7 ms·
I.R.S. Warns States Not to Circumvent State and Local Tax Cap
- koolba 8y ago> New York recently began allowing taxpayers to convert local property taxes into charitable contributions, which are fully deductible from federal taxes. Other states, like New Jersey and Connecticut, have been moving forward with similar plans to reclassify state taxes as charitable contributions. If they consider their taxes a charitable contribution I should be able to decide to not pay it. I know a lot of charities I’d rather give money to then the government.
- tango24 8y agoWait, property and state taxes are already deductible on federal 1040, right? So why are the states even doing this? The article is paywalled so surely I’m missing some info here.
- DennisP 8y agoFrom the article: > The I.R.S. warning comes in response to states, like New York, that have looked for ways to blunt the impact of a new $10,000 cap on the state and local tax deduction, known as SALT. The cap, which was included in last year’s $1.5 trillion Republican tax overhaul, hit predominantly Democratic, high-tax states hardest since it limits the amount of state and local sales, income and property taxes that residents can deduct from their federal taxes.
- asveikau 8y agoLast year's tax reform put a cap on that, which is highly inconvenient to people living in high tax, high income or high property value states like California, New York, etc.
- evanpw 8y agoThe deduction is capped at $10k starting in 2018.
- Spooky23 8y agoThe tax reform hit many places hard. You can only deduct the first $10,000. Every suburb of NYC has an average property tax of over $10k, plus most people pay state income tax. These people are doubly impacted by the higher standard deduction, which makes it difficult for all but the wealthy to deduct.
- lr4444lr 8y agoNot following your latter point: isn't the flat rate for the higher standard deduction progressive?
- Spooky23 8y agoNot really. It’s subsidizing sparsely populated states that either don’t need to or don’t care to provide the state/local services that populated places need.
- lr4444lr 8y agoWhat does population have anything to do with it? It's based on income. The fact that more densely populated places have higher per capita service costs is the problem.
- bcheung 8y agoNot sure I follow. The wealthier have higher incomes and higher property taxes due to buying more expensive homes. The $10,000 cap hits them even harder.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 8y agoIf you live in New York, New Jersey, California, etc, a large percentage/majority of homeowners are impacted by the $10k cap. But you need to clear $24k in deductions (as a married couple) to even take that deduction. The average homeowner loses, as they can’t cross the threshold, and every marginal state/local tax dollar costs 15-25% more than it did before.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> If they consider their taxes a charitable contribution I should be able to decide to not pay it You still owe regular property taxes, with all the standard penalties for non-payments. What these laws do is give "municipal and county governments and school districts the legal authority to create special charitable accounts" and then let "local governments offer residents who contribute to the new accounts a nearly dollar-for-dollar property-tax credit, effectively turning their property tax bill, at least on paper, into a charitable contribution" [1]. Your contribution to the charitable account is voluntary. Your property-tax obligation is not. [1] http://www.njspotlight.com/stories/18/05/06/new-law-lets-local-governments-turn-property-taxes-into-charitable-contributions/ http://www.njspotlight.com/stories/18/05/06/new-law-lets-loc...
- lotsofpulp 8y agoI would be surprised to see a judge take kindly to that type of nonsense.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> I would be surprised to see a judge take kindly to that type of nonsense We're a nation of laws. Not taking kindly to a case isn't justification for a ruling. The tax law was haphazardly drafted and written specifically to increase wealth transfers from surplus states (e.g. Delaware, Minnesota and New Jersey) to deficit states (e.g. New Mexico, Mississippi and West Virginia) [1]. I see valid arguments for both sides. [1] https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2011/08/01/the-red-and-the-black https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2011/08/01/the-red-...
- dahdum 8y agoThe SALT deduction was a handout to the most affluent and a subsidy to the wealthiest states. It allowed them to increase their state and local taxes at the expense of federal revenue, spreading that burden across the country. The tax plan certainly had flaws, but capping SALT was egalitarian IMO.
- mhneu 8y agohttps://www.yardbarker.com/nba/articles/bill_russell_once_lectured_charles_barkley_about_tax_complaints/s1_127_26113595 https://www.yardbarker.com/nba/articles/bill_russell_once_le... Charles Barkley: "Bill Russell called me one time… He says, “Charles Barkley.” I said, “Yes, sir, Mr. Russell.” “You grew up in Alabama. Right?” I said, “Yes, sir.” He says, “Did you go to public school?” I said, “Yes, sir.” He says, “Did the cops ever come to your neighborhood?” I said, “Yes sir.” He said, “Any of the houses ever on fire and the firemen come?” I said, “Yes, sir.” He said, “I don’t want to see your black ass on TV complaining about your taxes anymore.” I says, “What do you mean?” He says, “So now that you got money you don’t want to help other people out, but when you were poor, other people took care of you.” And I says, “You know what, Mr. Russell, you will never hear me complain about my taxes again.” And it was a very interesting lesson for me, because I do think rich people should pay more taxes. I’m blessed to be one of them, and we should pay more in taxes. I learned my lesson. I never complain about taxes. ---------- "I like to pay taxes. With them, I buy civilization" -- Oliver Wendell Holmes
- mindslight 8y agoI doubt those on the receiving end of the bombs share Holmes's sentiment.
- eschevarria 8y agoThat people who complain about taxes get some utility from the government activities funded by these taxes does not imply that they are better off with the combination of the services and the taxes than without. If this argument is meant to show that people should not complain about taxes, then it is invalid.
- anoncoward111 8y agoin another analogy, we should not praise the house robber for re-arranging our funiture after stealing our valuables
- RHSeeger 8y agoI don't have a problem with paying taxes. I have a problem with the government taking the money I pay in taxes and wasting it.
- larkeith 8y ago"...The $10,000 cap was imposed as a way to offset some of the cost of other individual and business tax cuts. The Treasury Department and the I.R.S. are worried that the workarounds could further balloon the cost of the tax cuts, which are projected to add more than $1 trillion to the national debt over a decade." Describing this as likely to 'further balloon' the cost of tax cuts seems inaccurate and misleading - the cost remains precisely the same, it's an attempt by certain high-tax states to avoid a tax increase designed to partially offset the static cost.
- drak0n1c 8y agoAdditionally, the CBO recently recalculated the long-term cost of the tax cuts to be $440 billion due to the changes in economic growth after the tax cuts came into effect. The NYT article is ignoring the more recent $440b April estimate in favor of citing the trillion dollar December estimate. https://www.cbo.gov/publication/53651 https://www.cbo.gov/publication/53651 https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/trump-tax-cuts-revenues-deficits-paying-for-themselves/ https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/trump-tax-cuts...
- selectodude 8y ago"For the 2018–2027 period, CBO now projects a cumulative deficit that is $1.6 trillion larger than the $10.1 trillion that the agency anticipated in June. Projected revenues are lower by $1.0 trillion, and projected outlays are higher by $0.5 trillion." "Laws enacted since June 2017—above all, the three mentioned above—are estimated to make deficits $2.7 trillion larger than previously projected between 2018 and 2027, an effect that results from reducing revenues by $1.7 trillion (or 4 percent) and increasing outlays by $1.0 trillion (or 2 percent). The reduction in projected revenues stems primarily from the lower individual income tax rates that the tax act has put in place for much of the period. Projected outlays are higher mostly because the other two pieces of legislation will increase discretionary spending. Those revenue reductions and spending increases would result in larger deficits and thus in higher interest costs than CBO previously projected." Thanks for the completely unsourced editorial from a really trash biased source, but it definitely requires that you don't read a single word from the CBO report.
- mindslight 8y agoEnough of a push for some states to grow a backbone, stand up for their citizens, and work towards expelling this ever-consuming totalitarian USG? Nah, probably not.
- jkaplowitz 8y agoSome states often stand up for their citizens, and with a Democratic NY governor versus Trump and the GOP, I have zero doubt NY will fight this to the extent the laws and courts allow. Trump is strongly and actively disliked in his home state.
- virmundi 8y agoWe are to pick this as a topic to fight back on? How about fighting back on law requiring people to purchase a product that they don’t want? No, USG says I have to have insurance while I don’t use doctors in network because they are worth less than WebMD. Instead I go to a doctor that I pay $160 out of pocket for a full hour visit that keeps notes on me that help to inform my future care. Fighting what largess the USG wants to afford in deductions is silly. They could say there is 0 deduction for State taxes and be within their rights. NY is sulking because their government has gotten so out of hand that they have to strangle their citizens to avoid total default.
- mindslight 8y agoI share your gripe, but I brought it up around this topic because interest of the states and USG are in a bit of conflict. The local governments know that once people aren't able to deduct as much of their real estate rent, they'll be pushing to get their rent lowered.
- duxup 8y agoAren't networks and medical insurance a problem across the board? I've had that problem on employer provided insurance plenty of times... it's got nothing to do with the federal requirements, it's just how dorked up the medical industry is. I get what your'e saying but the details if what you describe is the a whole healthcare industry issue. Too often I see "OMG THIS IS THEIR FAULT" no it's just how the insurance industry is and nobody has a backbone enough to deal with that tangled mess. This networks and providers have been an issues since before any federal requirement(s).
- gnicholas 8y agoTLDR: the tax reform bill put a cap on deducting state and local taxes, which were previously fully deductible. Now you can only deduct $10k between property tax and state income taxes. Residents of CA, NY, NJ, etc. easily hit these limits, so some of these states are giving residents other ways to effectively pay their state/local taxes while maintaining full deductibility for federal tax purposes. Now the IRS is trying to fight back against these rules. But the IRS will have a difficult time drawing distinctions between the existing allowed deductions and the novel deductions they are trying to exclude. As a (former) tax lawyer, I agree that this is an uphill battle for the IRS. If the states do a good job of creating alternatives to state income taxes, the IRS will have a very tough time defeating them in court. It's interesting to see the Republican administration attempting to close these "loopholes" and heavily-Democrat states arguing in favor of said "loopholes". Quite a role-reversal! Edit: clarified language in last paragraph
- ngoldbaum 8y agoCapping the state and local tax deduction isn’t closing a loophole. It’s punishing blue states for funding social services and state government via state taxes.
- gnicholas 8y agoYou’re right. The “loopholes” that people are discussing are the novel workarounds to get around the cap. When I said “enforce” loopholes I meant they are trying to defeat them.
- MrMorden 8y agoThe "role-reversal" is only surprising if you had believed that the parties have actual principles.
- bcheung 8y agoClassifying local taxes as "charitable contributions"? I'm really on the fence about this. On the one hand, it seems an absurd and grossly inaccurate characterization, borderline lying and definitely tax evasion. On the other hand, there's this: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people." Also, someone needs to tell the IRS that they don't get to dictate Federal law. The legislative branch decides the laws, the judicial branch interprets them. The IRS is neither.
- noobermin 8y agoNot really. The IRS is enacting the law Congress gave them, as it's supposed to. You can disagree with that law (I do) but I don't see them stepping outside their constitutional authority
- bcheung 8y agoIn spirit, yes, but I think this is a matter of debate and ultimately will need to be decided by the tax courts. The states are following the letter of the law but definitely circumventing the spirit of the law. This really comes down to how much leeway the Federal government, more specifically the tax courts, gives the IRS.
- ojbyrne 8y agoAn obvious solution (though not necessarily a good idea) is to raise state corporate taxes to offset the federal cuts and lower state individual rates correspondingly.
- adventured 8y agoIt's wild to watch the Democrats argue in favor of preserving tax advantages for the top income tiers. Ie arguing for regressive tax policies and for preventing taxes from going up to where they should be on high income persons. And not just argue, but invent ridiculous schemes to try to maintain that special tax treatment for well-off people. 88% of the SALT deductions were going to households earning over $100,000. 1% were going to households earning $50,000 or less. The tilt is obvious: this was a tax benefit for better off persons, a way for higher income earners to avoid paying the full high tax rates in states like New York and California. This is an extremely ugly hypocrisy as it pertains to what their platform is supposedly all about. I've yet to see very many prominent people on the left, either politicians or media, call it out. It also defangs the left's ability to pursue Republicans for their favoritism toward high income brackets regarding taxes: they're plainly arguing & working to preserve a tax cut for higher income earners.
- joejerryronnie 8y agoThe SALT cap clearly impacts lower-middle class and middle class home owning residents of California and New York (in addition to higher income earners). This had zero to do with tax reform and was 100% punishment for states that did not vote for Trump.
- chriskanan 8y agoWhy are property taxes in NY state so high? I moved to upstate NY a few years ago for work, and while houses are cheaper than in CA, property taxes are far higher ($20K in property taxes per year for a $500K home). Some people I know are paying even $30-40K in property taxes per year. I was excited about the cheaper home prices in this area, but now that I am finally thinking about buying a home, it is fairly difficult if one includes the property taxes (without taking into consideration deduction schemes).