6 ms·
Open Source Calculator Teaches Us about Quality Documentation
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI've got two of these and I love them. One if for development and has the 10 pin debug connector soldered in, the other is in its "standard" form for the most part except that it exfiltrates the UART because part of my plan is a make it the visual output of an VNA. The only complaint I have (and its minor) is that the contrast on the case is poor. A black case with white, light blue, and orange labels would have been stellar, with the white case things fade into the background.
- techdragon 9y agoThis is actually one of the biggest reasons I’ve not bought one already. The colour selection is deeply flawed in my opinion. I say opinion but it’s my opinion based on years of paying attention to user experience and ergonomics. It has a low contrast and low contrast is bad on items intended for swift and decisive use. Sure, too high of a contrast will be bad, but that’s partly dependent on font and other aspects of the design as to when it becomes “too high contrast”, regardless of that, this colour scheme is far too low contrast.
- jiveturkey 9y agoSince nothing but the logo is printed on the case (the button membrane has all the symbols directly printed on it), unlike say the swiss micros, you could very, very easily take it apart and spray it another color.
- imcs 9y agoCan you solve equations on it? I tried on the online simulator and even looked through the manual but it doesn't seem to have it.
- siproprio 9y agoIt looks like an underpowered copy of the HP Prime. Why should I own one, because it is open source?
- janoc 9y agoYou are missing the point. These are calculators designed specifically for the high school market, with the special, mandated by law, exam mode and restricted functions. Nobody else really needs one. BTW, the Prime is $50 more expensive than this thing and doesn't have the exam mode -> illegal to use in exams in France, for ex.
- connorelsea 9y agoAnd Prime doesn't seem to run python or any scripting language. This open calculator does
- siproprio 9y agoWhat do you mean by scripting language? I think that any advantage of being able to run python is moot considering that it has only 256KB of RAM.
- siproprio 9y agoActually, the HP Prime has exam mode. And for high-schools, personally, I think something simpler and less expensive would be nicer. And I also wish there would be a calculator more targeted at engineers.
- stuntkite 9y agoI had not heard of this project before and I ordered one after reading this article and I have to say that everything about their web UI/UX experience is world class. Possibly some of the best I've ever seen. Their simulator[1] is accurate AND responsive to even weird mobile form factors. The web site is snappy and has zero cruft. I feel like their design was inspired by or comes from the same school as Teenage Engineering, who made the OP-1 synthesizer. These cats are doing amazing work. This is a masterpiece. [1] https://www.numworks.com/simulator/ https://www.numworks.com/simulator/ [2] https://www.teenageengineering.com/products/op-1 https://www.teenageengineering.com/products/op-1
- saagarjha 9y agoLooks great, but there are a couple things that I think they could work on: > $99.99 This is in-line with, or slightly above, other players in the market (e.g. TI, Casio). I'd love to see someone challenge them in this space with something that's like $25. I can get a cheap $10 scientific calculator that does 60% of the same things for $10, so it really seems like there is a spot here for a lower price point. Especially since the hardware is so "old". > 20+ hours of use on a single charge A couple hundred hours would be nice. The benefit of a normal calculator is that it works without charging really being a thing that most people have to worry about.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIf they're going for quality, it's hard for a small operation to beat the larger players on price. Presumably as they become more well known, they can go for higher volume shipments and benefit more from economy of scale. I'd agree a good old-fashioned set of AAA batteries like my old TI would've been a better choice though, everyone's been pushing rechargeable batteries, but beyond the need for recharging regularly, they degrade over time and are often a pain to replace.
- blattimwind 9y ago> A couple hundred hours would be nice. The benefit of a normal calculator is that it works without charging really being a thing that most people have to worry about. This is almost certainly due to using what looks like either a transmissive LCD or an OLED display, which require a lot of power.
- saagarjha 9y agoYeah, I'd love to see something like an E-ink display that holds its charge much longer.
- froindt 9y agoHow would an E-ink display work for a calculator? I haven't used them for more than about 20 minutes in my life, but as long as there isn't a lot of lag while typing, it seems line it'd be a good choice. Much of the time a calculator is glanced at while doing math on paper or sitting idle while waiting for the next input. A 0-energy display would be ideal for this. It'd be interesting to see a breakdown of energy and energy consumption by part on a calculator.
- dm319 9y agoI very much like the idea of this calculator, particularly since it has a python implementation. However, there are a couple of caveats - it uses binary arithmetic, though since release it seems they've improved the accuracy, and also I'm not sure how free this license is[1]. For something that isn't open-source, but uses RPN and has quad-precision binary-encoded decimal precision the DM42 looks really nice[2]. [1] https://github.com/numworks/epsilon/blob/master/LICENSE https://github.com/numworks/epsilon/blob/master/LICENSE [2] https://www.swissmicros.com/dm42.php https://www.swissmicros.com/dm42.php
- klez 9y ago> I'm not sure how free this license is No need to wonder, if by "free" you mean "free as in the fsf definition". This violates at least freedom 4 by having the ND clause. You can't redistribute your modified version.
- gaius 9y agoSwissMicros calculators are beautiful, I have a 15L and will be adding a DM42 as soon as they are available. If you are thinking of ordering any of their products, you will not be disappointed!
- PetitPrince 9y ago>I'm not sure how free this license is. There is an ongoing discussion about what license to use for what part of the project, and what is the rational behind such and such choice. See this Github issue: https://github.com/numworks/epsilon/issues/38 https://github.com/numworks/epsilon/issues/38
- aw3c2 9y agoIf anyone from the project reads this, your website is unreadable due to abysmal contrast. Please see https://www.w3.org/TR/UNDERSTANDING-WCAG20/visual-audio-contrast-contrast.html https://www.w3.org/TR/UNDERSTANDING-WCAG20/visual-audio-cont...
- sriram_malhar 9y ago+1. The site is beautiful, but isn't good for older eyes. Too many sites seem to do this nowadays. I applaud them for their creativity, but they need an older person to test-drive it.
- jiveturkey 9y agoyeah unfortunately this is the norm these days for "beauty", even though it goes against every single guideline on the topic. and of course numworks most certainly knows this. otherwise of course, the website is masterful.
- antirez 9y agoPlayed a bit with the online simulator and immediately ordered one for my son (high school). Great UI, I could immediately print a function, realize that it was showing sin() in degrees and immediately found how to change it in radians and to cap the graph to x between -5 and 5. Trivial things but usually I don't find my way easily in a calculator that I do not know because most UIs suck.
- wycy 9y agoWould this be a good calculator to get for actual engineering work, or is it too limited by its testing restrictions? If not, what is a good engineering calculator these days?
- wtallis 9y agoThis calculator is made for high school math, not science. Its main concession to exam rules is a special mode that you don't have to engage. Outside of that mode, the big feature that's still missing is a Computer Algebra System. But what's usually not even on people's radar is whether the calculator can handle units. The line of HP calculators that ended with the HP 50g had the most useful system I've seen for computation on quantities with units. It serves both as a type checking safety feature and provides automatic conversion. TI's top graphing calculators have had similar functionality since at least the TI-89/92 generation, but (as usual) without a good user interface to make it worth using. The NumWorks calculator does not appear to have any capability for unit conversions, let alone carrying units throughout calculations.
- haZard_OS 9y agoI hate to be a naysayer here (because I actually like the idea of this calculator) but I use R for virtually every mathematical and statistical problem I encounter. It's always open on my computer while I'm working and I'm comfortable enough with the program that most of the syntax requires little thought on my part. If I'm in the field and need to perform some calculations, I either use my phone (for simple calculations) or my $17 Casio statistics calculator. As a risk assessor and environmental scientist, I have NEVER needed anything more than these.
- newen 9y agoI have a TI-89 emulator in my android phone. I use it all the time from simple calculations to graphing. I think I might have used the calculus functions a couple of times. Anyway, it's really convenient and now I wouldn't even think about carrying around another device that only does what a calculator does.
- GuB-42 9y agoThis calculator is designed for high school students, and it is certified for tests. I think the days where engineers, scientists and students shared the same calculators are gone.
- bobcallme 9y agoHow is this "Open Source"[1] when everything is licensed CC BY-NC-ND? What was the point of releasing anything if changes can't be made or shared? One might as well get a TI-84 since there are FOSS firmware replacements [2] and it would be much more free than this. I would have bought one of these if the license was not so restrictive. [1] https://opensource.org/osd-annotated https://opensource.org/osd-annotated [2] Knight OS http://www.knightos.org/ http://www.knightos.org/