8 ms·
I think this is attributing too much agency to "government". Voters wanted slavery, and so public officials supported it. Voters wanted wars and a surveillance
by fulafel 9y ago
I think this is attributing too much agency to "government". Voters wanted slavery, and so public officials supported it. Voters wanted wars and a surveillance state after 9/11. Etc.
(Same goes for the good things that the public sector does, of course)
Yes there is inertia and self-perpetuation, like in any organisations, but not overwhelmingly much.
- wallace_f 9y agoI am not so sure about that. Did voters ever vote on the surveillance state? Wars like Iraq, Vietnam, etc, were created by lies that would not exist without this agency. The WMD lies and Gulf of Tonkin lies have been well documented in respectable news outlets, so it is not like these are at all conspiracy theories. Yesterday was May 4th, the anniversary of when the agency in government murdered unarmed, peaceful war protestors at Kent State, then 11 days later bayonetted about a dozen peaceful war protestors at University of New Mexico. These are not things free people compelled their government to do.
- fulafel 9y agoI'm sure we both know that voters vote for representatives, not laws, so that question is not applicable. But in general, there has been popular support for things like "patriot act", and wars, as measured in polls.
- mr_spothawk 9y agopolls are stated in such a way ... theyre part of the control
- called_it 9y agoThere has also been even more support for the opposite, so that's just more sophistry.
- fulafel 9y agoIraq war and patrioct act both saw more support than opposition in polls, when they happened (law passed, invasion was started). Wars did get less popular when they went badly, so you can argue that they would have been shorter if public officials would have retreated when polls turned against them. But that's a separate discussion.
- nasredin 9y agoVoters wanted Iraq War when they voted Bush in 2004. I remember those "love it or leave it" years well.
- coldtea 9y ago>I think this is attributing too much agency to "government". Voters wanted slavery, and so public officials supported it. The voters vote what they're told to -- and they're told to by those in power who can pay for campaigns, have their pals in party positions, etc. Plus, the voters get all kinds of stuff that benefit the powerful that they never explicitly asked or voted for, and that were never on any platform. Even whole wars can be promoted onto them... https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/posters-sold-world-war-i-american-public-180952179/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/posters-sold-world-wa... Besides, there were tons of dirt poor whites picking cotton in the South. And they had no slaves, the were closer to slaves themselves... It's more poor vs rich, than white vs black. Even if poor whites were also racist, those plantations weren't owned by poor white folk either...
- chii 9y ago> voters vote what they're told to who's "they"?
- coldtea 9y agoI think that the syntactic structure makes it pretty clear that "they" refers to the voters.
- chii 9y agoi think i was unclear in what i meant - who are the people telling the voters what to do?
- graedus 9y agoBroadly, those with power and money. Having enough money to lobby congress is one manifestation of that. Having enough money to wage large multichannel PR campaigns on the population is another. Funding think tanks, funding PACs, ownership of or influence over the major media outlets. People with this kind of power and money form a series of formal and informal interlocking networks, and often interests align across most or all of those networks. Tax cuts for the rich and for corporations is perhaps the most obvious one. Pushing for war might be a bit less unanimous, but wars do produce near-immediate profits for the military-industrial complex and those invested in it, and potential future business opportunities for other sectors (for example if the war results in regime change, which leads to an opening of previously closed markets, the sale of state-owned businesses and assets, etc).
- stickdogg 9y agoWatch zeitgeist on YouTube and you can discover the true story of what occurred on 9/11.
- jMyles 9y agoThis seems like a differently-worded variant of "we get the government we vote for." But that conclusion has been convincingly rejected by sound political science for quite a while now. The policy preferences of the voting constituency in any given national election are not strongly correlated to policy results. This is shown convincingly in Benjamin Ginsberg's book, "Do Elections Matter?" I strongly recommend this book - after reading it, you will never again try to explain away an act of government by attributing it to voter sentiment. It is a difficult-to-deny fact that, in the USA, the government frequently and quietly advances policies which do not appear to be derived from any kind electoral mandate, nor are favored by a substantial portion of the electorate.
- visarga 9y agoGovernment represents the interests of capital, not of ordinary people.
- fulafel 9y agoIt's not exactly the same idea. But of course I would be interested in hearing if the referenced book could explain away my observations of government/popular opinion alignment in the issues discussed. Random chance is of course one possibility.
- haZard_OS 9y agoI'm interested in the concept but do you have a suggestion for a book published more recently? "Do Elections Matter?" was published almost 30 years ago.
- tsbertalan 9y agoWell, there's [1], but see also references in this Vox article, which hedges that somewhat: [2] [1] https://www.vox.com/2016/5/9/11502464/gilens-page-oligarchy-study https://www.vox.com/2016/5/9/11502464/gilens-page-oligarchy-... [2] https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/files/gilens_and_page_2014_-testing_theories_of_american_politics.doc.pdf https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/fi...
- u801e 9y ago> Voters wanted wars and a surveillance state after 9/11. It could be argued that voters were manipulated towards that point of view.
- hnpromomessage 9y ago> It could be argued Not in polite company. In polite company the "voters want wars and surveillance" by prep school secret society "blue bloods" cum "masters of the universe".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]