56 ms·
Eran Tromer's Attack on Ray Ozzie's CLEAR Protocol
- joe_the_user 9y agoBy the article's description, CLEAR is a "trusted computing" approach - law enforcement can control things about the phone that the user cannot. Aside from the particular attack described, such systems are both inherently undesirable and unlikely to stop serious criminals while decreasing the security of the casual user. see: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/can-you-trust.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/can-you-trust.en.html
- dcow 9y agoIf two people are allowed to talk privately in person, and if that right extends to the digital realm, then strong encryption is a must. In a world with CLEAR people would just send ephemeral messages. Unless we fundamentally assert an individual's right to privacy we'll just end up in a crypto arms race.
- chacham15 9y agoWhile the situation described here has measures that can be taken to prevent, the entire system is trivially compromised by the fact that the consumer controls the software. All a bad actor needs to foil this entire schema is to unlock the phone and program it so that whenever it is asked for a device unlock request, it will simply factory reset the hard drive (or even more covertly, reimage it to a different drive). With this approach, the criminal reveals nothing and law-abiding citizens are open to multiple undiscovered attack vectors.
- abcd_f 9y agoThis is covered in the article: Another problem is that CLEAR phones must resist "jailbreaking", i.e., must not let phone owners modify the operating system or firmware on their own phones. This is because CLEAR critically relies on users not being able to tamper with their phones' unlocking functionality, and this functionality would surely be implemented in software, as part of the operating system or firmware, due to its sheer complexity (e.g., it includes the "device unlock request" screen, QR code recognition, crytographic verification of unlock codes, and transmission of data dumps). In practice, it is well-nigh impossible to prevent jailbreaking in complex consumer devices, and even for state-of-the-art locked-down platforms such as Apple's iOS, jailbreak methods are typically discovered and widely circulated soon after every operating system update.
- dcow 9y agoWhat about CLEAR makes it novel beyond the blown fuse (which doesn't actually impact the threat model anyway)? AFAICT it's literally just single key escrow where the vendor is the escrow service... why is it getting so much attention?
- Arnt 9y agoDoesn't seem novel to me either. RFC 1925 point 11 applies.
- notOnYourLife 9y agoIn this example, government is in possession of a locked phone, tablet, PC, or other device, and has obtained a legally-authorized warrant permitting access to the contents of said device. The vendor in this example would have implemented a new gesture at the lock screen – perhaps a multi- finger swipe or twist gesture - to gain access to a special “Device Unlock” screen shown on the next slide. Ha ha ha! Oh wow! Nope, forget it. I will never use another cellular phone again, if such a thing ever exists.