7 ms·
Tech Breakthroughs That Could Make People Love the Bus
- hprotagonist 9y agoElectrification will cut the exhaust stench down a lot, but it won't stop the lurching or the overheating in winter, both of which reliably make me nauseated. I'll stick to my bicycle.
- loser777 9y agoThat depends on what the source of the lurching is---if you live in an area where surface street road quality is rough (e.g., Seattle), then it won't help much. But electrification can mean the bus will use a fixed gear instead of a rough-shifting transmission.
- reaperducer 9y ago> overheating in winter Fun story: The double-decker buses in Las Vegas overheat in the summer. You wouldn't think that a desert city where it's 100°-120°F for months on end would have buses that overheat. The problem is that the double-decker buses are sourced from a company in Britain, which has a very different definition of "hot" than Nevada. If you ever go on vacation to Vegas and see one of the double-decker buses driving down the Strip with its back engine cover wide open, it's the driver trying to keep the bus from overheating. There was an article in one of the Vegas newspapers about it. The official policy is to simply let the buses overheat and go out of service. The bus drivers get in trouble for cooling their engines that way. Vegas also has level four self-driving buses, as mentioned in the article. The first one got backed into by a truck within minutes of being deployed.
- kazinator 9y ago> My brief electric bus ride was not mind-blowingly different from a conventional one. It has been possible to experience an electric bus ride for well over a century to verify that it's not "mind blowingly different". Ever heard of the trolleybus? It's an electric bus that draws power from overhead cables. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybus#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybus#History
- iopuy 9y agoI lived in a city with a "trolley" that turned out to be a bus painted like a trolley and I've heard of others with the same experience. I have to laugh when I see a city advertise it's trolley service when in reality it is nothing of the sort.
- nataz 9y agoThat's not really what the OP is talking about. Not sure why they aren't popular in the US, but many cities in Europe have extensive electric bus networks powered by electrical lines overhead. I suspect the benefits are you don't have to lay rail + you can use normal vehicle lanes + you get the benefits of not having a combustion engine (smog, mechanical issues, fuel storage/re-fill).
- dodgedcactii 9y agoHere's a non tech "breakthrough" to help people love the bus: have the goddamn police enforce people who double park, and rip out parking and car lanes for buses only. Buses are great when they work, and they fall off when not. Its easy AF and proven across the world without the need for techbro innovation.
- incomplete 9y agoi love how SF deals with this: every muni bus has a camera that takes pics of parking scofflaws and they automatically get a ticket! :) but the biggest thing that will make people flock back to the bus, imho, would if they actually ran on schedule. i commute to work daily via AC-Transit in berkeley and have already lost count this week alone how many times the bus was scheduled to appear and didn't...
- the_snooze 9y agoAC Transit is a dumpster fire. The schedules are so unreliable that I wonder why they even bother posting them anyway. It's insulting when they say a bus runs every half-hour, only to see it sitting in its downtown start-of-route spot with the driver nowhere in sight, five minutes after it's supposed to have gotten on its way! For all the bleeding heart liberalism in Berkeley, it's amazing how little pride and professionalism AC Transit has in delivering a service the working poor need to depend on.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>i love how SF deals with this: every muni bus has a camera that takes pics of parking scofflaws and they automatically get a ticket! :) At best I begrudging tolerate some amount of automated law enforcement as a necessary evil. I don't love it. Then again, I'm one of the people who reads 1984 as a warning, not an instruction manual.
- closeparen 9y agoDouble parking is not even close to the number one concern making buses unpleasant. 1) Time it takes to walk to the station. 2) Waiting for an indeterminate amount of time, often in excess of 10 minutes, which is considered a good peak-hours frequency for some reason. 3) Standing-room-only, overcrowding, the relatively intense motor coordination task of staying upright while the bus lurches around, the unpleasantness of holding an arm over your head for tens of minutes. 4) Difficulty of escape from someone trying to talk to you or polluting the cabin with the smell of urine or music from a shitty phone speaker. 5) Absurd travel times 3-5x what it would take in a car due to frequent stops and use of surface streets. I rely entirely on public transit, and the only good bus experiences I’ve had were with a suburban commuter express which behaved like a car (or better, due to priority lanes) for the vast majority of the trip. But it was so infrequent, and the subway from my office to the bus depot had such high variance due to extreme congestion among trains, that it was no better for end-to-end travel time than a car.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoNone of these "breakthroughs" address cleanliness. Dedicated lanes addresses timeliness but if the number of people per hour of a bus lane is less than the traffic it replaces it's a net negative from an infrastructure perspective (yes it's more environmentally friendly, whether it's worth it is up for debate) Autonomy would be nice because then you could cut some pretty big costs but I expect unions to prevent that. Accessibility is basically catering to edge cases. As others have pointed out in the past, it's more efficient to have a subset of buses be handicapped accessible or have a dedicated handicapped accessible van service This is just a puff piece that doesn't really address any hard issues.
- 0xdada 9y agoI already love the bus. The trick is to live somewhere with great public transport.
- falcon620 9y agoI live in Scandinavia where public bus systems are plentiful, heavily subsized (with my taxes...) and reasonably on schedule. The things that make me avoid them and instead use my car: - You get sick by using them. The passenger density is way too high and invariably you'll end end up having a seat neighbor with some cold or flu virus. - There is no privacy at all during rush time - it's super packed and just a horribly stressed environment. I don't want to sit squashed up to some random stranger. The solution to all of this is obvious: Instead of 2+2 seat arrangements, look at business class seat configurations. Or just make the buses longer, and go with 1+1 seat configs.
- holydude 9y agoSadly Europe is full of social democrats that are in favor of this cattle transportation. Cant stress enough how healthy I am since i started to commute by car.
- falcon620 9y agoThe reason is that many of those social democrats see this kind of flu/cold as a bonus, or at least a neutral thing - it's a way of getting a valid excuse to skip working and spend some quality time at home.
- mattnewton 9y agoI don’t think this kind of comment could possibly have been made in good faith. Please don’t do that here.
- falcon620 9y agoExcuse me? It was certainly done in good faith. What evidence do you have to the contrary? Are you saying that being negative to social democratic policy is the the same as saying things in bad faith? Really?
- sctb 9y agoSince it seems you won't stop starting generic flamewars here we've banned the account. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ebiester 9y agoIn America, it's frustrating, but the breakthrough Americans need is some sort of separation between mass transit and poverty - that mass transit is something for all of us, not just the poor. (I also argue that it needs to be faster than individual transit. Unfortunately, individual transit is something people won't accept being slower, even if mass transit could make the whole trip faster.)
- jessriedel 9y agoI expect Uber and Lyft to likely provide a separation by expanding their carpool service to vans. They'll be as cheap as jitney vans but much more timely and everyone inside will have to own a working smart phone.
- ryandrake 9y agoDo NYC residents look at the subway as something only poor people use? Honest question, I don’t live there. I don’t consider “associating with the poors” to be an impediment at all. What stops me from using mass transit (including bus and rail service) is that its schedule in my town is totally inadequate. Stops are not frequent enough, service starts too late in the morning and ends too early at night, and travel time to most destinations is slower than by car. Fix these major problems and I happily use transit.
- marnett 9y agoMost residents of NYC use the subway, at least for long distances - it's simply the cheapest and fastest way for a large majority of routes throughout the city. The socioeconomic spread is large; granted, I'm sure the wealthy with their door-to-door black car service probably think it is still for "the poor."
- zaphoyd 9y agoNot sure about NYC, but there are absolutely people in Chicago and Milwaukee who will call a rideshare (or insist that they pick up/be picked up by family) even though there is a city bus that goes literally directly door to door and the vehicle is sitting there ready to leave in a few minutes. It is depressing. Anecdotally it is much worse in cases where the bus in question passes through areas where non-affluent white people will be getting on and off.
- ars 9y agoIf you think these things will make "Normal People Love the Bus" you don't have any understanding of why they hate the bus in the first place.
- danieka 9y agoCare to elaborate? I love the bus and would like to think that I belong to the category "normal people".
- ajross 9y agoOf those, only "Seamless Payment" really seems relevant to most people. The rest is just stuff transit nuts like to think about. But being able to pay as a regular person without buying a pass or finding change or using a vending machine is big. Just walk on the vehicle unimpeded and pay using nothing but what you carry around with you (e.g. a smartphone). And it inexplicably misses the single biggest and most obvious criterion: SERVICE FREQUENCY. No one cares about how slick the bus service is if you have to wait 10 minutes for it to show up. Because while 10 minutes might be OK for most people what that really means is that inevitably a vehicle gets skipped or breaks down (this happens a lot more than you think) and you have to wait 20 on a day when you really can't wait 20 minutes for a ride. If you can't get the buses to show with no more than 10 minute wait at every stop on every day, people won't take them. If you can, they're better than cars. But you have to have the service level first before worrying about glitz like the stuff in the linked article.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoFrom the article: "“If there’s a 12-person little vehicle coming down the street every 5 minutes versus a 40-person vehicle coming every 20 minutes, then you’ve got more capacity in that corridor and and a much better experience for people,” Total game changer.
- sdhgaiojfsa 9y agoThe idea of a trackless train also appeals. If they had a separate right of way and could get integration with the stoplights the analogy could be extended in terms of utility as well.
- Frusteek 9y agoWe had buses like that in my part of the UK in the early 90s. They disappeared many years ago, we just have normal buses now and have for many years. I don't know why they got rid of them. Maybe cutting costs by having fewer drivers?
- ars 9y ago> If there’s a 12-person little vehicle coming down the street every 5 minutes What about a 5 person little vehicle that only comes exactly when people call it? And for even better service it works point to point, which cuts down of fuel and wasted time. And to reduce costs even further maybe drive it yourself instead of paying a driver. Although we need to a cost analysis on this. It could be some people would prefer to pay a driver, and other would drive themself.
- nategri 9y agoWow do I resent this headline. It implies that people who currently take the bus should for some reason be considered ab-normal, which they definitely should not be, by any non-classist definition.
- mrob 9y agoIt doesn't imply that people who take the bus are abnormal, only that people who love the bus are abnormal. Do you really believe anybody but a small minority loves bus travel? AFAIK most people who travel by bus only tolerate it.
- sctb 9y agoWe've removed that from the headline. Regardless of interpretation, it's a little weird and clearly distracting.
- closeparen 9y agoSomeone who is forced into taking the bus for economic reasons doesn’t necessarily love it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rufb 9y agoThis post reads like a Buzzfeed article of pointing out not quite impressive iterations of known technologies or fixes to "it ain't broke" situations. Electric buses have been around for a while, they're called trolleys. Putting the batteries inside the buses is an improvement, but hardly a breakthrough, and I'm not entirely sure it would make me "Love the Bus" Likewise, autonomous buses have been around for at least a couple decades in the form of driverless trains. For high-density routes with lots of passengers doing the same itinerary, I feel it's probably cheaper in the long run, more maintainable and safer to use rails, so I'm not sure an autonomous bus is an innovation we want over trains. Seamless payment is not a tech breakthrough at this point, it's just a matter of getting regulators and government contractors to implement seamless payments. "Accessibility" is not a tech breakthrough and the things mentioned in the article make me question the author's understanding of the state of assistive technology and the actual current needs of people with disabilities. As for "Minibus or ‘trackless train’", that's indeed a super interesting question that hasn't been solved in the space of transportation: given a very dense ad-hoc demand for transportation from region A to region B, how can you broker a collective transportation solution that is cheap, efficient and desirable over, say, a slower multimodal option, or more expensive private transportation. Sadly, the article discusses minibuses (which we've had, in Brazil at least, for longer than I can remember) and only mentions they "can" be routeless but doesn't fully explain how that could be achieved.
- transitstory 9y agoTech breakthroughs won't help. There's no replacement for an investment in infrastructure. Let me explain. I used to live in Seattle, without a car, which meant taking the bus. I thought it worked pretty well until I moved out of downtown to just off the main drag in West Seattle (California Ave.) There, the bus still worked great! Until King County Metro decided to pull service. Suddenly, all-day, all-week service from the stop by my apartment turned into 5 rush-hour trips to downtown a day, weekdays only, peak direction only. Getting anywhere else suddenly required a 2 mile walk to Alaska Junction (or, unrealistically, a local bus transfer. The 2 mile walk was faster.) I was naive and a fool (fortunately, didn't invest much and was able to move shortly thereafter.) People who invest in areas on the basis of bus service are fools. It's constantly being tinkered with for a host of regions (fluctuating budgets, political pressures, and the damnable need for people making careers to "do something.") You cannot trust a bus route. Tunnels or tracks in the ground, and associated stations? Those don't move. (They do sometimes get abandoned in the worst cases of nonfeasance.) One can generally rely on continued service over a period of time suitable for investment. There's no substitute for sunk costs as a signal of commitment. It's the investments in density that come with a real transit network that make the difference, not "attracting ridership with fancy buses." See yet again, Seattle. (Sorry, RapidRide is a joke.) You know what has historically driven ridership and attracted investment in Seattle? Areas around the trolley bus lines. Because, again, you know the route's not going away if the lines are up.
- komali2 9y agoWhat did your local government say when you contacted them about this? That sounds extremely frustrating.
- xxpor 9y agoI'm guessing the OP is talking about the big service change in the Fall of 2012. In cases like that, the county council actually has to approve the changes. So they'd probably tell him too bad.
- jpao79 9y agoAgreed. I'd be curious if Chariot (now part of Ford Mobility) might have helped or would there still not have been enough riders in your neighborhood to make Chariot service reliable enough. https://www.chariot.com/cities/seattle https://www.chariot.com/cities/seattle Hmm... after looking it seems they haven't done the full roll out to Seattle.
- mattnewton 9y agoI feel like what would make me love the bus is rails and a reasonable time schedule. These are all lipstick on a pig for me.
- Raphmedia 9y agoThe only thing I want is a quiet engine and adult sized seats. I rode the bus for two years until back pain and migraines from the noised made it so I vowed never to ride one again.
- pjc50 9y agoSeamless payment is very handy. Buses should just take contactless payments; some already do. Driverless is an interesting prospect, but shared unsupervised transport starts to feel like a safety issue, especially late at night. Systems that don't already have live bus tracking, syndicated into map apps etc, should get it - it makes the system far more usable. Edinburgh already has hybrid and full battery buses, and I believe Glasgow will get some soon. The main driver here is dealing with diesel emissions. https://lothianbuses.co.uk/news/article/Lothian-introduce-the-first-all-electric-buses-to-Edinburgh https://lothianbuses.co.uk/news/article/Lothian-introduce-th...
- jon_richards 9y agoA large part of my issue with busses is that where I am they stop literally every block. It makes them miss every light (since if there's any traffic, they can only get to their stop during a green light), which just makes them too slow to be very useful.
- emiliobumachar 9y ago>“The thing that Uber and Lyft have done that is really revolutionary was just removing some of the transportation anxiety that exists from not knowing whether you’re going to be able to get a ride, not knowing how long it’s going to take for that ride to get there, not knowing exactly how much it’s going to cost,” he said. If bus operators could make all of this information as transparent as Uber and Lyft do, they’d win more riders. I think up-to-the second awareness of time remaining would be a major improvement to the experience. I know the time remaining is uncertain, but a lot of information exists but is not making its way to the user. Allow me to browse my phone while I wait, without paying attention at all, until I get a notification when the bus is 30s away. If I'm wandering whether to go in the nearby bakery, allow me to see a "best guess" estimate and a "surely won't take less than this much" estimate for the remaining time. For very infrequent routes, allow me to set my alarm clock to X minutes before the "surely won't take less than this much" estimate to the stop near my home, to be evaluated at runtime.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoI commute daily by "coach" - I live thirty miles outside London in the commuter belt, and in general it is great. But it's great because mostly there is a bus service locally (dr gong round picking people up every few hundred yards) and then mostly a motorway drive to London - once past the first drop off (Canary Wharf) it grinds to a halt along with every one else in sheer weight of traffic The fixes needed are simple - and related to the to comment on "infrastructure as a commitment signalling device". Just charge the living bejesus out of single occupancy cars, force major roads to be bus and cycle only, and have serious decade long plans for pedestrianising most city areas - the car has to go.
- wink 9y agoHow about "enough room to sit comfortable if you have long legs" and then on top "I can work on my laptop".