12 ms·
Reddit's redesign increases power usage of user's devices
- learnstats2 9y agoYep, this page set my fan running.
- jumpman500 9y agoWhat are the best Reddit clones these days? I've seen voat but heard it's overrun by the alt right. Hubski seemed interesting but basically seems dead now. Anything else out there? Reddit is really losing its appeal to me with their desktop/mobile site changes. That and I feel the contents been getting less interesting. Like it's just memes or sensational politics everywhere. Maybe I'm just getting old.
- Skunkleton 9y agoHacker News isn't a bad alternative ;)
- tomc1985 9y agoThis place has a really strong pro-cloud pro-JS bent tho
- dawnerd 9y agoPro js? Seems every thread about something built in javascript is full of people bashing it.
- tomc1985 9y agoWe are but tiny voices against the masses
- chomp 9y agoJavaScript is a pretty popular language. Also HN is a slice of the developer community at large. I think anything that discusses JS is going to look pro-JS to a person that hates it. I don't think parent will find any high traffic developer discussion forum where people don't discuss JavaScript. I admit I don't like the language, but there's definitely both camps on this site, seemingly in similar proportions.
- Skunkleton 9y agoIt beats the pro-meme bent of other sites though.
- soperj 9y agoLobste.rs
- Skunkleton 9y agoHow is life over there? The idea of an invitation tree certainly sounds nice.
- stephengillie 9y agoNo other language executes in browsers for historic reasons.[0] And there is reduced friction to developing all parts of the stack in a single language. Not all Javascript developers support the current state of the Node ecosystem. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17051521 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17051521
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoOf course it is because it serves the startup community and something like 99.999% of startups are web apps and ... well... javascript.
- md224 9y agoThe key is subscribing to subreddits that match your interests. /r/all is like the sun: it can brighten your day, but if you stare at it you might just go blind. Also, if you find The Next Reddit, let me know so I can build a new AskOuija there. :P
- dingaling 9y agoFor me, just casually dropping in to subreddits from a web search, I recoil at the suggestion of signing-up and slogging through curating and filtering until I achieve Reddit Nirvana. Life is too short. Particularly when other topic-focused communities already exist i.e. what problem are subreddits solving? And to invert that to the whole set, what problem is Reddit solving? I think they've asked themselves that and the response is this new UX which has the non-answer 'don't know, but let's keep eyeballs on our site and away from Facebook'.
- md224 9y ago> Particularly when other topic-focused communities already exist i.e. what problem are subreddits solving? Subreddits don’t necessarily solve a problem... they’re just a well-made framework for content sharing and conversation, combining ideas from previous message board systems to provide a good user experience. But it’s the way Reddit combines them that makes them useful, which means I can’t answer this question without answering the following one: > And to invert that to the whole set, what problem is Reddit solving? Maybe I’m misunderstanding you, but the answer seems blatantly obvious to me: it allows you to have all of your communities on a single platform. It creates a kind of meta-community... a user you interact with in one subreddit may show up later in another. Why would you create multiple independent accounts at multiple message boards across the web when you can have one account and one simple feed of relevant posts from all of your communities? > I recoil at the suggestion of signing-up and slogging through curating and filtering until I achieve Reddit Nirvana. Life is too short. I’m honestly perplexed as to why you think setting up a Reddit account is this gargantuan task. You find a few communities based on your interests and you subscribe to them. That’s it. And you don’t have to do it all at once. You can join as many or as few subreddits as you like, whenever you feel like it. I must be missing something here. What topic-focused communities do you prefer? Are you talking about Facebook Groups?
- rnet85 9y agoLike with anything, you need to carefully curate what you consume. Like Twitter, Reddit can be an excellent place if you follow only subreddits that intrigue you.
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoExactly. There are some really good communities on Reddit and really awful communities on Reddit. A couple examples of good ones: /r/homelab /r/homeserver /r/selfhosted
- kmfrk 9y agoThere just aren't any. The same thing goes for the forums (bulletin boards) I go to. But Xenforo is a really polished CMS with some good skins beside the god-awful default one. It's no vBulletin.
- SteveNuts 9y agoTheir redesign looks like something you would have seen in the early 2000s. It's (barely) one step above a Geocities site.
- chomp 9y agoThe redesign is a single page app, so refreshing it is not a normal workload. I can understand a large amount of pageviews on the old site since each person has to constantly reload everything, but in the redesign a user should only have to load everything just once (or a couple times depending on how many tabs they want to open). Or did they address this and I just missed it?
- blutfink 9y agoHeadline is wrong. 68GJ per month, not GW, which is roughly 26kW.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lucb1e 9y agoYes. I was not sure how familiar people are with joules, so as I said in the post: > (In the headline I used GW because people are more familiar with that, and it's kind of the same.) Saying "kind of the same" won't please engineers who know what they're talking about and are used to correct units, but for the general public who won't read beyond the headline and (if I'm lucky) the conclusion, I think it's close enough. I am just hoping to get people's attention to the fact that an inefficiently coded redesign of the 6th largest website on the planet has impact.
- ggg9990 9y agoRather than just being flat out wrong, why not use gigawatt-hours which is a well known unit.
- lucb1e 9y agoBecause I find Wh (or kWh or MWh or...) a very weird unit. The Watt is already a "per second" unit, and the appended hour makes it have a double time component in the definition. While a Wh has a simple joule value (3600 if I'm not mistaken) and so it's directly convertible, I still find it more difficult to wrap my mind around. Joules seem like a better unit, but they're not known to people... but maybe you're right and I should have picked that.
- ggg9990 9y agoAll over the world, the watt-hour is the unit of electrical power consumption among the general public.
- smaili 9y agoGiven the old site was built off of older libraries/frameworks and the newer site is presumably built using more modern ones, wouldn't this be an indicator of latest tools being heavier and/or more bloated?
- nostrademons 9y agoThe old site also did mostly server-side rendering while the new site is largely client-side rendering of structured data. One of those isn't necessarily heavier-weight than the other, but it does shift the energy usage from the company's data-center to the user's computer or mobile device. Server-side rendering also opens up more opportunities for cross-user caching, which AIUI Reddit used extensively.
- majos 9y agoIs shifting costs from servers to clients such a massive savings that it could outweigh annoyed users? I genuinely have no feel for the relevant amounts here.
- nostrademons 9y agoI would bet that both directions were a minor consideration in their plans. A bigger concern is probably development time (much easier to find React developers than Pylons or whatever Reddit used to use now) and the ability to integrate new features like r/thebutton or r/place.
- ItsMe000001 9y agoThe argument is not right though, because the data reddit needs to display can be rendered much faster. Come on, browsers on Giga(!)-Hertz computers (I added the ! because I come from the single-digit MHz era). It requires a lot of attention to detail to make them so slow... /s
- sverige 9y agoI've been using the old format, only partly because of this. Mostly I just prefer the old look -- simpler, cleaner, easier.
- bnolsen 9y agoAlso fewer clicks and no drags required for me in the old interface. They pretty much hid all the useful navigation stuff.
- rland 9y agoI do not understand what extra functionality is gained by making the site so much slower. I go on Reddit primarily for text content. Threaded comments and HTML <a> tags. WHY does it NEED to be so SLOW? For this degree of sluggishness, it feels like you could build a site that fulfills all of reddit's functionality—and have a crypto miner running in the background.
- mmagin 9y agoI had the same feeling when Chase redesigned their online banking and I had to upgrade my dedicated linux banking computer from an old Lenovo Ideapad to a somewhat more powerful old Thinkpad.
- blunte 9y agoWells Fargo took a mediocre but functional site and made a slow and useless site
- kowdermeister 9y agoDo you REALLY think they engineered it intentionally slow?
- greggyb 9y agoA couple of statements followed by a point. Performance is readily acknowledged as a feature.[0] There are gradations of intentionality and prioritization. I don't think anyone said, "Let's make the thing slow." That being said, there was definitely someone(s) out there intentionally prioritizing something(s) other than performance. [0] https://duckduckgo.com/?q=performance+is+a+feature& https://duckduckgo.com/?q=performance+is+a+feature&
- vokep 9y agoYes they did, by not engineering it to be intentionally fast.
- stephengillie 9y agoTo switch from black/white hat hacker to tinfoil hat... who would make money from Reddit's site being slower and using more electricity?
- alistproducer2 9y agoAfter a bunch of back tracking on his much I hate site redesigns I try to give them a chance but this one really takes away from the experience of using reddit.
- trelliscoded 9y agoNo it doesn’t, people don’t leave their devices refreshing reddit 24/7. Also, watts aren’t joules.
- lucb1e 9y ago> people don’t leave their devices refreshing reddit 24/7 But if the new website takes more power, and we know that there are roughly X million pageloads a month, then we know it will use a lot more, right? > watts aren’t joules The very definition of a Watt is one joule per second. Not the same, definitely, but it's close and in specific cases 1:1 convertible.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bitL 9y agoDo something for the environment: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/old-reddit-redirect/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/old-reddit-re... https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/old-reddit-redirect/dneaehbmnbhcippjikoajpoabadpodje https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/old-reddit-redirec...
- frfl 9y agoAnyone from reddit's dev team reading this? Or youtube's dev team, because my question applies to both. The previous design was great. The new version of both sites is slow, sluggish and provides me with no benefit. Why was the change implemented? The previous design wasn't broken! How's the user feedback? A/B testing really indicated to you this was a good choice?! If you have any insight -- I'm sure this was a decision made much higher up than dev -- please do share.
- hnaccy 9y agomake-work
- meesterdude 9y ago> Why was the change implemented? There's no easy back peddling from a year of development. It may be crap, but they put so much time & effort into it they can't turn back now - even if a lot of users hate it. They're also working more on becoming an Advertising platform, and this redesign allows for more flexibility there, like linkedin's auto-play videos when scrolling into view.
- vokep 9y agoNone of that justifies it. They wasted their time, so now everyone has to pay? I don't think so. If the old design wasn't easy to go back to, I'd only view reddit through API based things (app) at this point.
- yongjik 9y agoMy favorite comment from TFA: > None of your math makes sense. All your measurements have only the consumption at one exact instant, not over time, the total energy used is the integral of the energy flow over time. You'd need to measure the consumption over time, or total discharge of the battery, to actually have the energy used to load a page (in J, not W, you can't measure the energy required to load a page in W). > You just multiplied a banana times Pi. And showed the results in meters of strawberries.
- lucb1e 9y agoEveryone's dodging the point of the post (versus the exact numbers and terminology). As I said on reddit as well: > The issue is that the redesign uses more power across millions of devices, and that has an impact. > I might have gotten the exact number wrong, but the exact number doesn't matter that much. It's about it being a significant difference.
- jimrandomh 9y agoSimply put, you don't have the expertise required to measure this. It's not just that you didn't get the exact number, it's that you haven't got a usable measurement at all. For all we know from your tests, the new site uses less power than the old one.
- jonas21 9y ago> I might have gotten the exact number wrong, but the exact number doesn't matter that much. It's about it being a significant difference. Of course the exact number matters. Let's say you're off by a factor of 1000. Then the power difference isn't really worth worrying about.
- hunter23 9y agoHow do you know it's a significant difference if you haven't measured it correctly?
- KirinDave 9y agoThe only reason we're even talking about this article is because of your outrageous number. When folks who recognize how these kind of measurements actually are done say, "this seems extremely wrong" you should definitely expect some pushback. To be honest, this reads to me like a reddit user angry about a site change trying to make a sensational article to protest it, knowing cynically that even if it's very wrong it won't matter, the headline is too sticky for reddit to ignore.
- Proven 9y agoSo what? I pay my own power bill. I am using the old design, because the new is crap.
- Scoundreller 9y agoReddit's Digg moment!
- meesterdude 9y agoI was hesitant to think/say this, because it is a different beast.... but the more i read about what other people think, as well as my own usage of it - it might be. Although to be fair, reddit has had it's fair share of past dramas too. I think it's time we move beyond reddit and build something bigger and better. It was nice while it lasted.
- atwebb 9y agoI keep thinking that can't happen, right now it seems to be because there's not a good competitor. That's a scenario we've seen play out enough in the past, I'm personally waiting for something and have been on reddit since 05/06 time.
- microwavecamera 9y agoWell I could have told you reddit was a waste of energy.
- drharby 9y agoBazinga
- nilkn 9y agoBetween... * feeling completely overrun with sensationalized politics; * the new design feeling sluggish and painful even on my maxed out late-2016 MBP; * the general community feeling more hostile and downvote-heavy than ever before; * and the content being increasingly image-, video-, and meme-focused... reddit has really lost a lot of its magic and appeal to me. I do still use it, but I find it almost intolerable if I'm not logged in with my very carefully curated set of subreddit subscriptions. I don't really know what the solution is. I don't think reddit is dying, but I do think it's becoming something different, and there increasingly feels like there's space for something more like the old reddit to coexist. HN is a considerably higher quality site IMHO, but also considerably more focused and with much stronger moderation.
- darkstar999 9y agoMost of your criticisms are solved by unsubscribing from those bad subreddits like politics, funny, and all the picture/meme ones.
- nilkn 9y agoI don't disagree -- I wrote as much in my own post. The site is okay once I've unsubscribed from virtually everything it throws at you by default and instead subscribed to a heavily curated selection of subreddits that I found over the years. Even then, though, subreddits that used to be great have often degraded significantly -- in many cases simply by getting too big. Perhaps that's the primary difficulty. Even some "niche" subreddits often now have 100k+ users. The site is just so much bigger and more active than it was when I first started using it that it's very difficult to capture what it used to feel like, even with extensive subreddit curation and filtering.
- atwebb 9y agoYour point about the content is true and always tips the hand to Reddit's other issue. The content moves so quick, and the user base switches so much, many subs wind up with the same post/style of posts over and over. The search has at least gotten better and sidebars help somewhat, though the new redesign kills both of those items.
- cool_shit 9y agoI deleted my Reddit account which kept the old design on it. Now when I occasionally browse Reddit as a non-user, it looks like an awful implementation of material design with tons of wasted space. For example, I see about 1.5 cards per page on my 13" laptop. Who designed this? It is horrid and nearly unusable. Not that I'll be using Reddit that much anymore, but it's like they deprecated the desktop version for mobile-everywhere. There's a reason the form factors are different!
- graeme 9y agoInteresting. New users can't access the old design at all?
- dredmorbius 9y agohttps://old.reddit.com https://old.reddit.com I believe it's possible to set that as a default regardless of account age. But it's a PITA.
- pxlt 9y agoThis Chrome extension does it for you: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/old-reddit-redirect/dneaehbmnbhcippjikoajpoabadpodje https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/old-reddit-redirec...
- dredmorbius 9y agoNot on Android ...
- Casseres 9y agohttps://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/old-reddit-redirect/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/old-reddit-re...
- 9y ago
- jacobparker 9y agoShameless plug: Here's a minimal UI for browsing r/politics/rising specifically: * https://www.f6oclock.com https://www.f6oclock.com * https://www.f6oclock.com/#ninja https://www.f6oclock.com/#ninja if you want something more discrete It updates live and throttles way back when the page doesn't have focus.) The default links go through https://outline.com https://outline.com which is a reader-mode like service (sadly it requires JS - I've got a prototype of a non-JS/server-side rendered version here: https://www.f6oclock.com/readability-demo/test.out.html https://www.f6oclock.com/readability-demo/test.out.html ) (viewing the stories from r/politics is a guilty pleasure of mine that I'm a little bit ashamed of.) --- The reddit feed-reading APIs are very easy to use. Just add .json in front of a URL and make sure to send a User-Agent. You can whip up bespoke UIs to suit your particular needs--e.g. I have some things that I send through IRC.
- Whitestrake 9y agoHey, that seems pretty cool. What'd you build it with? Any chance there's a repo I could check out? I'd love to try replicate something similar. Edit: Nevermind, found it - seems like I wasn't looking very hard! https://github.com/j3parker/f6oclock https://github.com/j3parker/f6oclock
- sengork 9y agoIt is time for green web design and green application design (eg. lite versions of applications which are otherwise bloated like Skype with large emoticon animations).
- rajacombinator 9y agoGreat example of why you should not keep designers on staff.
- dingle_thunk 9y agoAnd here are a hundred great examples of why you should: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BMHUKij1yUE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BMHUKij1yUE
- kethinov 9y agoThis is just a symptom of the webdev world's over-reliance on JavaScript to draw interfaces nowadays. The web stack has HTML, CSS, and JavaScript for reason. Quit doing everything in the third layer. Make your stuff with progressive enhancement. Knock off the do-it-all-in-JS stuff and your web apps will perform better.
- hyperpallium 9y agoprotip: https://i.reddit.com https://i.reddit.com
- egfx 9y agoOh wonderful. Domain search. Missing. https://www.reddit.com/domain/news.ycombinator.com/ https://www.reddit.com/domain/news.ycombinator.com/
- ddingus 9y agoI hate it. And I also hate to say that a little bit of spit and polish on old-school Reddit, probably would have done a lot more good, been a lot more lean, and more useful. I would trade all this crap for a little bit better markup language for a few more options in posts and comments.
- myf01d 9y agoReddit new design is amazing, SPA websites are clearly the future, you guys will complain about anything more than just 100% static html pages that can run on lynx
- robbomacrae 9y agoThank you!!
- trumped 9y agoI use the Redirector Firefox addon to make sure that I always visit https://ns.reddit.com https://ns.reddit.com because I hate the new design.
- vit05 9y agoFor me it's not a matter of taste or choice, I just could not use the new model. It's slow and it looked like my laptop had turned into a toaster. The same goes for facebook. And that's why I use it in the mobile version, even when on the laptop.
- CuntyMcCuntface 9y agoIt's decreased the power usage of mine, because now I won't spend time on reddit anymore.
- gremlinsinc 9y agoI never use Reddit outside of Relay ...the app just works perfectly and has everything I need and not all the bloat/ugliness.
- prrrush 9y agoi've also noticed that on every page load, the sidebar pops out for a couple seconds before automatically hiding again. Very annoying. Chrome, Windows.
- kup0 9y agoThe new design fundamentally feels worse to use. It feels slower for sure. I don't mind the cleaner aesthetics, but the animations, layout, and general feel of using the site makes me feel like I'm one one of those blogs that has the "dickbars" and other UI elements that feel more annoying than useful. The mobile site is frustrating as well (but using apps gets around this easily). I've gone back to using the old.reddit.com for now, but who knows how long that will remain
- hokkos 9y agoYou are just browsing the new reddit wrong, stop spawning new tabs from the front page, just click on a thread, it is so mush faster than old reddit because it only load the content, not the whole markup.