45 ms·
IBM bans USB, SD cards, flash drives and portable devices from every office
- bigmattystyles 9y agoSeems like the move addresses accidental data leaks through portable device misplacement. I don't think it can do much to protect against intentional leaking. I mean, they want people to be able to work from anywhere from the sake of business, so I guess this addresses 1 vector. Hopefully, they understand this.
- krona 9y agoWell, it's still not going to stop the general institutional incompetence that permeates the company when it comes to security. For example: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/25/world/europe/ibm-sweden-data-outsourcing.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/25/world/europe/ibm-sweden-d... Keeping sensitive data off the cloud altogether is the more sensible option.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIt's not stuff getting out that's the problem. It's stuff getting in. This move addresses the certainty that if a malicious actor manages to drop a flash drive in the parking lot it's practically certain that it will be plugged in. When you're a large global company like IBM you become the target of lot of groups.
- slededit 9y agoI remember they came to our school to show off their new hot desk software they wrote. Look how efficiently we can use space! I saw it as saying your so unimportant we won't even give you a dedicated desk. Now apparently you can't even use common tools to get the job done. If I had a big meeting I wouldn't take a chance on the network to keep my presentation.
- ghaff 9y agoHot desk-ing mostly makes sense only if you're 1.) short on space and 2.) have a fair number of people who only come in intermittently. Otherwise, you're not really saving anything and you make it harder to find people who aren't sitting in a fixed location. Presentations would be the big inconvenience for me. I always carry a backup on a USB stick when I'm presenting at an event or conference. Just today, I loaded a presentation onto a conference laptop that was supposed to have been preloaded but wasn't. I could probably have worked around by getting the presentation off the network but I never like to depend on WiFi at an event. ADDED: Especially for an external public presentation, I'd get it onto a USB stick one way or the other.
- ggg9990 9y agoHot desking is actually a positive indicator for some people. It means they only expect you in the office intermittently.
- cf498 9y ago>Now apparently you can't even use common tools to get the job done. If I had a big meeting I wouldn't take a chance on the network to keep my presentation. Then you are an active threat to your networks security. You sound like you have an incentive and willingness to put in effort and take personal risks to circumvent the security protocol at your workplace. Looking at employees without bad intents, this is as bad as it gets. This is a great example why social engineering is unlikely to go out of style anytime soon. People who think they know better and are confident in being qualified to take a risk are never in short supply.
- slededit 9y agoFirst, using USB drives was never against security policy at my work - so your personal attacks are unjustified. But secondly my powerpoint presentation isn't exactly top secret classified material. If we were talking about handling the private signing keys I would agree with you. Different types of data have different levels of security needed. Over classifying trivial data just makes it harder to get things done.
- yborg 9y agoMaybe IBM should just ban pockets instead.
- hackme1234 9y agoThere are other places you could hide USB and SD cards ;)
- fhood 9y agoHa! If I worked at IBM they would never catch me. My flash drive is disguised as a tiny sports car! Foolproof! Anyways, did IBM have a big leak recently or something? This seems rather draconian to have been put into place without some fairly strong motivations.
- gaius 9y agoAnyways, did IBM have a big leak recently or something? Yes, this is almost certainly about leaks to publications such as El Reg. Eg. https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/02/26/ibm_gives_services_staff_until_2019_to_get_agile/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/02/26/ibm_gives_services_...
- fhood 9y agoWow, wouldn't want valuable corporate secrets such as your particular form of Agile leaking to outside sources. How devastating.
- abiox 9y agowhen i viewed that link there was an ibm advertisement on the top and an interstitial one as well. couldn't help but chuckle.
- justherefortart 9y agoSlack instead of email? That's hilarious.
- philwelch 9y agoNot to mention sad, soulcrushing, and generally illiterate.
- tpeo 9y agoI too thought of it as being draconian at first but come to think of it, USB drives seem much less important nowadays than they seemed back in 2007. They're still prolific, but they aren't thought of as a boon as they once were. Maybe IBM is onto something.
- awakeasleep 9y agoWithin a business, security has to be understood in the context of risk analysis. Will the measures taken damage the company more than the benefit of the increased security? In my eyes, banning storage media without a practical replacement is on the wrong side of the risk analysis equation. Sure, it's not desirable that files can be moved without full access control and auditing, but if people don't have a tool that works the same way then all your employees who rely on it will suffer. It would have been great to see a standard encrypted portable drive, probably with the decryption software on a different partition establish a foothold in the world. With the addition of DLP software, that could have allowed employees to continue to do their work while mitigating the risk of lost or stolen data. edit: what this doesn't cover is transferring large files quickly, or transferring files to a computer that isn't currently configured with the systems required for file transfers.
- theandrewbailey 9y agoIn this case, is cloud storage not a practical replacement?
- Something1234 9y agoThe analog loophole. If I can access the resources from my local device. The odds are I can get a copy of it without the protections on it.
- rtkwe 9y agoWith the rise of VPNs, fast home internet, and fairly ubiquitous public wifi along with laptops gaining enough power for most applications the question is what's the real use case that requires removable media that can't be accomplished with an internal FTP/network drive/email and using company laptops?
- lb1lf 9y agoOffshore work, for instance. Lots and lots of vessels have painfully slow satellite links - think <=64kbps - whereas the others mostly have very slow satellite links - ~512kbps. Trust me, in such conditions you do not want to cough and ask whether you can download your training material off the corporate VPN... (Heck, in many cases, shipowner policy prevents any third party computer from being connected to any onboard IT infrastructure, anyway.)
- amelius 9y agoProduct idea: a dongle with male & female USB connector, that you can place between USB drive and computer, and which catches possible security violations.
- pkaye 9y agoThere is already some Windows software that monitor the USB ports for storage devices and blocks them.
- beefok 9y agoUntil 'they' figure out a way to tunnel through the dongle for yet more security violations, haha.
- Kadin 9y agoThere are lots of forensics tools which block USB writes to prevent modification of data on drives under analysis. However, the solution is to create tools that are easier to use and get the job done better than USB pen-drives. IBM seems to be all about the stick, no carrot. If they really enforce this (and as a former IBMer, I can tell you they are really long on pronouncements and very short on actual follow-through) I just foresee people bringing more laptops and multiple laptops around into places they previously would have brought a USB drive. E.g. if you can't easily move that Powerpoint from Laptop A to Laptop B because you're in some low-bandwidth hellhole, well, guess you're bringing both laptops along for the ride.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Retra 9y agoAll USB data already has to go through your USB drivers. So you've got a software solution vector right there.
- amelius 9y agoYeah, but software can be mismanaged. Perhaps a solution would be a combination of the two. E.g. dongle converts USB protocol to (say) XYZ protocol, and software converts from XYZ protocol to readable filesystem.
- cepth 9y agoThis is already standard practice for several industries. For example, you’d be hard pressed to find a pharma company nowadays that allows the use of any removable media. The likely “replacement” is that IBM employees will have to use some sort of corporate VPN to work remotely.
- kevinSuttle 9y agoThey already do.
- forgotmysn 9y agoI thought IBM was ending their remote work options?
- ascagnel_ 9y agoRemote work and working remotely are two very different things. The former usually refers to making your own arrangements for normal working hours outside of commuting to a corporate office; the latter usually refers to off-hours or one-off arrangements. IBM may not want people remote working, but they'll be happy to have people working remotely at nights, on weekends, etc.
- kevinSuttle 9y agoRight. Even when you're on a campus and not on the employee SSID, you need to VPN in.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- collinf 9y agoWhat sort of Fortune x00 company doesn't use a corporate VPN?
- joombaga 9y ago
- genericone 9y agoThis is common at many semiconductor companies. Not only is it a ban at one specific semiconductor oem I know of, the usb-ports are disabled and the usb-ports on new issue computers are epoxied to prevent trying to use them. Semiconductor technology is one of the areas of global-technological competition which surely benefit from secrecy. For example, several years ago one of the c-level executives at this specific OEM was caught taking pictures inside of one of their customer's facility. Only the engineering staff from that oem is allowed inside those facilities now, and only for maintenence activity. It's a very secret industry, and getting even tighter now since China has been blocked from acquiring the latest semiconductor technology. China has so far invested over $40 billion in boosting their chip-making abilities, to acquire capital, IP, and knowledge-workers. Given their history of borrowing technology from other countries without attribution, if I were at the head of a semiconductor related company, I would clamp down on the secrets ahead of the danger.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoAre cases locked / glued shut? It seems like it would be easy enough to connect a new usb header...
- rasz 9y agoor unplug a mouse for 5 seconds
- Lionsion 9y agoIf you're going through the trouble of epoxying USB ports, you could probably epoxy the mouse to its port as well. Or just monitor connected USB devices and shutdown if something unapproved is installed, a la USBKill. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USBKill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USBKill
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIf mouse is epoxied - cut the cable, cut and splice in a male->female cable, connect your device.
- mc32 9y agoDon’t FB and Goog already do this in practice if not completely enforced (i.e. epoxying the connectors). What’s the news about this?
- Ftuuky 9y agoThis is also something very common in banking.
- Lev1a 9y agoAnd hospitals (not the glueing part, but the blocking of anything that's recognized as a USB storage medium).
- Pamar 9y agoAbsolutely - I don't understand why this is "new", "odd" or "difficult". I work for an European company (travel/tourism) and the day they hired me (4 years ago) I got a corporate laptop with Windows 7 which would accept usb mouses, keyboards, charge smartphones... but would not "mount" anything that had storage. Interestingly enough I can connect my (personal) iPhone, and I can read pictures stored there, but I cannot write to it - I haven't tried installing iTunes because I don't need to backup to my work laptop so no idea how it would work with dedicated sw, but for sure there is no need to use epoxy glue or physical locks. (Granted, I never tried to see how strong the protection was because it's not my specialty and frankly I don't care, but it looks like it works well enough as it is).
- salgernon 9y agoI met with a medical specialist at a huge hospital in New York - I had a usb drive with about 50G imaging data (pet, ct, mri) and they refused to access it. Fortunately I was also hosting it on my own server in various formats - nope, they can’t access the external network. I ended up burning the whole set to a spindle of dvds, which they could then import .. and shred.
- mc32 9y ago
- rubidium 9y agoOffice workers will be fine. It's the field people that are going to have it rough. Even the best 4G LTE stick won't matter if you're installing in the basement of a huge complex.
- mseebach 9y agoFirst, if USB sticks are out for data exfil reasons, 4G sticks (and anything else that isn't a HID device) are out as well. Second, such networks generally have an approved way of getting data on to them, typically involves handing your USB stick or DVD to someone with access to a particular machine with unblocked ports and specially firewalled off access to a particular shared drive on the network, and nothing else.
- rasz 9y agoHow will they work with no phones?
- Lev1a 9y agoThere's no reference to them intending to ban phones in the article, at least not that I could find. The "portable devices" in the actual body of the article is phrased differently from the title, like so: portable storage devices like a USB, SD card, or flash drive
- monocasa 9y agoSurprised it took them so long. Outside of exfiltration, there's the issue with sketch USB sticks with malware making their way on to your network. It's amazing how many people will plug in any flash drive they find in a parking lot.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoThere's a very large Cryptocurrency convention taking place in New York right now, and I wonder how many USB drives are "lost" in the area.
- programminggeek 9y ago$1 says they give out IBM branded USB keys at trade shows ;-)
- jacquesm 9y agoThe question is what's on them ;)
- kevinSuttle 9y agoJust another act of IBM's security theatre, and a testament to their backwards views on employee experience.
- chiph 9y agoYou're not wrong on their poor employee experience, but there's very little theater involved - there's good reason to protect their IP. Any firm that invests multi-millions in original design will want to protect their property from theft. Semiconductors were mentioned, but also think about someone like Pixar.
- kevinSuttle 9y agoThe thing is, what's stopping employees from uploading files to a server? The physical devices are a fraction of a fraction of IP theft. Hence the term "theatre".
- jacquesm 9y agoHopefully a firewall.
- racingmars 9y agoPresumably they use network security devices and can see every bit of data that leaves their network to flag possible exfil. Devices like those in use at a company I used to work for man-in-the-middle all HTTPS traffic (using certificates from a CA that corporate IT pushes to all workstations/phones under corporate control, so they're trusted), man-in-the-middles SSH traffic (presumably assuming users just always answer "yes" to the "is this the right key?" question, or the user says no in which case the connection is effectively blocked, so either way the network security device wins), etc. Data exfiltration via USB key is a very real threat that is largely invisible to the company when it happens... no audit trail or anything to look back at.
- chiph 9y agoA business like this is likely to have a WebSense network appliance, and/or policy enforcement software on the desktops.
- lsiebert 9y agoMost android phones can function as portable storage devices, but I don't see them banning them.
- agumonkey 9y agoI hope employees don't use sonoff wifi plugs :)
- tgsovlerkhgsel 9y agoIs there something particularly bad about Sonoff (as opposed to most other IoT devices, where the saying "the S in IoT stands for security" applies)?
- agumonkey 9y agonah just that its the cheap mainstream model
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- prudhvis 9y agoWould it be possible to just disable the usb driver from the OS(or just limit it, to a very very few tasks). Without it being a burden for UX purposes. One could argue that an exploit might be written in such a way that, it could be triggered before the OS boots from the BIOS. But, at that point, any external user-land exploit would provide the same level of access to sensitive data.
- gaius 9y agoWould it be possible to just disable the usb driver from the OS For that you would need the capabilities of a world-class IT outsourcing company.
- acdha 9y ago> Would it be possible to just disable the usb driver from the OS(or just limit it, to a very very few tasks). Yes, but think about what verifying that would look like. Epoxy is much easier to install and it doesn't disappear 3 months later when a Windows update ships.
- emilfihlman 9y agoBanning removable media is 100% the right direction (of course there needs to be exceptions for DSLRs and install media and whatnot, duh) The amount of idiocy I've seen with storing sensitive and work intensive documents in USB sticks is horrible.
- alexanderdmitri 9y agoyeah, except this is why it's happening now: https://features.propublica.org/ibm/ibm-age-discrimination-american-workers/t https://features.propublica.org/ibm/ibm-age-discrimination-a...:
- edeion 9y agoFixed link: https://features.propublica.org/ibm/ibm-age-discrimination-american-workers/ https://features.propublica.org/ibm/ibm-age-discrimination-a...
- Rafuino 9y agoInteresting but seems kind of late, no? Even the US State Department has banned USB drives since at least 2008. I don't think US government is particularly well known for being good at security.
- sailfast 9y agoAgreed - this doesn't seem like that big a step at all from a security perspective. The main change is that it will now force a bunch of folks to think about how they manage their data and their consulting teams especially will get annoyed with how "hard" it is to transfer that powerpoint deck for their presentation. Leaving data lying around on a stick is one vector. Malware and other considerations is quite another that should be discussed more often. Especially if your posture is jelly-filled. I'm guessing they got burned here at least once with a relatively large dataset that somebody left in a cafe somewhere.
- HillaryBriss 9y agoagree. US defense contractors limited moving electronic media in/out of their facilities back in the 90s, i think.
- jpalomaki 9y agoIt’s one thing to ban stuff and another to actually provide practical solutions for people so that they can continue working. Banning stuff looks good on paper, but sometimes the clever work arounds people invent are then much worse than the original thing. Practical example from past. Policy denies creating user accounts for externals. In big orgs you anyways sometimes have the need to have some external do work on systems. Idealistic view is that employee baby sits the ext guy and performs everything on behalf of him. But in reality people have their own work and deadlines, so it becomes tempting to just log on and let the ext work on your credentials.
- hb3b 9y agoRight, they need to prevent the innovation from leaking out -_-
- 6nf 9y agoThey're just trying to keep Watson contained
- 13years 9y agoIf this is about security of leaking things out, is IBM also ending their open web policy? Otherwise I fail to see the point, anyone could easily just send anything to anywhere over the net. Don't need a USB. Therefore, It seems to me this is about unintentional leaks of information, not intentional.
- jacquesm 9y agoMost companies that are somewhat serious about their business and the privacy of their clients (and their clients' clients) have a removable media policy. IBM's is nothing special in that respect. Besides cutting down on exfiltration vectors it also nicely takes care of some ways in which you might end up with malware on your corporate systems. If your company does not have some kind of removable media policy then you are probably working for a very small company.
- asah 9y agocellphones? cellphone tethering?
- brian-armstrong 9y agoPreventing exfiltration? Nobody tell them about my library [1], they'll need to ban line out ports and headphones :) 1: https://quiet.github.io/quiet-js https://quiet.github.io/quiet-js
- wyldfire 9y agoAwesome! A GMSK modem in js? Good on you. Submit for show HN? Have you tried other modulations?
- brian-armstrong 9y agoThanks! It made the rounds on show HN a couple years ago. Also my dirty secret is that it isn't really JS, it's C via emscripten https://github.com/quiet/quiet https://github.com/quiet/quiet Currently supports everything Liquid DSP supports which is GMSK, PSK, QAM, OFDM and a lot more. Working on adding DSSS soon edit: Here's a sort of lab/playground https://quiet.github.io/quiet-profile-lab https://quiet.github.io/quiet-profile-lab
- Sammi 9y agoSo what transmission rate can you hope to get with this?
- brian-armstrong 9y agoDepends quite a bit on what you have. I've seen about 10 kbps over air and 64 kbps over cable
- AstralStorm 9y agoIt is pretty conspicuous over the air though. It also won't get rid of watermarks. TEMPEST is probably easier and more reliable than this.
- JdeBP 9y agoThis is a third-hand story. Most of it is lifted verbatim from the PCMag article ... * https://www.pcmag.com/news/361098/ibm-employees-cant-use-removable-storage-anymore https://www.pcmag.com/news/361098/ibm-employees-cant-use-rem... ... which is in turn sourced from an article in The Register. * https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/05/10/ibm_bans_all_removable_storage_for_all_staff_everywhere/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/05/10/ibm_bans_all_remova...
- floatingatoll 9y agoI emailed hn@ycombinator.com to ask the admins to fix this.
- ssharwood 9y agoThank you so much for pointing that out! As the author of the original, it's irksome to see kudos (and revenue) go to outlets that re-re-report a story.
- dang 9y agoOk, we've changed to that original URL from https://boingboing.net/2018/05/10/ibm-bans-usb-sd-cards-flash.html https://boingboing.net/2018/05/10/ibm-bans-usb-sd-cards-flas.... Thanks!
- ssharwood 9y agoGosh, thanks! Certainly didn't expect the change or want to be seen as asking for it. But it's lovely that you did it so thanks!
- dang 9y agoWe much prefer to have original sources. This is in the site guidelines actually: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- BasHamer 9y agoSo what they are saying is that every car in the employee parking lot will have a cellphone in it? Wouldn't that cause a lot of break-ins?
- notananthem 9y agoThis is really common and good practice
- jackconnor 9y agoThis is a security move to prevent more documents getting leaked. They're under fire for the ageism layoffs, which were partially verified by leaked docs, and so they probably got paranoid. Not that they shouldn't take this measure regardless. But there's a very specific reason it's happening now.
- TYPE_FASTER 9y agoWorked at a financial institution ~10yrs ago, they pushed out a group policy change to not allow USB ports for storage for security reasons while I was there.
- antoineMoPa 9y agoThis is nice until you have to transfer 78.2GB for one project and the transfer takes many hours.
- 6nf 9y agoCopying large files to and from USB storage is probably slower than just copying across their internal network.
- benzesandbetter 9y agoWell, treating your employees like middle schoolers is one way to quickly get rid of the remaining talent.
- squarefoot 9y agoThis is going to hurt everyone but really motivated hackers in there. If I had to smuggle some data out of a PC I'd use the audio card at a very low volume but known frequencies to output the data the FSK way, leaving a phone near the speaker recording the audio, then at home I'd reconstruct the data just as old modems did 40 years ago. Other methods could also be used: blinking a pixel (or the optical mouse led left on the phone camera), raising the cpu power usage by making it run busy loops according to data ones and zeroes (nobody would object a bluetooth power consumption measurement device connected to the PCs mains cord), or manipulating innocuous fields into IP packets such as the Time To Live: make it higher than X and it's a one, make it lower and it'a a zero; routers will ignore the trivial difference but a passive (100% undetectable) tap into the network cable still allows to sniff the data. Actually, unless the infrastructure is instructed to report Ethernet frames sent to wrong addresses, one could send malformed frames carrying data into the payload so that they could be ignored at switch level but still readable by a tap on the cable: that would allow data smuggling at blazing fast speeds, much higher than USB.
- slics 9y agoIn many ways it can be stated: “the worst thing about security is too much security”. People always try to find ways to bypas security simply just to do their job.
- d0ugie 9y agoPerhaps fairly inevitable eventual breaches of client data are more forgivable when a given firm can point to efforts such as this as evidence of having tried to keep a lid on leaks, and to elevate confidence that it is less likely to happen. From what I've seen some firms' internal security practices in general seem more to be about appearances whereas other firms tighten and scrutinize everything as if the company's reputation and survival depended on it.
- zippitydoodah68 9y agoGood for them.