7 ms·
Definitely. And my real issue with Jobs is more the ripple effect. So many people read stories of Jobs being an asshole and think, "Oh, this is how you success.
by wpietri 9y ago
Definitely. And my real issue with Jobs is more the ripple effect. So many people read stories of Jobs being an asshole and think, "Oh, this is how you success." Ignoring the many assholes who weren't as brilliant or as thoroughly lucky.
Look at Theranos, for example. The CEO was practically a Jobs impersonator. From the turtlenecks and the air of brilliance to the controlling, abusive, and secrecy-oriented behaviors. How many people fell for the fraud? And I can't count the wantrepreneurs I've come across that had similar theories.
- lowken10 9y agoI think Elizabeth Holmes belongs in prison. However, I read her bio and she was a genius on par with Jobs.
- paulcole 9y agoFor breaking what law(s)?
- rpedela 9y agoFraud? The kind of fraud that can get someone hurt or killed like the bogus diagnostic tests which could mean a patient ends up taking the wrong drug and/or dose which hurts them.
- paulcole 9y agoDo you think Elon Musk should be in jail for the misleading content on this page: https://www.tesla.com/autopilot https://www.tesla.com/autopilot
- paulsutter 9y agoHuman drivers kill over 1 million people per year https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-related_death_rate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic...
- rpedela 9y agoNo because as far as I am aware Elon has not tried to actively hide the problems even if he sometimes paints a rosier picture than reality. That is very different from telling everyone, including regulators, that the diagnostic tests work great, safe, effective. And there are documents showing they knew it didn't work. Theranos is like Enron.
- gameswithgo 9y agoFraud, theft.
- luddaite 9y agoHonest question: Is raw intelligence or wisdom more important for success in biotech? It seems to me that raw intelligence is useful when studying systems that are either designed rationally or can be understood easily from a mathematics perspective. On the flip side, I think experience is important when dealing with biology which is often messy and not easily understood because so much is still unknown and everything is the result of an accumulation of random variations.
- aaavl2821 9y agoMost biologists I know are very high in raw intelligence. However there's a distinction between biology as a science and biotech as an industry. The key insight that starts development of a new drug often comes from pure molecular biology, but after that, a different type of biology, as well as chemistry and pharmacology quickly become very important. The industrial drug development process is one of the most technically complex, risky and highly regulated processes in industry. You basically need PhD level experience in almost a dozen distinct technical domains to get a drug approved. Most biotech VCs prefer CEOs with decades of drug dev experience because they know where the pitfalls are and how to execute better That said, Ive heard a very experienced biotech VC / former big pharma drug developer describe the process of developing a drug as "hanging on by your fingernails", and the traditional dyed in the wool drug industry strategy has pretty much put the industry on a long term declining trend, so maybe experience isnt as powerful as the industry tells itself
- geezerjay 9y ago> However, I read her bio and she was a genius on par with Jobs. In short, why do you believe that Steve Jobs was remotely close to being a genius, and what made Elizabeth Holmes do to lead you to believe she also met you definition of a genius?
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agohttps://www.wsj.com/video/reporting-on-theranos-and-elizabeth-holmes/22C3F84E-0985-4EEE-8B74-256CD6D489D7.html https://www.wsj.com/video/reporting-on-theranos-and-elizabet... At 4:00 in this video they talk about Holmes fake "deep voice". I think its pretty clearly her fraud tendencies run really really deep. I don't think you could trust anything you think makes her a genius. The only things we actually know about her is that she could get into Standford, where she dropped out. She could also raise money really well. I don't think she is by any means dumb. But there is absolutely no evidence of genius.
- rhizome 9y agoFunny, lowering the pitch of your voice is a tropey power move that gets zero criticism when practiced by men.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoAny "tropey power move" should be criticized. Didn't you just criticize it by the category? When I was raising capital I definitely heard VC's making fun of men who spoke in a false voice, practiced their handshake, or artificially held eye contact way too long. I'm fine if you want to say my criticism of Holmes is influenced by sexism. But to make the statement that men speaking in a stupid fake voice get zero criticism... is hyperbole to point ridiculousness.
- jrs95 9y agoThis knee jerk reaction is part of why she was able to get away with it for so long.
- jackhack 9y agoGenius isn't enough. In fact, it can be a detriment in the right (wrong?) environment resulting in stunted emotional and social development. The problem with geniuses is that they tend to think their aptitude is enough to grant them magical ability to be correct. It takes experience and humility to learn that it's not the same, but a life of being pampered and put on a pedestal limits the genius' opportunity to learn this life lesson. The self-serving genius is roughly equivalent to the pychopath. Once you begin to look for these antisocial behaviors among so-called geniuses you'll see a frightening pattern.
- WalterBright 9y agoPeople thinking they are smarter than they are, and that this entitles them to run other peoples' lives, is hardly limited to geniuses.
- gameswithgo 9y ago>I read her bio and she was a genius on par with Jobs. What were either of them geniuses at exactly? Psychology?
- xenihn 9y agoSure. People with certain personality disorders are extremely good at reading others, and convincing them to do what they want. Two common (and apt) terms I see thrown about are "social chameleon" and "reality distortion field". You can also learn how to do it if you don't have one by studying those who do. Regardless of how someone ends up with the ability, I don't think it's unfair to refer to it as genius, even if it's specifically based on emotional intelligence. They're just on a completely different level in comparison to the general population when it comes to bending others to their will and getting their way.
- philwelch 9y agoI've unfortunately been very close to people with cluster B personality disorders, and I think "savant" is a better term than "genius". In many cases, these people don't even realize how manipulative they are; it's just an unconscious reflex.
- whatshisface 9y agoThere's a line beyond which Jobsian behaviors will ruin the productivity and happiness of the Woz. Holmes/Kissenger and friends flew over it and landed in "scientists are being forced (and encouraged) to lie to keep their jobs," territory.
- rajeshpant 9y agoI googled her images after reading your comment and it is so funny to notice the impersonation. Also, every C level guy(also middle management wannabes) impersonates Jobs.
- saagarjha 9y ago> I googled her images after reading your comment and it is so funny to notice the impersonation. Well, it's not like she made any effort to conceal it. In fact, she was very public about her desire to appear like Jobs.
- WalterBright 9y ago> thoroughly lucky. Jobs made a huge success 3 times: 1. the Apple II 2. Pixar 3. return to Apple and transforming it from 90 days to bankruptcy to the biggest corporation in the world You can ascribe one of the above to luck, but faced with all three, Jobs was just that good, and made his own luck.
- timr 9y agoYou have to be able to separate the things that were good about Jobs (e.g. design sense, marketing instincts, etc.) from what was bad (i.e. being an asshole). It's the difference between being effective and being Cargo Cult Steve Jobs. Far too many baby entrepreneurs try to mimic Jobs' behaviors, but fail to couple it with any sort of skill or good taste.
- talmand 9y ago1. Wozniak 2. Lasseter (and others) 3. Ive His success was being involved with people with genius and vision that were willing to put up with his shit.
- badcede 9y agoThat's in no way a counter-argument.
- hellofunk 9y agoAll three of those guys were/are clueless about business until Jobs made their ideas work.
- talmand 9y agoI believe that I made that clear. He was a salesman, obviously a great one, for other people's ideas.
- abritinthebay 9y agoNo. He was a businessman and a product guy. He could sell, but as a side effect. I see this too often from fellow developers - anyone pushing business objectives and strategy instead of engineering choices is a "salesman". It's not true at all. Calling Jobs a salesman is like calling Einstein a Civil Rights campaigner. Certainly they both did that, and did it well, but it sort of misses the major thing they were good at.
- mmsimanga 9y agoLook I see your point and I agree. However, having worked in a number of big companies I am really at a loss as to what is the right way to coerce a number of humans into the "right" direction. I have sat in meetings where ignorant executives have blabbered on and on about nothing because the company and CEO felt it was important to hear everyone out. This works if everyone at the table is knowledgeable and able to swallow their ego. You get people making ridiculous statements like we need to replace our database that runs the whole organisation. I have also worked in a company where the CEO cut people who were blabbering short, mostly rightly but rudely so. I think the two approaches have a time and place. There is probably no need to be rude but I don't know how one cuts someone off without being rude.
- wpietri 9y agoWhat if there were right ways that don't involve coercion? What if we can't find them because we let coercive assholes run amok, seizing advantages and damaging people in ways that make it hard to create non-coercive structures that are also highly creative and productive?
- mmsimanga 9y agoI wish I had an answer. It seems to be getting worse or I am just getting old. From where I am standing, management .i.e. "coercion" is considered a stand alone skill. I understand management but I don't buy that it is a standalone skill. Most IT people will not be able to manage a hospital well. I use the word most because I don't want to use the word all and derail this argument. There are off course exceptions, but these are very rare. The number of people who can effectively manage in an industry/business unit they do not understand is less than the number of people currently managing an industry/unit they do not understand. Money, ego, selfishness ... you name it, humna traits get in the way. We all have these one of these traits and we are all affected by these traits. One of the issues with modern world is that big talkers are rewarded over reserved more knowledgeable people. The more you appear online, the more you talk in meetings and the higher profile you appear the more likely you are to be promoted. It is the way of the world.
- jrs95 9y agoA Jobs impersonator...but without the talent, taste for design, passion for products, or virtually any other positive quality that he had. IMO Holmes has more in common with Jordan Belfort than Steve Jobs.