12 ms·
> By and large, it doesn't, very well. I know Twitter isn't known for being the best at advertising, but it was made exceptionally clear to me that online adv
by madeofpalk 9y ago
> By and large, it doesn't, very well.
I know Twitter isn't known for being the best at advertising, but it was made exceptionally clear to me that online advertising is a massive bunch of lies when I did my GDPR Twitter data export and it included me in a bunch of incorrect, non-sensical and contradictory ad targeting groups.
Twitter claims I:
* Own a cat, dog and other animal (I don't)
* Have between $100k- $999k liquid investible assets (I don't)
* Have a net worth between $1 and $1m (cool - I own *something*)
* Am highly affluent (/shrug)
* Am a high spender (okay...)
* Am a frugal spender (...but how can I be both a high spender AND frugal)
* Own a house (I don't)
* Have multiple families (I don't)
I was very disappointed that the Google and Facebook data exports don't contain this data. Maybe it's for their best.
- rebuilder 9y agoFor the frugal/high spender conflict, I can kind of see how that might happen. I try to buy quality goods because cheap stuff doesn't last. That means spending more up front to spend less in the long run. So frugal, but also maybe high spender? My mom always says: if you're poor, you can't afford to buy cheap.
- madeofpalk 9y agoI guess the 'spoiler' is that I'm fortunate enough to certainly not be a frugal spender. Yet another data point they have about me that they sell, but is completely incorrect.
- walshemj 9y agoI think this might be it eg spending $250 instead of $50 on shoes or boots for longer life and improved comfort.
- pishpash 9y ago$250 shoes do not last 5 times as long as $50 shoes. Improved comfort is the main benefit.
- ebullientocelot 9y agoThe math can work out in some cases. I've had my 400$ Allen Edmunds for 8 years, some wear, but generally still in fantastic shape and very comfortable. Prior to getting them I bought 1-3 pairs of ~70$ department store shoes per year.
- zaarn 9y agoUsually it's very anecdotal and hard to tell ahead of time. My current shoes cost 40€ and that was about 4 years ago. So they have lasted atleast half as long as your expensive shows for 1/10th the price.
- perl4ever 9y agoI have some inexpensive Chinese-made boots that are over a decade old, I think. It can't be the norm that shoes last 4 months, unless you are talking about wearing down the soles of running shoes.
- walshemj 9y agoeasier to repair also
- pishpash 9y agoThat almost never works for the reason you describe. For any quality item that lasts M times as long as the cheap item, you can almost always find N > M such that you can buy N copies of the cheap item for the price of one quality item. You do not spend less in the long run, though you can convince yourself of that. The primary effect of buying cheap is not financial, it's that you're dealing with less quality over the entire usage lifetime (hence getting less utility out of it) and the replacement effort has cost (but which for poor people is very little by definition).
- concerned_user 9y agoIt is probably because they have to show you the categories/tags but they are not required to show you the exact percentage/probability. So in their db they have it like 80% frugal spender, 15% high spender but when exported you see it as a yes/no which is confusing.
- d1zzy 9y agoAll things equal (features that I need from the product) I like to buy high quality things because they make me feel good (they look well built, they give me this warm feeling inside that I got my money's worth). But I realize this is all emotional and rationally I shouldn't, in most cases. I don't think they pay off long term, at least it seems heavily dependent on the product type. That's because we are playing a lottery game, even if this product breaks in 0.1% cases vs 5% cases for a much cheaper product, we're not buying large numbers of them, we're buying just one and while the probability to break on me is smaller it can still happen and the monetary loss would be much larger than if I were to buy the cheaper product. That is, the warranty doesn't scale with the price (the expensive top quality TV is $2000 and the cheaper one is $500 and both have 1 year of warranty), for the same money I can buy 4 of those $500 TVs and would last at least 4 years (but very likely to find at least one that will work much longer, since I'm buying up to 4 of them).
- jlmorton 9y ago> I was very disappointed that the Google and Facebook data exports don't contain this data. Facebook has it available, if not in their Download Your Information tool. Go to Settings -> Ads -> Your Information -> Categories.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- madeofpalk 9y agoMine says "You do not have any behaviors in your ad" preferences. https://i.imgur.com/giAxfiF.png https://i.imgur.com/giAxfiF.png But interesting page. Looking at the "advertisers who have added your details to their targeting list" it again shows how bullshit this industry is: * Playstation in 19 countries * Musicians which I definitely don't listen to, like Keith Urban, Post Malone, Jack White, YBN Nahmir, and Ziggy Marley, whoever these people are. * Pages like "Top Kickstarter Watches" and "Top Kickstarter Inventions" * A bunch of restaurants that I've never been to, but are in the same complex that I used to live in (thanks whoever sold/'shared' my email, literally probably my former real estate agent)
- vmarsy 9y agoLast time I checked mine, it was pretty accurate, but I have a lot of the "PlayStation in <random country>" too! I also see a lot of PlayStation related ads on my news feed... I haven't used a PlayStation since I got an Xbox one!
- dnautics 9y agoFacebook believes I'm african-american (I'm not)
- wolco 9y agoYou might just be to facebook because you like content similiar to others in an ad group labelled african american.
- avian 9y agoFor Google, something similar can be found under My account -> Personal info & privacy -> Ads settings.
- mikestew 9y agoMost of the topics Google thinks I'm interested in are close enough. But American football and Parenting? I don't know where they got those. I have to consciously think to come up with the name of the local team ("Mariners? No, that's baseball."), and we don't have kids nor any plans to do so. Maybe it was all the clicking on CafeMom.com (mommy blog with tons of trackers and ads) while I was testing the Pi-Hole set up. :-)
- wdr1 9y ago> GDPR Twitter data export and it included me in a bunch of incorrect, non-sensical and contradictory ad targeting groups. This is expected. It's not desirable, but it is expected. The problem is your comparing it to an absolute. I.e. to perfect. If advertisers had that choice, they would love it. They generally don't. Remarketing is kinda close, but limits the scale. Rather, the only other scalable options are far worse. Think about it. What are the marketers other choices? The one that should come to mind, and the one they spend most of their money: TV. With TV you pick up a huge amount of waste. Say you buy a spot on Big Bang because you want people thinking of buying a new iPhone. Not a big stretch, right? At the same time thinking of all the other people they have to buy, who watch the ad, and aren't buying an iPhone. It's waste. And that waste is huge relative to what you're talking about above. So you're asking the wrong question here. It's not how good is the targeting in terms of precision/recall. The question is what's better? The waste here is generally known & its priced accordingly. > I was very disappointed that the Google and Facebook data exports don't contain this data. It's in my Facebook export. Under "Information About You" did you uncheck "Ads"? That's where the information is contained & it's checked by default. You can also view it here for both FB & Google, as well as opt of both: https://adssettings.google.com/authenticated?hl=en https://adssettings.google.com/authenticated?hl=en https://www.facebook.com/about/basics/advertising https://www.facebook.com/about/basics/advertising
- marcosdumay 9y ago> Rather, the only other scalable options are far worse. Is it really worse than "this article is about X, Y is related, let's show some ads for Y"? I bet from the point of view of the advertisement middlemen it is not. Because they capitalize mostly on showing ads of products that people already decided to buy or are very near deciding. But that is yet another racquet that only decreases the value of the industry. My question is, from the point of view of the real advertisers (the ones selling something), is it really worse?
- dmoy 9y agoRight but the advertising budgets for things actually related to articles or other media content are vastly dwarfed by the advertising budgets for unrelated things that actually make more revenue/profit. So you'll end up having to try to monetize something that has little no no related things that are profitable to advertise.
- phillipcarter 9y agoYeah, my impression is that this whole "smart, targeted ads" thing is actually just a lie, and that it's really more of a "spray and pray" kind of thing. It's a bubble!
- Moru 9y agoBut everyone using this spray and pray knows it is far from perfect. You just use the best you can get and knows about the imperfections. Spray and pray also works in a broad sense.
- nine_k 9y agoHave they got the following mostly right: * Your age bracket; * The fact that your net worth is positive (not deep in debt); * Whether you live in a city / suburb / countryside; * Which part of country is that; * Your gender; * Your race / ethnicity, broadly? If so, they still have an immensely precise focus on you, compared to TV, radio, or paper media, even if they're mistaken about your cat.
- seem_2211 9y agoYep agreed. As a salesperson, knowing someone went to college is often more helpful than knowing what exact college someone went to - too personalized is just creepy. I think the trick is somewhere around the space being able to accurately engage someone with of "hey you look like the sort of person who might be interested in xyz".
- reaperducer 9y agoHe just doesn't want to admit on HN that he has a cat.
- krageon 9y agoI don't know about the person in question, but in order: * Yes, but the age bracket for me is _very_ wide (it says "alive and not in need of new knees yet probably", but not much more) * They didn't have this info * This was wrong * No, they didn't have this (although the country itself was correct) * Wrong * They did not have this
- reaperducer 9y agoThat's not a failure of advertising. That's a failure of technology. The fact that you choose to purchase certain items over other equally suitable items is largely because of advertising.
- levashovbiz 9y agoI had very similar experience with Facebook when tried to check my profile. Out of 20 interests only 4 were correct I think it is an intentional stretching the interests way to far to look better for advertisers. In more details: https://levashov.biz/can-trust-facebook-audience-interests/ https://levashov.biz/can-trust-facebook-audience-interests/
- kerng 9y agoThe idea of advertising is also to create interest where there is none. If you all of a sudden see an ad about those other topics your aren't super interested yet, maybe you will become. That's the idea of manipulation and marketing.
- usrusr 9y agoThat's the kind of advertisement TV is selling, not what social media are claiming to sell.
- hammock 9y agoWould like to see my own. How do you do that?
- thisisit 9y ago> Facebook data exports don't contain this data Facebook does have demographics and targeting data. Go to Setting -> Ads -> Your Information -> Your Categories. I haven't found a way to export it. On the categorization side, Facebook does a half decent job considering I don't upload anything on FB or any other sister sites. Twitter on the other hand might be running algorithm which tries to extrapolate too much from the available data.
- nl 9y agoI've never looked at the Google export, but you can see what topics they think you are interested in here: https://adssettings.google.com/authenticated?hl=en https://adssettings.google.com/authenticated?hl=en Twitter is just entirely incompetent at everything, so no surprise they get their advertising product wrong too.
- hannasanarion 9y agoThose are just arbitrary names given to clusters of users. If your behavior and responsiveness is similar to others in the group, why should the advertiser care if the label isn't literally true?
- belorn 9y agoOne can see it a bit like search where it can be more important to do fast exclude than to have correct include. Those 8 ad targeting groups are potential matches, but what the data do not say is the hundreds of targeting groups which twitter claim that you are not. This kind of fast classification is good as a performance/cost saving technique when the error cost is also low. Also, one can be high spender and frugal. A person who buy one pair of very expensive shoes and wear them for 10 years rather than buying 10 pairs of inexpensive ones would be such person.
- bryanrasmussen 9y agoHow much do you use twitter?