18 ms·
Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light
- Someone1234 9y agoI'm glad the FAA does what they do. While it is easy to hand wave away their concerns, it is better to over-spec it now and to test the design than to just let manufacturers put "alpha" products into commercial usage and only fix them after a body-count. If driving/vehicles/roads were held to the same or a similar standards to aircraft there might be fewer accidents and deaths today. Ironically self-driving is held to a much higher standard than regular driving; which is appreciated but further makes one question why regular "dumb" vehicles are so under-regulated (the analogy that springs to my mind is when HTTPS with a self-signed certificate used to be treated much worse than regular HTTP, it took years to treat HTTP as the insecure connection it is, manual vehicles are the same way, something that has been around so long we ignore its safety issues).
- Waterluvian 9y agoPut autonomous cars in the exact same conditions as all cars today rather than an easy mode Silicon Valley subset and the body count will be way higher. I don't disagree with your sentiment about the FAA. I don't believe autonomous cars are being held to a higher standard needlessly.
- foobarrio 9y agoHow often is failure of the car itself the cause of a fatal automobile accident? Just looking at lack of seatbelt use and alcohol make up 50% of traffic fatalities. It seems that the "Human Choice" is the biggest thing to fix when it comes to auto accidents. * https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/812318 https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/...
- tomohawk 8y agoI have a relative who worked at the FHWA (Federal Highway Admin) for many years. The estimate I often heard is that improper pavement design and maintenance were a factor in 20% - 30% of fatalities (think: asphalt). That friction with your tires is all that's really keeping you on the road. Many states refused to perform testing of their pavement because (a) they would have to remediate, and (b) they would likely have to go with less politically connected companies for pavement that would work better.
- rizzom5000 8y agoAccording to USDOT and NHTSA human error is responsible for 94% of human fatalities involving traffic crashes (including cyclist and pedestrian deaths).
- burfog 8y agoIf the human drives right into a huge wheel-swallowing pothole, is that "human error" or is it "improper pavement design and maintenance"? The human should watch out. On the other hand, the pothole should be fixed. It is probably typical to have multiple factors, making it easy to bend the numbers to one's liking.
- furgooswft13 9y ago> If driving/vehicles/roads were held to the same or a similar standards to aircraft there might be fewer accidents and deaths today. Vehicles are already regulated with regards to safety features; seat-belts, airbags, anti-lock braking systems etc. These have and do prevent many deaths and serious injuries. But holding cars to the same mechanical rigors as airplanes would make them neigh unaffordable for most, to say nothing of yearly inspections many states have which is often considered nothing more than a government subsidy to mechanic shops. It is also entirely unnecessary, as when a car has a mechanical failure, it can just roll to a stop. As for preventing accidents in the first place, car crashes, as with plane crashes, are caused overwhelmingly by operator error.
- walrus01 8y ago> But holding cars to the same mechanical rigors as airplanes would make them neigh unaffordable for most, to say nothing of yearly inspections many states have which is often considered nothing more than a government subsidy to mechanic shops. It is also entirely unnecessary, as when a car has a mechanical failure, it can just roll to a stop. For engines, yes, but it's scary how many people don't maintain their brakes properly. Or otherwise drive vehicles that are unsafe to be on the road. https://www.reddit.com/r/Justrolledintotheshop/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Justrolledintotheshop/ There's a reason why many states, particularly northern and road salt states, have mandatory inspections. There's also very good reasons why state patrols and the DOT do mandatory inspections of larger cargo trucks. Obviously a car does not need to be maintained to the same standard and expense as a light aircraft. If you fuck up your own clutch it's nobody's problem but your own wallet.
- furgooswft13 8y agoBrakes and tires are two legitimate inspection points that often get neglected by drivers. Still, brake inspections especially, are very often abused by mechanic shop and/or unreasonable regulation terms to force car owners to replace far before is actually necessary. At least in my experience, it seems every single year the shop states they won't pass the car unless some of the brakes are replaced. I suspect in this case they are just bald-face lying, as recently I balked at yet another ~$600 maintenance charge to pass a routine inspection, took the car to a friends shop out of town, and was able to conclude that the original shop never even checked the brakes, as the wheels took _a lot_ of force to remove once the lug nuts were off. Similarly with emissions checks. It often turns into nothing more than a yearly tax on your vehicle and does nothing to improve anyone's safety.
- walrus01 8y agoNot related to autonomous vehicles, but related to the risk of death for light aircraft flight vs. NASA spacecraft human-rating... The FAA seems to be relatively OK with the current annual fatality rate for light-sport aircraft, homebuilt experimental licensed aircraft, and light aircraft in the size range of the Cessna 172. For pilots with less than 1000 hours, flying a light single engine aircraft is a relatively dangerous activity on a per-hour basis. If human spaceflight had the same number of annual fatalities as the current number deaths in the US 48 states while flying homebuilt/kit/light sport aircraft, both NASA and the news media would be freaking out. NASA is requiring spacex to put the Falcon9 and Dragon2 through a very expensive and rigorous period of qualification before it can carry humans on commercial launch contracts. The likelihood that there will be a totally catastrophic disaster that the launch escape system can't recover from is low, but the standard of safety (in terms of flight-hours per human per year) seems to be much, much higher than the FAA's.
- meredydd 8y agoThe Space Shuttle suffered 2 total losses in 135 missions. Apollo had 1 total loss from a dozen or so flights (plus several heart-stopping near misses). If privately flown Cessna 172s had that kind of fatality rate, I (and many other posters on this board) would long since be a smoking hole in the ground. Space flight is spectacularly dangerous, and US launch vehicles have a particularly gnarly safety record. Some paranoia is probably warranted.
- walrus01 8y agoThe space shuttle, Apollo and early Soyuz were also very different spacecraft than current designs and technology. Challenger and Columbia were lost due to institutional ineptitude. The engineers that were the manufacturer of the SRBs on Challenger specifically warned against the cold temperatures and were overruled. People noticed the foam shedding issue with the space shuttle many years before the Columbia incident. The space shuttle was a catastrophic clusterfuck of a pork barrel political design. There was actually no launch escape system or possibility of recovery from early launch phase anomaly once the SRBs were lit, until they burned out (unlike the launch escape system on Soyuz, Apollo, Dragon2, etc). The space shuttle had a ridiculous number of moving parts and degree of complexity compared to a Dragon2 on a Falcon9 (or a Soyuz on top of its booster) The soviet union and russia have had zero fatalities since Soyuz 11 in 1971. I would actually venture that at this point it might be statistically safer to fly along as a passenger in a modern Soyuz mission than to fly as a second passenger in some sub-500-hour pilot's kitbuilt piper cub clone.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>If driving/vehicles/roads were held to the same or a similar standards to aircraft there might be fewer accidents and deaths today. But at what cost? Ground transportation wouldn't be very useful if we couldn't afford it Sure, "human life is sacred" and all that but that's kind of a first world problem you don't get to care about except when you already have infrastructure that's good enough for most use cases. >Ironically self-driving is held to a much higher standard than regular driving; which is appreciated but further makes one question why regular "dumb" vehicles are so under-regulated Design and construction of new vehicles is subject to a large and ever increasing amount of regulation. It just doesn't make the news when a FMVSS gets updated to require that brake hoses meet a later revision of some SAE spec which specifies a more rigorous QC procedure. Regarding maintenance, some negligible fraction (I've heard 6%, "less than 1%" and 0.5%) is caused by mechanical failure. If mechanical failure caused a meaningful portion of crashes you'd see insurance companies harping on about it and offering elective inspection programs in non-inspection states.
- sunflowerfly 8y agoBringing the same rules to light aircraft as airliners has actually made them less safe. Bringing a new four place plane to market has been cost prohibitive. The majority of new planes built today were designed in the 50’s on slide rules. Imagine if we were all still driving 50’s era automobiles. Luckily, the FAA loosened these rules this week.
- 8note 8y agoThat's assuming that over those years, the market would select for safer flights and not cheaper ones at the expense of safety.
- selectodude 8y agoThe issue is that non-commercial aircraft are being held to the same standard as a 777, not that the 777 is held to an extremely high standard. There's nothing safe about a Cessna 172, period, and it's far too expensive for them to redesign it. So it's going to continue to be a 60 year old plane with updated avionics.
- tdubhro1 8y ago> There's nothing safe about a Cessna 172 Genuine question: is the 172 really considered unsafe, googling "cessna 172 safety record" brings up a lot of articles suggesting it is as safe or safer than comparable aircraft - or are you saying that light private aircraft aren't very safe in general?
- cjrp 8y agoNot specific to the 172, but a sizeable part of the training when getting your license is about what do when the engine stops (gliding, finding a suitable field/road/etc.) - and if you fly long enough there's a fairly good chance you'll have to put what you learned into practise.
- anfilt 8y agoYou do realize most airplane crashes are small planes.
- stephenr 8y agoWhile there are some mechanical failure caused crashes, aren’t the vast majority of car crashes/incidents caused by driver error? Either drunk, speeding, not paying attention, deliberately being a bellend, etc? If anything that just means the licensing process should be stricter - not specifically a change in the cars themselves. With self-driving cars the car is the driver so of course it has to be more strictly controlled - it has to make decisions.
- rayiner 8y ago> Ironically self-driving is held to a much Is it?
- pc86 8y agoThe FAA is a common source of criticism and complaint among the aviation community. It's the driving force behind the continually rising costs in general aviation. Owning a small single engine plane with a hull value of $40-50k requires a financial commitment tantamount to purchasing a second home. But, it's good to step back and recognize every now and then that every Federal Aviation Regulation (FAR, 14 CFR) is written in blood. The FAA can be a pain to deal with sometimes but every pilot I know is very, very glad that they do what they do.
- ejlangev 8y ago> The FAA rubber-stamped those measures Friday. Not sure what this line is supposed to mean. Is he referring to them approving them without knowing what they are? I'm glad for the FAA's rules. U.S. air travel is extremely safe despite constant efforts on the part of airlines to reduce costs for themselves without enough concern for safety. I don't think we can trust any transportation company to value the lives of its passengers at an appropriately high level so they need to be forced with regulation.
- hughes 8y agoI don't think the FAA does anything lightly when it comes to passenger air travel. The author probably misunderstood the meaning of the phrase.
- tomohawk 8y agoBoeing and the FAA proceed on these things as a partnership. Boeing has their name on the line, and they have way more engineers and other technical specialists than the FAA. In the past, Boeing has essentially written the specs that must be adhered to by all equipment producers, and, once the FAA approves those specs and procedures, ensures that they are followed. This book gets into how this worked with the 747: https://www.amazon.com/747-Creating-Worlds-Adventures-Aviation/dp/0060882425 https://www.amazon.com/747-Creating-Worlds-Adventures-Aviati...
- wahern 8y agoBoeing is part of a duopoly. If a Boeing plane falls out of the sky, most people would chalk it up to the inherent danger in air travel rather than to fault Boeing specifically. OTOH, part of the reason the duopoly persists is because of heavy regulation, and specifically the strict safety regimen. From that angle Boeing has significant economic motivation to promote costly safety margins, particularly those which raise barriers to entry into their markets. I understand the argument that Boeing employs countless conscientious, professional engineers. But in 2018, with American business culture having internalized decades of cynical, anti-social business practices, I'd be careful about overestimating the influence of the professional class.
- amelius 8y ago> some plane crashes occurred after pilots did not secure flaps on wings before takeoff. The FAA required Boeing to have several warning systems to make sure pilots won't attempt a takeoff before the wingtips are locked in the correct position. And Boeing couldn't imagine that might be a good idea in the first place?
- mrfusion 8y agoShouldn’t they automatically lock? In what scenario do you want wings down and unlocked?
- sidlls 8y agoIt's not just about locking in-place. These warnings will almost certainly include warnings about them being up instead of down, for example.
- annerajb 8y agoI guess it's hard to awnsers have we landed and should we move the wingtips to locked positions? Airplanes afaik have no state machine that says taking off landing taxiing. They may be able to detect it by reading all different systems example landing gear extended altitute from ground radar over 4 feet landing wheel moving etc. But I assume it's too many variables?
- detaro 8y agoWho says that Boeing didn't plan on having warnings? That warnings are required by the FAA in the new rules created doesn't mean Boing wanted to have none, it just says the FAA wants warnings.
- amelius 8y agoIt says several planes crashed because of this. I assume they are talking about the same type of planes, perhaps test-models.
- 8y ago
- mrfusion 8y agoI thought a wider wings would cause more drag? What am I missing?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chiph 8y agoThe shape probably comes into it - this wingtip sweeps upward at the end, so it can shed the vortex smoothly. Much like the wingtip airfoils you see on other current planes.
- kgilpin 8y agoYou’ll be interested to read about aspect ratio: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspect_ratio_(aeronautics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspect_ratio_(aeronautics) As the ratio of the span to the chord increases, the ratio of lift to drag increases as well. The drag of an object in the sense of forcing its way through the air (eg a semi truck on the highway) is important, but for airplanes there is also a very important phenomenon of drag due to lift (“induced drag”). It’s kind of non-intuitive. But if you’ve ever seen those strong vortices coming off a wingtip, you’re seeing induced drag. Think of the energy creating this: https://youtu.be/uXrnGiIMGLs https://youtu.be/uXrnGiIMGLs It’s energy created by propulsion but turned uselessly into spinning air.
- phumbe 8y agoYou beat me by two minutes on the aspect ratio bit :) Here's another good video showing wingtip vortices: https://www.instagram.com/p/BhzCLgFnVzL/?hl=en&taken-by=edseguin https://www.instagram.com/p/BhzCLgFnVzL/?hl=en&taken-by=edse... Not sure what you mean by "energy created by propulsion." The vortices result from low pressure on top and high pressure below making the air want to curl around. That imparts downwash on the wing, reducing its effectiveness.
- kgilpin 8y agoI mean that the airplane’s propulsion system is ultimately the power source behind those vortices, by forcing the wing through the stationary air.
- VectorLock 8y agoI wonder what the failure modes for this would be like. Consider a Boeing 777X going along at its cruising speed and the locking mechanism for the wing tips just disappears; primary and secondary. The wingtip is effectively unsecured. What happens?
- theothermkn 8y agoIf we're going to do failure modes effects analysis, we'd need to know what the mechanism is in order to enumerate the possible failure modes (along with their likelihoods). For example, if the wing tips are actuated by a worm drive, then there is no "and the locking mechanism...just disappears;" The drive would be the locking mechanism. There are probably also suitable bistable mechanisms that lock in the open and closed positions, requiring actuation to unlock them. > What happens? In the large, I'm sure the teams of engineers at Boeing have it covered.
- theoh 8y agoThe conventional locking mechanism that I've seen documented is like the lock on a bank vault: several pins, aligned with the hinge, which slide parallel to it, locking inboard and outboard sections in place. This locking mechanism means that the number of pins and their dimensions can be scaled to handle arbitrary loads, and there's no single point of failure.
- VectorLock 8y agoThats what it looks like just looking at the video. Some kind of pins that slide in when the hinge is fully down. So one in a billion confluence of errors makes the pins disengage in the middle of a flight. What happens?
- theoh 8y agoWell, the lift on the wingtip is going to make it fold up. In the worst case, I guess it might break off, but it's a very small part of the wing, and it presumably doesn't contain fuel tanks. Chances of it damaging the inboard section have to be quite small and I wouldn't be surprised if the hinge is designed to cope with the forces involved. For comparison, see these stories of aircraft flying safely with a much larger wing area unintentionally folded: https://theaviationist.com/2014/02/19/us-navy-fighters-folded-wings/ https://theaviationist.com/2014/02/19/us-navy-fighters-folde...
- namirez 8y agoThe correct term for these is winglet, which is a special kind of wingtip device. There are other wingtip devices too. For example A380 has wingtip fences.
- NickNameNick 8y agoThese are not winglets. Winglets are fixed. These are new longer wings, which would make the aircraft too wide to use existing terminals, except that Boeing have built the wingtips to fold up while taxying and at the gate. In flight they are extended straight out as extensions of the wings. Winglets are cool, but a longer, straight wing can achieve the same effect more efficiently by giving the wingtips washout (negative angle of attack).
- namirez 8y agoMy bad! Thanks for the correction!
- basicplus2 8y agoI wonder why one would not make the wingtips fold down.. Thus providing the opportunity to provide a permanent thrust face for the majority of the in-flight forces and thus significantly reducing any risk of failure. There apears to be adequate ground clearance.
- nikanj 8y agoThey want to avoid the inevitable "ground crew drove a van into the wing tip"-delays.
- peterbraden 8y agoI wonder if it's so they can later experiment with winglets, which would fold inwards when vertical, rather than outwards which a downward fold would mandate.
- exabrial 8y agoSort of off topic, but sort of related too. How do you differentiate between the types of planes Boeing makes? I know the 737, 747, 757, 777, and 787 are all different but never really understood the meaning behind the numbers. I know certain pilots can fly certain ones, but I've never gotten the similarities between the designs and why that is.
- avar 8y ago"The FAA also wanted assurances that there was no way the tips would rotate during flight". Does "no way" include the pilot deciding they should? If so this goes against tho grain of the philosophy that the pilot should be in full control of the plane. Interesting that they made an exception for this.
- raverbashing 8y agoUsually yes. > If so this goes against tho grain of the philosophy that the pilot should be in full control of the plane. Clearly not. Pilots are usually prevented from destructive actions unless there's a good reason for it or a technical impossibility (and for a large object flying at a large speed, there are several ways they can do something wrong) If there's no technical reason why they should be allowed to unlock the wingtips in flight, they will be prevented from that.
- Bromskloss 8y agoWhat does it actually take to get a thing allowed? What are the specific requirements?
- blackrock 8y agoTo be honest, all these advancements in plane efficiency and design, is irrelevant to me, as a passenger. Why? Because the airlines will continue to cram you like a sardine in a can, and will give you barely any sitting space on the plane. Unless of course, you pay for it, to fly first class, or business class. And to the capitalists, then this is perfect. It's exactly what a market economy system is all about. You as the consumer, get what you pay for. What is troubling is flying coach on a long haul international flight, that lasts for over 10 hours. There just isn't any room to move around in your seat. Sleeping during the plane is uncomfortable, if can even do so. And good luck if you end up sitting in the middle. Nobody wants to sit in the middle. If there is one thing that the FAA should regulate, it is the minimum space allotted to flying coach on a flight. Give us back some human decency please.