4 ms·
" once you accept that humans are fully physical, embodied minds in a sea of whatever chemicals can cross the blood-brain barrier" I'm not disagreeing, but is
by CalRobert 8y ago
" once you accept that humans are fully physical, embodied minds in a sea of whatever chemicals can cross the blood-brain barrier"
I'm not disagreeing, but is this something that everyone reasonable would agree on without any sort of support?
"Humans are part of a society that can harm them without effective means of redress."
Indeed. I am sad every morning I walk my child to creche and her head (in a pram) is at the same height as the exhaust pipes next to her. Yet, there's nothing to be done, apparently.
- Iv 8y ago"I'm not disagreeing, but is this something that everyone reasonable would agree on without any sort of support?" We are lucky then that there is a ton of support to this claim. Some people may argue with the word "fully" but if you replace it by "in big part" I don't think one can disagree with that without throwing a century of medical research out of the window.
- krageon 8y agoThere is no consensus about how consciousness arises from the brain specifically, or how it works. We're pretty sure that if the brain breaks, the expression of consciousness will also break (occasionally in predictable ways). Further than that, you can make no definite statements about it and call yourself scientific. It's still mostly a philosophical problem with no clear solutions.
- CalRobert 8y ago"how consciousness arises from the brain specifically" This seems like the most important question in the universe, and one not nearly studied enough. For instance, the idea that consciousness is a fundamental feature of the universe that is simply manifested in brains sounds very woo - but hasn't been falsified. The question of when an animal goes from "unconscious, animate matter" to "thinking self-aware being" seems unclear as well (and is very relevant to medical ethics w.r.t embryo experimentation, etc.) By comparison to another out-there idea, if we're willing to take the Many-Worlds Interpretation seriously (and enough well-informed scientists do) then I'm not sure it's a _completely_ settled matter that we have a good sense that humans are "fully physical, embodied minds". However, lead is bad for brains. I think we know that much.
- jerf 8y ago"This seems like the most important question in the universe, and one not nearly studied enough." If anything, I think the opposite is true. We study it far more than we actually should in some sense, relative to the tools we have. Bear with me, this is going to seem a strange diversion: One of the biggest problems in particle physics is that the smallest possible tools we can use to examine the universe, like quarks, electrons, photons, etc. are all radically larger than what seems to be the smallest size of the universe itself. Compared to the Planck length, all of those things are enormous. I liken it to trying to determine whether a planet has life on it, when your only tool is the ability to smash other planets into it, and examine the resulting blobs six months later, from a distance so great they're just dots in your telescope. It's really hard to determine how the universe works at such small scales when your smallest tools are orders of magnitude too big. We have the opposite problem with consciousness research. We have tools that can measure a neuron somewhat. Honestly, we're not even all that great at that. (We can measure voltages fairly well, but our visibility into the deep biochemistry is very weak. Honestly even a single neuron is beyond us in some non-trivial ways.) We have some tools that can take extremely broad averages across massive chunks of neurons. Meanwhile, we have every reason to believe that whatever consciousness is, it lies a good ten+ orders of magnitude above that (we can see this from the fact that it seems to require a human brain to be human conscious, and even the animals that appear to possess a lot of it like dolphins and birds still have brains far, far beyond anything we can treat quantitatively). We're ants trying to determine the nature of the entire planet we're sitting on, and the tools we've got to investigate it are that we can move these grains from here to there. Occasionally ants get up on their tiny little soap boxes and declare "Damn it, it just shouldn't be that hard to understand our planet with these tools!" Sometimes they declare "It's obviously just all topsoil!" or other equally silly things. It doesn't particularly help; it just shows the smallness of the ant in question.
- sandworm101 8y agoCareful. Much of the consciousness is more than the brain argument arrises from pro-life religious groups. They argue that brain death, or lack of a physical brain, does not preclude consciousness. This is to support anti-abortion rules and prevent the removal of life support from the brain dead. These arguments are a minefield of religious dogma.
- zepto 8y agoYes! We should only consider ideas that nobody anywhere is misusing.
- krageon 8y agoMaybe where you are, but not where I am from. Here, you are considered a religious extremist if you do not support abortion (and I think that this is the reasonable stance, but that is not relevant right now). I'm thus not very concerned with what secondary agenda you associate this argument, and I will definitely not be careful of having an uncertain stance just because this is the case.
- CalRobert 8y agoHuh, have heard a lot of arguments from pro lifers lately and this wasn't one of them. A discussion of the nature of consciousness and its mechanisms would have been refreshingly elevated, to be honest. Incidentally we're having a vote today on that very topic.
- naasking 8y agoThere's also no real consensus on what differentiates animate from inanimate matter, but vitalism is no longer a viable take on it. Dualistic theories of consciousness will soon follow vitalism into the dust bin of history.
- adrianN 8y agoMaybe we could start with a definition of consciousness that allows us to check whether something is conscious or not.
- BatFastard 8y agoIndeed, any illusion that we are the only conscious beings on this planet is narcissism.
- DmenshunlAnlsis 8y agoA lack of definite knowledge isn’t an excuse to fantasize. Every time people have insisted that the gaps in our knowledge imply gods or ghosts, they’re rudely disabused. Every time we learn more about how things work, it turns out magic isn’t a factor at all. Meanwhile we really desperately want to believe in magic. It’s probsbly a good idea to be skeptical of God of The Gaps arguments that appeal to what we wish were true in the face of what appears to be more likely.
- CalRobert 8y agoI am not trying to appeal to any supernatural explanation. The closest (crude) example I can think of is seeing the effect of a magnet on iron filings for years and then finally determining there's a magnetic field involved. Without study I suppose somebody could conclude that iron filings just really liked magnets and creating interesting formations. I am curious as to the mechanism behind the... subjective experience of being, I guess. Ultimately, I was simply unsure about the assertion that all parties would naturally agree (without support) to "once you accept that humans are fully physical, embodied minds in a sea of whatever chemicals can cross the blood-brain barrier". This raises a number of questions, which other people have raised before (Does consciousness require a wet brain or just the information processing that goes on within (or something else)? is a computer that simulates the processes of a brain conscious? Is a computer that simulates 1% of the processes of a brain conscious? I am conscious now, and if my brain were dissolved in acid I would not be, but what structures and processes must be destroyed or interrupted to bring about that end to consciousness, and is it a discrete or continuous phenomenon? Are computers now conscious but only infinitesimally so? Is there a degree of consciousness in any structure that processes information? How would we even know? What is consciousness?) I would try to elaborate, but really it's better described at the articles (and sources for same) here - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_problem_of_consciousness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_problem_of_consciousness I accept this comment is weak. However, it's not an assertion as to what the nature of consciousness is.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lambda 8y ago> I'm not disagreeing, but is this something that everyone reasonable would agree on without any sort of support? Somehow, the field of psychiatry doesn't seem to actually act on it. Or they do, since they prescribe drugs which are designed to cross the blood-brain barrier, but even when they decide to prescribe drugs, they don't actually do any kind of blood tests to determine which drugs are likely to be effective. They prescribe drugs based on simply you talking about your own symptoms, or observing your symptoms, and then just trying things until they find something that works or that you report works. They don't even seem to use any kind of formal testing of cognitive functionality to determine what effects the drugs are having; they just rely on purely subjective chats with the patient.
- perl4ever 8y agoThis seems consistent with what I know of psychiatry - and to be clear, I am not someone who disputes that psychiatric medications can be helpful. Was anyone down-voting this because they said to themselves "no, that's not how psychiatrists work at all"? To me, believing in the physicality of the mind is the most important qualification a psychiatrist needs. That's not at all consistent with naive behaviorism though.
- lambda 8y agoI think people may have been downvoting me because I misinterpreted the question I was replying to; but I stand by my description of one of the things I find wrong with psychiatry, the lack of much in the way of rigorous objective testing.
- sjg007 8y agoWell electric cars will help in the long term because we can localize the pollution control to the power plants. The UK/Europe really has a problem though with diesel ultra fine particulates and the NOx. You might covering your pram with a rain/wind cover that might help as recommended in: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/mar/09/use-buggy-covers-to-combat-air-pollution-danger-parents-warned https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/mar/09/use-bugg...
- CalRobert 8y agoThanks, might try that. Also have petitioned city councillors for quietways to no avail.