3 ms·
This is because Chinese recycling companies underbid most of their western (more local) competition, essentially putting them out of business. Because the Chin
by joe_the_user 9y ago
This is because Chinese recycling companies underbid most of their western (more local) competition, essentially putting them out of business.
Because the Chinese do an inadequate job of disposing of the waste of Western countries, so their costs are less, so this Western waste winds-up in the oceans with stops in China and the folks in charge in the Western nations more or less let this happen.
But your post does a job of framing this chain of events as if China was entirely at fault. A bit reflection should show the reader this isn't the case.
- seanmcdirmid 9y ago> But your post does a job of framing this chain of events as if China was entirely at fault. I did say that Western countries should have proactively prevented this through trade restrictions. Free trade sucks when your trading partner doesn't care about pooping in their own yard for some short term gain. Sometimes developed western countries need to step up because the other country is being irresponsible and just can't manage to do the right thing for their own interests on their own.
- joe_the_user 9y agoGood point
- Sabinus 9y agoExactly. Free trade only works well if both countries are playing by the same rules. Which I guess is why trade deals take years and hundreds of diplomat hours to arrange.
- Clubber 9y agoThere is no motivation to stop it. China doesn't want to do it because they would have to hike prices to offset the cost, thus making them less competitive. US companies don't want to change anything because they don't want to start paying for proper disposal either. Also, free trade is freedom from regulations / tariffs, etc. I always thought it was free to compete (i.e. anti-trusts / monopoly). Silly me. So it could be said this is a direct result of free trade in it's classical economic term. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_trade https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_trade
- caf 9y agoConsidering that China has now banned importing most of this kind of waste, it seems likely that the waste operators weren't operating in accordance with government policy in the first place.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoYes, but since China lacks much rule of law its not like there was any hope they would act accordingly in the first place. The only kind of regulations that really work in China are heavy handed ones (ban to-recycle-waste from entering at all, ban coal from being used at all, etc...).
- L_226 9y agoFYI, China has recently upped the purity requirement for recycling imports. This is causing a somewhat large and expanding issue in Australia, where waste exporters who previously could offshore recycling collections from municipal councils cheaply, now must warehouse and sort that waste before China will allow it to be imported.[0] [0] - https://www.businessinsider.com.au/australia-recycling-crisis-2018-2 https://www.businessinsider.com.au/australia-recycling-crisi...