3 ms·
But conversely, in Norway at least the possibility of being transfered to open prisons like this is a motivation for many prisoners to behave better as well. It
by vidarh 9y ago
But conversely, in Norway at least the possibility of being transfered to open prisons like this is a motivation for many prisoners to behave better as well. It doesn't need to solve the problem alone.
- ams6110 9y agoSo motivation to avoid prison altogether doesn't work (given the need for prisons) but prisoners will be motivated by the possibility of transfer to a better prison? Not sure.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoWhen you're caught you're caught, when you're in you'll want to make your stay as pleasant as possible. Crime reporting and solving rates are relatively low, so most people get away with it [1]; only half the crimes are reported, and of those, less than half again (for violent crimes) or less than a fifth (for property theft) are solved. Statistically speaking you have less than 10% chance of getting arrested, and depending on the crime, even less chance of getting convicted. So yeah, your odds of not going to jail when committing a crime are pretty good. [1]: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/03/01/most-violent-and-property-crimes-in-the-u-s-go-unsolved/ http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/03/01/most-violent...
- vidarh 9y agoThat some people commit crimes despite the risk of punishment does not mean the existence of punishment has no deterrent effect at all. And nowhere did I suggest that all prisoners will be motivated to do what is needed to get into these open prisons. It's not necessary either (though desirable): every prisoner who does behave better to earn better conditions free up resources to deal with those who don't. The more open prisons in Norway often have waiting lists of prisoners applying for transfers, and every indication I'm aware of is that prisoners often put in a lot of effort to qualify.
- SlowRobotAhead 9y agoThe population of Norway is about 50% that of Ohio USA in over 2x the area (5 million people). About 2.5% the population of Brazil. It’s a high cost of living nation with very limited poverty. I don’t think you should use it in ANY comparison to Brazil.
- krageon 9y agoTheir argument was about incentives, not about poverty. I don't understand the relation between your argument and theirs at all.
- derangedHorse 9y agoMaybe they were trying to say that the need for these incentives might be moot. With such a great disparity in wealth, I’m sure their prison systems are probably still better than any alternative prison in Brazil.
- paulojean 9y agoEven if you think about this motivation, it does not work where the priosonal system has corruption and organize crime. In those case, people who are in the organization that "owns" the place, can be forced to have bad reviews/reject the transfer when offered.