5 ms·
There Are 101 Americans with Over $1M in Student Loans
- mirimir 8y ago> Bottom line: with so many borrowers set to default on their student loans, those who can't make ends meet will be able to pay roughly 10% of their income for 25 years. The remainder, such as Mark Meru's $2 million balance, will be an obligation of the United States taxpayer. Is this generally true now? I mean, "10% of income for 25 years"? That's not so bad, really. Only half of 20% income tax bracket.
- dnsco 8y agoIt's not so bad for the individuals who are paying 10% of their income, it is bad for US taxpayers who are as I understand this article collectively liable for that burden in 25 years.
- mirimir 8y agoI get that. It's just that this is the first coverage that I recall which doesn't focus on unemployable graduates.
- onion2k 8y agoThat's not so bad, really. That 10% is what middle-income people would typically use to save for things like a 401k, a house deposit or a car. If people can't afford those they'll be much poorer in retirement, stuck renting for much longer which will keep them poor, and for many it'll mean they choose not to have children because they're financially unstable. On an individual level these things are unfortunate; on a societal level they're catastrophic. An aging population can ruin an economy. Tax receipts don't cover basic services. It's happening in many places already (Japan, UK, etc).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- anovikov 8y agoHerd mentality: if everyone is getting a degree, i must too. If getting a degree is an investment, why don't put as much money in there as possible, if ROI is constant? Both wrong. Most people who are getting college degrees nowadays simply can't make enough use of them to even break even. People have to stop! They are the only ones to blame; capitalism has no checks in place to prevent people from harming themselves, maybe that's bad, but ultimately, it is their decision to get a diploma they don't need and can't hope to put to good use, is to blame.
- dnsco 8y agoThis article focuses on someone who went into debt for dental school. I prefer the idea of an educated dentist to dentists without diplomas. All that said, I agree with your sentiment, college is for many people completely unnecessary. As per the article, we as tax payers are on the hook for the debt that will be defaulted on, so the fact that this system has spiraled out of control will hurt all of us.
- roenxi 8y agoCan't challenge your preferences, but I would encourage a bit of reflection on why you think that education is an advantage here. I had some routine dental work done recently; some of my teeth were drilled out. It is a complete mystery to me why we think that a college level education is required for the man holding the drill. My body is very important to me, but it seems a tough sell that years of higher education would give a better outcome than years of, say, straightforward practice. I want a competent dentist, but their education isn't worth as much to me as the steadiness of their hand and their willingness to be gentle with my poor mouth. In theory, any job could be done better by a more educated worker, but we could break it up into generalists and specialists like we do with electricians and electrical engineers. Save the education for people who deal with unusual problems.
- anovikov 8y agoMaybe there's just too many people who want to become dentists; resulting in too much demand and too high prices for dentists diplomas, and too many dentists for prices on their work to justify these diploma costs? Why not just allow everyone with a medical dimploma from a 1st world country to come, get GC at the airport, and get to job the next day? What are the downsides, except liberals around the world nagging again that U.S. were robbing them?
- awat 8y agoIf you owe the bank $10,000 the bank owns you. If you owe the bank $1,000,000 you own the bank. Probably not entirely accurate for this situation but I would still love to see the risk calculations for allowing a ~mil in student loans.
- Johnny555 8y agoThe numbers are a little outdated -- multiply by 10 or 100, then it's more relevant.
- awat 8y agoNo argument on that I should probably just write it with variables.
- jdboyd 8y agoThey didn't loan him $1,000,000 all at once. The person used as an example initially borrowed $601,506. That seems high since he was told to expect the program to cost $400,000 to $450,000, but the original WSJ article explained that unlike normal medical residences, dental residencies typically charge tuition, which is another 3 years of loans on top of the original 4 year program. After the residence, he took a year of forbearance to get established. Of course, for all 8 years, the interested kept accruing. From the $601,506 starting point, the $1,000,000 comes from him paying less per month than interest rate thanks to a government program he is in. He pays $1,590 while the debt grows something like $3,900 a month, so he isn't even trying to pay off his loans currently. After 25 years, the program he is in has the federal government paying off the loan, which at that time is estimated to be about $2,000,000.
- TomK32 8y agoSounds like the US finally have a government-financed higher education - of some sorts...
- dnsco 8y agoIt's absurd that becoming a medical professional requires saddling yourself with an exorbitant amount of debt. My doctor friends advise people contemplating med school not to go for this reason. It's incredibly sad that the economic situation is incentivizing intelligent people to stay out of medicine.
- vostok 8y agoI'm willing to bet that the AMA caps are keeping more smart people out of medicine than the costs are.
- pitaa 8y agoHow does anyone think it's a good idea to take out $1M in loans for an education? Yes, tuition costs are ridicules and in general students have no control over them. In general, I feel like students are taken advantage of. HOWEVER, students certainly can choose not to attend a certain school. If you choose to rack up $1M in debt, I feel like that's solely on you and your (obviously) poor decision making skills.
- dnsco 8y agoThis article focuses on a man who took out ~600k in loans to become an orthodontist. That interest has since compounded to 1mm. I would imagine he took the loans out because becoming an orthodontist was his highest-paying career option. Had he known that the variable-rate loans would be impossible for him to pay off he probably would not have taken them out. We should not be putting aspiring medical professionals in this position.
- yellow_postit 8y agoWhile we are at it let’s stop artificially limiting the number of medical professionals.
- candiodari 8y agoSo the state will be increasing the budgets for university medical departments, then ? In contradiction to what has been done for decades now ? So, what I mean to say is that we will be increasing taxes some amount (not much, but let's say 0.5%) to allow for this and other subjects to train more people ? (medicine is actually one of the most expensive things to train, requiring lots of tools, infrastructure (literally entire hospital complexes), ...)
- fencepost 8y agoHis first year loans were only ~$43k, but then the interest rate spiked and tuition also got hiked. He might be able to make more of a dent in the balance, but it's high enough that the only way payments are affordable is using the 10% of income rule, which results in a number to small to even keep up with the interest. At this point student loan debt is like a treatable but incurable disease - you take the meds / make the payments hoping you last long enough for a cure to be found / legislated.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ggg9990 8y agoWhy is Mark Meru allowed to pay back only 10% of his discretionary income? He has a $225,000 income and can pay back more than $1,590 a month for the education that got him to this salary level. Then he could make a dent in the principal.
- gok 8y agoBecause... those were the terms the lender agreed to?
- mirimir 8y agoAnd because he realized how things were going, and refinanced at the right time, in a smart way.
- vidarh 8y agoAnd according to the article it is not that simple: the forgiven debt amount will be taxed as ordinary income. Which means he'll also need to plan for å substantial tax charge at the point when his debt is discharged.
- jurassic 8y agoCosts are out of control and university interests are not aligned with student interests in this matter. It seems like federal educational lending should be capped at some lifetime maximum ($200-300k per student?). The higher ed industry will figure out the cost side of the equation in a hurry when students no longer have unlimited access to credit.
- joe_the_user 8y agoThe state should get out of the business of guaranteeing student loans entirely and instead only give grants. The loan guarantee system is exactly what misaligns university and student interests in loans. Universities have no disincentive to give students loans they can't pay back. I don't think a cap would change university behavior - it would only affect a few students, who would be tossed out by the university to make way for the next students.
- candiodari 8y agoBut the rub is in congressional abuse of accounting practices. A loan guarantee "costs": 1) in reality: the future default rate, times the average loan that gets defaulted on 2) in theory: the past default rate times the average loan amount What's wrong with this: a) default rate : the default rate under very different circumstances: the default rate for guaranteed-by-the-state loans vs the default rate for large-personal-consequences loans b) amount of the loan: average loan amount vs average amount that gets defaulted on. Everyone who's ever had a late credit card bill knows the vast difference here. So congress got to vastly overspend, giving the money to banks (>72% of the dollars spent will be at the banks in the end, according to one study), while pretending to give it to their constituency (students, overwhelmingly democrat), in a way that will drive a wedge between them and republicans for decades ... So of course they did this ! I mean, sure, it will throw a decent number of those people into destitution constantly for decades, but it's not like that's going to make those guys change their vote. Oh, mor... ? M-what ? Oh, morality ? I donate extensively to my self-owned charities ! I mean, let's give credit where credit is due here. Democrat party : I bow to your absolute genius.
- Simulacra 8y agoThis was discussed in depth in another post a few days ago. This guy also lives in a 5000 square-foot home, and based on a little digging by others, it appears he has more of a spending problem then a debt problem.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- microcolonel 8y agoMy ingenious solution: don't buy so much education, if the loans are too much. You know you shouldn't buy a house, a car, or a business asset which you know you can not afford or leverage to pay for itself, why do you take on debts (and make other decisions around payments) that you know you can not repay? I have to hope that people aren't counting on bailouts, but given the political rhetoric that gets tossed around, it's hard to imagine that doesn't factor in to people's poor decisions.
- benrbray 8y agoI think this is too black and white of a perspective. First off, plenty of people buy cars they can't afford out of necessity. Or, rather, they NEED a car for work and buy a cheap used car that inevitably needs repairs and sucks up money they need for food, rent, etc. I think attending college is a similar type of decision. We're told over and over that college is the only path to decent life, and in many ways it is. There's very little hope of someone without a degree making more than minimum wage and even less hope of doing meaningful work. If they're already poor, getting a job right out of high school won't pay enough to help improve their quality of life. So they go to college hoping things will be better.
- microcolonel 8y ago> I think attending college is a similar type of decision. We're told over and over that college is the only path to decent life, and in many ways it is. You're also told that Harvey's makes your hamburger a beautiful thing, that smoking Marlboros will make you a man's man, that Tesla will deliver the Model 3 at the promised rate, and that you can keep your doctor. If your contention is that people should not be judged for believing what they are told, then I guess you could make that case. I certainly don't agree. > There's very little hope of someone without a degree making more than minimum wage and even less hope of doing meaningful work. I think there is something wrong with this, I have had 10th+ percentile income since I was 17, and I never attended high school. I get the impression that a number of people who have gone to college may have spent money and time better on books and begging for an internship. The people who benefit from college don't need assistance paying it off. I'm aware I lost something by not going to college, but I figure it can't be too bad, if I can't really tell what that something is.
- sschueller 8y agoNext congress will pass a law forcing these debts to be transfered onto your children.
- cbanek 8y ago> Any balance remaining after 25 years is forgiven, effectively covered by taxpayers. The forgiven amount is then taxed as ordinary income. -WSJ It's going to be a pretty penny still to pay the federal taxes on a $2m+ loan (like, $400k, and that's not a loan, that's IRS money at that point).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- himom 8y agoI worked at a university that frittered away $150 million on a software rollout that was eaten by consultants and ultimately failed in every regard. Also, the same university is on a building binge, replacing donated buildings barely 10 years old with shiny new ones. Given the cost of CIP projects, that’s why tuition is so expensive... the universities playing “Keeping Up With the Yales” by pouring money into construction. If it weren’t for building binging, tuition would be much saner and in the realm of affordable for the taxpayer to prevent stalling the economic futures of students to be chained in debt with a degree that doesn’t help them enough to escape white-collar poverty.