9 ms·
Google Bans Bail Bond Ads, Invites Regulation
- stevespang 9y agoGoogle: Today, we’re announcing a new policy to prohibit ads that promote bail bond services from our platforms. Studies show that for-profit bail bond providers make most of their revenue from communities of color and low income neighborhoods when they are at their most vulnerable, including through opaque financing offers that can keep people in debt for months or years. Well, you could extend that further: governments and their so called "justice systems" penalize communities of color and low income neighborhoods when they are at their most vulnerable . . . . expensive defense attorneys, years of probation fees, court fees, supervisory fees, law enforcement budgets are among the highest costs for communities. Court appointed lawyers are almost a sure way these poor folks are going to serve time, while wealthy offenders do probation or walk.
- whataretensors 9y agoGoogle keeps blanket banning industries because bad actors exist. There are legitimate ICOs and legitimate bail bond companies, as the author said, and google decides to not differentiate between them. They are an AI company they should be able to detect outright scams. Or god forbid they need to hire someone. Then Google and Facebook use this and anything else to ask for regulation. Because regulation for entrenched players is just collusion to prevent disruption which will bump stock price.
- SlowRobotAhead 9y agoI’m fairly antiregulation and they have me cheering for Google and Facebook to get government regulation. Remember when their motto was “do no evil”... deciding they should defacto censor the Internet is evil. Sure no one is going to go to war for ICO and bail bonds ads, but if anyone can’t see the precendent for why this is bad - well - I’m sure some people will jump to tell me why Google is good for “looking out for us” or some such nonsense.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoIs there precedent for telling a company who's ads they must show?
- chrisco255 9y agoYeah, it happens in political advertising in particular. You can't deny one or the other party's ads.
- GeneralMayhem 9y agoBut surely you can choose not to show political ads at all, which would be the parallel situation?
- magicalist 9y agoOnly in broadcast because the FCC licenses the spectrum to them and the supreme court has found that part of the first amendment is that the government has an interest in fostering political discourse. Applying the equal opportunity rules to advertising networks in general would be the legal battle of a lifetime. Applying them for commercial ads is never going to happen.
- SlowRobotAhead 9y agoInteresting that the internet is broadcast sometimes and not other times then.
- magicalist 9y agoBroadcast as in companies that are FCC licensees to use spectrum, so they're able to have more restrictions placed on them than the first amendment would usually allow.
- Guvante 9y agoIs disallowing ads but allowing search really that bad for businesses?
- dragonwriter 9y agoIt's bad for ones that spend a lot on advertising placement to capture business and make up for with high prices.
- ihsw2 9y agoThe precedent has been set and we are one step closer to blacklisting it from search too. They have thusfar made no pledge that their search results are a neutral public space free from politicking, in fact they have done the opposite on numerous occasions.
- cuckcuckspruce 9y agoThis reminds me of the concept of censor-bait in movies. Filmmakers sometimes include over the top, obviously gratuitous scenes, images, or language in their films so that the MPAA ratings board feels like they've done something when it's cut to later make an R or PG-13 rating. This feels like Google inviting in regulation here so that lawmakers can feel like they've done something good and just, and that Google can later rely on this saying, "Hey now, we're not fighting regulation! We invited you in to look at the bail bonds thing!"
- dvtrn 9y agoAlso the concept of "ducking" comes to mind, from the story of the guy who would talk to a rubber duck while debugging. A former colleague took this to whole new levels and would implement unit tests that would deliberately fail and print "Quack" to the terminal as a way of forcing QA to actually execute tests.
- sigstoat 9y agoif they want to improve the bail situation, they could help fund the setup of more organizations like the bronx freedom fund. http://www.thebronxfreedomfund.org/ http://www.thebronxfreedomfund.org/ the stats on the freedom fund's site don't make it sound as though you're doing anyone any favors by leaving them in jail. owing money to the bail bondsman isn't great, but it sounds better than losing your job because you're stuck in jail for weeks awaiting trial.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- aikol 9y agoHuh, did they copy Brooklyn Bail Fund? https://brooklynbailfund.org/ https://brooklynbailfund.org/
- kevin_b_er 9y agoI disagree with the author on the goodness of bail bond services. A bond should be payable but a hardship upon the person. The very existence of bail bondsman means the bonds themselves are so frequently beyond any reasonable cost to the humans. That the bail bondsman is also somehow involved in legal advice navigating pretrial conditions is a further crock of excrement upon the system. Also I'm astounded the Koch brothers are involved in this, and I'm curious what their profit motive is as I don't believe they have a single bit of altruism in them.
- nsxwolf 9y agoThe point of bail is to keep jails as empty as possible while ensuring defendants still show up for their day in court. If you can't put up the whole amount, you can pay a bail bondsman a fee and you become his problem. Both these concepts are good things for the accused. What is your alternative? Fill up the jails? Just use the honor system?
- wl 9y agoThat's a false dichotomy. There's nothing inherent to the bail system that requires huge bail bonds that defendants cannot afford on their own. If bail schedules were abolished and bail was tailored to the individual, bail bondsmen would be unnecessary.
- rayiner 9y agoBail is set at an amount high enough that people can't afford to lose it, and thus show up to be prosecuted for a crime. If you set bails so low that most people could afford them out of pocket, they'd be so low that the risk of loss wouldn't have any deterrent effect. 60% of Americans couldn't cover even a $1,000 unexpected expense: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/18/few-americans-have-enough-savings-to-cover-a-1000-emergency.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/18/few-americans-have-enough-sa....
- inlined 9y ago
- testfoobar 9y agoGood for Google. Although their stated reasoning is flawed (bail bondsmen don't target poor minority communities for any diabolical reason, they target them because they are part of the entire criminal justice system that targets minorities), the effect will be positive. Mixing profit and capitalistic incentives with criminal justice is fundamentally flawed.
- rayiner 9y ago> Studies show that for-profit bail bond providers make most of their revenue from communities of color and low income neighborhoods when they are at their most vulnerable And doctors make most of their revenue from sick people! Makers of cheap food make most of their revenue from poor hungry people! Makers of cheap cars make most of their revenue from low-income people just trying to get to work! The level of ignorance in Google's statement is breathtaking, reflecting the mistaken view that selling goods and services to poor people is a bad thing. Bail bondsmen provide a valuable service: they allow people for whom bail is required, because a judge deems them a risk for not showing up at trial, to be released and keep going to work. If bail bonds are being disproportionately required for people in low-income and minority communities, that's the government's fault. Targeting the bail bondsmen doesn't fix that problem--if those people can't make bail, they'll just stay in jail and potentially lose their jobs. Indeed, preventing them from advertising makes the problem worse, because it reduces competition in the market that would drive interest rates down.
- conistonwater 9y agoReading Google's statement perhaps rather too charitably, perhaps this might be what they meant to emphasize? > including through opaque financing offers that can keep people in debt for months or years. This would be a way to make their logic not horrible.
- rayiner 9y ago"Opaque financing offers" is handwaving. If its anything like payday lending, the real complaint is that the bonds "keep people in debt for months or years." But that's not because of opaque financing, but because poor people don't have much free cash flow to service a loan, and are bad credit risks statistically so the interest on that loan has to be relatively high. Removing the ability to advertising makes both problems worse, by reducing competition.
- joshuamorton 9y agoPayday lending goes beyond that. Its rent-seeking in the same way that reordering charges to repeatedly overdraft someone is rent-seeking. Sure "don't be poor" is one way to solve that issue, but even a poor and reasonably reliable person can be taken advantage of by payday loans (whose interest rates are always >100% APR, which is 10-20x more than anything else). There's a reason payday loans interest rates are capped [in many jurisdictions]: a 500% APR isn't something that arises normally.
- jfasi 9y agoNote that they're banning bail bond ads, not links. This means if you search for "bail bonds" you'll see organic links but no ads. This is a crucial difference that this post seems to overlook. The search algorithm goes way out of its way to determine some measure of "legitimacy." Obviously this is a vague and hard-to-define measure, but the goal is commendable: show results that are both relevant to the user according to Google's relevance metrics and legitimate according to who links to it, quality of the page, freshness, etc. Whatever qualms you might have about the vagaries of the search algorithm, you can't dispute that it's difficult to game. Meanwhile ads are chosen by what brings the most long term value to Google. Gaming this system is much easier, and usually begins with paying more per click. This favors advertisers with higher margins, which is harmless for innocuous queries like "flowers" which make up the bulk of search ads. For bail bonds, however, this favors advertisers with higher margins, which in turn rewards exploitative providers over the legitimate bail bondsmen this author seems to think will be harmed. If anything, this is actually a boon to the more socially-minded bail bondsmen this article is concerned about: exploitative bail bonds businesses that go out of their way to saddle their customers with debt will not appear on the top of the page, raising more legitimate ones. Another point: one of the consequences of being able to pay for ranking is you can place ads on terms that are not really related to your business. For instance, "Home Depot" queries tend to show ads for Lowes and other competitors. In a similar way, searching for "bail bond counseling" and other terms tends to include at least one for-profit bail bond operation that offers no or nominal counseling. Meanwhile if there are no ads, then the legitimate counseling services will float to the top of the page. Likewise for queries for all the other services this article claims will be hurt. Source/disclaimer: These are my personal opinions as someone who works in ads at Google, (but was not involved in this decision). All my points come from publicly available info. Please don't mistake this for anything but my own views.
- ksk 9y ago>Whatever qualms you might have about the vagaries of the search algorithm, you can't dispute that it's difficult to game. Nothing personal against you, but as a user I find that google's algorithms are trivially gamed by the SEO industry. Apart from the ads themselves, I personally think a small ranking boost for pages that don't run ads will go a long way to clean up the search results.
- CobrastanJorji 9y ago> Indeed, [bail bonds] are a necessary service for the legal system to function. This is untrue. While bail bonds are a major feature of the U.S. legal system, removing the whole bail bond system would be an improvement.
- imglorp 9y agoWhat would a replacement look like?
- CobrastanJorji 9y agoUnsecured bonds seem promising. "Show up to court or else you'll owe $10,000." Partially secured bonds also seem not so bad (pay refundable 10% of the bail to the court, rest becomes a debt if you don't show up). Some recent studies have indicated that these might be just as effective as regular bail. DC's PSA ( https://www.psa.gov/ https://www.psa.gov/ ) has shown that this sort of thing can work fine for regular, minor cases. You could go completely cashless and say that most small offenses are just released on their own recognizance and everybody who IS a flight risk gets an ankle bracelet.
- gnicholas 9y ago> removing the whole bail bond system would be an improvement. How would this improve the system? This would mean that only rich people who can bail themselves out would be able to await trial as free men/women. Poorer people would stay in jail and presumably lose their jobs.
- CobrastanJorji 9y agoI was suggesting that the entire idea of bail money was a bad one, for exactly the reason you describe. Rich people simply leave a deposit, and poor people effectively pay a permanent fine of 10% of that deposit regardless of their innocence. The idea of ensuring someone shows up to trial by holding onto something they value isn't terrible, but the implementation certainly is. If you want to set bail, why is it based mostly on the crime and not on the wealth of the suspect? $1000 of bail means nothing to a billionaire and everything to someone living hand to mouth.
- skybrian 9y agoSome markets are hard to police at scale. I'm reminded of Google's ongoing problems with fake locksmith listings [1]. One way to solve the problem is to try harder to police it. Another (if alternative ways of searching are better) is to get out of the market. This can be a reasonable decision even if it's a perfectly legitimate market. I'm guessing Google doesn't want to devote the resources into figuring out which bail bond advertisers are legitimate. They have lots of other rules about not accepting ads for legitimate businesses. [1] https://marketingland.com/locksmiths-try-sue-google-fake-local-listings-208189 https://marketingland.com/locksmiths-try-sue-google-fake-loc...
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Google’s decision to ban ads from bail bond providers is deeply disturbing and wrongheaded. The case made for that is distinctly underwhelming. > Bail bonds are a legal service. That doesn't mean Google needs to carry ads for them. > Indeed, they are a necessary service for the legal system to function. No, they aren't. They are a necessary service for the abusive system of excessive cash bail to function, but the entire system of cash bail is facing widespread (and not along traditional party lines) criticism as being incompatible with the fundamental values of our legal system. But even if this description was accurate, that doesn't mean Google carrying advertising for the industry is necessary. > Whatever the cause, preventing advertising doesn’t reduce the need to pay bail it simply makes it harder to find a lender. No, it doesn't, as doing a Google Search for “bail bonds <city>” and comparing the advertising results, map results, and organic web search results would show. > Restrictions on advertising in the bail industry, as elsewhere, are also likely to reduce competition and raise prices. The source cited for the argument for the general effect here studied effect of advertising taxes, which increase the price for equal visibility; whether the Google ban is in any way comparable really depends what the main mechanism is for people finding bail bonds through Google-placed ads. If it's mostly search advertisement on relevant terms, banning the ads gives organic results the same effect that paid ads use to have, and reduces the cost of visibility, which would have the exact opposite effect of an advertising tax. This would, therefore, be expected to increase competition and lower prices.
- rayiner 9y agoIf Google wants to lobby to get rid of bail bonds, more power to them. But focusing on bail bondsmen is (a distinctly liberal sort of) feel-good ignorance: focusing on the “evil” business instead of the state that is actually causing the problem. There is a good argument that the government should ensure adequate water supplies in the event of disaater. But if the government fails to do that, banning private businesses from “gouging” people by selling water at market rates feels good but actually hurts people. Targeting bail bondsmen in a world where the government abuses minority and low income communities by requiring excessive bail is likewise misguided.
- 9y ago
- georgek 9y agoThis is a slippery slope for Google, and raises questions about their handling of ads for other industries where questionably ethical and/or illegal ads are run on Google. As an example from my industry (full disclosure- as cofounder of an Obamacare-only startup, I am very biased here): Search for 'Obamacare' on Google and you'll be presented with ads for sites that do not sell actual Obamacare plans, but use misleading language suggesting they do. The goal is to bait and switch - bring people in promising Obamacare plans, and then sell them plans that pay higher commissions but do not meet the requirements of the Affordable Care Act such as no restrictions on preexisting conditions, coverage of maternity services, paying for hospitalizion, etc etc. This is definitely unethical (people think they are covered for e.g. hospital visits and aren't) and in some cases illegal under state insurance law, but state enforcement personnel don't have the bandwidth to audit Google ads, and Google's auditors don't appear to have the industry-specific knowledge to catch that behavior. Given this move with bail bonds, will Google seek to more broadly enforce an ethical standard on its platform (not to mention laws)? Or is this a one off? Note that insurance is a significant portion of Google's ad revenue, whereas bail bonds are negligible.
- SilasX 9y agoIs this just Copenhagen Ethics[1] striking again? "Bail bonds companies are associated with something bad (the current criminal justice system), so they inherent the taint of evil." What do they expect is going to happen when you make it harder for potential customers to find alternatives to the loudest bail bondsman? You just make it easier for the fewer, established bondsmen to offer harsher terms. With that said, there is a right way to approach problems like this[3]: actually help the ostensible victims find a good alternative that does care about not exploiting them. For an example of the model, here's my experience when I visited a California check-cashing place (long story): before cashing the check, on ridiculous terms, they walk you through several cheaper alternatives (no idea if this is a legal requirement). I don't see anything in their announcement[2] that suggests they'll take this approach, which would be something like: replace the "bad ads" with ones for the superior, non-profit alternatives that they want these communities to use. It's just unhelpful moralizing from advocates with a dubious model of the harm's causation. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10367855 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10367855 [2] Warning: it will probably set off your add blocker: https://adwords.googleblog.com/2018/05/google-bans-ads-for-bail-bonds-services.html https://adwords.googleblog.com/2018/05/google-bans-ads-for-b... [3] by "this", I mean a case where there's a bad system, and a for profit group that's offering a local improvement but seems slimy nonetheless
- inlined 9y agoMany other posters suggest that native search results (still allowed) will better find legitimate and helpful bail bond companies
- SilasX 9y agoI saw one or two other posters, and that's conjecture at best. If bail bonds companies really are exploitive and their announcement isn't just virtue signaling, they should be actively pointing people to the orgs that aren't exploitive (and have an actual model for what counts as not being exploitive), not just praying that the exploitive ones don't learn SEO.
- panzagl 9y agoI'm going to become a bail bondman and refuse to serve people of color. I bet I'll get tons of accolades for being so progressive.
- tbyehl 9y agoI've gone to a bondsman twice and neither time was I presented with any financing options. Perhaps because the bail was only a few thousand dollars, with the bondsman taking 10% (state law capped at 12% under $10K, 15% over). The whole infraction -> arrest -> bail -> fines -> probation cycle in my state is highly punitive. Trivial things can lead to a warrant / arrest. Bondsman collect their fees, the courts get theirs. If they've sat in jail for a bit, they may be getting charged for the privilege. Afterwards the person ends up on probation, which collects more fees and produces more opportunity for someone to be arrested again over something trivial. It's nuts, and that's just one tiny aspect of the policing-for-profit economy.