26 ms·
EU censorship machines and link tax laws are nearing the finish line
- pjc50 8y agoCan we direct some of the GDPR ire at this please, because this is (a) genuinely bad for everyone except a few legacy publishers and (b) not yet finalised?
- scribu 8y agoPlaying devil’s advocate: What if the link tax will replace advertising as the main source or revenue for publishers? Wouldn’t that be a Good Thing (TM)?
- greglindahl 8y agoComing up next: European publishers discover that search engines preferentially link non-European publishers due to the link tax. Coming up after that: More unexpected effects.
- Silhouette 8y agoComing up after that: More unexpected effects. Which presumably most of us in Europe won't hear about, if all the sites with a link/discussion format like HN and Reddit will be faced with paying huge fees or stopping/geoblocking/etc...
- joejerryronnie 8y agoDoes anyone know if the transatlantic telegraph cables are still operational? We'll do our best to keep you in the loop!
- IanCal 8y agoI'm not sure why HN would be affected, there's no link previews or anything pulled from the article. Links themselves do not seem to be a problem if I understand right: > This protection does not extend to acts of hyperlinking which do not constitute communication to the public. section 33, page 19. http://ec.europa.eu/transparency/regdoc/rep/1/2016/EN/1-2016-593-EN-F1-1.PDF http://ec.europa.eu/transparency/regdoc/rep/1/2016/EN/1-2016...
- Silhouette 8y agoI'm not sure why HN would be affected It's not the link's address that is the problem under the questionable proposals, but rather the text that describes it. HN's normal custom is to use the original title/headline for that description, and HN's own mods actively change submissions that don't follow that policy. It looks like that could easily get them caught in the same trap as a site like Google that offers accompanying snippets. Maybe YC would be willing to accept the risk of publishers trying to extract money from them, just as running HN itself is a favour to the community, but I see no good reason they should be expected to put up with that risk and any actual costs incurred just to continue providing a useful service that they already generously provide for free.
- yuhong 8y agoYea, I don't like the current debt-based economy in the first place that treats people as consumers to be extracted from.
- anoncow 8y agoGDPR and the proposed copyright laws will break the internet irrecoverably. The start-up industry will be a long forgotten dream. These old b@$%%%s will turn the internet into cable television. Scumbags would want to go back to a world of slavery, colonisation and wealth locked up as gold in personal treasuries. I hope all the other countries follow suit and then the only thing we will be able to aim for is a job in these government bodies or the few surviving monopolies. Sorry for my language.
- downandout 8y agoGDPR and the proposed copyright laws will break the internet irrecoverably. Yeah but there's nothing wrong with that per se. It's the EU's choice to return to the stone age. There are Amish communities in the US where nobody has computers and their primary form of transportation is horses and buggies [1]. The rest of the world will simply move on, and like Amish communities, those in the EU that wish to participate in modern society can simply move. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amish
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoI'd argue the EU is "moving fast and breaking things" because the industry was incapable of self-regulating.
- donatj 8y agoI think it's self regulating just fine. It's met the needs and desires of the majority. I just think Privacy advocates are a very vocal very small minority whom found themselves in power in Europe. Basically everyone save a select few would rather have the convenience Facebook has brought over the privacy GDPR tries to bring. I assure you the majority would rather have free services than self righteous lack there of. The majority do not want nor really care about Privacy to such an extent. The majority do not see themselves as easily manipulated, and do not see the harm. I happen to agree and think the EU has killed the economy in the name of something no one really wants.
- fairpx 8y agoIt would be great if all these new regulations only applied to companies of X size. Scrappy startups with no access to good lawyers and understanding of these regulations are more likely to suffer vs the big guys who were the cause of all of these changes in the first place.
- greglindahl 8y agoI'm an advisor to several startup European search engines which are likely to be annihilated by the combination of these changes and the GDPR.
- pjc50 8y agoWho would start a new search engine in this day and age? You'd need some really unique features which Google can't duplicate, and the only one which seems to have made it is DDG with their privacy promise.
- Cyph0n 8y agoThat doesn't make it alright for the EU to kill new entrants through regulation...
- fairpx 8y agoJust as a side note: not every search engine is a direct competitor to Google. You can have vertical search engines serving a specific purpose. These can do very well by executing on a narrow use case. Something the Googles can’t do.
- merinowool 8y agoSo that the access to information is more democratic? What stops Google from suppressing certain information at the request of bureaucrats or corporations? When you have a choice you are more likely to see information from different sides. Of course most people won't bother, but suppressing choice can only end up sad.
- 8y ago
- nickpp 8y agoAs public regulators all over the world are busy pushing regulations (what else? that is their sole job after all) maybe it is time to stop and ask: are we losing more than we are gaining? Everything has a price and free markets are the only mechanism for determining that price. But regulations overwrite that price with one determined by politics and lobby and populism. This new price is paid by all no matter if we want to or not. So the question is: is it worth it? I make this kind of cost analysis in my life every day. But is it anybody doing them at the society level? As the costs of regulations add up so does the cost of the product. Can, we, as a society, afford it? Or maybe we are pawning our future to pay for these imposed costs today?
- merinowool 8y agoIt is worth it for those that do it. This is thousands of hours of paid meetings, presentations, lunches, conferences. They just get themselves busy and collect tax payers hard earned money. If it is good for the society? Bureaucrats don't care, as they are winning.
- bitL 8y agoImagine most of those involved in regulations are barely able to use Word/Excel, yet are "elected" to decide the fate of technology.
- rnnr 8y agoAnd who is going to stop them, when even multi-million companies just shallow the pill(like GDPR) and even try to market it positively that they are gonna adopt it first.
- lucio 8y ago>multi-million companies just shallow the pill They're very happy. It's not a "pill" to swallow, it's a tool to squash any small competitor.
- c3o 8y agoBig business massively lobbied against the GDPR. One big reason it ended up so strict is because the final negotiations happened to coincide with the Snowden revelations, giving cover for politicians to resist the lobbying.
- jsnell 8y agoI had not realized that this insane bit with an inalienable right to monetary remuneration had made it to the drafts. We already know from the past cases that if given the choices between paying for the privilege of linking vs. not linking at all, search engines and social networks will do the latter. The economic value of e.g. news searches must be miniscule. But maybe there is a little bit of value there, even if not a ton. So one can maybe imagine a Google or a Facebook signing a deal with a couple of publishers per country. It's just that the marginal utility of additional publications will go down very quickly. Most publications will a) not get paid for the links, since they're not linked to b) not get any traffic, and lose a large chunk of their ad revenue as well. It absolutely boggles the mind that anyone would think this is a good idea. Unless they're a top 2 media conglomerate of an European country, and would like for all their weaker competitors to be killed off.
- merinowool 8y agoThis makes perfect sense for socialist regime - keep few large outlets that you can control easily. It really boggles my mind that people believe EU has any good intentions. They aim for total control of every aspect of ones live.
- mrlatinos 8y agoBingo.
- joejerryronnie 8y agoAt least China is upfront and honest about their push toward techno-totalitarianism.
- whataretensors 8y agoI don't necessarily agree but the immediate downvotes anyone receives for questioning the EU's pure intentions is interesting. People are either extremely trusting of huge global governments or we're being brigaded.
- deleted 8y ago
- bo1024 8y agoIgnoring what the laws are actually about, GDPR and copyright are similar in this: one entity gets legal control over others' use of certain information. But while the privacy law is aimed at allowing individuals to assert some control over companies, the expansion of copyright is used by companies to assert control over individuals.
- nickpp 8y agoDon't forget that companies are made of people and an individual is a company of 1. GDPR is pretty much DRM for an individual's personal data.
- beevai142 8y ago> Don't forget that companies are made of people This is totally irrelevant, because the governance model of a a company is a limited dictatorship, and not all those people are equal. A company is only the people at its top, the rest are chattel. A company is also not made of people in the legal sense, it is a separate entity.
- nickpp 8y agoThat is BS. You are talking about businesses as if all you know about them is from Hollywood movies. I suggest you go ahead and build a company, any company. You may learn how things really work, not the evil caricature you have in your mind. It's not that hard and it’s quite rewarding.
- zaarn 8y agoWell, to be technical, in Europe a company does not enjoy the same rights and privileges as an actual person (natural vs legal person). So legal persons are made of natural people and natural people are a legal person of 1 but also enjoy a lot more rights and privileges than legal persons.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Kenji 8y agoThe EU should stop fucking with the internet. It worked great in the 90's where they weren't involved at all whatsoever.
- exembly 8y ago[deleted]
- Silhouette 8y agoThis seems a highly unusual approach. Does it achieve anything at all? At least in the UK, our convention is normally that representatives only deal with their own constituents, and we have a set of MEPs for each geographical region. If you're in the UK, you can identify and contact yours via WriteToThem: https://www.writetothem.com/ https://www.writetothem.com/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bitL 8y agoSeems like the past 15 years were once-in-history-and-never-again blip where we had some illusion of building a better society. Oh well, my face goes back under the stamping boot...
- pacnard 8y agoProbably there have been some other times like this, but we forgot them
- carapace 8y agoThe Sixties!?
- walterbell 8y agoWe need a list. Early days of amateur radio? Print?
- bitL 8y agoMaybe. But those required quite a lot of money or rare resources, so while they were supporting emerging classes that could afford it, only Internet allowed almost everyone to have a voice (well, OK, still most of the Earth's population has problems surviving, so we aren't there yet).
- arpa 8y agoEverything changes yet remains the same. The Man and the people are always in balance. Have hope. We shall prevail.
- whatshisface 8y agoCould websites exempt themselves from link tax renumeration in an automatic way with something like a robots.txt?
- pacnard 8y agoAnd that kids is why you don't give powers to the State
- clishem 8y agoThis is blatant fear mongering. Furthermore, calling these directives 'link tax laws' is simply a cheap frame. You can link to articles freely. Including a snippet that has 'no independent economic significance' is allowed. Agreed, that is not very precise. But is that really such a big deal? Sure, you might get sued. That's life. You have to trust the reasonableness of the courts. And don't worry, they won't go after you. The publishers will go after some big fish such as Telegram (which blatantly copies entire articles and strips it of everything but the article). Case law / Jurisprudence / Jurisprudentie / Fallrecht will develop around this issue and everyone will be happy. And for some, just including a minimal snippet may not be an option. They'll have to pay. That's also life. Journalists and publishers need to eat too. Their work is too important to be allowed to wither.
- mc32 8y agoShe's asking that people read, learn and get involved in the process early in order to have some influence, so as not to be caught off-guard once these laws are enacted because once enacted, it'd be hard to have change happen. She's talking to a particular audience and that may not mesh with what all publishers in general want.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Bizarro 8y agoSure, you might get sued. That's life. You have to trust the reasonableness of the courts. And don't worry, they won't go after you. That line of reasoning is wrong on so many levels it's comical. And unfortunately, we keep on seeing this on the GDPR debate too.
- clishem 8y agoIf you don't abide by the law, you may get sued. If you do abide by the law, you may still get sued. There's no reasoning in there, it's a simple fact. 'My startup may get sued' is not a good argument against a law.
- pdkl95 8y agoFrom the associated article about this supposed "link tax". > Anyone using snippets of journalistic online content must first get a license from the publisher. Re-publishing a portion of a published work is not a "link". A link is only a reference (address) where something (e.g. a published work) may be found, which not part of the work itself. Displaying a portion of work might be an allowed "fair use"? (I only know US copyright law; the EU may have very different laws about when it is "fair" to bypass copyr8ight and use part of a work) However, it is important to remember that (at least in US-like jurisdiction) that the amount of work included in a snippet is one of several features used when judging if a use is "fair". Another important question is if the use affects the market for the original work. An academic paper that quotes snippets from an article is probably fair (nobody would read the paper as a substitute for reading the original article), while an aggregator using the same snippets may not be a fair use if people are reading the aggregator to read the article instead of continuing to the original publisher. In general, each case probably requires judge to rule if a specific use is "fair". > Because readers need to know what a link leads to before clicking, sites almost always include a snippet of the linked-to content as part of a link. This is deliberately attempting to conflate re-publication with a hyperlink. Link previews are not needed, are not used for the vast majority of links on the web. Claiming that previews are "almost always" included is patently a lie. Should it be necessary, this kind of feature is better implemented in the user agent. I'm fairly certain I saw link prefetch+preview extensions for Firefox ~10 years ago. > Small publishers disadvantaged: Aggregators create a level playing field for independent publishers with less brand recognition to reach audiences. Did Google or FB write this doublespeak? Allowing aggregators to republish copyright protected works benefits the big players by allowing them to steal existing markets.
- nitwit005 8y agoYou're treating this as a conventional copyright issue, but I'm not sure that's correct. To quote the EFF's summary: > This isn't a copyright, because the link tax is paid to the publisher rather than the author, and because it is payable even if the portion of the news article taken isn't copyright-protected, falls within a copyright exception, or is freely licensed. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/02/how-have-europes-upload-filtering-and-link-tax-plans-changed https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/02/how-have-europes-uploa...
- microcolonel 8y agoWhat a disaster that only the parties which are steadily alienating voters have a stance against enabling general censorship of publishing.
- microcolonel 8y agoDoes anyone know of a good way to comprehensively (and believably, in the eyes of the court) block the EU from your web services? It's getting out of hand, and I'd like to be able to avoid this cost in some cases.
- aianus 8y agohttps://apility.io/2018/05/25/gdpr-lazy-block-european-users-cloudflare-workers/ https://apility.io/2018/05/25/gdpr-lazy-block-european-users...
- fanzhang 8y agoI hope this dies just like many laws the US tries to pass on regulating the Internet in a way that promotes special interests versus that of the public good. But as a thought experiment, if you were a lawyer tasked to argue this was publicly good, what could you even say? Content creators deserve money for creating content. Aggregators are stealing some of that value and that's inefficient but currently unenforceable? .... I just can't even think of another reason. Maybe this is protectionism (both nationally and of existing enterprises). French publications are upset they can't get more of the pie from Google who is US based. EU publications in general are upset that aggregation theory ( https://stratechery.com/2015/aggregation-theory/ https://stratechery.com/2015/aggregation-theory/ ) has taken hold and distributors like publishers are getting wiped out. This will surely accelerate a trend that Google is already doing without monetary incentive: creating their own content and putting in on top.
- kd5bjo 8y ago> But as a thought experiment, if you were a lawyer tasked to argue this was publicly good, what could you even say? The primary economic value of many news articles is provided by timeliness and one or two key facts, even if they appear in a longer piece. By including a copy of those facts adjacent to the article link, the linking party is taking that value without actually doing the work of journalism. Copyright is a mechanism that is already in place to deal with undesirable distribution of an author's work, so the simple solution is to extend its protection to even tiny parts of journalistic writing.
- merinowool 8y ago> what could you even say? That it is just a fact of life. Every creation is based directly or indirectly on past creations, then how about looking after the rights of entities that contributed to the content created? Should content creators share their revenue? That places them in privileged position. What about profit content creators get from exposure given by aggregators? Should they share too? And so on. This is just terribly stupid.
- shiado 8y agoIf the sites don't want the traffic from links that drive their revenue then why don't they identify the servers which are prefetching content and IP ban them and file abuse complaints. They probably have very identifiable User-Agent strings. Also this link tax reminds me that I think browser vendors should provide better privacy options for removing the referer header from link requests to prevent tracking.
- reaperducer 8y ago> They probably have very identifiable User-Agent strings Yes. Because bots never change or spoof their user agents.
- beagle3 8y ago"link tax" is aimed at mature aggregators and search engines, someone you can actually sue. GoogleBot, BingBot and friends do not change or spoof their user agents.
- reaperducer 8y agoIf you think being a large company means its user agent doesn't change, you haven't been monitoring user agents very long. The fact that you choose to use Bing as an example proves my point. Bing is only eight years old. Before that it identified itself as msnbot.
- beagle3 8y agoWow. Once in 8 years. Quite a point you have there /s Every single respectable search engines (which can be targets of lawsuits, and are thus targeted by this law) has proper identification. If a content owner worries so much that their data might be available somewhere (search engine, aggregator, ...) they did not approve, they should whitelist rather than blacklist. They can (and should) also whitelist/blacklist at the referrer level. But a law actually lets them have it both ways; They only sue those that they dislike, after the fact, letting others keep linking. At least that's the thinking - in practice, if such a law is written (which has happened before), Google, Facebook and others will drop those sources that don't give the info for free, those sources will see their numbers drop 90% over a month, and come back begging to be reindexed. I find it quite infuriating that laws are being put into place for problems which already have a very simple and precise technical solution.
- Improvotter 8y agoYay Belgium makes it better! Go Belgium!
- HappyDreamer 8y agoWhat if Google reacts by showing ads, as the first 20 search results, instead of normal search hits? (in Europe.) If "normal" search results, become expensive to Google.
- toyg 8y agoThis is why EUParliament exists: to keep national elites, embodied in the Council and Commission, in check. This is one of those instances where MEPs can shine by holding the line against idiotic regulation. Call your MEPs and let them know this is a chance for them to get visibility by doing The Right Thing, voting down this crap. And if they reply with boilerplate, make sure you vote a different party next time - the proportional nature of EU elections makes it easy for smaller parties to benefit from small swings in numbers.
- tannhaeuser 8y agoTLDR: Excuse me, but MEP Julia Reda always uses strong languages and makes a civil liberties drama from everything (it's her job after all). AFAICT, the rights and interest at stake are 1. the commercial and moral rights of content creators (well not the content creators themselves but their original publishers) 2. the rights of providers of search engines (Google) to scrape content from news publishers to the extent that users aren't visiting the news site, but get everything from the SERP page already; it's a similar problem with Wikipedia articles presented in full or large parts on Google's SERP 3. and, unrelated but combined into the same directive, a new law that would require platforms to make an effort to detect "copyrighted" (if there were such a thing in EU law) content Maybe there's also a law involved that would make linking to "illegally provided", "copyrighted" content unlawful. The major pros/cons discussed are - search engines argueing that they are executing fair use rights, and are helping to discover content which news publishers were happy with in the past and want them to continue to do - restricting fair use rights creating a case for restrictions of other fair use such as academic or journalistic quotation - content scanning only feasible for large platforms, thereby only helping defacto monopolies - the two issues not belonging into the same law. Please downvote or criticize if you have an issue with this synopsis.
- tannhaeuser 8y agoTo be clear, I don't have an opinion on these issues yet. I respect commercial interests of content producers. For me, making everything free for all just because it's technically feasible/trivial isn't a solution and will just result in pushing more power to platforms. OTOH, I believe the material issue with news scraping could be very easily and practically solved by - using RSS or other syndication format rather than full-page scraping, or using HTML metadata to limit what search engines may display - using HTML metadata, deep linking/embedding or giving credit (like is done for photo credits) for citing larger excerpts My gut reaction to implementing user content scanning, or any other technical details is that something like that has no place in this law. But maybe I'm misunderstanding the intent of the law, in that it's a lesser evil compared to making platforms liable for damages by uploaded "copyrighted" user content.
- tannhaeuser 8y ago
- techsin101 8y agoHere we go... Internet will soon be completely segerated by regions, clutched by regulations and policies, and under few. Soon to make a blog you'd need to hire 30 developers and 40 lawyers to cover specific legal issues of China, Russia, USA, EU, India, UAE, and so on. You'd have to apply for University Grant to open a blog on diy cleaning.
- lucio 8y agoI believe country names in the article should be replacex by "x bureaucrats", e.g. * Germany is standing in the way of an agreement over what the “link tax” should cover (see above). * Austria and Italy want to extend the duration of the “link tax”. Should be: * Germany bureaucrats are standing in the way of an agreement over what the “link tax” should cover (see above). * Austria and Italy bureaucrats want to extend the duration of the “link tax”.
- Keverw 8y agoSo if you link to a website, you are suppose to pay the website you linked to money? That is insane... I hope this doesn't passes or I'm misunderstanding somthing. Links pointing to something is helpful for search engine ranking, plus every link is free traffic basically... Linking seems like a good thing and beneficial to the website and other parties too. I'm sure someone who's article gets on the front page of HN would most likely to happy, but I guess HN would have to pay every website some money then?
- jsnell 8y agoNot websites in general, just press publications.
- IanCal 8y agoNot that either, you need to be pulling something from the article and republishing it.
- deadlocked 8y agoFrom what I understand, 'link' is a misnomer; linking to an article is fine and always will be. If you do a search on Google for, to use a topical example, the repeal of the 8th amendment to Ireland's constitution, the results are likely to include links to news and Wikipedia articles, as well as excerpts from those articles. This is what the directive is intended to address, the principle being that if the pertinent information is included in the excerpts on the search-engine results page, why would I bother following the link to read the full article?
- Reason077 8y agoThese kinds of laws are symptomatic of the democratic deficit that exists in the EU. These days, the commission can pretty much push through any crazy law it likes. Because no-one is paying any attention.
- kuschku 8y agoAnd the worst part is, ALL the heads of states of EU nations are in support of this law. The council approves of it. This means that even if you’d end the EU, these same people would still be able to pass the law.
- Reason077 8y agoThe EU commission can get away with things that individual nations can not, because they are not subject to the same level of public scrutiny. If a controversial law is proposed in a national parliament, then it becomes big news. A politician pushing an unpopular agenda would eventually find him/herself voted out. But average people don't usually hear about laws the EU is creating until they're implemented. Hardly anyone had heard of the GDPR until it was too late. And the whole legislative process of the commission is opaque: you can't tell who in your government was responsible for supporting a particular position.
- kuschku 8y agoYeah, that’s the one big issue with the EU - the fourth power, the media, is missing. There’s no discussion, no involvement of the public, neither the good nor bad is shown when it happens. Instead, 4 years later, the same national politicians that wrote the law blame it on the "undemocratic" EU.
- c3o 8y agoCouncil (assembling the member state governments) is opaque, but the directly elected European Parliament is quite transparent – more so than most national ones. Both have to agree to any Commission proposal, so theoretically being able to follow and influence one gives us, the public, veto power no matter the failings of the other. You're absolutely right about the media.
- cJ0th 8y agoIs there anything a simple citizen can do to prevent these ideas from becoming laws?
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoSo how would this affect Hacker News?
- xstartup 8y agoHaving already exposed EU's wealth preservation strategy here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17163772 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17163772 Imperialistic ambitions are back, this time no place to hide. I saw this coming! EU wants to destroy American and rising nation business.
- MrEldritch 8y agoAt this point, I'm just exhausted. I'm tired of fighting this battle that we lose every single step of the way. I kind of just want privacy, expression, user safety, and free speech on the web to be dead already so we can skip the inevitable grinding progression of crushing defeats as it dies bit after bit as we expend massive amounts of effort, will, emotion, and stress campaigning against the latest in a long line of stupid ideas only to see the ratchet progress one tooth further. The Web is on life support. It's not going to survive. I just wish we could pull the plug already instead of watching it die in slow motion like this.
- arpa 8y agoThe fight is far from over. We still have crypto. If that is outlawed, we'll have steganography. When that's outlawed, well, we'll still have sneakers. Iron curtain and Stalins' organs failed. Stasi failed. War on drugs is failing. We, the people, shall prevail. Have hope, brother.
- MrEldritch 8y agoA niche, encrypted deep-web for cypherpunks to serve as a channel for La Resistance(tm) would be a web that had already lost any actual reason to use it. I use the Web to talk to people, learn things, and explore cool stuff other people made. If those other people aren't using the niche crypto/stegano services, then what am I going to use them for? Yes, there will always be some way to have privacy online, if you're beardy enough and avoid using most popular consumer technology in favor of homegrown hackerly solutions. But a Web without the network effect is a Web that's no good at all for almost all the reasons I care. It'll be good for dissension, semi-legal activity, dubious porn, safety ... there's plenty of times that people need true privacy and security. But when your network's only good for that, then it'll still be dead in all the other ways that made the Internet so amazing.
- arpa 8y agoPeople made copies of "forbidden" material on x-ray photos. There was samisdat (underground press). There were anticommunist anecdotes told at night in soviet kitchens. And somehow these people managed to do that without explicit permission of their government, and even under the proespect of severe punishment: incarceration, torture, labor camps and death penalty in extreme cases. Thing is, it was worth it for people who did that. Now, ask yourself: is the web as important to you that you would start using deep web, steganographics, etc., or are you just a consumer who just needs mass production? Because facebook and google and their services are here to stay: they're bigger than china and you need not worry about them; me - over the years of them fighting the web it has lost only one thing: its' individual freedom. Thing that you call the network effect, i call the tvisation of the web: there are no blogs, no self-hosted material, no homepages, only content "channels" owned by the select few: facebook and google. It has, for me, no appeal of the early, wondrous thing, only ad-riddled cancer. And so, my friend, the web is already dead in that aense, but it will continue evolving, and what i hope for is that some iteration of niche cyberpunk web will bring back the wondrous thing that was before.
- fnord123 8y agoGDPR is great. Link Tax is shit. The EU is perfectly balanced. As it should be.