13 ms·
Hundreds of Bitcoin Wannabes Show Hallmarks of Fraud
- ballenf 9y agoArticle is non-paywalled for once. Exhaustive analysis of ICO white papers shows about 1/4 contain major red flags. The bar the WSJ set is pretty low (as in easy to pass without raising flags). Any white paper that didn't plagiarize long passages, re-use others' headshots or fail to name principals, or fail mention risk basically passes. It's also worth noting that the multi-billion dollar figure cited for total funds raised through ICOs is about as reliable as the ICOs themselves, since it's based on self-reported figures from ICOs that frequently appear out of thin air with multi-million claims of funds raised so far.
- findyoucef 9y agoThere is a pay wall.
- ballenf 9y agoStrange, it is indeed now paywalled. Earlier it wasn't. Sorry about that.
- chatmasta 9y agoAnd that’s not even considering the many white papers that are original work, but completely wrong. Many of them propose fundamentally incorrect and exploitable systems. But of course none of the papers are peer reviewed, so if the idea sounds cool to some armchair tech nerds on reddit, off to the races you go! Want to see something truly scary? Pick a coin, any coin, that has had a major vulnerability discovered by researchers in a peer-reviewed publication. Then go onto that coin’s subreddit and watch in amazement as a bunch of security illiterate redditors bend over backwards to invalidate the paper’s claims with conspiratorial nonsense and cries of spreading FUD. Blind loyalty is bad enough in meatspace. In the cryptocurrency realm, it’s simply dangerous. The crazy thing is that any one of these coins could have a double-spending vulnerability, which by its very nature would likely be undiscoverable. There could very well be some clever hacker somewhere exploiting double spends and slowly bleeding money out of exchanges.
- Shorel 9y agoBy the nature of the technology, there's no double spending on a blockchain. Because every node has the same database. All and every one of the miners maintain a copy of what's essentially the same DB, the same distributed ledger. But there are plenty of stolen keys and seeds for wallets and if someone gets your wallet, all your money will be moved to someone else's. This, sadly, happens frequently.
- bsenftner 9y agoIt's the gold rush that killed crypto-currencies. They are dead, but their gold rush enthusiasts are going to hang on for a decade hoping to recoup their pride.
- tramGG 9y agoLast gold rush for crypto was in 2013 so ~5 years.
- astrodust 9y agoThis goes in cycles, like everything.
- Liquix 9y agoThere was definitely a substantial influx of new (often clueless) investors in the past 12-18 months.
- johnpowell 9y agoWhen Bitcoin hit around 14K my mom had heard all about the rise on MSNBC/CNN. So she asked me how to buy bitcoin. She needed to replace her radiator. She had about 500 and needed 1200 so she thought it was a reasonable gamble. So I had her send the money to me and I told her I would invest for her. I did not.. But I did inform her that when it crashed I just stuck her money in my savings account. And nothing was lost. I was willing to eat the loss if it had gone up when she wanted to cash out. And I did buy her a new radiator. I don't have to give a shit about mothers day for the next decade.
- daanlo 9y ago:)
- mihaifm 9y agoNot sure what your point is here. Predicting price movements is not an easy task, even for experienced traders. If you bought at 14k and sold at 20k, you would've made money. Nobody really knows the direction the market is going, otherwise we would all be rich now. Some trades make better profits than others based on experience, but for the most of us it's just pure luck.
- hudon 9y ago- The space is littered with fraud. - Wallets have bugs that lose hundreds of millions of dollars - Energy consumption forecasted to hit 0.5% of the world’s electricity consumption by end of 2018 - Promoters yelling “decentralize everything” while exchanges, development teams and mining are all highly centralized - No legal use case found to date Blockchain is a parasite on society.
- mtaksrud 9y agoIt sounds like the future to me... as currencies, not as investment objects... the similarities with our current national currencies is eerie.
- roywiggins 9y agowhen was the last time someone pitched an "initial dollar offering"?
- repomies6999 9y agoWhen you have violence monopoly backing up your business, it is easy to limit competition.
- roywiggins 9y agowe tried wildcat banknotes and it didn't exactly revolutionize anything https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildcat_banking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildcat_banking
- CryptoPunk 9y agoThe share of our attention captured by isolated bank failures is disproportionate to their effect relative to the systemic banking failures created by centralized banking systems. I would argue that the negativity toward such things as the wildcat banking era is a result of cognitive biases like this that manifest when dealing with complex social systems. More on the wildcat banking era: https://www.alt-m.org/2015/07/23/real-pseudo-free-banking/ https://www.alt-m.org/2015/07/23/real-pseudo-free-banking/ >>Indeed, the all-around record of U.S.-style free banking improved significantly as the Civil War approached. Even banknote discounts — another consequence of unit banking that has been wrongly treated as a necessary consequence of having multiple banks of issue — had become almost trivial by the early 1860s. According to my own research, someone who, in October 1863, was foolish enough to purchase every non-Confederate banknote in the country for its full face value, in order to sell the notes to a broker in either Chicago or New York, would have suffered a loss on that transaction of less than one percent of his or her investment.[9] That's less than the cost merchants incur today when they accept credit cards, or what people typically pay to withdraw cash from an ATM that doesn't belong to their own bank.
- fredgrott 9y agoTo be fair, How many startups listed on Angel list ar in fact frauds? No, not just illegal stuff like intershipsp for no pay but more major stuff like outright fabrication of founder bios, etc.
- gooseus 9y agoLegitimate frauds? Or "Fake it till you make it" type frauds who think their idea is legit and just inflate some numbers and their capabilities to get the money they need to prove it? What matters more, it seems to me, is that both the cryptocurrency and tech startup world are filled with bad investments which are going to make the next economic bust exponentially worse.
- AdamM12 9y agoI think the difference here would be that Angel's List and SEC rules in general provide/create/act-as gatekeepers for investment and thus can better filter outright fraud (note: not fake it till you make it "fraud") and limit investment to those who can afford to lose money. ICOs are circumventing that and allowing outright fleecing of small time investors on an unheard of scale and velocity. Obviously a snake oil salesmen is nothing new and you would only have to watch American Greed to see small time investors getting fleeced well before ICO's ever existed.
- favorited 9y ago> think their idea is legit and just inflate some numbers and their capabilities to get the money they need to prove it how is that not "legitimate fraud?"
- duskwuff 9y agoBecause there's at least an actual idea, and an intent to execute on it. A lot of the fraudulent ICOs, on the other hand, don't even have that -- their real business plan is "take the money and run".
- null000 9y ago
- wufufufu 9y agoCan someone smarter than me try to write a formal proof that you can only have 2 of the following: distributed, fast, secure?
- npongratz 9y agoI don't think there's a formal proof, but the idea has certainly been entertained. The scalability trilemma might be what you're looking for: https://multicoin.capital/2018/02/23/models-scaling-trustless-computation/ https://multicoin.capital/2018/02/23/models-scaling-trustles...
- dnautics 9y agocan you propose a formalism for your notion of "fast"?
- tobltobs 9y agoAs fast as a system which is either distributed or secure?
- hdespiritu 9y agoThere's decades of academic work in the form of "impossibility" results showing that handling byzantine fault tolerance in distributed consensus is alot more computationally expensive than omission/crash fault tolerance. The following (FLP impossibility result) being one of the most famous ones: https://groups.csail.mit.edu/tds/papers/Lynch/jacm85.pdf https://groups.csail.mit.edu/tds/papers/Lynch/jacm85.pdf
- neffy 9y agoYes, that's the root of the problem. A deceptively simple sounding result.
- brothercolor 9y agoRelated: Bitcoin is [x] distributed [x] secure but NOT [] fast. It is a global clock that self-adjusts to tick roughly every 10 minutes, and that tick is used to extend an immutable ledger by adding verified transactions to it. The tick-time is chosen to allow for global propagation to happen. Incidentally this global clock can be used for other things than sending money, such as cryptographically tying something in the real world to a point in time.
- geraldbauer 9y agoFYI: Beware Investors! At the Bits & Blocks Press Bookself I've collected books/booklets to warn about blatant crypto frauds and fudge. See Best of Bitcoin Maximalist - Scammers, Morons, Clowns, Shills & BagHODLers - Inside The New New Crypto Ponzi Economics [1] or Crypto Facts - Decentralize Payments - Efficient, Low Cost, Fair, Clean - True or False? [2] or Get Rich Quick "Business Blockchain" Bible - The Secrets of Free Easy Money [3] [1]: https://bitsblocks.github.io/bitcoin-maximalist https://bitsblocks.github.io/bitcoin-maximalist [2]: https://bitsblocks.github.io/crypto-facts https://bitsblocks.github.io/crypto-facts [3]: https://bitsblocks.github.io/get-rich-quick-bible https://bitsblocks.github.io/get-rich-quick-bible
- mythrwy 9y agoThe anti blockchain sentiment on HN is something like the anti-Trump hysteria in the period leading up to/immediately after the election. Tons of grandiose "it's SO horrible" posts, tons of downvotes. I predict it will shake out about the same way also. Blockchain and bitcoin aren't going anywhere in the near future. Some people have, and will continue to have, a use (for whatever reason). The "I hates it precious!" screeds won't change this. In the end it will turn out it's not the savior the proponents claimed it would be nor the demon incarnate the detractors claimed either but just another instrument of the powers that be. Why folks can't take less emotional views on these two phenomenon is beyond me. It really is. You don't like Bitcoin? Fine, ignore it. I simply don't get the mouth frothing hatred.
- aaaaaaass 9y agoI think this to. They probably have known about bitcoin since $1 and are trying to convince themselves and the world they were right not to buy.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tdb7893 9y agoI think the negative sentiment is largely because of how much the bitcoin evangelists promise. There's a lot of hype and lofty goals tossed around but cryptocurrencies have been around for nearly a decade (If I remember bitcoin started early 2009) and they mostly seem to be used for fraud and speculation now. I'm not saying that the technology is fundamentally useless but the mismatch between delivery and retoric has made me sour on it. A good more concrete example of this is the DAO from Ethereum. A lot of verbage was wasted beforehand saying how it was going change everything about corporations and investment but as far as I can tell little has changed.
- nikanj 9y agoFraud, speculation, and drug trade. Don't forget about the drugs.
- tptacek 9y agoIn the end, the "reputable" ICO-backed companies will mostly (perhaps entirely) turn out to be no better. Enron was a real company that did real things. During the time it operated, hundreds of aspiring future Enrons were born in the penny stocks, took down a few thousand in profits, and died. Skeptics of Enron could have pointed to those overt frauds and said "sure, the space is littered with frauds, but look at Enron over here; there are real companies too". In the end, it didn't matter; in fact: Enron was the more disastrous of the two threats.
- sygma 9y agoInteresting comparison, but I think it breaks fairly quickly. If Enron were in fact like Bitcoin, they could not have committed institutionalized and systemic accounting fraud. The books are fully open and transparent. It's fair if you think that Bitcoin will fail at becoming anything significant in the history of the Internet, but calling it a fraud seems unjustified.
- jeffreyrogers 9y agoI read the person you're replying to as talking about cryptocurrency backed companies, not cryptocurrencies like bitcoin in general.
- FooHentai 9y ago>the "reputable" ICO-backed companies will mostly (perhaps entirely) turn out to be no better. It seems ironic that such trust/reputation has become a central point, in light of blockchain's nature as a decentralized trust-less system.
- zby 9y agoEarly stage is just not very well suited for dispersed ownership. The investors need to do a lot of work to dig up and verify the information and this only makes sense if they have big stakes in the company. This is a general problem with crowdfunding (https://medium.com/@zby/proof-of-work-8d8265def194 https://medium.com/@zby/proof-of-work-8d8265def194). Then there are specific problems with ICOs - which have no legal meaning and give no guarantee to the investors at all.
- mmgutz 9y agoIt basically boils down to the world is full of suckers. I'd like to find alternatives to Bitcoin and Ethereum that are actually innovating. For most coins, forking is the extent of their technology.
- mempko 9y agoThis! I wish other projects tried harder.
- headsoup 9y agoThere are many replies in this thread that seem to be forms of 'yeah but there are issues with other stuff too!' Not a convincing rebuttal.
- root_axis 9y agoOne of the most under-appreciated problems regarding the "soundness" of blockchain tokens is that they are trivial to create and so everyone does so. A given blockchain token is only nominally distinct from a potential fork of itself that literally creates blockchain money out of thin air. The bitcoin-cash fork is a perfect example of how blockchain tokens can be trivially summoned out of the void with identical properties to the parent token which spontaneously "creates value" when the sum total value of the fork and the parent exceeds the value of the parent pre-fork. What this tells us is that blockchain markets are very inefficient and the vast majority of money in the system has near zero understanding of the intrinsic properties that underpin the token's ability to even exist as a thing that can be traded on an exchange. Once the market is saturated with an understanding of how these tokens are actually infinitely abundant and not at all scarce as we know it, we are going to see a catastrophic correction.