9 ms·
Tesla that crashed in Autopilot mode sped up before hitting truck: police
- tobyhinloopen 8y agoTesla has no autopilot or self driving capabilities. It is just something called Adaptive Cruise Control and Lane Assist in other vehicles with some minor additions. Tesla’s marketing gives the impression that it is much more, but it isn’t.
- nicky0 8y agoIf Tesla calls it Autopilot mode, you can hardly blame everyone else doing so.
- michaelmior 8y agoJust because Tesla calls it Autopilot doesn't absolve drivers of responsibility in my mind. Especially since Tesla explicitly says drivers should still be attentive. That said, I agree it's poor marketing.
- RobLach 8y agoAutopilot is not a word made up by marketing though. It’s already defined: https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/automatic_pilot https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/automatic_pilot “A device for keeping an aircraft on a set course without the intervention of the pilot.” If you enable an autopilot, intervention by the pilot is not necessary by definition
- hyperbovine 8y ago“By definition“ you are not driving a car.
- cynix 8y ago> If you enable an autopilot, intervention by the pilot is not necessary by definition Only if you're happy for the aircraft to continue travelling in the same set course. I guess by the same virtue, driver intervention is also not required if you're willing to let the vehicle travel in the same direction and disregard the firetruck ahead... Tesla's Autopilot is perfectly capable of maintaining direction/speed of travel, and it even follows the curves of the road most of the time which is presumably more than an aircraft autopilot system can do. It is the driver who is not willing to disregard the obstacles ahead, the same way presumably aircraft pilots are not willing to disregard obstacles in their course and will take over control of the aircraft if there is one. Nothing wrong with our tendency to avoid obstacles in order to not die, of course, but it's not the autopilot's job since the definition of autopilot is to maintain a set course, as you quoted. You may be confusing it with full self-driving, which doesn't exist yet.
- readams 8y agoAircraft autopilot will happily fly you into a mountain or other aircraft.
- King-Aaron 8y agoI'm glad someone mentioned this. It's frustrating that the general public doesn't understand what the word 'autopilot' means... Otto the automatic pilot from the movie Airplane! isn't what an automatic pilot is. However, since it is commonly misrepresented, they should change the name of Tesla's system.
- Twisell 8y agoWhile true, there is like a lot of redondant auxiliary warning system in a plane that work independently of the autopilot. So if autopilot tried to fly you into a mountain, the humans pilots would have to willingly ignore all the warnings thrown at them (it happened recently, and was qualified as human error). What is terrifying with Tesla autopilot is that there is seemingly not enough auxiliary warning system. With only two of them (hand on wheel or stop, static object detection) you could have avoided almost all Tesla crashes. They putted beta vehicle in hand of customers, that’s a choice, now they have to live with it. Edit: first sentence was misleading
- Sharlin 8y agoGeneral public has little idea of what a plane autopilot can or cannot do. Somewhat ironically, the Tesla Autopilot is quite close to a real plane autopilot in that it’s a rather dumb system that cannot adjust to unexpected events. But Joe R. Driver reads Tesla marketing material and doesn’t realize that, dictionary definition notwithstanding.
- watwut 8y agoSo, now that we pinpointed who is responsible, can we discuss which design leads to many people making deadly errors and which design leads to few people making deadly errors? And how much responsibility the designer when choosing between former and latter?
- rebuilder 8y agoIt seems like deceptive marketing to me. If I sold shoes with proprietary NailStopper soles, with a disclaimer the soles don't actually stop nails and it's up to the user to make sure they don't step on any, would that be cool?
- michaelmior 8y agoI'm not saying the marketing is cool. Although your example is fundamentally different since in the "Autopilot" case, you're not just dealing with your own safety, but the safety of others. (Presumably you're not putting others in danger by wearing NailStopper shoes and continuing to step on nails.)
- rebuilder 8y agoFair enough. I guess this is a case of something lost in translation. To me, bad marketing is when the marketing doesn't help sell the product. Deceptive marketing misleads the consumer as to what they're being enticed to purchase.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kingkongjaffa 8y agoTesla's marketing has directly contributed to a number of deaths now.
- JoshCole 8y agoIt's also directly prevented a number of deaths. The same is true of the consumption of water. However, I can count the number of deaths caused by Tesla on one hand, but I cannot count the number of deaths caused by the consumption of water on one hand [1][2]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_autonomous_car_fatalities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_autonomous_car_fatalit... [2]: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/strange-but-true-drinking-too-much-water-can-kill/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/strange-but-true-... If you really care about road safety? Encourage the use of Uber among the intoxicated. It saves more than a handful of lives in this world in which more than a hundred thousand people die each day.
- perl4ever 8y agoPeople frequently argue that "X hasn't caused very many deaths compared to Y" and thus the dangers of X are insignificant, while ignoring that people are reacting in a frightened way to X because it might scale such that it soon becomes significant.
- JoshCole 8y agoWhat I was hoping to show was that there are things where the property of causing deaths doesn't mean that the thing itself was a bad idea. Water is an example of that. Going without water is fatal. Getting water can be fatal. It would be very easy to write thousands of news articles about water killing people. But its still good that people can drink water. The same is true of these driver-assistance technologies. Without them, people are already crashing and dying all the time. They do this at a greater rate than the rate at which people crash and die in vehicles that have these driver-assistance technologies. So on the whole, its actually better to have people in cars with these driver-assisting technologies, not worse.
- 8y ago
- oldcynic 8y agoPeople are buying, using, and in some cases dying because of the impression they gained from the clearly pitched marketing.
- MikkoFinell 8y agoLets change the marketing, then people won't die from car accidents anymore.
- vntok 8y agoWell they won't die from Tesla car accidents anymore. That's something, right?
- abhiminator 8y agoPrecisely. Although it makes reasonably good cars, Tesla still relies heavily on hype and astro-turfing (mostly on sites where enthusiasts/potential buyers congregate) [0] to get the word out and generate gargantuan amounts of intrigue. Choosing this 'hype-heavy' model of "advertising" can sometimes thrust customers into relying on those hyped-up features way more, thus leading to accidents like the article talks about. I'm saying this with the firm understanding that majority of the responsibility for safety lies at the hands of the driver in command, but letting Tesla's hype driven marketing strategy off the hook would be unfair to the customers. [0] https://www.talkwalker.com/blog/tesla-marketing-strategy-social-ceo https://www.talkwalker.com/blog/tesla-marketing-strategy-soc...
- bjelkeman-again 8y agoAfter talking to quite a few drivers and driving thousands of miles on Auotopilot myself, I don’t think people are confused by the name. It is pretty clear very quickly what the car can or can’t do. I think people are poor at estimating risk and we would have these accident whatever you call these semi-autonomous features. The interesting thing for me is that despite the shortcomings of the current Autopilot, I wouldn’t go back to a car without. It lowers the strain of driving sufficiently to really be worth it. And I am a driver with a hand on the wheel and eyes on the traffic, all the time.
- abalone 8y agoHelp me understand. How does it lower the strain of driving if you have to remain 100% as attentive anyway? Or are you actually less than 100%.
- chrisper 8y agoI don't have a Tesla, but I have a car with ACC. When I activate ACC I do not have to pay 100% attention to the distance between my car and the one in front of me and the speed. The car does all the work for me. I only have to keep steering and make sure that if the car in front of me stops in an emergency way that I start breaking myself because in certain cases it is too late for ACC to notice it. In traffic jams (< 30 km/h) ACC takes away 90% of the work. The difference is that my car got marketed with ACC as a driver assitance and not "self driving autopilot."
- abalone 8y agoI am not talking about ACC. I’m talking about autosteering. But it’s interesting you concede the primary benefit is paying less attention. If you did that in a Tesla you would be violating the TOS and be responsible for resulting accidents. Ergo, what is the TOS-compatible benefit?
- chrisper 8y agoI would rather say, it allows me to pay more attention to other things, like the traffic around me, or doing lane changes etc. But that TOS thing is kind of weird. What is "not paying attention"? Looking at a sign while the car in front of you slams the breaks? Technically you are not paying attention to the car at that moment and breaking the TOS.
- Roritharr 8y agoI'm driving a 2018 VW Tiguan Allspace with ACC, Lane Assist, Side Assist and everything. If that's what Autopilot is, i'm scared. In part I ordered those features because of assessments like yours that this is pretty much Autopilot. It isn't. My car can in theory follow the lane, but only in pretty much ideal conditions and even then it sometimes loses the lane and goes straight ahead, even in turns, possibly plowing into oncoming traffic or off the road. If it follows the lane, it does so very broadly, sometimes with driving actually on or a little over the lane in a turn, screaming at me to take control. This is the best case scenario. I can't imagine Autopilot being this bad when looking at YouTube. Don't get me wrong, I love my car and those systems for what they are, but they couldn't be called Autopilot in anyones wildest dreams.
- chrisper 8y agoI am pretty sure VW is advertising them as driver assits and not as autopilot.
- Roritharr 8y agoYes, VW does so, but multiple people in this Thread say that Teslas Autopilot is ACC + Lane Assist. That's what I'm challenging.
- pavs 8y agoIts neither a driver assist or an autonomous car, it's somewhere in between. Which makes it even worse, because the driver is not aware of the limitation unless it's too late. Ramming into stationary Red Firetruck TWICE is not an edge case.
- 1234 8y ago1234
- bgarbiak 8y agoThe systems in VWs are like that by purpose. Their premium brands do behave better, yet they still not on the level of Tesla's system (I refuse to call it autopilot). Still, no one knows if what Tesla does is indeed that much better, or it just has all the settings set to eleven. Digression: I've seen a direct comparison of all the popular semi-autonomous systems somewhere, but can't find it now. So, take it with a pinch of salt, but from what I recall the only worthy rival to Tesla's system is GM's SuperCruise, and BMW has a somewhat competent lane assist system.
- beenBoutIT 8y agoRedBull got in some trouble for claiming that 'RedBull gives you wings'. Tesla should be in for more trouble than RedBull, considering a number of people have died as a result of their false claims. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/11155731/13m-lawsuit-proves-Red-Bull-doesnt-give-you-wings.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/...
- myaccountforhn 8y agoHuh, I'm a little concerned with how much information they were able to collect and therefore possibly get her to admit she was looking at her phone instead of the road and hands on the wheel. I hope she's got great insurance because that guy who got whiplash is probably going to get a bit of money.
- blockchain-help 8y agoBlockchain Help, since its inception, has been providing cutting-edge technology solutions and in-depth domain expertise in bitcoins, blockchain development, ICO launches and cryptocurrency development. Ably supported by an exceptionally talented and experienced team of technocrats, Blockchain Help is quickly gaining recognition as the one-stop solution to everything related to blockchain and cryptocurrencies. TO KNOW MORE, PLEASE CHECK OUR WEBSITE:- http://www.blockchainhelp.pro http://www.blockchainhelp.pro
- aresant 8y agoI don't get it. "Autopilot" aka adaptive cruise control is going to continue failing since drivers think it's more than that. More people are going to die in spectacular, headlining fashion. Imagine if that was a schoolbus instead of a firetruck. Even Tesla's "non-autopilot" crashes are front page news because it's such a story. Every front page story whittles away a little at the magical Tesla brand. A brand, which in the midst of production issues, capitalization issues, and leadership issues is their major asset that could carry them to the other side. Turn the thing off if hands aren't on the wheel, end of story.
- michaelmior 8y ago> Turn the thing off if hands aren't on the wheel, end of story. I assume you mean that Tesla should do this automatically.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- aylmao 8y ago> "Autopilot" aka adaptive cruise control is going to continue failing since drivers think it's more than that. > Turn the thing off if hands aren't on the wheel, end of story. Spot on. IMO calling this "Autopilot" was a big marketing misstep-- it should've been called "Advanced cruise control" or something along those lines. "Autopilot" yells "this car can drive itself", which is great marketing, but if your consumers have that idea no matter how much you warn them they'll assume it's probably not that dangerous to take their hands off the wheel and leave the car unchecked for a minute.
- pavs 8y ago> Turn the thing off if hands aren't on the wheel, end of story. To make things even worse, there have been several instances (mentioned on Reddit and other forums) where Tesla doesn't register you having your hand on the car. You will actually have to nudge the wheel a bit. This is not universal and can differ from car to car. So just putting your hands on your car might not be good enough.
- foobarge 8y ago
- staunch 8y agoWhy doesn't Tesla have an eye tracking camera that ensures the driver is watching the road? It would cost hundreds of dollars at most. Basic eye tracking is a solved problem and would ensure drivers are actually paying attention.
- ClassyJacket 8y agoThe Model 3 does have a driver-facing camera, but would require a software update to enable eye tracking, assuming the resolution and angle are good enough.
- barbegal 8y agoIt's definitely not a solved problem in the real world. Eye tracking in the lab works great but in the real world there are lots of challenges. Low light levels at night, drivers wearing sunglasses, drivers squinting etc.
- staunch 8y agoThat's solvable: if it can't see your eyes, then you can't use Autopilot. That should still let the majority of people use Autopilot the majority of the time.
- marmshallow 8y agoI want to wear sunglasses.
- blackrock 8y agoI am now starting to fear being in front of a Tesla on the freeway, or on the streets. Why? Because the idiotic driver might not even be paying attention to the road, and is dazing off and looking at the clouds, or his phone, instead of focusing on the car in front of him, or the surrounding traffic around him. These Tesla crashes are not only a danger to the Tesla occupant, but, it is even more dangerous to the victim that the Tesla would hit! Because that victim can now suffer from whiplash, or worse.
- dirktheman 8y agoThe trouble is, I see a lot of drivers that aren't paying attention to the road, who are dazing off, who are looking at their phones/clouds whatever. The majority of them aren't driving Teslas. At least with a Tesla I know there's a backup system (the 'autopilot'). I'm not saying the Autopilot is 100% faultless/reliable. I am sure however that humans have a much higher chance of handling a situation badly than the autopilot, simply because they're human and humans do stupid shit.
- burlesona 8y agoI don’t agree. The machines and humans make different kinds of stupid mistakes.
- blackrock 8y agoLet's take a scenario. This seems to happen all the time on the freeway. You're cruising down the freeway at 75 MPH. All of a sudden, traffic comes to a screeching halt. There are 3 cars in this scenario. The first car is the one that slams on his brakes, and comes to a stop. The second car, cannot stop in time, and he swerves out of the way, and safely gets into the adjacent lane. Close call, but he drives away safely. The third car, is the Tesla, with the driver on Autopilot, and browsing Facebook on his iPhone. So, he is inattentive. The whole sequence plays out in less than 5 seconds. In this scenario, the third car, the Tesla, will not recognize the situation that the second car swerved out of the way. So the Tesla will collide into the first car at high speeds. The velocity of the impact kills all occupants inside the first car, and the third car, the Tesla. So, if both cars are full of occupants, then maybe up to 10 people are now dead. The problem is that the Tesla does not have situational awareness. It cannot read the current road condition. It cannot see through the tinted windows of the 2nd car, to see that the first car has slammed on his brakes. So, the accident severity of the Tesla, is much greater, than compared to a scenario where a human was driving the third car. In this scenario, I think the human might be able to see the situation, and attempt to avoid it. Or to at least mitigate the severity of it. Like, he would slam on his brakes, or steer out of the way, or something. He might still collide with the first car, but probably at a much lower velocity, that all occupants of both cars can still survive. It just seems that the severity of the accident with current robotic cars, just seems greater, than compared to when a human is the driver.
- thelastidiot 8y agoAnother one of those dreaded "autopilot" malfunction reports. When are people going to realize that an 'autopilot' system required to be supervised at all time is not something any non super-human driver is able to override timely.
- yellow_postit 8y agoWhen Tesla stops advertising it as such? Maybe also when the system aggressively disables itself when not under human supervision (hands on wheel)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cameldrv 8y agoTesla "Autopilot" cannot see stationary objects. It has a radar, but it is 1-D and low resolution. It uses this to localize other moving cars. In theory, it could use this to see a highway divider or firetruck it's about to hit, but since it's 1-D that would also mean that it would have to slam on the brakes when it sees an overpass coming up, because it can't tell the difference between an overpass and a highway divider or a firetruck. It can assume that overpasses aren't driving at 60mph, so it will see other cars. The Tesla algorithm is "look for lane markings and try to stay between them, and don't hit any moving vehicles. If there is any stationary object, including another a vehicle in your lane, the "Autopilot" will plow right into it. If they're not explaining this to customers, it's negligent.
- aerovistae 8y agosource?
- deelowe 8y agohttps://www.wired.com/story/tesla-autopilot-why-crash-radar/ https://www.wired.com/story/tesla-autopilot-why-crash-radar/
- erikb 8y agoAlso there was a car between the truck and the Tesla for some time. Since they are not specific about the timing, the car in front might have just avoided the truck which leaves little time for sensors below the lights to even register that there is something else. Does Tesla also have sensors at the top to see two+ cars ahead?
- piva00 8y agoMy gripe with this argument is that even some humans can have a reaction time to at least start braking under these circumstances, I don't mean all drivers but as an example: I raced go-karts (just as an amateur but took some lessons and also some racing classes in cars with 300 hp) and sometimes my reflexes while racing were surprising, even for myself, narrowly avoiding collisions at 100+ km/h in tight circuits. With that said I'd have thought that sensors and computers could be much faster than even my trained reflexes.
- burlesona 8y agoIt seems fairly obvious me that an imperfect autopilot is worse than no autopilot at all, since it trains drivers to “relax” and let the computer drive when some non-trivial percentage of the time the autopilot will get things wrong. It’s unfortunate that there’s no real way for there to be a perfect computer driver, and all the real world training data these things are collecting is needed to ever get close. But if these systems keep making mistakes like this that seem “stupid” to humans, I suspect these things will be banned before long.
- MikkoFinell 8y agoI agree. Moreover, it's obvious to me that an imperfect human pilot is worse than no human pilot at all.
- aviv 8y agoThe use and marketing of the word "Autopilot" will go down in history as one of Tesla's biggest mistakes.
- haser_au 8y ago> The driver of the vehicle, Heather Lommatzsch, 29, told police she thought the vehicle’s automatic emergency braking system would detect traffic and stop before the car hit another vehicle. > Police say car data show Lommatzsch did not touch the steering wheel for 80 seconds before the crash. She told police she was looking at her phone at the time and comparing different routes to her destination. This is not news. This is someone not following the explicit instructions of the manufacturer to maintain control and awareness while driving. They choose to ignore those instructions and it resulting in a crash. Replace "Telsa" with "Audi/VW/Toyota/Holden/Ford/GM using adaptive cruise control", and this doesn't make front page news. aresant's comment below is spot on. "Turn the thing off if hands aren't on the wheel, end of story."
- kevincrane 8y agoAudi/VW/Toyota/Holden/Ford/GM didn't name their feature "autopilot" though.
- mikejb 8y agoAnd don't advertise on tesla.com/autopilot that the feature is capable of driving itself.
- ddoolin 8y agoIn bold letters on the same page: > Please note that Self-Driving functionality is dependent upon extensive software validation and regulatory approval, which may vary widely by jurisdiction. It is not possible to know exactly when each element of the functionality described above will be available, as this is highly dependent on local regulatory approval. Are you suggesting that it's not the people's fault they can't get to the bottom of the marketing page before going out, buying a Tesla, ignoring obvious UI warnings, and driving it without knowing that it currently doesn't full drive itself?
- Jasper_ 8y agoYes, it's not the people's fault, when there's a large video right there showing the car driving itself. The text makes it seem like it's just a "red tape" thing where autopilot is there like in the video but it just needs approval in your jurisdiction. If this marketing came from any other car company, you probably wouldn't be defending it.
- megakid 8y agoAs an autopilot regular, I hate reading stories such as this. Just last night I had a 150 mile drive in non-perfect conditions (light rain and dusk) and had Autopilot (v1 with a single camera) engaged for the vast majority of it. It is probably my favourite feature of my Tesla. It is significantly better than Audi’s lane assist features I have used and genuinely reduces strain on long journeys. I now perform journeys without hesitation (sometimes looking forward to them coupled with a supercharger stop to recharge myself) when before I’d expect to arrive at my destination stressed and exhausted. However, I will admit that to use Autopilot safely and effectively you MUST understand the system’s inputs, what its behaviour is based on those input (and driver controlled variables) and what its limitations are. I am a software developer by trade and whilst I couldn’t hope to replicate the autopilot software stack, I probably could write a detailed pseudo code representation of the systems behaviour (without factoring in sensor failure etc).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- yellow_postit 8y agoHow much do they detail those inputs, variables, and limitations vs you making assumptions about them?
- ahakki 8y agoWasn’t v1 made by mobileye (?) and teslas in house v2 has a much worse rep?
- aylmao 8y agoIt irks me that not only this feature is called Autopilot, but it doesn't even come with a "beta" label. Gmail was in beta for like 5 years. You go to Tesla's website and it greets you with (as of the time this comment was written): "Full Self-Driving Hardware on All Cars" "All Tesla vehicles produced in our factory, including Model 3, have the hardware needed for full self-driving capability at a safety level substantially greater than that of a human driver." Which gives the impression this car can drive better than one can, and gives little indication to the fact the _software_ is in active development even if the hardware for "full self-driving" is already there.
- cheerioty 8y agoHm. Any one hear willing to talk about the fact that the driver didn't had the hands on the wheel for 80 seconds before the crash and got away with "just" a broken foot?
- ddoolin 8y agoI've kept my hands off the wheel for much longer when driving cross-country. I don't see how they're related, though.
- jonhendry18 8y ago"got away with "just" a broken foot?" She's fortunate she didn't plow into the back of a church van full of kids instead of a fire truck. The kids would probably be dead thanks to the high speed impact of a 4,900 pound car.
- siliconunit 8y agoI think a lot of factors could be ironed out by a solid mathematical grasp of the problem, instead of letting customers become guinea pigs or running simulations and then deduce a blanket solution that looks okay in those average cases, a room with a bunch of mathematicians will surely state the problem, limits and solution in a infinitely:) more solid way. I have seen this happening with software countless times, spend the money on a math ph.d and save endless testing time with half guessed solutions where limit cases are ignored...etc.
- whataretensors 8y agoI'm an early adopter but I have no idea why anyone would early adopt self-driving or autopilot features, much less pay for it.
- mannykannot 8y agoTo be fair, the fact that the car increased speed just before the crash is entirely irrelevant here. It is not as if the car was some conscious agent being willfully reckless.
- beenBoutIT 8y agoThe Darwin Awards are going to become a big Tesla advertisement.