6 ms·
> It would have violated our understanding of physics, but it's not like that's never happened before. I've heard this sentiment a lot when it comes to the EMD
by hn_throwaway_99 9y ago
> It would have violated our understanding of physics, but it's not like that's never happened before.
I've heard this sentiment a lot when it comes to the EMDrive, but honestly I think it really misunderstands how science progresses in general. For EMDrive to be real, virtually everything we know to be true about physics would have to be false: if you're saying conservation of momentum can be violated, or conservation of energy can be violated, then basically all of modern physics would have to be wrong.
When science, and especially physics, advances, it is very rarely, if ever since Newton's time, that the settled physics is 100% wrong. Instead, the "old" physics tends to be an approximation under most conditions, or there is a new phenomenon that can be explained without really violating the old rules. For example, conservation of momentum still holds under special relativity, it's just that we discovered things without mass can have momentum.
Thus, the only explanation that would really be plausible is if there is "something else" going on with the EMDrive where momentum and energy are still conserved, just that there is something happening beyond our current understanding of "energy" or "momentum". I haven't seen any explanations that even try to postulate what that could be. All I ever have seen is "but the old physics could be wrong!" without an explanation of how it could be wrong.
- mdorazio 9y agoI could be wrong, but I believe the postulation was along the lines of a quantum effect utilizing virtual particles from quantum vacuum fluctuations to generate microthrust. If that were true, it wouldn't really be a violation of the standard model - more of an addendum like a lot of things involving quantum mechanics.
- whatshisface 9y agoIf virtual particles are the ones I know from Feynman diagrams, then momentum is still conserved at every vertex (interaction element). Unless the person who speculated that meant something else by "virtual particles," I don't see in the slightest how they could be used to obtain momentum or squirrel it away. Besides, virtual particles have to go away at the end of every diagram... They can act as conduits between other particle fields but if a new particle remains after the interaction it will be just another reaction product (nothing virtual or spooky). Some go so far as to say that virtual particles don't particularly exist, but that's a philosophical statement I guess (they do indeed lack many properties of other things that exist). However I can't say much about that as the arguments for this-or-that nonintuitive ontology usually emerge from advanced theoretical research that is beyond my knowledge. (I.e. in momentum space virtual particles don't even remotely seem to exist, but maybe the picture seems more reasonable when you write it all down some other way.)
- smaddox 9y agoVirtual particles are particle-antiparticle pairs that are constantly being created and annihilated in empty space due to quantum ground-state variations. Supposedly their effects can be observed at the event horizons of black holes, giving rise to Hawking radiation, though this may be a simplification for the layman. They also conserve both energy and momentum.
- raattgift 9y ago> though this may be a simplification for the layman It's almost the opposite of that: a simplification for professionals' sake. You can set up an eternal black hole and enjoy the simplifications its time-invariance permits, but then you have to match the outgoing Hawking radiation flux (as seen at infinity) with an ingoing one. With a collapsing-matter black hole you lose time-invariance, because, coarsely, there is a region of spacetime where there is spread out matter and no trapping surface ("event horizon", or whatever, let's be agnostic about that), there is a region of spacetime where there is a trapping surface, and finally there is a region of spacetime where the trapping surface is gone and there is a gas of thermal radiation. But on the bright side, then you don't need any ingoing flux to balance the outgoing Hawking radiation. Instead you look at non-trivial Bogoliubov transformations between these different regions, which model how observer in region-with-horizon sees particles that observer in region-with-uncollapsed-matter ("no horizon yet") does not. (You can additionally change the speed of collapse, which changes the difference in particles that the later observer sees: sufficiently slow collapse means no Hawking radiation at all.) (Professionals even make other simplifications, like dealing with a free-as-in-linear scalar quantum field rather than realistic interacting matter; it won't matter much since "real" Hawking radiation would be almost only photons anyway, and the stark problems around the border between the region with the horizon (and Hawking radiation outside it) and the region with only Hawking radiation (and no horizon) likely do not depend on the precise content of the hottest Hawking radiation.)
- Tuxer 9y agoI have no understanding of physics, but given that 70% of the known mass isn't measurable, couldn't something like the EMDrive "just" (lol) send dark matter one way, and get momentum the other way? This is probably stupid to anybody that knows about physics, but I had to ask :)
- whatshisface 9y agoThat's a perfectly astute guess, and it sounds more plausible than the original theory behind the EM drive. However photons in a cavity, at these energies, are unlikely to be producing many particles - the effect you're describing is known and can happen (not even with dark matter, photons can directly produce regular matter and antimatter), but we have a good idea of how much is produced and it's not enough to thrust anywhere. (It would be easier just to shoot the photons out the back of the rocket - they're massless and therefore carry momentum with the highest possible energy efficiency.)
- aetherson 9y agoWe don't think that there's very much dark matter in our immediate vicinity. If there were, we'd probably have an easier time detecting it. Even though there's (according to theory) a lot of it in the universe, it clumps much less strongly than regular matter, so it's diffuse. And the characteristic of dark matter is that it interacts very weakly or not at all to electromagnetism. It would be very odd if it interacted so strongly with the EM drive that the EM drive could generate noticable thrust from such a diffuse medium. Finally, dark matter, if it has inertia, should have an inertial frame of reference. That frame is unlikely to be "at rest relative to the surface of the Earth." Therefore, if the EM drive is pushing off dark matter, we'd probably expect it to work more strongly in some directions than others. Think of it as a sail in a ghostly wind.
- whatshisface 9y ago>we'd probably expect it to work more strongly in some directions than others. According to the paper, the EM drive did actually quit working when rotated. However the dark matter wind seems less likely of an explanation than the Earth's magnetic field. ;)
- Nomentatus 9y agoHorsefeathers. To name two examples. The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen's paper on entanglement “Can Quantum Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?” (Einstein et al. 1935) ignored as trash for decades. The Casimir effect was predicted from quantum theoretical calculations, but again, no-one did the experiment for decades because they felt it was a trash prediction that couldn't be true 'cause it ignored basic physical laws that everyone knew had always held and always would. Empty space just couldn't do that. And on and on and on - I've just covered this century a tiny bit, not all the time since Newton. Dark energy anyone? Knowledge of the mechanisms behind X doesn't always precede discovery of X (why would anyone think it would always do so?) Lack of a known mechanism was why John Newlands version of the periodic table was greeted with contempt, and Mendeleev didn't find it easy sledding at first, either. But the contempt was unjustified. Birds were able to fly before the airfoil was discovered or airflow understood. Electricity was a broad field of study (Maxwell's equations, etc) long before the electron was discovered. The how usually trails the what in the history of science. I won't be shocked if the Emdrive is a wrong turn, but the idea we could know that in advance is sciencism - the satanic inversion of science - not empirical science.
- whatshisface 9y agoThere is still some place for using theoretical predictions to guide experiments. For example, I have developed a rune that may be used to cast Fireball - it consists of three triangles carved in to a very expensive gold-titanium laminate. If that test fails, I suppose we also ought to try four triangles, a triangle and a circle, the word 'fireball' engraved on the perimeter of a hexagon, three triangles engraved onto a momentum-nonconserving cone... More seriously, there was a good reason to strongly suspect that the EM drive wouldn't overturn physics: we have probed electromagnetic interactions at energy densities far higher (gamma ray scattering) and far lower (radio telescopes) and everything in-between, and they all seem to be points on a continuous surface defined by Maxwell's equations applied to quantum mechanics. A working EM drive would actually be very close to the magic rune I described above: a wildly noncontinuous point where the laws of physics became massively different for one particular arrangement of matter, and then go right back to normal if you step in any direction around it.
- raducu 9y agoI've got a limited understanding of physics, but what I understood from the em drive website, was that basically it did not violate ths conservation of energy, the em-drive was more of a direct energy-momentul convetsion tool. So, supposedly, if em drive worked, you could produce a flying car that could hover without new energy input (it was supposed to use superconducting materials in the cavity). As soon as you started mooving the energy in the cavity started to decrease - so you would be transfering the energy/momentum of photons in the cavity to your ship? Anyway, my physics gut told me this was all bullshit, but I wanted to believe sooo much, if this worked, it would have been the greatest invention in human history.
- saalweachter 9y agoOne problem is that we actually already have a direct energy to momentum generating "EM" drive. It is called a laser; light possesses momentum (in some sense, it is nothing but momentum) and emitting light asymmetrically produces thrust. The "EMDrive" claims to be orders of magnitude more efficient than laser propulsion (as well as not incinerating anything in it's wake), which is why it was both interesting and probably impossible.
- roywiggins 9y agoConservation of momentum is almost as important as conservation of energy, and indeed, if you have a reactionless drive you can extract unlimited energy: "applying a constant force results in a constant acceleration, the kinetic energy of a mass driven by such a device increases quadratically with time, while the energy input increases only linearly with time. Thus, at some point, the kinetic energy of the device-driven mass exceeds the energy input, and if this energy is collected via decelerating the mass (via regenerative electromagnetic braking, for example), then there would be a net gain in energy." https://arxiv.org/abs/1506.00494 https://arxiv.org/abs/1506.00494
- geon 9y ago> if you're saying conservation of momentum can be violated, or conservation of energy can be violated, then basically all of modern physics would have to be wrong. Conservation is not a fundamental law, but an emergent property of a deeper principle called Noether's Theorem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noether%27s_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noether%27s_theorem https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=04ERSb06dOg&t=594s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=04ERSb06dOg&t=594s And it is constantly violated.
- smaddox 9y agoCan you give an example of how it is "constantly violated"? One not involving a "perpetual motion machine"?
- geon 9y agoThe linked video mentions the expansion of the universe, and relativity.
- raattgift 9y agoJust to follow-up on my longer reply above: the solar system is not expanding. So within the solar system, there should be exact conservation of energy. (And we do test this in many ways, and it holds up). The metric expansion only operates on scales much larger than that of the solar system (and even larger than that of the Milky Way and its collection of nearby neighbours). (One can take a theory other than General Relativity and finely-tune the expansion of the solar system to match the null results on measures of it, and this is done in some quintessence and other models, but this won't help one do away with exact conservation of energy at scales of EmDrives; or give much room to have more energy moving into (or out of) a boundary drawn outside the solar system and the wider universe).
- igravious 9y agoThe section of the video dealing with Noether's Theorem and The Symmetries of Reality actually ends at t=594s :/ so just the main link is needed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=04ERSb06dOg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=04ERSb06dOg If one or another of these so-called fundamental laws is being apparently broken by the EmDrive then that would make it a very very unusual object. Consequently there would need to be repeatable verifiable evidence that it does so and at least the beginnings of a theory as to how in fact this breakage is occurring–Noether's theorem notwithstanding.
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoI still believe it’s possible and even likely that there are aspects of our universe that are totally undiscovered, much like radio was a thing no one knew about until it was discovered. It seems reasonable to me that we might discover ways to create gravity on demand, or to contort spacetime in other ways using electrical devices. Any of this would upend our understanding of physics to a large degree. But nothing will falsify existing observations - apples will always fall from apple trees. That doesn’t mean there can’t be more out there.
- lopmotr 9y agoThe less you know, the more likely all those things seem. People who know nothing about chemistry believe you can make a car that uses water or air as fuel (but big oil is suppressing it). Children wouldn't be the least bit surprised to learn that momentum was not conserved in space or in nuclear reactions or in aeroplanes because they didn't even know it was supposed to be conserved in the first place or that those things were known to follow the same laws as their toys. So I think being skeptical of accepted physics in any specific way isn't something a layman has much business doing. Of course there will be things we think we know that turn out to be wrong, but a layman can see such things everywhere, not just the places they will actually appear.
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoEh, I don’t think it’s just about ignorance. I had a fantastic science teacher for chemistry and physics in high school, then took another few quarters of chemistry and physics in college, and I am fascinated by cosmology today. I’ve read Steven Hawking and I love lectures by Lawrence Krauss. I’ve watched probably every Feynman lecture on YouTube. I’m still perhaps a lay person (I am an engineer by trade), but I DO have an understanding of physics and chemistry. I don’t think there’s science people know that they’re keeping from us. I just think it’s naive to think we’ve discovered almost everything there is to know about the universe. I’m not trying to build a straw man, but I’m saying either there’s “just a little bit more” to know or there’s a whole lot. I’m inclined to believe there’s a whole lot left to discover when it comes to things that will have a big impact on our world. And to be clear, I’m not being skeptical of accepted physics. When radio was discovered it didn’t change the accepted body of knowledge so much as it added new things we could do.
- noetic_techy 9y agoTo say there are NO theories as to how this can operate and NOT violate conservation laws is incorrect. Laymen just don't comprehend that there are possible theoretical paradigms they have not considered or are not aware of, so their knee jerk reaction is "not possible!": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RF_resonant_cavity_thruster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RF_resonant_cavity_thruster "Vacuum energy Main articles: Zero-point energy, Quantum vacuum thruster, and Pilot wave Harold White, the lead scientist in the NASA investigations, suggested in 2014 that their model could be an example of a quantum vacuum thruster (QVT). This is a theoretical system that would use magnetohydrodynamics to generate thrust, similar to conventional plasma thrusters, only using the fleeting vacuum quantum fluctuations of the zero-point field as an extremely low-density plasma.[82][23][83][84] White's 2016 paper states that pilot-wave theories, non-mainstream interpretations of quantum mechanics based on the de Broglie–Bohm theory, may help explain how QVTs could "push off of the quantum vacuum and preserve the laws of conservation of energy and conservation of momentum.". In 2017, a Portuguese team published a paper proposing pilot-wave theory as a possible explanation to the EmDrive thrust, that would not break conservation laws. The principle is that a sufficiently strong asymmetrical electromagnetic field could act as a pilot wave. The cavity would then be attracted toward regions of higher electromagnetic intensity. The researchers propose to increase thrust by shaping the cavity with an exponential form like that of a trumpet bell instead of a frustum.[85][86]"
- roywiggins 9y agoDoes this sidestep the perpetual motion problem? https://arxiv.org/abs/1506.00494 https://arxiv.org/abs/1506.00494
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jasonwatkinspdx 9y ago> Laymen just don't comprehend that there are possible theoretical paradigms they have not considered or are not aware of, so their knee jerk reaction is "not possible!" Skepticism about the EmDrive from Physicists has been nearly universal. There's always a few contrarians and heretics, but the consensus is what it is for good reason: it's best supported by the evidence. This is not about "laymen" lacking comprehension, and the condescension doesn't help your case.