14 ms·
SpaceX's plan to fly you across the globe in 30 minutes [video]
- api 9y agoThere is definitely a market for this. When you hit really high levels of the corporate or governmental world, time becomes enormously more valuable than money. The market might bear a cost many times that of a private jet flight if the time were this short. This is an incredible idea for subsidizing the Mars rocket program via rapid transit for executives, heads of state, etc. Of course it would also have to be demonstrated to be at least as safe as air travel first before it would hit the mainstream in that market.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- trevyn 9y ago>time becomes enormously more valuable than money In some sense this is true, but keep in mind you're not actually creating more time -- time spent on business jets can be quite productive, in-person encounters are not always necessary, and it is often possible to use scheduling to get two powerful people in a room together when they happen to be near each other anyway. Also not sure if the video goes into this, but rocket launches are LOUD, and so tend to be away from densely populated areas -- plan on another 20-30 minutes on each side to get to/from the pad. (Maybe tunnels will help with this? Load yourself into a tunnel pod, which then gets robotically loaded on the rocket, so door-to-door transport? Man, the future's gonna be sweet!)
- grendelt 9y ago20-30 minutes for checked luggage. 20-30 minutes for security groping. 20-30 minutes waiting for that idiot to find his seat. 20-30 minutes waiting for luggage or the carousel.
- selectodude 9y agoPutting on a pressure suit, guaranteeing your body can handle 5-6 Gs sustained for a few minutes, having a death rate of 1.5 percent.
- programbreeding 9y agoFlying a VIP (semi-private) airline avoids all of this, and surely anyone that would take a rocket is already flying a fully private airline. Using this as an example because I make this trip often: I can fly Cincinnati, OH to Charlotte, NC on a VIP airline for $500 round trip. I drive my car right up to the plane, and there is a rental car waiting for me at the plane exit on the other side. The entire plane is first class only. There is no baggage check, no TSA, no nothing. I can walk on to the plane 5 minutes before takeoff.
- ben_w 9y agoAs I recall, that was the justification for Concorde. The market said otherwise, and that was before video conferencing had become too cheap to meter.
- Retric 9y agoConcorde was run at a significant profit for years. R&D costs where not recuperated, but that that's just a question of scale.
- adventured 9y agoIt was in fact the justification for the first commercial airplane travel in general. Initially only well off people traveled by commercial passenger plane. It was extremely dangerous and very uncomfortable. Fortunately we didn't stop our pursuit of progress due to such challenges. Now 3.5 billion or so passengers take extraordinarily safe, comfortable flights every year.
- icc97 9y agoConcorde is about 4x faster than an airliner with a fairly limited range. BFR is 10x faster with global range. The point being that you can do 10x the trips and make 10x the money compared to airlines. Plus there's no taxiing around an airport. It's purely refuel and go. Even if my numbers are out Concorde was borderline viable and BFR should be more capable of bringing in money. Plus you go into frigging space. Branson wants to sell just that, this gets you into space and down to China. Another advantage I can think of over Concorde is that there should be more space and the trip is only ever 30-40 mins, so no cramping up in the seat. Finally a Concorde ticket was about $12,000, BFR was mentioned to be $1-2k at the end of the video.
- ben_w 9y agoThat ticket price is definitely relevant. For some reason I thought Concorde was “only” $2500. However, your point about cramped space made me realise that although the BFR isn’t going to be volume limited, that’s because it’s mass limited. Every 10kg of luggage will add about $250 to the price.
- cletus 9y agoWhile I agree with you that there's a desire for this I'm not yet convinced there's a market for it. As you say, this needs to be proven to be at least as safe as air travel. Beyond that, for certain wealthy individuals, government dignitaries and the like commercial flight represents an unacceptable risk and cost in time eg Apple's board requires Tim Cook to fly private now. Next, if the launch and landing pads are indeed offshore and otherwise remotely, this adds travel time at either end. Also, rockets are subject to weather much more than planes are. If your landing pad is offshore then those weather effects are more pronounced as you have to deal with sea conditions too. Lastly, current SpaceX landing is a "dead stop" approach (vertical velocity is designed to hit 0 when altitude is 0), which seems like it may not have the safety margins for mass transit. Future designs may of course improve on this. So much as we'd like this, I'm not yet sure how we get there. Planes have to log many thousands of hours to be certified for passenger flight. Will we have enough launches to certify rockets this way? Even reusable rockets are, in comparison to planes, expendable because they're combusting huge amounts of fuel. Like I don't see you reusing the same rocket every day for 30 years like you can with a plane.
- mongol 9y agoI don't understand your point about dead stop approach. What would be the alternative?
- cletus 9y agoIt's an issue of safety margins. Just consider the airplane. - A two-engine plane can operate on just one engine - In the event of losing power or losing both engines, a plane has a certain glide capability - Runways are built allowing a certain amount of overshooting - A bad approach allows you to circle back around and try again - Planes can land and takeoff with significant winds and precipitation (including cross winds) - A plane can actually land in a body of water (as happened on the Hudson). Now compare the safety margins for a dead stop rocket reentering from space at Mach 30.
- skykooler 9y ago
- gldalmaso 9y agoI have yet to see any mention of how the passenger experience is going to be. I assume it is much worse than some ear pain on take off and landing. Can the average person handle this trip comfortably? Or do they have to pass some astronaut-like conditioning test?
- mieseratte 9y ago> Or do they have to pass some astronaut-like conditioning test? I wonder about military applications. One would imagine that special forces groups would meet requirements. Being able to move SEALs around the world in a matter of minutes would be a boon for force projection.
- DmenshunlAnlsis 9y agoRocket launches take a certain amount of planning and favorable weather. Plus, they are impossible to hide. All in all, not desirable.
- mieseratte 9y agoAh, I forget that rockets are no where close to planes... At best one could maybe speed up pre-planned movements, as opposed to allowing a QRF to more rapidly react.
- regularfry 9y agoSome of the things Burt Rutan has said over the years imply that this niche is already filled.
- computerex 9y agoForget about comfort. Rocket engines are dangerous and unreliable compared to planes and any other mode of transportation. People aren't going to tolerate the risk.
- Klathmon 9y ago
- Shivetya 9y agoI am still awaiting a day when you can be projected anywhere and acceptance of it as a means of face to face. The old hologram style of science fiction interaction.
- newlaptopnewacc 9y ago"SpaceX's plan to fly richer people than me across the globe in 30 minutes"
- arijun 9y agoI'm surprised they're talking bout having the landing pad 10km off shore--it seems like that wouldn't be far enough for noise reduction, both outgoing (rocket engines) and incoming (sonic booms).
- Retric 9y agoDoubling the distance only gives you a 6db drop. So, the best approach is probably to have structures in the way to redirect sounds. Which should make a dramatic difference.
- greedo 9y agoUnless the structure was miles high, wouldn't the sound just bypass it as it climbed above?
- nwah1 9y agoGuess we have to build a dome around the city.
- Retric 9y agoThis mostly deals with ignition and static firing where the rocket is not moving. Rockets have ridiculous acceleration, but create a lot of noise on the ground. I assume being kind of noisy for 5-10 seconds a few times a day is not that big a deal. Assuming ~20 stories aka 200 feet is reasonable at 100 feet per second acceleration aka just over 3 g's in 2 seconds the base of your rocket is just over the 20 story building and your doing 130 MPH. Even still that building is still going to be blocking a lot of sound as the fire is below that level. 7 seconds after launch your (5 after clearing the building) your doing 477 mph and have traveled 1/2 a mile. At 12 seconds your doing 820 mph and have traveled 2 kilometers up. PS: Falcon Heavy is apparently ~160db vs 120db for thunder, which you can barely hear at 10km. So, it's going to be noticeable at 10km, but not that noticeable.
- taf2 9y agoI was thinking this was the use case for Hyperloop and the boring company... take an underground shuttle to the launch pad in 30 minutes or less...
- computerex 9y agoThis has been addressed and debunked by: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phil_Mason https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phil_Mason My apologies for not including the link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4KR4-TN-Yo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4KR4-TN-Yo He raises excellent points imo.
- constantlm 9y agoWhat? Where?
- Tade0 9y agoFor a guy working as a "scientist" he's pretty ignorant when it comes to basic chemistry. His "debunking" of Goodenough's battery shows that he doesn't understand the difference in the way energy is stored in carbohydrates vs batteries.
- computerex 9y agoHe has a PhD in chemistry. I don't know about the Goodenough's battery debunking, but imo his analysis on BFR Earth-Earth flights is spot on.
- Tade0 9y ago> He has a PhD in chemistry. If that's so then I find his videos intentionally misleading and remain skeptical. Edit: added newline.
- agildehaus 9y agoHis comparison of the Shuttle to SpaceX reusability is pretty bad considering how non-reusable the Shuttle actually was and how almost none of the reasons behind the Shuttle's problems apply to Falcon 9 or BFR. I think noise/safety are the real show stoppers. You can get the noise down by moving it further away from civilization, but I think the distance required would simply be too far. I also don't think a rocket will ever approximate the safety of a plane with current tech. If it was 10x more dangerous than a heavy aircraft (which is highly optimistic) would anyone go? I think SpaceX can make it work, can make it affordable to some degree, but making it a practical form of travel is ... yeah, no. I have no problem with them trying though. Their money.
- ben_w 9y agoThis, combined with all the tech needed for a Mars colony, would make it trivial to build a permanent settlement in Antarctica. A domed, self-sufficient, city in Antarctica would also be a cheap way to test most (not all) of the tech needed for Martian self-sufficiency, along with the psychological impact of living in a desolate wasteland where rockets are the only way in or out, and it would be a good insurance policy against many possible global catastrophes.
- pilom 9y agoWe already have domed cities in Antarctica that test the psychological impact of living in desolate wastelands. It is in fact so desolate there that we can't physically access those places for months at a time and rockets wont change that one bit. You literally can not move a person to or from the South Pole research station for months of the year. Rockets aren't the tech needed.
- ben_w 9y agoWe have domed villages, not cities. Musk is aiming for a million, dynamics might be different. Or not, I’m not a psychologist.
- dogma1138 9y agoWe already are doing that there is no need to do it in Antarctica since there is an atmosphere there and the soil isn't toxic. Deserts, volcanic landscape like those of Hawaii and even a large enough basement would be just as good of a simulation without needing to worry about the environmental impact in Antarctica. And plus we already have a "city" there.
- jonathankoren 9y agoI often think about this Bruce Sterling quote on The WELL from 2004: ``I'll believe in people settling Mars at about the same time I see people settling the Gobi Desert. The Gobi Desert is about a thousand times as hospitable as Mars and five hundred times cheaper and easier to reach. Nobody ever writes "Gobi Desert Opera" because, well, it's just kind of plonkingly obvious that there's no good reason to go there and live. It's ugly, it's inhospitable and there's no way to make it pay. Mars is just the same, really. We just romanticize it because it's so hard to reach.``
- stuaxo 9y agoAh, the HOTOL from the 80s.
- gnode 9y agoExcept this isn't HOrizontal TakeOff and Landing, as I understand it?
- JulianMorrison 9y agoCompletely dissimilar except for being a cylinder with stubby wings. It's not single stage to orbit, it's vertical launch, it only has rockets not an air breathing engine, It's not a space-place, and it's interplanetary. Much simpler and builds on established technologies.
- akavel 9y agoCan somebody tl;dr what is new in there? I tried jumping through the video, but there seems to be a lot of fluff and background exposition for the assumed "not in the loop audience" of TED. So I'm not sure where some new stuff starts, if at all, for someone moderately aware that Falcon Heavy did succeed, and BFR is planned?
- icc97 9y agoNothing new, all from old footage.
- godelski 9y ago> and the longest part of the trip is the boat trip In other words, how to make human pancakes in 30 minutes. But really, these are ballistic trajectories. Are we going to put everyone in G suits? And you're going to really restrict who can/will go on. They will likely go slower, so everyone doesn't have to go through endurance training. Plus, being 5k-10k out from land, the total trip is definitely going to take much longer than 30 mins (yeah shorter than the airline flight), to get people on to the boat, onto the rocket, baggage loading, etc. It takes about 30 minutes between when they start loading people onto a plane and when they take off (and baggage is already on!). Let's be real, if they get it working, it will be 2-3hrs trip. Which is still great, but not 30 minutes.
- schiffern 9y ago>But really, these are ballistic trajectories. Are we going to put everyone in G suits? I assume you mean because minimum-energy ballistic trajectories[1] come into the atmosphere very steeply, so the G-forces are much higher. But by using flatter trajectories (closer to an orbit than a parabolic "hop"), you reduce the angle of entry considerably, at the expense of using more fuel. The result is that for Earth-to-Earth rockets, essentially all trip distances require the same amount of fuel. >It takes about 30 minutes between when they start loading people onto a plane and when they take off (and baggage is already on!). I wonder if they can pack baggage into a lightweight "carriage" during the boat ride, the simply load that single carriage onto the rocket. Or even a few carriages. It will incur a mass penalty ("box within a box"), which means fewer passengers. But if it speeds up total trip time it could improve competitiveness with long-distance plane trips. Either that, or just force everyone to buy SpaceX-brand standardized luggage that's ultra mass-efficient and supports automated handling/loading. :) [1] http://hopsblog-hop.blogspot.com/2014/06/travel-on-airless-worlds.html http://hopsblog-hop.blogspot.com/2014/06/travel-on-airless-w...
- greglindahl 9y agoYou mean pack baggage in containers like the ones already used for cargo on large passenger aircraft? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_load_device https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_load_device