging such content offline. If anything, making the content forbidden would make it seem more appealing.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> what would you filter out for teenagers? Most societies have an expectation that some content isn't shown to, for example a 13 year old person. In the US you have content ratings like NC-17, don't you? In the UK we have 15 and 18 rated content. So I guess content like that, some people would filter for teenagers.
- wafflebear 8y agoTeenagers can get jobs and buy their own devices. Any age restriction past 13 or so is kind of pointless in the 21st century.
- mehWhateverrr 8y agoFacebook is literally brimming with bad vibes, since the prevailing winds of perception are that the idea of anonymity is a flimsy wet paper bag, in the face of what technology really has going on. This sort of hopelessness is bringing about varying degrees of abandon, nevermind the negative examples of adults and celebrities that shed light on the total lack of any positive role model. They know that the only winning move is not to play, and sometimes even that isn’t an option. No one knows what they’re doing. No one knows what comes next. And many, many people have a sinking feeling about what’s already happened, and whether it’s all far too late. Instagram is an envy club. The vapidity of food, vacation, beaches. But generally lower on the spectacle, as a matter of trend more than anything else. Snapchat is for trading nudes, and general subterfuge, such as spreading rumors about eachother, with selectively memory-holed messaging. So even youtube, with the limited veracity of generally public video as a forum will fall too. It’s only so much of a salve for truthiness.
- asdsa5325 8y ago> Facebook is literally brimming with bad vibes, since the prevailing winds of perception... I'm pretty sure the real reason why teenagers are leaving FB is because their parents are joining.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> I'm pretty sure the real reason why teenagers are leaving FB is because their parents are joining. This doesn't make sense as a reason in 2018, does it? Everyone's parents and grandparents joined a decade ago - they're not joining now in significant numbers in the West.
- bnjms 8y agoYou're right. Better to say they never joined because there parents were on there. School is insular and the first group to have their parents begin reviewing their social interactions, I'd guess around 2012, 'taught' the younger grades that FB wasn't worthwhile compared to alternatives.
- 8y ago
- jpm_sd 8y agoGoogle+ was ahead of its time, apparently?
- on_and_off 8y agoThe idea of circles in Google+ is pure genius. It was shoddily implemented though. IIRC even the academic that had the circle idea ranted about how badly plus had implemented it. On one hand, I would rather have somebody else than Google handling the next social network, on the other, plus had some great idea and shined for a time in some areas like photography. I used to frequent it a couple of times a week several years ago. Nowadays, each time I open it by mistake I am taken aback by how extremist lunatics are everywhere in my feed (ymmv)
- swiley 8y agoLists on mastodon aren’t too bad, I don’t know if circles have some features lists don’t though.
- eat_veggies 8y agoNowadays, people manually emulate circles using multiple accounts--a rinsta [0] for the curated public circle, and a finsta [1] for close friends to post personal experiences and funny photos. Some people I know have multiple finstas with varying levels of specificity. [0] "real insta" [1] "fake insta"
- frizkie 8y agoWeird, those definitions seems backwards to me. The one for close friends seems like it should be the 'real' account.
- eat_veggies 8y agoIt feels backwards to me too now that you mention it. The logic is that rinsta is the "official" account, and generally the first one that people create and follow, so it's their main. You can conceptualize it as having a main and an alt--you'd never call your alt your real account.
- ggg9990 8y agoIt’s clear that Facebook.com is yesterday’s news but it seems like the alternatives may be as damaging to the individual and to his or her society.
- poulsbohemian 8y agoTeen dad checking in here. YouTube, Instagram, and Snapchat seem to be the mainstream among teens right now. I'd argue it is less a reflection on Facebook and more about what they admire and desire. YouTube and Instagram enable them to follow the people and activities that interest them, and entice them to be future "internet stars" too.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nightski 8y agoThat is not surprising to me at all. I'm in my 30s and have been using Youtube, Instagram and Snapchat to follow internet personas and keep in touch with family much more than Facebook. So if I am doing it then I am sure teens are well past that point haha.
- parthdesai 8y agoMid 20's, for me it's Youtube, WhatsApp and Instagram. Also, Messenger occasionally.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y agoMid 40's, for me it's Civilization: Beyond Earth and yelling at kids to get off my lawn.
- Andrex 8y agoWow, I thought I was the only person left to still regularly play that game.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y agoYeah, as if Sid Meyers would so easily return your soul to you.
- cromwellian 8y agoMy 13 year old uses mostly YouTube, Instagram, Discord, Twitch, and Reddit, no FB. I have nieces and nephews on FB, but they never post much, they hide most of their real content on anonymous Instagram accounts.
- dxbydt 8y agowonder why the market isn’t pricing in the FB misery.look at 3 month on FB. back in march it was on ~190, then the cambridge shit dragged it straight down to ~150, now 3 months later we are back to ~190, exactly where we left off.
- ieatasstoodontu 8y agoHmm, maybe because we are in a huge bubble right now and its just a race to see who can blow the biggest one before it all pops
- jakelarkin 8y agohave thought about this as well ... there's just so much runway to more effectively monetize the core audience. a lot of businesses are still figuring out how powerful facebook ads are and how to leverage them. fb revenue still growing. thats what wall st is focused on right now. certain long-term engagement numbers have been deteriorating for over a year its not really on the radar yet.
- jacksmith21006 8y agoBecause even though YT taking share FB still has fast growth and is really cheap.
- bob_theslob646 8y agoDoes it? Are you sure this is the case for America? Maybe growth internationally, but I never understood how people in poorer countries are able to be monetized as they are in more developed countries.
- jacksmith21006 8y agoYes YouTube growth is off the charts and surprising for how big it is. Heck yesterday we had "YouTube Is No. 1 Internet Platform Among U.S. Teens, While Facebook Usage Has Plummeted: Study" https://variety.com/2018/digital/news/youtube-teens-popular-facebook-social-media-study-1202827539/ https://variety.com/2018/digital/news/youtube-teens-popular-... It does have to slow down at some point. Google now has over 1.7 billion hours consumed on YT a day. That is about 100% growth YoY and has been accelerating. But there is only 7B people on the planet and so there is a limited numbers of hours. So right now Google gets 10 minutes of every human on the planet with just YT and would expect that to continue to grow but at some point further down the road slow down. Where do you think it will slow? 30 minutes? Could it ever get to an hour?
- buzzword 8y agoSoon they'll realize that if you can't see someone's face in realtime, you're can't get the full scoop!! That's why my momma and her friends outgrew the Ma Bell Party Line.
- drchiu 8y agoI think teens nowadays are much more guarded (given how long social networks have been around now). They've grown up with the knowledge of how social media, when misused, can come back to haunt them. Most of my nephews and nieces have multiple throwaway accounts -- some of which they share with their parents and other accounts that they use as their main one. Decreased FB usage is likely a reflection that they're wary of how FB utilizes their data, and realizing it's better to be choosy where they post info about themselves.
- matte_black 8y agoYou give kids way too much credit. If all their friends were on Facebook, they’d be on Facebook. Facebook failed to market effectively to up and coming teenagers, and as a result they have grown up into people who have chosen alternative networks that looked fun and cool, not boring and corporate blue. No one gives a shit about data.
- robotbikes 8y agoPeople care about their data when it can tangibly affect them. Teens know that their parents or other parents can see their data on Facebook. They are pushed to use their real names and in general the context creep is what drives them away. They may not care about the abstract notion of data in terms of data mining etc but they do care about having what they share being seen by people they don't want it to be seen by.
- davegardner 8y agoIt's not just that their friends aren't on Facebook, it's also that their parents and grandparents are there.
- keyle 8y agoGoing past the whole "X is better than Y". Isn't it just a symptom that the next generation doesn't want the same thing as their parents? e.g. I don't want to live in my childhood home, I don't want to wear my dad's clothes and I don't want to drive his car. So every largely successful social media platform is doomed to only be `the one` for 1 generation?
- programmarchy 8y agoGenerally yes but not sure that’s the main driver in this case. YouTube’s user content generally has a higher production quality than Facebook posts. It’s also easier to curate and subscribe to the topics you’re interested in, unlike Facebook.
- st26 8y agoIsn't that mostly because his car, clothes, and house are probably behind the times? A social media platform can grow & evolve, a house built sixty years ago can't much. The things my father owned that are still current are pretty special to me, actually.
- benwad 8y agoSocial media platforms can adapt with the times, but they often don't - Facebook was built in an atmosphere of "move fast and break things", but you can't do that when you're a multi-billion dollar company with shareholders who don't like it when you break things.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoFor YT I would say it's the depth and bredth of choice. Even for music there's no much you can't find. There's plenty of parent-centric content as well. Working adults just have the same amount of free time so those views are lower.
- vertexFarm 8y agoProbably also an effect of an overly-curated feed ruled by a needlessly opaque algorithm. I see some form of pattern where the old desire traditional news curation and authority while the young want to see more of what average people are saying in real-time.
- yeukhon 8y agoI am a few years away from 30. I have disabled FB and Instagram recently so I can free myself from some stress. I use YouTube a lot because I enjoy watching game plays (e.g. H2ODelirious, VanossGaming, etc.) YouTube is a good alternative to TV shows and Netflix.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoI never much cared for any of the social media platforms because they all seem to be just gamified crap, a great example of technology making people's lives worse instead of better. But Youtube and Twitch I like. It's kinda what cable public-access was trying to do, only way better.
- tyfon 8y agoI'm 37 and I don't have any social media except youtube. I use youtube instead of tv and even publish some things from time to time. Basically my private internet usage consists of youtube, twitch (sometimes), HN and resetera (games forum). Facebook has absolutely no appeal to me.
- jacksmith21006 8y agoAlso think Reddit as it passed FB to be #3 most popular site on the internet.
- 1over137 8y agoNot "on the Internet", only in the USA.
- Kluny 8y agoAnd Canada
- jacksmith21006 8y agoWas curious for the world and looks like the top 2 are the same, Google search and YouTube. But then Reddit is 6 but climbing fast. "This is a list of the most popular websites worldwide " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_popular_websites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_popular_websites
- icebraining 8y agoOn Alexa, which is not necessarily a reliable source. Plus it doesn't count app usage, making it a fairly useless indicator.
- josefresco 8y agoReliable is probably not the best adjective. Alexa ratings are very reliable if you measure them against previous Alexa rankings.
- jacksmith21006 8y agoWe have App numbers separately and the latest numbers had Google owning 5 of the top 10 used in the US for both platforms, iOS and Android. FB had 3. MS and Apple interestingly did not have a single one in the top 10. http://www.businessinsider.com/most-used-smartphone-apps-2017-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/most-used-smartphone-apps-201...
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI didn't realize this is new news. I mean when I see some obviously teen-centric piece of content with a gazillion views I'm not presuming working full time adults are the ones driving the views figure. This tends to be the top videos. Or at least consistently seems to be.
- vowelless 8y agoIs there anyone in HN legitimately using Facebook anymore? I deleted my account more than a year ago and initially I missed events, but more and more, my conversations and invites are moving to WhatsApp, Discord (surprisingly awesome), Instagram, Signal, etc. Events are really the only thing I miss from FB. Startup idea for anyone who wants to try to address it: independent Events app that connects with everything under the sun (FB, Google, etc.)
- Karunamon 8y agoFamily, local news, sales, and events are the reasons I still use it. The local sale groups absolutely annihilate Craigslist, letgo, and similar tools.
- komali2 8y agoYes, obviously lol. It is the primary communication tool for everyone I know in the bay area, excluding professionals that I email or teammates at code for SF that I message on slack.
- TheGRS 8y agoThere is a strange lock-in with facebook for me here. I use other apps for talking to close friends or anyone in the know. For talking to my partner or family who aren't very tech savvy Facebook is still the best choice. They are all reliably there and will respond. I used to vent about politics on there, but I've begun to shy away from that to twitter.
- wolco 8y agoThere isn't anything to do on facebook for the young/youth. The games are more for the middle aged player. They have no list of long lost people they wish to connect with. Everyone is a friend or friend of a friend. You can follow brands but the youth want to follow a band or an actor not a toothbrush company. Things like poking or using a fake name or having permissions connected to school or orgs created social group that you would share related photos. Now you have to manage a list or share with everyone. Facebook was a good way for college kids to connect with everyone from there school. They could create a new persona with fun photos/videos and show everyone how popular they are. Now you hide your friend list, avoid saying anything that you wouldn't say in front of your mother and secretly worry that anything you post will be purchased by a potential future employer enabling them to filter out your resume in record time.
- acchow 8y agoAnd events. I use Facebook Events extensively. As a teen, I'd go to the movies with my friends maybe 4 times a year. Never went to any events. The extent of our fun was playing basketball or just sitting around.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sanderjd 8y agoSee maybe this is why I never understood the supposed all-important-ness of Events. I still just hang out with friends or family or by myself rather than going to "events".
- jozzas 8y agoI follow local market and food truck events, a couple of cool bars and arcades I like that frequently have events on, a place that does dog-centric events, local car shows that are of interest to me, etc. Facebook then surfaces other events that it thinks are of interest to me, and most of them are. I'd say 75% of my social calendar comes from Facebook events. I can understand young people not being interested in any of this and following their specific interests, like following a band on instagram rather than a venue on facebook.
- andrewstuart 8y agoYouTube has become my primary TV viewing destination, above anything else. I watch it on the TV via my PS4.
- ehsankia 8y agoThe sites aside, I also appreciated the comparison of device, though I really wish they had split that up further by device. At the very least separate Desktop and Laptop. I'd be curious to see what % of people still have a desktop computer at home.
- sleet 8y agoHow would you separate desktops and laptops? (Honest question, I'm not sure how you would do that) I assume the stats are based on usage not a survey.
- fragmede 8y agoThere isn't one. As a proxy, one could do a bunch of data gymnastics based off of the number of times a machine+account uses a single IP address and display resolution + OS. It's a pretty bad approximation though.
- russdpale 8y agoIs there a way to detect webcam model? That's the one unique thing I can think of.. A lot of desktops don't have them and if they do its like logitech whatever model.
- ehsankia 8y agoThey're dividing by race, income and level of education. Did they get all that from their models too? I assumed it was a survey.
- ransom1538 8y agoDisclaimer: I work on a large high school social app. High school kids hate facebook. It is what their parents use and they view it as a historical ledger of their actions. They view facebook more like a 'yearbook' not as a day to day hangout.
- indescions_2018 8y agoIt's amazing how much Periscope got right in its design. I'm guessing scaling mobile video broadcasts was the limiting factor. If you're Arianna Grande going live just before she steps on stage, or BTS landing in the US for the first time or basically any rapper dragging Drake right now. There is no other experience that is simpler to use, more immediate, or more real for interacting with your followers than Instagram Live. Given 200M+ daily story users, the stream quality is technically remarkable. Monetization for users with under 10K followers is much easier on Twitch.tv right now. Than on any other platform, including YouTube. The Fortnite cultural phenomenon is just beginning. And the ancillary revenue services such as Streamlabs involve direct sponsorship. As opposed to negotiating third party brand deals. Twitch popularity is creating the feedback loop that informs game design. Looking across the Pacific at Tencent and its 500M mobile gamers. Just can't help but think there is still phenomenal upside here ;)
- 1024core 8y agoI have a friend who has 2 teenage boys. The other day we're talking about stuff on the Internet, and he says something along the lines of "I wish I could monitor what they're watching on the Internet!". And I was like, I think there's some porn blockers around. And he replied, "I wish they'd watch porn! They're watching YT, getting crazy ideas from others and doing stupid things!"
- uptownfunk 8y agoI talked to my niece who is 19yo. Her take is that everyone is all about Instagram (basically personal brand/image management, checking out latest styles from other people, styles she can actually afford) Snapchat (personal circle of friends, unedited content) YouTube (lifestyle bloggers) Facebook is dying in their demographic.. pretty fast, except for Facebook pages for things she’s interested in
- paulie_a 8y ago"unedited content" is a euphemism for sharing nudity.
- nv-vn 8y agoNo, it's really not. I mean sure there is some of that, but you're wrong if you think that's all people use Snapchat for. People share things on Snapchat to their close group of friends which means you're willing to say things you wouldn't say in public about people, say things you wouldn't want your mom to hear, pass secrets around, or just talk in a more "anonymous" way. It's the difference between somebody taking 45 minutes to pose for and edit their next Instagram post vs. sending 45 snaps in a minute without even looking at the picture you take. It's almost like Casey Neistat's Beme--Snapchat encourages you not to care about what you send because it will be gone in 3-10 seconds.
- uptownfunk 8y agoYes you hit the nail on the head. I most certainly did not mean nude by unedited content.
- paulie_a 8y agoThe op was referring to a teenager... Unedited content absolutely is nudity. It's actually the reason Snapchat was invented.
- slow_donkey 8y agoIt's the reason sc was invented but definitely not what it has evolved into. I'm aware there's porn accounts but the majority usecase is simply a low-friction 0 commitment method of sending pictures/thoughts/happenings
- paul7986 8y agoI use YouTube(red) more then Netflix and Direct TV Now(comes free with my ATT plan). I'd rather just watch 10 to 20 minutes of professional content (favorite TV shows or clips of them) along with all the rando discovery that's tailored to my likes then long format stuff or annoying commercial TV. Im a few decades older then a teenager.
- hackermailman 8y agoJust came back from SE Asia (4 countries) and everyone I met or saw in public was using FB and WhatsApp, and YouTube for almost everything. Telecoms also offered 'Facebook package' or YouTube specific promotions.
- realusername 8y agoAlso living in SE Asia on my case and I confirm that Facebook is much much bigger than in Europe there. Facebook is clearly having a slow death in Europe, the real cut-off seems to be around the age of 30, the youngest, the less they are on Facebook. I wound not be surprised if the teens nowadays would not have any account at all.
- boot13 8y agoYouTube is the world's greatest repository of culture. And shitty comments. But mostly the culture thing. And Facebook is a bulletin board. No competition.
- beenBoutIT 8y agoI'm curious what these kids who start out on Facebook as sonogram pics are going to think of Facebook when they become cognizant.
- inventtheday 8y agothats an awesome thought
- ashelmire 8y agoThe first of those may be teenagers this year.
- beenBoutIT 8y agoEventually this sad crowd will get their own generational letter designation.
- ryanlechner 8y agoMy 11 y/o cousin says Facebook is "instagram for old people"
- deeteecee 8y agohow are the two even comparable?
- fragmede 8y agoThey're both ad-supported, so ARPU if you care about that, or average time spent on site or even just number page views. It's like trying to compare Cold Stone Creamery to Din Tai Fung Dim sum restaurant. They sell to completely different markets but ultimately they're both food places, so there are tons of axes to compare them on if one considers the question for a bit.
- sudouser 8y agopeople spending time on one or the other
- josefresco 8y agoThis, combined with Facebook's previous motivations to "get into video" are probably worrisome to FB execs.
- sudouser 8y agoyes! didn’t facebook plan to create a netflix competitor?
- seattle_spring 8y ago> America’s Teens Are Choosing YouTube Over Facebook Wow, that's like saying America's teens are choosing Jenkem over marijuana.
- jvreagan 8y agoAs a parent of two teenage boys who's had this conversation with many parents of teenagers: a) this has been the trend for several years b) they are choosing Youtube over TV, Netflix, etc c) teens go where their parents aren't (Discord, WhatsApp, Snapchat, etc). As I heard a teenager say a couple years ago "why would I create a Facebook account, its for old moms."
- marcodave 8y ago> teens go where their parents aren't > As I heard a teenager say a couple years ago "why would I create a Facebook account, its for old moms." Precisely. Apart from the illusion of becoming an internet star, kids simply cater to the places where is most unlikely that their parents and older relatives can find them. Why post the latest slumber party photos on FB, if your aunt could somehow see and comment on those? (yes yes I know, privacy settings, custom lists, private groups, yada yada... )
- noonespecial 8y agoMy teens don't even have accounts. They used to talk about when there would be more dead people on facebook than alive. I think they were mistaken about the alive people still on facebook part. Facebook is going to be a small, odd, digital graveyard from the early 'net.
- gfo 8y agoLet's back up for a second... This article only refers to usage as 'visit(ing)' the sites, but nothing about interaction. Are we to assume that teens are actively consuming and producing content on YouTube? There's a huge difference here. When I still had Facebook I would have never said I spent most of my time there. It's very easy to say YouTube consumes more of your time considering how easy it is to go down the rabbit-hole of related videos, how-tos, etc. Even my dad always tells me to 'get on the YouTube' to look up videos on how to do things when he isn't here to show me because it has videos 'on everything'. What I'm really getting at is there are completely different uses for each site. For advertisers it's important to know where the majority of time is spent but I don't think that means Facebook is becoming irrelevant.
- gunnyguy121 8y agoI see Facebook and YouTube as completely different and I think a lot of people would agree. For most people YouTube is all about consuming. Sure some people make videos, but most go nowhere. Most people are just using it to fill their day, or for background noise while they do other stuff, just like people have been doing with TV for years.(why do you think YouTube made autoplay a thing). Facebook is more about connecting with people and expressing yourself than it is about consuming things.
- nicky0 8y agoI renovated my house using skills learned mainly from YouTube videos.
- princeb 8y agoFB has always had a MSN.com or Yahoo.com vibe, but with the latest "see other posts across facebook" update, it's gone completely Taboola. that's not even half as entertaining as instagram or snapchat right now. i feel like snapchat should really be a little bit ahead, because the social experience is a lot more interesting than instagram's, but instagram's larger user base means more interesting pictures and videos right now, even if these videos are a little bit "detached" from the user's social experience. facebook's social experience has totally lost the plot when they started trimming the social feed in favour of links to websites outside of facebook. really the crux of these social websites is that they need to have a social experience. if i wanted gossip news or political reading i'd go to a gossip website or a political journal.
- onion2k 8y agothe crux of these social websites is that they need to have a social experience I think something people forget when they're talking about social media is how new it is. Social sites have yet to prove they're something people genuinely want to engage with in the long term. There's no particularly good reason to believe someone who joins a site in their teens will still be on it in their 30s and beyond. They might move on to something else. Or they might not. Teens might not want to join it now that it's an established platform and not 'trendy', but they might come to it later. We don't know. There is no data for this. No previous social network has lasted long enough to discover what happens. Let's not forget that Facebook has only been around for 14 years, and for a couple of those it was closed to world outside of academia. 12 years is nothing when you're trying to work out how people use something. This entire thing is a fascinating experiment. We're a long way from drawing any conclusions yet.
- adventured 8y agoI agree with the Yahoo vibe. You know the left wall of navigation items on the desktop browser version of Facebook? That shows eg: Events, Marketplace, Groups, Pages, Friends List, On This Day, Find Friends, Photos, and other similar junk. It looks just like a portal straight out of 1999. It comes across as generic, soulless - a product trying to be everything that ends up being nothing in particular. Here's the most recent Yahoo version of that left strip of be-everything-and-nothing portalism icons (archive.org stray example from 2014): https://web.archive.org/web/20140420105343/https://www.yahoo.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20140420105343/https://www.yahoo... I consume a lot of content from YouTube. It's fun, mostly enjoyable (can easily ignore the trash comments). Facebook is an extremely mediocre product by comparison, it's not much fun at all. I use YouTube regularly to watch video that might include everything from news, movie trailers, documentaries, vblogs, entertainment show clips, sports clips, speaker forums, and so on. Facebook by contrast, I consume with a bare minimum type approach: I use it as little as necessary. The only two complaints I have about YouTube's product, is the quality of the comments, and there are still too many fake automated junk videos on there (or otherwise the: you won't believe what happened next junk). Most video search results require a bit of filtering through that.
- crb002 8y agoMinecraft videos.
- josefresco 8y agoThis. My 9 year old has basically stopped playing Minecraft and now only watches Minecraft players on YT. This seems to be her favorite: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC1hvCOA0eQXwSAsW3jKs8IQ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC1hvCOA0eQXwSAsW3jKs8IQ I've tried to counteract this by purchasing the PC version (for her and her cousins), helping her with mods, encouraging her to "cast" her own gaming sessions, gaming with her (this works the best) - nothing has really worked. I'm not going to lose sleep over it but I'm also not giving up with trying to encourage her to be a "creator" and not just a consumer.
- smattiso 8y agoThis seems like a strange comparison. Teens have eschewed FB in favor of Instagram and Snapchat for years. My feeling is that YouTube is simply becoming more popular and Facebook is becoming less. This is like saying that "America's Teens are Choosing Buzzfeed Over Facebook." They aren't even in the same category. The writing is on the wall for FB as a web property.
- kumarvvr 8y agoYoutube is seriously addictive. Cognitive load of watching videos is much lesser than reading. I spen hours on YouTube watching America's Funniest Home videos. Trying hard to get out of that addiction.
- KhayriRRW 8y agoYouTube and Google has better regulations against cyberbullying compared to Facebook. ~ Khayri R.R. Woulfe
- ziggytoplop 8y agoThat I understand
- FrozenVoid 8y agoThe key factor many would miss is gaming videos and gaming-related livestreams, that are really popular with younger demographics. Many of them don't even play games, they just watch it on Youtube(or Twitch), like sports fans.
- webbrahmin 8y agoFor me HN is more valuable than FB. Value of HN has stayed the same for me over the years while the value/utility of FB has gradually eroded and I hardly ever use Facebook now.
- blockchain-help 8y agoThe world is changing incredibly fast, and we are not all aware of it. Blockchain technology and cryptocurrencies are an irreversible advancement that is disrupting established industries and the ways in which we interact financially. For that reason, I believe understanding and being aware of this blockchain wave is incredibly important. Blockchain advancements will financially affect the majority of citizens in both underdeveloped and developed nations, and are already doing so. Most importantly, I evaluate whether this change is positive or negative for both individuals in society or large institutions such as banks. After extensive immersion into this subject which includes tremendous amounts of research and actual ownership of cryptocurrencies, I became extra confident in the results I found. for more information please check our site:- http://www.blockchainhelp.pro http://www.blockchainhelp.pro or contact us:- +4565711212
- WheelsAtLarge 8y agoGoogle is missing the opportunity to use youtube as the basis for a social network. Zuckerberg is not one to stay still, he'll copy youtube and use it to keep Facebook relevant. It's only a matter of time.
- josefresco 8y agoFacebook already has been trying to "copy" YouTube for several years now. I remember a couple years back FB touting videos and how much time was spent on FB watching video. This news, seems to indicate they have not succeeded in denting YT's market share.
- mortdeus 8y agoA few days ago I decided I was done with Facebook for good. It just makes me depressed nowadays. I listened to a talk given by Chamath Palihapitiya and another given by Sean Parker and they both used a phrase that kinda freaked me out. They both separately talked about how they specifically designed "dopamine driven feedback loops" to take advantage of user psychology. To get them hooked. And then I just started realizing how creepy it is that they don't even allow somebody to outright delete their profile unless they have died and their legacy admin proves they have died and deletes it for them. How creepy is that? They are like a manipulative partner in a relationship, who thinks they have their hooks in you so deep that they act all compassionately when you say you want to break up, but deep inside they are saying to themselves, "You'll be back bitch. You know you need daddy." It used to be a good thing. I mean i've sparked a few relationships using facebook. But nowadays it's just political banter, pictures of single mother's babies (i lost my baby son 5 years ago so this makes me uncomfortable when im bombarded by everybody else's little bundles of joy), memes memes memes memes, stories about dead/missing people, non stop selfies, and nothing of real substance. Aren't we supposed to like not know so much about other people so that when we get together we have something to discover about each other? It's like we have gotten to the point where we NEED to know everything about people we actually don't really know that well in real life. And everybody is competing for points on who can be the most self obsessed and nosey at the same time. I'd rather watch Youtube videos because at least that is art in a way. People taking time to make sure what they say is presented in the best format possible.
- gaius 8y agoA few days ago I decided I was done with Facebook for good. It just makes me depressed nowadays. I listened to a talk given by Chamath Palihapitiya and another given by Sean Parker and they both used a phrase that kinda freaked me out About 2 weeks after I stopped, I no longer even wanted to use it and actually thought it was a little weird how I ever wanted to. But in 2007, it was cool and fun.
- welly 8y agoI get facebook and was a user (on and off as I almost annually deleted my account) but then I found it a massive waste of time so gave up entirely just after Christmas. I did join back up again for one specific facebook group. however I wasn't getting much out of it and on top of that, the Cambridge Analytica debacle just left a bad taste in my mouth and I've dropped facebook entirely, again. It's been about 3 months now and I really have no desire to sign up again - occasionally I've browsed the group as an anonymous user and nothing has inspired me to join. I've also dropped Twitter and other social media sits - I feel that until they get their shit together as far as privacy concerns, I'm just not interested in being part of any of that. So it's HN and a couple of subject specific forums for me, and that will do for my "social media" needs. I've considered joining reddit but the jury is still out on that.
- bebe3000 8y agoFor a 25 years old student from a middle european country that I am, everything happens on facebook. I don't post or see posts of others. I simply hid that feature with a browser extension long time ago. But I use groups extensively for discussions and help in any field i'm interested in. There are groups where you can only sell things, that's also very useful. I use messenger to connect to literally anyone I know, my family, friends, my colleagues. I receive events there too. Some of the places I go to only have a facebook page. Last time a good confectionery posted that they close in a week. How else would I know if I didn't use facebook? It's pretty much perfect for me because I can't think of anything else that I would need. Another interesting thing is a group where almost all of the country is represented and they have varying quiality posts on everything that happened to them. If someone keyed your car, you ask for witnesses there, if you lost your wallet on a tram, you ask for help there. Currently the admins share abortion stories to keep the sources' anonimity. So that's a nice group with all it's quirks.
- MrJagil 8y agoAlright, I'll post this as top-level: > The sole reason I’m still on Facebook is because events are organized on Facebook. (eksemplar) I study Music Management at the conservatory (university), and spend most of my time on events and festivals. It is my impression that few in the tech business understands the magnitude of this market, and how Facebook entirely owns it. The entire concert-format is under enormous pressure from the booming festival and club scene, making services like Songkick irrelevant. ResidentAdvisor is good, but too editorial, too little tech. Facebook democratised event-making in a great way. You can trust that a good portion of the people attending an event is actually going. You can make events private, which is good for pirate-parties and other underground events (Lead Users). And importantly, it gives event makers insight into who is coming, how many, how the growth curve is etc. Artists can link to their personalised profile, that people will actually follow for updates. This is hugely important for creators. If you start a competitor, it'd be natural to focus on music, but then you'll still leave all the people interested mostly in art-exhibitions on Facebook. Facebook is content-neutral, which is a huge advantage. Further, they have an entire business-suite platform (groups) on top of this, meaning I can discuss our events, plan them, while linking to relevant artists, venues etc on Facebook. I can book artists, book a venue and market the event entirely on the FB-platform. That is an important advantage in the space of social media. Facebook is, without comparison, the best tool for events.
- f_allwein 8y agoIt also baffles me why there is no good (open?) solution for showing, finding and managing events I might want to attend in my town. Music venues, cinemas, theatres, ... all have their own separate listings, and in most places, it is impossible to see them all in one place, let alone to import them to your own calendar, or to get personalised recommendations.
- paps 8y agoFacebook Local?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- oh-kumudo 8y agoI am wrapping my head to think about what Facebook could do that I can't live without. Essentially, it is a contact book. But it is so much more complex than just that. It has a bit of everything: Photo sharing, Event organization and opinion advocating. But as it all adds up, Facebook is becoming less and less social overtime: people posted stuff, but they don't really expect interactions, they only want reactions, and the ones they expected. Unlike chatting, unexpected conversation could happen, and could genuinely help discovery of new perspectives. Facebook, in its current form, is just a static wall of trophies, a decorated personality about what you want people to think you are. It is tiring and indeed requires high maintenance. It will not be surprising to me, that Facebook's downfall is just the beginning, they might keep buying other social apps, but it does little to keep their current audience from going away.
- z3t4 8y agoLast time I checked you needed to be 18 or older to have a Facebook account, most likely to protect Facebook themselves.
- josefresco 8y agoDad with two pre-teen kids here. The order of apps by most time spent is the following: YouTube (by far), Netflix and then for my older one, Snapchat, Music.ly with some random Instagram. As they get older, I see usage of Snapchat and Instagram increasing. Neither of my kids have Facebook accounts or want FB accounts (yay!) Activities on YT: Slime videos, Minecraft videos, and lots of "pretty young girls doing stuff" (crafting, lifehacks etc.) They don't comment, and despite my repeated encouragement, don't really publish their own videos.
- alistairSH 8y agoIs it just teens dropping Facebook? My wife and I are GenXers and we've both mostly stopped using it. I removed the apps from all but one device and deleted the bookmarks from all browsers. I check it once a week or so, mostly for events and photos from my parents. I'm half tempted to disable/delete my account and see if I miss it at all.
- sharemywin 8y agoVIOLATORS!!!! 2.3 You may not use the Service and may not accept the Terms if (a) you are not of legal age to form a binding contract with YouTube, or (b) you are a person who is either barred or otherwise legally prohibited from receiving or using the Service under the laws of the country in which you are resident or from which you access or use the Service.
- davisonio 8y agoAs an 18 year old the only things Facebook is used for in my circle is: 1. Facebook Events for invites 2. Facebook Marketplace 3. Facebook Groups of interests 4. The occasional profile update or "on this day" post With the news of the new Facebook dating service, it seems that Facebook is moving away from users reading a single feed and having separate parts for all functions. For sure, it is not used to share or read anything meaningful in my circle.
- mkirklions 8y agoWhat social media do you use? What are the most common things you do on the internet?
- Harvey-Specter 8y agoMy brother is 19, he basically only uses Instagram and Snapchat. He even uses Snapchat as his primary messaging app, which is infuriating.
- techsin101 8y agoMy prime use is messenger and groups. There isn't alternative for groups.
- forgotAgain 8y agoFB was cool to teens when it was limited to college students. Scarcity is gone and coolness left with it.
- qwerty456127 8y agoPerhaps because emotions are easier to express and read this way rater than in text form. But it still feels to me like watching 99% videos is mostly a boring waste of time compared to quick-read text&picture scrollable feed posts. I'm just not comfortable with the slow pace and low concentration of the information flow in videos (and books). Is the "Twitter generation" that prefers to consume information quickly in small high-concentration portions passing away?
- erikpukinskis 8y agoFor me, YouTube is less about browsing low quality content quickly and more about identifying videographers who I really like, and enjoying 10m that someone really put effort into.
- qwerty456127 8y agoAren't such harder to find as video content is not searchable?
- erikpukinskis 8y agoYes very hard. It seems to take years to build up a good list of subscriptions. Reminds me of early Twitter in that sense. I sometimes come across an account and discover it’s a part of a whole community of accounts. I pick through and subscribe to some. Sometimes my feed takes a turn for the repetitive and then I prune accounts. The homepage is OK but the subscription feed is the only thing you can get to a worthwhile state but it takes some tending to it. Similar to RSS too in that sense.
- yellowboxtenant 8y agoThis is one big "duh" for literally anyone around teens and pre-teens.
- thanatropism 8y agoIn Brazil top youtubers are outperforming television stars and traditional entertainers in the celebrity game. Books featuring these people are always in the best-seller lists and live appearances draw rock star-level crowds. Most interesting: these people are appealing mostly to the sub-14 crowd. Children find about youtubers by word of mouth but also by fumbling with tablets and cell phones.
- irrational 8y agoThis aligns extremely well with what I have seen with my teenagers and their friends. Recently I was at an event where a teenager was giving a speech in which he mentioned Snapchat or Instagram and said, as an aside, "That's like Facebook for you old people".
- optimuspaul 8y agoI'm over 40 and I totally get it, youtube is guaranteed to have something entertaining on it that I can find in seconds. Facebook, not so much.
- morbusfonticuli 8y agoAlthough this might not add any value to the general discussion, i feel the urge to break my lurker-silence and share my latest epiphany: end-twenties german compsci-student here. in retrospective, my act of leaving facebook and (obviously in contrast to a lot of other users here) not replacing it with any substitute "social media" account might have had a bigger impact on my life as i would have guessed. Since years, i have been using Telegram, signal, SMS, the gold old phonecalls, email and IRC (my jabber contacts also moved to signal, etc.) and i can guarantee you to have a pretty reduced social life. In a more active phase of my life (a couple of years ago) i still went frequently to concerts with 2-3 friends who would send me routinely emails containing facebook-screenshots etc. ... Nowadays i lead a life most separated from the rest of the "social" world. Of course i still have friends and visit Them from time to time, etc. ... But on facebook i realized my self-consuming habit of constantly checking what other ppl i rarely knew thought or did or "liked". I have to admit that despite this time consuming social media habits i could really lead a reflected and productive life, but to be honest i still put feel time into passively(!) surfing the net, reading and watching a lot of news, journals, trivia, etc. Through other eyes this comment might seem bitter, but i actually enjoy my life without this burden of social media platforms on myself. Are here some other 'conscientious objectors'?