6 ms·
I can live with "glasses", "pants", "pliers" and "scissors", but "data" drives me crazy because even native speakers seem to be completely inconsistent when it
by weinzierl 8y ago
I can live with "glasses", "pants", "pliers" and "scissors", but "data" drives me crazy because even native speakers seem to be completely inconsistent when it comes to its number.
EDIT: Now that I think about it there is another one that is hard for me, even it I know it is the correct form in English: visa (singular) and visas (plural). In my mother tongue it follows the same pattern as datum and data, it's Visum (singular) and Visa (plural).
- jMyles 8y ago"People" too - as inconsistently numbered as data.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pluma 8y agoThat one is actually because it's two different words: "people" is the plural form of "person", i.e. one person, two people, as a group "people" (pl. "peoples") is a group of people as a unit, e.g. a tribe or an ethnic group or the citizens of a country "persons" is ALSO the plural of "person" but only used when you talk about individuals rather than a group (e.g. "person of interest" -> "persons of interest", not "people of interest") Yes this is a bit awkward and yes sometimes what's grammatically possible still sounds awkward even to native speakers (e.g. I'd argue "the polices" is a legitimate term when discussing multiple police organisations of a country as an abstract group but it sounds extremely wrong to most people apparently).
- wafflebear 8y agoI believe "persons" is similar to "people" but differs in register. For example, there is a UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Obviously, native speakers would say "people with disabilities" in almost every situation, but that would be too informal for the title of a treaty. Likewise, law enforcement use formal speech such as "persons of interest" to bolster their authority, but nobody would ever say "I sat next to two Australian persons on the flight".
- sverige 8y agoUm, I'm a native speaker and might say "I sat next to two Australian persons on the flight." Admittedly, it's more likely I'd say "I sat next to two Ozzies on the flight." (No, not Aussies, Ozzies. Like Ozzy Ozbourne. Because that's how it sounds to me when Aussies say 'Aussies.')
- notahacker 8y agoIts uneasy coexistence with the usually-technically-valid-and-occasionally-preferred persons is the real problem. Peoples is pretty rare and only for the specific case where it's referring to a plurality of tribes/nations as peoples...
- jMyles 8y agoStill - I'm pretty sure I encounter the word "peoples" more frequently than the word "datum." :-)
- whatsstolat 8y agoI see the word datum often in code
- jMyles 8y agoYeah? I don't. And it doesn't seem like a great name in code. Link me to some examples?
- toast0 8y agoData is a plural of datum, if you're considering the individual pieces, but it's more commonly used (in my experience as a US native) as a collection singular like sand. Ex the sand has formed a hill, the data has filled the hard drive.
- mc32 8y agoIn some contexts the plural of datum is datums, making it a bit more complicated than just a collective noun.
- weinzierl 8y agoThat's interesting. I've never encountered "datums" but a quick Google search turned up plenty of examples (like "Tidal Datums") and that "This plural is permissible only in the sense of 'fixed reference points'" [1]. Which contexts did you have in mind? [1] https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/datums https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/datums
- mc32 8y agoYes things like surveying and mapping was what I was thinking—similar.
- timthorn 8y agoAnd in the UK, Lego.
- bovine3dom 8y agoLego is the brand name; "let's play with Lego" is short for "let's play with the Lego bricks". I think it's much closer to a group noun :) See also: Meccano, Duplo, Brio, Scalextric.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoLEGO(tm) brand bricks
- jgtrosh 8y agoI have the same pet peeve with media, especially in french where média is used only as a singular, with les médias for the plural. Médium is exclusively used for ways of expression, and médiums for speaking with the dead. I get that language evolves but this specific evolution really bothers me.
- SuddsMcDuff 8y agoIn Australia, is the singular of darta "dartum"? (Genuine question for any Aussies)
- yesenadam 8y agouh.. I don't think dartum is used, I've never heard it. "A piece of data" maybe.. But it's rare to have to talk of just one.
- NamTaf 8y agoWe use the spelling datum/data. We pronounce it 'dar-ta' not 'day-taa'. I want to say we pronounce it 'day-tum' not 'dar-tum' but both sound fine to me, possibly thanks to all of the exported American English we consume or possibly just because we're weird. I appreciate the apparent strangeness of this, but it's certainly not unique within the language. That's English! :)
- ekianjo 8y agoMedia is another word that is not used consistently either. It is the plural of medium in latin but is not always understood as a plural.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoFewer people know Latin in Britain now. So the Latin derived words are usually used as fully adopted words target than being treated as quoted Latin. This seems right to me. "Forums" (rather than fora) seems a little awkward to me, but "data point" seems more natural than "datum". But then I never learnt Latin at school. At some point we need to stop applying the grammar rules of foreign languages to fully adopted words.
- ekianjo 8y agothe point is that they were initially adopted specifically in this way in the dictionary in the first place. Ignorance and years of bad education took their toll.
- andrewbinstock 8y agoThe visa thing sounds like a back-formation unique to your mother tongue. The word "visa" is the past participle of videre (Latin for "to see"). So it is not a plural in its formation/derivation.
- bmn__ 8y agoYou're mistaken. The verb is vidēre, videō, vidī, visum. There is also the noun vīsum, -ī, plural visa with the primary meaning the seen [thing], appearance, perception. This is the word that was borrowed into English and other languages.
- andrewbinstock 8y agoWhy not look it up before you assert someone is wrong? It's explained in detail in [0]. It's clear that visa is used as a past participle, not as a noun, and it's applied in the singular. There is no support anywhere for the use of visum as a singular and visa as a plural. Which is what I believe I said above. [0] https://www.etymonline.com/word/visa https://www.etymonline.com/word/visa
- anitil 8y agoAs a native speaker I refuse to say 'these data' or the word datum. I prefer 'this data' for plural and 'this piece of data' for singular. Yes I know its wrong in some sense, but I think that ship has sailed
- kazinator 8y ago> that ship has sailed Wha? Oh, you mean quae navis navigaverunt.
- anitil 8y agoHaha yes of course!
- philwelch 8y agoI've also seen "data point" used when a singular form is required. I think in common usage, "data" is a mass noun like "mayonnaise" rather than a plural.
- kazinator 8y agoThat's a good point! Because the compound noun rules in English normally call for all nouns, other than the head of the noun phrase, to be singular. This applies to the singulars that denote single objects too: scissor lift, pant leg; not scissors lift or pants leg. According to this principle, it should be datum point, where only the head noun point may be pluralized. "Datum point" exists, but I've never seen or heard it in use; it's just a "confirm by Google".
- anitil 8y ago'Data point' - much better!
- vorg 8y ago> in common usage, "data" is a mass noun like "mayonnaise" Were you also commenting on its pronunciation? I'd instead say: "data" is a mass noun like "mahyonnaise" and "tomahto sauce".
- sverige 8y agoMy recent peeve is Americans who use 'bespoke' instead of 'custom.' And 'in agreeance' instead of 'in agreement.'
- Wildgoose 8y agoThat's because "data" is a "mass noun". Think coffee - you have one coffee (singular), two coffees (plural), and some coffee (an indeterminate amount). One datum, Two data, Some data.