15 ms·
Macron Vowed to Make France a ‘Startup Nation.’ Is It Getting There?
- tradedash 8y agowhat does "startup nation" even mean?
- ttul 8y agoIt means a bunch of tiny firms that mostly fail.
- topbanana 8y agoI would imagine it means a cultural and legal infrastructure lending itself to entrepreneurship. As a US citizen it's easy to take this for granted
- agumonkey 8y agomany fuzzy things wrapped in a taco: - having a French silicon valley (I believe attempts have been done before but failed) - jump on the wave of smart iot app fad - leverage the previous thing for (probably super bad) software education - Macron seems to be in the self-made man (with state support if you're positive minded) so reviving a liberal entrepreneurship model fits his views ps: also it doesn't seem to have any major factual impact (they may have helped a bunch of people but I didn't hear about anything groundbreaking); annnnd the disrupt startup motto is not well received nowadays, Uber -> Uberization... gig economy .. it didn't catch on really (for good reasons IMO)
- zapita 8y ago> what does "startup nation" even mean? A nation where startups can succeed?
- ldng 8y agoIt's more, managing a nation like a startup
- matte_black 8y agoIsrael is an example of a “startup nation”. Edit: Downvotes!? Israel has the most startups per capita of any nation. Look it up, not doing homework for you.
- asdsa5325 8y agoYou are getting downvoted because you didn't answer the question. What are the qualities of being a "startup nation", other than simply having the most startups in the world, which is likely not what Macron meant.
- adventured 8y agoIsrael has so many start-ups and so much VC, solely because of the vast capital investment flows from the US. That's hardly a reasonable example for a large nation like France to work from. It'd be like pretending Ireland's $70,000 GDP per capita is organic, rather than the result of US corporate giants using it as a tax device.
- prolikewhoa 8y agoTranslates to "slow erosion of labour rights".
- makotech222 8y agoA nation where you can abuse your workers and exploit them by promising financial gain, work them to the bone with low pay and benefits, and actually deliver nothing for them. AKA America.
- scrollaway 8y agoI flagged you because I am seriously sick of seeing questions get answered by pure concentrated sarcasm. You don't even attempt to be helpful here. There's a middle ground between "worker abuse" and "useless bureaucracy". France is closer to the latter right now (I'm french, I've got experience setting up companies both in the US and in France). This is because: 1. Many systems aren't properly automated and/or don't know how to communicate between each other. So you have to deal with extra paperwork when not necessary. Go in-person somewhere that isn't even necessarily the city you live in, you have to plan ahead for these things. Fax or snail-mail things where email would be sufficient. Etc. 2. Complying with european laws isn't always easy. You sometimes have to deal with slightly-different versions of certain laws, regulations, etc for no good reason. This is what the EU is supposed to fix, and the EU helps but it doesn't always work. 3. Complying with VAT is super hard for the same reasons. This is being worked on in 2018 and 2019. It should be getting easier soon. 4. There's less tooling, documentation, and marketing around creating startups in France. If you're in the EU you'll be tempted to do it in Ireland for tax reasons. Otherwise you'll end up in Delaware. This isn't even because it's necessarily a good idea for your case, but simply because everyone else is doing it. But, you know, your helpful cynicism too.
- dang 8y agoWe've banned this account for posting unsubstantive and uncivil comments, and for using HN primarily for political battle, all of which is against the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.
- olivermarks 8y ago'what does "startup nation" even mean?' It's aspirational happy talk to disguise a bureaucratic log jam reality, calculated to appease the voting public's economic frustration and keep up a posture of being 'business friendly'. In reality the politicians are bought and paid for by big global businesses who don't need any competition...
- kworker 8y agoEscape the Brexit. Many EU startup gone to London for some reason.
- Symbiote 8y agoIt's extremely easy to register a company in the UK, probably even easier than in the USA. You just fill in this web form and pay £12: https://www.gov.uk/limited-company-formation/register-your-company https://www.gov.uk/limited-company-formation/register-your-c...
- benwilber0 8y agoI don't know much about the startup landscape in France (or anywhere in the EU), but I've always heard that it is difficult to incorporate a small company and hire employees due to large regulatory/bureaucracy hurdles. The "move fast, break things" pattern of setting up a Delaware LLC and getting an angel seed in a matter of days/weeks really just doesn't work. Can anyone comment on this? Is this way off base?
- JumpCrisscross 8y agoRecently helped a friend launch a French subsidiary. It is a pain. First, you must pay a lawyer or formation agent to write and register your by-laws. Next, you must seek an introduction to a bank manager. With that secured, you get to draft a book report of a business plan. This is tedious and pointless. Once completed, the bank manager reviews it. (They will also ask for lots of personal documents, each requiring expensive notarization.) If they approve, you get a business bank account. Into this account you must deposit no less than €4,000. Unfortunately, these funds are frozen until you get your extrait Kbis. That won't happen for at least two weeks. Now you have to buy an ad in a French newspaper. These are expensive. After a week or two, papers will arrive in the mail. You take these to the Commercial Court, where a bunch of agencies on different floors will stamp them. With those stamped papers in hand, your €4,000 will be unfrozen. (Usually. On the next business day.) Finally, you have to appoint a French accountant. They continually monitor your business and continually charge you fees. Now you can business! Meanwhile, in Delaware, 24 hours and a few hundred dollars buys you an LLC. A bank account, set up online or in person, can get you going the next day.
- rdm_blackhole 8y agoAnd that is not the worst part. When you sell your company, you may have to wait between 6 to 9 months to get your money! Basically, taxes are always delayed and to calculate the exact amount that you owe to the diverse government agencies, it takes an army of accountants. Even sometimes the accountants do not know what is going on as the tax laws are always changing, sometimes at the last minutes. Meanwhile, you have sold your asset, your money is stuck in escrow for more than 6 months, you have no revenue and no money. Welcome to France! Source: my parents sold their business in October last year and just got their money a week ago.
- nkkollaw 8y agoI understand why a small percentage of startups could benefit from being in San Francisco and similar and want to enjoy the ecosystem, hire people, etc. However, I have no idea why any early-stage startup would go to France and last 3 months, while with the same money they could go to Poland and enjoy the same level of support from the government, availability of highly-skilled tech people, and twice-4 times the buying power compared to any other similarly attractive country in Europe. While I've never even come close to creating an even barely successful anything, I would think that being able to survive for 6 months can make the difference compared to running out of money after 3 months. I mean, the 3-months guy would totally miss a big contract at month 5.
- lkrubner 8y agoThe risk of going to Poland is that the government of Poland is currently expressing views that are extremely hostile to the EU, and therefore you must take into account the political risk that Poland might try to pull a stunt like Brexit -- at which point you find that you have been building a business on the assumption that you are inside of the EU, and now you suddenly find yourself outside of the EU. I have thought about setting up an office in Krakow. I've been impressed with every software developer I've worked with from Poland. But settling there has some serious political risks. Poland seems to have the best of both worlds, with an independent currency, but otherwise inside the EU. It is worrisome that the Poles feel the desire to destroy this.
- sheepmullet 8y ago> The risk of going to Poland is that the government of Poland is currently expressing views that are extremely hostile to the EU Are they? Or are they simply not bowing to the will of Germany? I think the political risk to the EU is coming from Italy and Germany at the moment. I see less risk of political problems in Poland than with
- petre 8y agoFirst of all, that doesn't happen suddenly, you have time to relocate in a different EU country. Look at Brexit. Then a startup always means risk. Political risk is one of those. The EU is not that rosy, not for Eastern Europeans anyway. It works fine for Germany but the other countries, Central and Eastern European ones specifically are second class citizens in the EU. Fortunately most of us still have our own currencies and are not totally at the mercy of the EU. It's still better than being "friends" with the USSR though.
- duxup 8y agoHow far has he gotten with labor law changes? I some HR folks complain at a company I worked for a while back. They complained that if someone in France was going to be fired there were three different government departments that may choose to get involved and sometimes each had a different idea on how the situation should be handled.
- walshemj 8y agoDo you mean fired for cause or redundancies over a certain size - the USA has that procedure as well (WARN Act) you know.
- repsilat 8y agoHoly excluded middle, Batman :-). Most of the US[1] are in "at will" employment states, in which individuals can be fired without cause. This is probably what the grandparent was comparing France's law to. The WARN act probably doesn't bear a great deal on the US's place as a "startup nation"... 1: by area, population or state count, including California but excluding New York
- walshemj 8y agoI think your missing the point you can get fired for gross misconduct quickly even in states in the EU with stronger employment laws. If at will makes it so easy why are US employers including startups terrified of firing people - look at all this obsession with not making a bad hire if it was truly easy to fire this would not be the case.
- repsilat 8y ago> terrified of firing They aren't. From experience, startups have no problem firing people for simply not being exceptional. Startups are worried about wasting time, though -- the cost of a bad hire is taking longer to get someone good to do the job, because it's going to take time to realise they aren't performing, and it's going to take time to do the search again.
- rdm_blackhole 8y agoHiring and firing people in France is particularly hard. Most companies do not scale beyond 10 employees as after this threshold the regulatory burden increases dramatically. Taxes on small to medium businesses are downright confiscatory. Most French people still see business owners as exploiters of their workers.
- Rjevski 8y agoSeconded. In French culture the “boss” is traditionally considered as an asshole. While I’m not saying there aren’t bad bosses out there, this kind of hostile culture towards management doesn’t really help anything. Taxes are awful as well, and filing them is a pain, even for a sole trader.
- rdm_blackhole 8y agoThe social ladder is also broken. If you don't have the right diploma, no matter what your skills are you will never make it to the top. There is a real mindset of "Us vs Them" where "Them" is your boss or manager and you should despise them no matter what. I have left France 5 years ago due to those issues, I am now much happier in a country where your skills come first and nobody cares what you did before so long as you can do the job that is required of you. France will most likely never be like that.
- walshemj 8y agoNo change then years ago I interviewed with a uk subsidiary of a French company traveling 3-4 hours down to the south coast to do that. When they found I had not been to university - they looked at me like I had just taken a dump on the floor.
- Rjevski 8y agoNo change - if anything, it's even worse, as the education requirement now means everyone has a degree (even though they might not have the passion nor the actual skill for it), and since the requirement no longer works as a filter for good candidates (I'd argue it never really worked, but now it's even worse) they are now requiring education and experience (for the same pay an intern would get in the UK). Even assuming you have a degree, how are you supposed to get the experience when pretty much all the jobs require previous experience? And no, the trick of applying despite not having experience and making up for it at the interview doesn't work - job requirements are very rigid in France; either you'll get rejected right at the start, or if you do make it through all the interviews they will still reject you at the end once they find out (and possibly even consider you as a fraud for applying anyway despite not having the experience).
- gnicholas 8y agoIt has historically been difficult to fire employees in France, compared with the US. Apparently they considered relaxing this policy on 2016 [1], but IDK whether their efforts were successful. Considering the Silicon Valley mantra of “hire slow, fire fast”, it will be interesting to see how things evolve in France. Will they relax their labor laws/customs, or will they find a different way for startups to grow? 1: https://www.pri.org/stories/2016-05-13/france-employers-resort-harassment-drive-employees-away-not-much-longer https://www.pri.org/stories/2016-05-13/france-employers-reso...
- gregoriol 8y agoThere has been an "Auto Entrepreneur" status created a few years ago (2010?) that is used by many startups (mainly gig-economy like drivers/delivery/...) which has helped a lot to get started. It's not an employee status, more like a contractor status. It's easy on the company, but not like freestyle though as abuse could be re-qualified as a regular contract ("CDI" ie. employee contract) by a judge. Regular employment is still much protected for the employee.
- JeanMarcS 8y agoYes. If you have only one client, it's considered as desguised employment. The difference is that the wellfare taxes as Auto Entrepreneur are very low compared to en employee, for the same service in hospital or doctors.
- p0nce 8y agoI'm using this for a software business and it's easy as pie (but less than in Delaware says the thread).
- zenovision 8y agoI doubt that France will be able to do this - they have many disadvantages comparing to USA: - high taxes - a lot of buerocracy - language burden to attract high qualified foreign employees - lower salaries - fragmented political system in the EU - much lower population in France comparing to USA and if you want to cover the entire EU, you have to support many different languages, currencies, etc...
- jedisct1 8y agoBureaucracy... not so much. Things have been drastically simplified.
- briandear 8y agoUntil you deal with a bank. Simplified is very relative. Also, while there might be slightly less paper, attitudes are the same.
- JeanMarcS 8y agoTo be fairly honest, sinc I start reading HN and some post about burocracy in the US, I started to think that France may not be THAT bad. It's bad, but perhaps not as bad as I thought it was (disclosure : I'm a French business owner)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- desu_ 8y agoAs a French, it saddens me a bit to say that but you also missed one point: culture. My background includes some grad school experience at a top French university and then at a top US university. One big difference, which became even more obvious to me after I crossed the Atlantic, is that there is (almost) no hustle culture in France. Make fun of the stupid apps and the copycats but so many undergrads at my American alma mater were trying something, and that is already so much more than what I saw in France. I have seen some undergrads in America make serious money through their side projects and big companies are more often seen as a stepping stone towards something else. In France, the holy grail is to get a CDI (permanent employee contract) at a big company and that’s often pretty much it. They can be great employees but making money within a structure simply does not require the same resourcefulness. I don't know if the culture is contagious once you arrive in a country, or if universities attract different profiles (probably both), but I thought it was also interesting to note that the immigrants were often resembling the locals in both countries. In my opinion, even the best version of Macron’s plan is bound to produce underwhelming results. While French taxes and bureaucracy might not help entrepreneurship, I do not think that’s why France isn’t a startup nation. Rather, it’s the fact that France isn’t a startup nation that explains why bad policies and bureaucracy have been tolerated for so long. Understand me well: my comment is the opposite of an attempt to diminish the accomplishments of French entrepreneurs, who exist and face higher administrative hurdles than their American counterparts, but is simply written to share some observations on campus culture and entrepreneurship at two top schools.
- chillidoor 8y agoI seriously doubt it. There are just too many hurdles to get over. Even trying to get staff from another EU office to come and work is a pain the arse, as my previous place of work discovered when they tried to get one of the devs to move to Paris for a few months.
- pwaai 8y agoI actually looked into this with the local France Business startup organization. At the time, I was young (30, I am now 31) and started learning French with hopes of trying out a alternative to Anglo culture. But reality hits hard. I don't know how I would be able to adjust from living in a multicultural and laws where minorities are protected and enforced to a republic where it is not. Once you are in France, you are expected to become fluent to the point of having no accent, because god forbid if you come from Quebecois speaking region you will get bullied and made fun of. So it's like wtf???? Here I am learning your culture and trying my best but it won't mount to shit if it's not French. Very dangerous to set elusive set of criterias based on ethnocentric ideas and see what sticks. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQzR6zKpbKQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQzR6zKpbKQ The most crazy part is that it's other minorities attacking other minorities in France.
- briandear 8y agoBe lucky you don’t have an Algerian sounding name.
- boobsbr 8y agoGive Belgium a try, maybe? People still speak French, but it has a TON of accents from people all over the world (at least in Brussels, that is).
- pwaai 8y agoWill do, are there any specific tech hot spots in Belgium? I no very little about the country but so far very disappointed with what France had to offer to startups.
- boobsbr 8y agoBrussels has a lot of opportunities. Change your LinkedIn location to Brussels and watch the recruiters salivate. You can look for jobs on http://www.actiris.be/ce/tabid/93/language/fr-BE/Offres-d-emploi.aspx http://www.actiris.be/ce/tabid/93/language/fr-BE/Offres-d-em.... I once submitted my resumé to one company, and it somehow got shared with other companies and recruiters and I had a flurry of offerings. Most of what I receive is for the Brussels metropolitan area, but sometimes I get stuff from Antwerp, Ghent, Liège/Leuven.
- merinowool 8y agoMaybe start-ups as groups created in large companies that take on copying emerging US enterprises? Small companies are not supported in the EU because of regulatory hurdles, excessive taxation and employment laws one size fits all. Most businesses are grant driven - that is you write a business plan that satisfies bureaucrats, get money and hope to stay afloat for year or two so you don't have to give it back. Rinse and repeat. There is no room for innovation. In some EU countries entrepreneurs are treated as potential criminals until proven innocent.
- mabynogy 8y agoIt's not real. If it was, YC should be involved (because they are the best at that). It's a old story because he needs to talk about something. The previous governement created a fund for that. It is nearly totally unaffected (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bpifrance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bpifrance). He does nothing because there is nothing to do. France destiny is sealed by european threaties. To change something the treaties must be broken but people are afraid by that. France is in a waitstate until something happens at a global scale (like a war).
- 40something 8y agoCulturally it can’t happen. They need their own version of Trump to erase 3 regulations for every new one. In addition the youth have zero ambition due to the strong safety net.
- mtremsal 8y agoI'm curious, are you arguing that the US was not a "start-up nation" before Trump's election?
- altharaz 8y agoTo those who talk about the administrative & HR issues in France: these are definitely true. However, the government is running two programs that will try to improve these elements[1][2]. For instance: - the French Public Investment Bank (BPI) will receive more money in order to create a better leverage for fund raising, co-investing with private funds in startups; - France will work with European Union to create the european equivalent of the DARPA challenges; - France Expérimentation will provide exemptions to some startups trying new business models; - new APIs will be provided to help accomplishing administrative tasks automatically; - public contracts will have lower entry barriers; - public aids (which are really important in France) will be simplified; - the HR thresholds will be reviewed in order to promote startup growth; - a study will be conducted on "renting contracts" for startups (most contracts have a 3/6/9-years engagement clause, which is not adapted to startup growth); - corporate tax will be lowered; - ... This is not perfect and we are indeed accustomed to a lot of rules and administrative work, but still: it is good and motivating to see that the government is trying to do something. Moreover, we have great landscapes and food, so let's give France a try :). [1] https://www.numerique.gouv.fr/actions-startups/elements-de-portee-generale/ https://www.numerique.gouv.fr/actions-startups/elements-de-p... (in French) [2] https://www.pacte-entreprises.gouv.fr/ https://www.pacte-entreprises.gouv.fr/ [edit] styling
- pilooch 8y agoI run a machine learning company in France. Call it a startup or not, doesn't matter. Most of what I read in the comments here is not exactly true nor relies on statistics (sound like my story is...). For companies acting within the science or innovative space, France is a haven. CIR is a tax return that covers 30% of R&D personnel, JEI is a status that halves the taxes on personnel for 8 years, and nullifies gov taxes the first year, halving them the second year. Add to this the region and gov backed projects that match 50% of your investment in a project. The truth is it is much much cheaper than in the US, and probably unmatched in Western Europe. Now, all this preexisted Macron. Some hurdles remain investment, low margins for companies around 20 employees and 2M yearly, they get stuck at that stage and lack of transparency. One major pain is interacting with large French corporations, with payment delays unheard of in the US. This slows many startups down when it does not kill them. Once bootstrapped it seems to get better. I'm not sure what a startup nation is not whether I'd like to live in it, but France is certainly in good position to fuel early small innovative & scientific companies, not more but not less :)
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> The truth is it is much much cheaper than in the US, and probably unmatched in Western Europe Business formation (i.e. forming a legal entity, getting a bank account, hiring your first employee and getting paid for your first service) in France is much more expensive than in Britain, Luxembourg or Poland. And the U.S. is faster and cheaper still. That said, if you have the right connections, it can be a haven. There is a lot of inefficiency in the French economy. And it contains an incredibly well-educated and commercially-reasonable population.
- pjc50 8y agoCan you form the company in e.g. Luxembourg and then operate in France? I feel that this is the sort of thing the Single Market was supposed to make easy.
- Uberphallus 8y agoFrance will force the hell out of you to open a branch in France. I have a company in Estonia and France is the only country that asks me to do such thing in the EU. Luckily I live in France, you'll need an address here, and have fun opening a business bank account with papers in, say, Estonian, or even English for that matter. Spent thousands in translations, whereas creating the company in Estonia was over the Internet and under 300 EUR. France will do all it can to drag you into its bureaucratic hell.
- 6t6t6t6 8y agoMost of startups fail miserably. Some become extremelly successful. That's what Macron wants for the country he manages?
- lurena 8y agoI'll go ahead and be 'that guy' and say it: I don't want my country to become a startup nation. I don't want management methods and labor laws to be reformed, or modernized, or to mimic those in the US. I don't want corporation-friendly tax rates to be enacted. I don't want regulations to be lifted. There are, give or take, 65 million people in France. (Incidentally, this number is also, give or take, the amount of Americans who live in the most abject poverty seen in the developed world.) Not everyone among these 65 million is fit to 'move fast and break things'. Not everyone wants to be flexible, adaptable or able to sell themselves in a world of fast hires and firings. Not everyone is a young and dynamic entrepreneur full of 'innovative' ideas (whatever that means). In short, not everyone is a twenty-to-thirty- something with a moderately high level of education and relative affinity with the tech world. On the other hand, everyone needs a steady job to make a living. Everyone needs the healthcare, retirement plans and other benefits our current labor laws entail with that steady job. In short, everyone is a human being with basic human needs. Startups have one thing in common - they tend to fail. Maybe your average HN reader will be able to endure the typical working conditions with no guarantee of a stable income in the future, but they are the exception, not the rule. It is preposterous to imagine that an entire country's labor laws and regulation should align with the needs of such a narrow demographic so that foreign investors will maybe deign to notice it and shower said demographic with money. Yes, there are many things wrong with our current labor laws. Yes, maybe some regulations are needlessly tight and stifle the growth of blooming startups full of bright people. No, that does not mean the US as a 'startup nation' is an example to follow. And if that means the next Facebook or Instagram won't come from here, so be it. Many of these startups tend to produce services that are superficially useful at best or actively harmful at worst. We don't need them.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoAs an American, kudos for appreciating what keeps your country on solid footing, versus a culture that is essentially a lottery with more flash.
- megalomanu 8y agoFrance is a combination between Philippe le Bel, Zinedine Zidane, Louis Renault, Serge Gainsbourg, Marcel Dassault, Jean Jaurès, Auguste Renoir, Blaise Pascal, Napoléon, Arthur Rimbaud, Charles de Gaulle, and so on. Current social rights are not more a part of french culture than anything else and I think most of the current conflicts come from the thinking than progress is acquired and a marxist point of view (which is very valid and important, but not the source of all answers). We tend to forget than France existed before 1945.
- Legogris 8y agoJust sharing another experience: I am a technical manager at a small-size big data company. We opened a new office in Paris three months ago and our largest struggle by far is recruiting talent. Despite what other comments here are writing, the startup scene is booming. Station F[1] is huge. The four WeWorks are full and they are opening two more soon. Global companies like Microsoft, Google, Facebook and Naver are growing their presence. New companies are popping up all the time. Despite the academic strength of France in Computer Science, there is simply not enough supply of senior engineers in France to meet the demand. A couple of years ago Paris was lukewarm and we managed to open up in the midst of frying heat. I have met both Berliners and Parisians who say that there is more happening in Paris than Berlin right now. The language divide is definitely a thing. We are an international English-speaking company and that works both for and against us. (We're called Kaiko[1] if anyone reading this wants to reach out and connect) [0] https://stationf.co/ https://stationf.co/ [1] https://www.kaiko.com https://www.kaiko.com
- roel_v 8y ago"our largest struggle by far is recruiting talent" So, proof of the pudding and all - how much are you paying a senior engineer? To make it easier to compare, take an hypothetical software engineer with a cs degree and 10 years of experience in mainstream technologies?
- T-N-T 8y agoI am french and two of my friends left for the US because very large companies I won't name made them offers that are impossible to match in Europe. There is no lack of produced talents here, they just won't stay because they don't get paid their true market value.
- rdm_blackhole 8y agoCorrection, there are enough devs but the salaries are too low, so they go elsewhere like I did. I am not going to work 40+ hours a week or more to make 2500 euros and pay 1000 euros of rent in Paris. Whats the point? Also, Paris is a crime-ridden city that is way overpriced.
- auvi 8y agodoes anybody know how the France Tech Visa thing going on?
- jjcm 8y agoI'm seeing a lot of arguments in this thread against starting a business in France, so my question is this: outside of the US where would you start something?
- kolp 8y agoIreland - Eurozone, English speaking, light touch regulation, strong IT and customer support culture. However the high cost of accommodation in the cities, particularly Dublin, is starting to make recruitment difficult. I've anecdotal evidence of several 20-30 year olds looking to emigrate because they can't resolve the high cost of accommodation with their after-tax salary.
- heavenlyblue 8y agoGood luck hiring fast against the large IT companies over there.
- kolp 8y agoThere are a lot of good potential employees who don't want to be a part of the "burn 'em and churn 'em" practices employed by some of the larger IT companies. But, I agree, it's always a struggle in any country for small businesses to compete in the recruitment process with large corporations.
- heavenlyblue 8y agoIreland is an entirely different matter: it’s hard to find people on LinkedIn for example, since many of them are only in Ireland due to being hired by corpos with huge offices over there. That’s not the case for London as people don’t generally move to London purely for a better salary as companies don’t get a tax discount over there.
- tajen 8y agoI have found that paperwork is very simple in Australia and UK. On the other hand, Mike Cannon-Brookes complains about something regarding starting in Australia, so I guess we should get his input to understand from what size it starts to become painful to be an Australian startup.
- Antifragile1 8y agoNo EU beurocratic shithole is going to be good for startups.
- nopless 8y agoI am curious about the real number of founders in this thread? It seems that most of the replies are focused on system criticism… and it's a completely false statement. Creating a startup in France is really easy to do if you do it well. Take an accountant and he will handle almost everything for you, from the creation to the run. Man Power is cheap compare to the USA. The only limitation seems to be the motivation… and to become a founder you are going to need a lot of motivation ! So what are the difficulties: 1. Market 2. Money The initial market is small. This means that you need to go directly to international business. We have Europe but the point is that Countries are a little bit too patriot. From this point, addressing the USA market is really difficult without having a headquarter there, even with fully digitalized services and English native commercials. Don't know why but you can read Criteo founder's feedback on this point. Addressing China is almost impossible. So here is the point: to address Europe and USA you need huge funds. Money is easy to get at the beginning and you have a lot of public helps on this phase. Then it's more difficult (>2M€). VC market is clearly not as developed as in the USA. That where most of the startup ends… Best case, you will raise money in the USA and move there. Otherwise you are looking for an exit. That will be my conclusion. France is a very cheap place to buy a startup ! (An no such bureaucratic barriers).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tajen 8y agoWell, I’m a founder... French paperwork is incredibly stupid (beyond any necessary explanation), and, for no employee, I pay my accountant 2800€ to handle said paperwork. Second, tax deduction and grants... There are full companies whose job is to get grants for others. But if you don’t know the right law or the right grant, you pay the higher tax. I’ve lost at least 150.000€ with that on my first 8 years, although I did have an accountant to advise me on this, which means I struggle on my first employee. Last, the marxist culture. As long as you earn money, you’re assumed to be an asshole, so you constantly have to remind people how much donations you make and how much you’ve worked to earn the right to earn your own money. It’s quite unhealthy to say the least. For 100k€, I give 63k€ to accountant and various taxes, donate ~1k in money in average (and 1% products) and participate to local education. Yeah, I’m flagged as a selfish guy by outsiders (not interns, my interns love their job, my internships are way above average). Besides, Macron said there are too many white males in IT, so you’re welcome to leave. Just to set the expectations.
- kolp 8y agoMy experience as an anglophone, non-French entrepreneur living in France is that the regulations and business climate reflect the belief system of the population. There is a fairly widespread acceptance, even among well educated French people, in several of the following beliefs: - Companies are exploitative of their workforce and should be strongly regulated to protect workers; - Excess company profits are a sign of unfairness and abuse, and maximum profits should be controlled to protect against such unfairness; - The role of an organisation is to provide employment; - Unemployment can be reduced by making it more difficult to fire employees or make their positions redundant; - France's international uncompetitiveness, especially vis a vis Germany, could be solved by making other countries similarly uncompetitive by imposing similar burdens. My partner is French and a Human Resources consultant to medium and large organisations. The horror stories she recounts would make most entrepreneurs run a mile. My business is online and I can locate it anywhere. I've chosen Ireland for a variety of reasons. Eurozone, English speaking with good multilingual talent availability, good international transport and relatively light touch regulation. Tax rate wasn't a significant factor because the effective rate of tax (after factoring in state subventions) is relatively similar between the two countries. France is a great place to live but a terrible place to run a business or to hold capital assets. The high taxes pay for a very good public health system and a good transport system. Unfortunately, they also pay for a huge amount of public sector waste. France for startups works well if you're well connected, in which case you're made. Connections are, however, largely forged early in life, in Lycees and Grand Ecoles, so connections and networks are much more difficult for an outsider to penetrate. As an example of French business mentality, my friend's business (online/social) has few actual users and no paying users and is 100% supported by a mix of grants and supports from a myriad of government organisations, and by large corporations who are obligated by government to set aside an annual budget for supporting such endeavours. My friend's business is considered a success in France. I consider it a personal success for him, insofar as he has navigated the system quite well. But it's not my definition of business success.
- Keats 8y agoSince you live in France, wouldn't your business be considered French as well, assuming you don't have employees/associates in other countries? Since the corporate tax residency cares about where the activity is directed from.
- erikb 8y agoPoliticians are weird. The start-up idea itself is slowly dying and now they start to really become active about it in politics. What's the point? Merkel also was in Shenzhen in her China trip.
- amelius 8y agoWhy does the concept of "startup region" even exist? Given that work has become more and more intellectual rather than physical, and products more virtual than physical, I would expect that geographical location matters less and less. Is it based on superstition of investors?