13 ms·
I'd ask a slightly different question: why is so much of our economic policy centered around new and higher paying jobs in a certain area, in disconnect with th
by majormajor 8y ago
I'd ask a slightly different question: why is so much of our economic policy centered around new and higher paying jobs in a certain area, in disconnect with the current residents preferences for housing policy? It seems like these things are controlled by very different interests that end up fighting in ways that treat the non-high-income/wealthy existing residents as collateral damage.
We want housing to be more affordable in LA, [a different but still local] we also want Amazon to come to town and bring in a bunch of new workers from out of town. Those two goals seems hard to reconcile.
- busterarm 8y agoI'm glad you are considering this and get it.
- taurath 8y agoEconomic growth without a civic plan creates huge bubbles. The second growth slows in Seattle I can’t help but think the market will be flooded with units from people wanting to finally get out at the peak.
- closeparen 8y agoYou say this like it’s a drawback. “Flooded with units” would be amazing and it’s exactly the condition YIMBYs are trying to engineer, because being “flooded with units” (relative to current population) is affordability.
- taurath 8y agoI did not mean to imply that! I’d love it in fact.
- Spooky23 8y agoOr the hood. I remember driving through the Bronx with my dad in the 80s when he worked there. It looked like a war zone. Bubbles tend to pop, and bankrupt buildings get boarded up, not cheaper.
- pcwalton 8y agoIf that were true, downtown Detroit would still be as expensive as it was during the American auto boom.
- Spooky23 8y agoDetroit is a failed city. Half the city was abandoned and much of it burnt to a crisp.
- closeparen 8y agoAnd then get picked up cheap and renovated by the young in the next cycle amid condemnation of the tragic gentrification destroying a working-class haven.
- BurningFrog 8y agoThat was also a time of insane crime rates in NYC. People left to survive. This discussion reminds me of people who dare not go to the gym because they're afraid of getting unsightly muscles. We're so very far from what you fear!
- Spooky23 8y agoEasy. Real estate people print money in these situations, and they fund local political races.
- pcwalton 8y ago"Real estate people" have virtually zero political power in the San Francisco Bay Area. Nobody has sympathy for them, not even the nonprofit ones. (Go look at how the anti-development left pillories Mercy Housing, of all organizations, in SF for daring to impose reasonable means testing at Midtown.) Have you looked at what it takes to make housing pencil out in the city? Developers are not "printing money". Construction costs are incredibly high, especially with inclusionary zoning.
- Spooky23 8y agohttps://www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/Powerful-interest-groups-funding-Wiener-Kim-state-10130727.php#photo-11584301 https://www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/Powerful-intere... I don’t live in SFO, but real estate and local politics are like white on rice. Developers are just one variant of real estate industry player. It’s often an old money game.
- jpao79 8y agoThe challenge is 'we' is not a homogenous group within a city such as LA. In fact they are very much heterogenous groups lumped together. We want affordable housing = existing residents who want to rent their affordable apartments or continue to own their single family house without additional traffic/school overcrowding and their network of friends to have that opportunity too, politicians who want to represent these folks We want tech jobs, more office space, more apartments = real estate developers, young tech professionals who want job options, incoming residents who aren't aware of how uncrowded these neighborhoods used to be, politicians who want to represent these folks
- majormajor 8y agoSo is there a way we can have those two sides hash things out in a more controlled manner? As well as the people not represented by either group? Right now we get the jobs, and we get the neighborhood protections and development restrictions, and in some ways everybody else loses. Cities that can grow outwards, like Houston or Dallas, can punt on this problem for a lot longer than LA or SF or NY can, but I'm very interested in seeing what that looks like long-term. Maybe Dallas hits a continuing density-vs-sprawl equilibrium that results in mostly-reasonable prices w/ mostly-reasonable commute lengths (people seem pretty tolerant up to 45-min one direction, IME) just over a wider and wider footprint without ever needing to densify - not many natural barriers for a while. But maybe it doesn't.
- jpao79 8y agoPersonally, I think the best option is to encourage the high growth companies in tech/finance/media to create secondary headquarters in nearby secondary cities that are ready to handle higher density growth (i.e high density residential and light rail systems, etc.). SF/SV -> Sacramento NYC -> Newark LA -> San Diego High level management can day trip it via 1-2 hour train/car/shuttle ride to the secondary headquarters without the expense/complexity of plane rides and overbite hotels, or conversely the employees can day trip it to primary headquarters. Plus there is no timezone difference for conference calls. And most importantly the employees can still be within driving distance of their social network and have a very similar quality of life (climate, outdoor recreation, etc.) but not all of their paycheck is spent on housing.
- dcosson 8y ago> why is so much of our economic policy centered around new and higher paying jobs in a certain area There are certainly hot spots in places like NY and SF, but it's not just one area. Lots of cities are growing. And it's not all due to evil corporations running amok, at a certain level it's just capitalism itself that requires growth - the GDP has to keep growing year over year, and the population probably has to grow slightly to provide for that growth. Immigrants move in, and children grow up and need somewhere to live. Add in the generational effect of baby boomers, i.e. that older people retiring and staying in their homes mean that we need more housing for the same number of jobs. Specific booms like tech in SF may exacerbate the problem even more, but fundamentally our way of life just requires continual growth. This is at odds with the NIMBY attitude that I have a right for not just my home, but every building in my neighborhood, to stay exactly the same as the day I moved in. It's not at odds with affordable market rate housing, that just requires supply keeping up with demand.
- majormajor 8y agoThere is a LOT of room in the country for growth, as you mention, and most of it has more room to expand and is starting from a much cheaper price point. So fighting residential development locally to try to push companies to other areas may be a rational strategy for some. I'm not convinced that perpetual population growth will always be required for economic growth.
- maoistinquisitr 8y ago> There is a LOT of room in the country for growth No there isn't. All the places with viable logistics and water supply are pretty much full up. Urban areas need barge transport, good rail grades, aqueducts, and rivers to carry away waste. You can't plop a city down in the middle of nowhere. The energy economics mean it will never work. All the sites worth building on have been built on. A lot of the places supplied mostly by truck are of questionable viability in coming years. Probably the only area of the country that could long term sustain a much higher population density is the great lakes region.
- 8y ago
- pcwalton 8y ago> Those two goals seems hard to reconcile. Historically, cities responded to this by building more housing, thus reducing the tension. In the 1970s, in certain locales like the West Coast, they stopped doing that. Forty to fifty years later, a massive housing crisis resulted. We could start by acknowledging our mistakes and working to correct them.
- linkregister 8y agoCities are the greatest economic drivers of societies the world over. Worldwide, people clamor to cities to improve their opportunities. Cities that don't manage this growth achieve congestion; cities that outright block growth experience longtime residents being priced out. Why wouldn't economic policy address one of the major challenges to improved opportunity? Also, wouldn't you want your kids to be able to afford living in their hometown? Many interests paint this as an all- or nothing- problem: "the developers just want to pave over Golden Gate Park!" "The NIMBYs just want their property values to increase!" In reality, nobody credibly advocates this. Building high-density apartments in previously single-family home tracts is one solution. Paris is an excellent example of housing that is both beautiful and functional. Apartments are limited to six stories, and have good public transit available, so congestion isn't like Jakarta.
- L_Rahman 8y agoIn reality, they do credibly advocate this and San Francisco is a key example: > At the meeting, one woman fretted that the tall building would violate the privacy of a nearby public school. > When Tillman said he saw his project as necessary so people like his daughter could afford to come back and live in the city, one particularly motivated activist said she wished his daughter was killed in a terrorist attack. > Parroting many of the Mission activists' concerns, Commissioner Rich Hillis complained that the design was "bulky, and a bit out of character" with the neighborhood, while Commissioner Kathrin Moore said that erecting an 84-foot tall building would be like "plopping a foreign object into this area and not thinking about the consequences." Commissioner Dennis Richards said, "I think a project absolutely belongs here. The question is what kind of project." https://reason.com/blog/2018/02/21/san-francisco-man-has-spent-4-years-1-mi https://reason.com/blog/2018/02/21/san-francisco-man-has-spe...
- ex3ndr 8y agoWe are started an a startup (Openland, W18) to find a way to product more housing and during initial research i found that there are a lot of empty lots in LA that costs about $10k-50k. Tried to search in different states and found same lots at Long Island. So why people are not trying to buy land and build something on it instead? Buying a house will cost magnitude more than buying land and building your own house. Building will take time and resources, but... paying for a loan for 30 years? I think i can spend two years building my own home for the fraction of a cost of buying existing one. Why no one is doing this?
- pxeboot 8y agoPeople are doing it, but building a home is a lot of work and usually ends up costing far more than anticipated unless you really know what you are doing.
- ex3ndr 8y agoMay be the solution is simplifying building instead of dealing with existing one? Even in SF there are a lot of land for housing! For example, there are hundreds of body repair/tyre shops in SF. Why city ever need them in the city where Uber wins over owning your own car? But you can't just buy them and build more housing - in most cases you need to wait several years to "clean up" the soil.
- timr 8y ago"Even in SF there are a lot of land for housing! For example, there are hundreds of body repair/tyre shops in SF." Yeah, well...those places are already in use. And if you want to change that use, you first have to buy the land from the people who are already using it. And that's expensive, because people know what the land is worth. In other words: those auto repair shops are there for a reason. You can't just ignore the reason(s) and pretend that the land is vacant. It's not as if every SF landowner is behaving in an economically suboptimal way because they're all stupid.
- 8y ago