13 ms·
Emergency room patients can face steep bills even when treatment is declined
- Carlton87 9y agoThere is an easy way to avoid this, don't go to the Emergency Room unless you have an Emergency.
- ishansharma 9y agoI guess the point of the article is exhorbitant fees. An ice pack and a bandage in ER don’t have to cost $5k plus.
- Arnt 9y agoWhat is it that does cost $5k? Keeping a mostly-unused tomography machine and crew ready in case someone at the ER needs it? Insurance premiums charged per patient who walks in the door? We get these complaints in Germany too (where I currently live) BTW. "A five-minute drive with an ambulance shouldn't cost €500!" someone complained to the newspaper here recently. It doesn't, what costs €500 is keeping enough ambulances ready that one can arrive within x minutes with y% probability, for IMO overcautious values of x and y.
- tunbgeetf 9y ago€500 is still something many people can pay in Germany, 5k isn't something the average American can foot (with no treatment to boot). It's not at all a comparable complaint. IIRC an ambulance ride in the US is 10-20k, that's indicative of just how much more medical care costs over there.
- JesseWright 9y agoI have never heard of an ambulance ride costing anywhere _near_ $10K-$20K. The average, out-of-pocket price of an ambulance ride is much closer to $1000 - and often less. New York's 2012 fee schedule offers a good example: https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/fdny/downloads/pdf/about/fee-schedule-ambulance.pdf https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/fdny/downloads/pdf/about/fee-sch...
- Arnt 9y agoSure, there's an extra digit. Much US healthcare seems to suffer from Extra Digit Syndrome. What might be similar that the billable item is not the costly item. Of course I don't know the first thing about US health care costs (as opposed to billable items).
- pyvpx 9y agowhat German health insurance plan does not cover an ambulance ride in full?
- merb 9y agoit does, if you take the ride and are allowed (if you are healthy you probably need to pay) to take the ride.
- Arnt 9y agoSome of the PKV companies offer cheapish plans that effectively do not, or that make you pay the first €x00/month yourself. Things like that. They're marketed as insurance against big problems for a small price.
- merb 9y agoeh in germany driving the ambulance is free - if you really need one. of course there are people who call the ambulance without too much reasons and even than as long as the amublance doctor will allow you to take the drive to the hospital you would still be on the safe side.
- falsedan 9y ago> a mostly-unused tomography machine and crew ready in case someone at the ER needs it No hospital administration would allow this: they would refer you to a separate medical imaging clinic, or run one on hospital grounds that all departments would refer patients to.
- a-saleh 9y agoAs far as I know, point of the exorbitant fees is the weird process of collective bargaining between the care-providers and insurers. I.e. you, as the hospital, inflate your price, by X00% margin over what you actually plan to charge the insurance. Then you let the insurance negotiators negotiate, and you negotiate down to the reasonable price. This looks really good on the paper. Unfortunately, you as a patient, if you don't have good coverage, you end up paying the inflated price, that you didn't really have the chance of negotiating (and wouldn't really have the chance even if you hadn't been unconcious ;) Like, if I compare it to Czech Republic, where I live (or even Germany), the prices seem much more reasonable (i.e. you would be able to get a complication-free birth in hospital for ~400$, more complicated, i.e. cesarean section ~1500$, including hospital stay, in US it seem to be 5-10x as much)
- kalleboo 9y ago> that you didn't really have the chance of negotiating Not American, but from what I've read in these types of news articles, you often CAN negotiate it down a lot, but when you get a huge bill in the mail, the first thing you think isn't "I'm going to try to haggle down my $5000 bill with this huge hospital" you think "I'm so screwed. Time to google 'personal bankruptcy', was it 7 years?". Pharmaceutical companies are also always saying that they will subsidize prescription medications for those who can't afford it, but I dunno how much that is BS or not.
- a-saleh 9y agoOh, good to know. From the horror stories you usually read in the news it seemed that "try to haggle down my $5000 bill with this huge hospital" is something you just don't get to do, if you are a patient, I will remember that if that ever comes up (even though I hope it doesn't :)
- maxerickson 9y agoIf you use insurance they are less willing to negotiate. (but you are getting the negotiated price anyway; the paranoid part of my brain thinks they run a scam here by recoding bills that come after the deductible has been met, which is a different sort of negotiation than agreeing on prices for services)
- nkrisc 9y agoHitting your head hard enough to cause injury is almost always a reason to seek immediate medical attention, especially if the head injury is the result of losing consciousness in the first place.
- Coffeewine 9y ago> “I decided to decline treatment because I can’t really afford any surprise bills right now,” she said. “The bill I’d probably incur would not be worth saving my ear, which was sad but a choice I had to make.” She felt that losing her ear was a possible outcome of the accident, which certainly seems like an emergency. More broadly, it can be difficult for a layman to determine what warrants emergency care vs what doesn't.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pandacat 9y agoI remember when I was still a school kid there was another kid that fell on his head when he did skate boarding. He said that everything was alright. In the afternoon he got headache but still claimed it was alright. Next day he was dead...
- assblaster 9y agoEpidural hematoma. Careful observation is necessary because if there is a sudden decline in mental status, emergency surgery is essential.
- sgift 9y agoYeah. Easy. When I went to an ER because I had fainted multiple times they wanted to send me away, because "that's nothing too serious" ... and I thought that sounds reasonable and wanted to go home, they are the experts after all, aren't they? A good friend told them to do their fucking job instead and they grudgingly agreed to check me, but "you will be out of here in no time, there's nothing" ... so ... they did a blood check and I waited. And waited. "Well .. we don't know, something is off, we will keep you here for the night. But it's only a precaution, there's probably nothing wrong with you!" ... next day they found Stage 3 cancer, which had spread through my whole body. I almost died, had to spend weeks in intensive care, get chemo and operations and the full program. And all of that only happened because my friend didn't take multiple "no" from the ER doctor for an answer and insisted that I get at least a rudimentary checkup by them, otherwise I would be dead. So, respectfully, your comment is bullshit.
- assblaster 9y agoYou could also go to a primary care doctor who would be capable of performing a detailed exam to address your chief complaint. Your friend was right in that the emergency room doctor should do their job, but their job isn't to be the primary physician, they're there to diagnose and treat emergencies. If you were tachycardic, tachypneic, apneic, hypotensive, hypertensive, febrile, hypothermic, bloody, pale, in severe localized pain, slurring speech, paretic, then the ER would investigate until answers are obtained, because all of the above are concerning. A complaint of only fainting has many non emergency causes, and you would have to provide additional information that would warrant investigation. Ordering fishing expedition tests in the ER is extremely wasteful in a non emergency situation. Imagine how many people go to the ER for nonemergency care and expensive tests are ordered unnecessarily! Because of defensive medicine, this happens way too much, which is why healthcare costs so damn much in this country.
- TallGuyShort 9y agoAnd if you do have an emergency you're fucked because the health insurance you were already required by law to pay for has incentives that, like the healthcare provider, do not align with actual patient care?
- analog31 9y agoIn my view "emergency room" is a red herring. I once went to an ER for something. My first interaction was at a window where a worker asked me what was up, then pointed me down the hall to a facility that looked like and was just a regular urgent care clinic. Medical care is anything if not statistical. If an ER is receiving non-emergency patients, they know it, and can design their care processes to handle those patients efficiently. If they're billing patients $5k for a bandage, it's solely a financial boondoggle. There is also a political aspect -- blaming poor people for "wasting" care by making unnecessary use of the ER.
- mfoy_ 9y agoAs a Canadian, we have our own share of problems with our health care system... but thank goodness this isn't one.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoHow can people read and hear about stories like this, and even possibly think it's OK or even normal? How do lawmakers in the USA convince people that this is acceptable? I have never directly paid a single cent for healthcare, and neither has anyone I know. When I had to get 6 stitches in my forehead at 2 AM on a Sunday morning, it cost me nothing. When my friend needed to get the tip of his finger reattached, it cost us $5 for parking. When my brother spend almost a week in hospital after coming off his motorbike, requiring surgery on both his knees, it cost him a grand total of $0 out of pocket. Are people just so blind to how extortionate healthcare is in the USA? The argument that I pay for my healthcare in my taxes doesn't hold water either. I pay less tax in Australia than I would in California, and I get free hospital care as part of that. I don't have health insurance and see no reason why I would purchase it either.
- bbarn 9y agoWe all know it's bad. We pay hundreds a month to insurance companies because it's a law that we have to, and our employers pay even more. The health care industry is massively profitable. There's simply nothing we can do about it, or many of the issues plaguing this country. Before anyone says so, the illusion that we can change it by voting is not helpful. We can all elect a representative who will say they are going to change it, and they don't have to do a damn thing we want them to. Our system of government is broken, not just our health care system.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe individual mandate was repealed. With the explicit goal of causing the individual marketplaces to implode. In the meantime it's increased the cost to taxpayers of subsidizing marketplace plans!
- humanrebar 9y agoThe individual markets were already a mess.
- 9y ago
- awicz 9y ago“While we cannot comment on rates for emergency room services..." Why not?
- Aeolun 9y agoBecause regardless of what they say it is going to make them look bad?
- c0nfused 9y agoTypically, the rates negotiated with the various insurance companies are basically secret. No one wants to share the data and there is great incentive not to. If you are in the insurer side, you think you have a competitive advantage compared to company Y. Sharing what you are paying per procedure is bad business If you are on the Hospital side, you want to make sure the insurers keep paying more, and publishing means a quick race to the bottom. This means that in most cases in america, you cant know what something is going to cost until after you get billed. Its great for literally everyone except the consumer.
- andruby 9y agoMy personal opinion is that this should be illegal. Prices for the same treatment should be equal regardless of patient or insurer. The insurance repayment policies could differ, but at least the base pay won't seem completely made up. Disclaimer: I only lived in the US for a year.
- mfoy_ 9y agoIsn't it anti-competitive? How can consumers make an informed decision as to which care provider to visit? Isn't this in the same boat as price-fixing?
- toast0 9y agoThe base rate is the same (in theory), but insurance policy A is only going to pay 18% of procedure Z and policy B will pay 27%; uninsured patients will be offered a 50% discount if they pay promptly, otherwise the bill will eventually be sold to collections for 1% if it's not paid)
- avs733 9y ago"Hoboken University Medical Center, where Pell was seen, declined to comment on the bill. The hospital did, according to Pell, reverse the entire balance after Vox began inquiring about the fees." I'll bet the hospital sees that as 'fixing the situation' and all I am left wondering is how many other people don't have Vox reporters sending emails for the same type of treatment. I'm hoping the CMS plan [0] to require published prices might help this type of nonsense just a little. [0] https://www.cms.gov/Newsroom/MediaReleaseDatabase/Press-releases/2018-Press-releases-items/2018-04-24.html https://www.cms.gov/Newsroom/MediaReleaseDatabase/Press-rele...
- maxerickson 9y agoI doubt it, hospitals were already required to make those prices available, the change is that they have to make them available on the internet. While hospitals are already required under guidelines developed by CMS to either make publicly available a list of their standard charges, or their policies for allowing the public to view a list of those charges upon request, CMS is updating its guidelines to specifically require that hospitals post this information. The agency is also seeking comment on what price transparency information stakeholders would find most useful and how best to help hospitals create patient-friendly interfaces to make it easier for consumers to access relevant health care data so they can more readily compare providers. One reason to doubt it is that an awful lot of people live within reasonable distance of 1 hospital, and almost everyone else lives near busy hospitals.
- ceejayoz 9y ago> While hospitals are already required under guidelines developed by CMS to either make publicly available a list of their standard charges... This requirement is useless, though. The "standard charges" don't reflect reality. My wife receives regular infusions in an infusion center. They bill $3k to insurance each time. Insurance pays about $400, which the hospital happily accepts. That $3k number is what an uninsured patient would be asked to pay, and it's the number they'll list as the standard charge, but it's complete, invented bullshit.
- 9y ago
- piyush_soni 9y agoOk, mine is way less than her, but at one of the ER in Wisconsin, they sent me a bill of $400 for literally telling me that I have no disease and sending me back. Out of that, the insurance paid $300, and I paid 100 out of my pocket. I had gone to ER only because it was at an odd time and no other hospital was open.
- assblaster 9y agoWhy didn't you just wait to see your primary physician?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- falsedan 9y agoLay people don't have the training to determine if an ailment is life-threatening or not; that's why they pay for insurance, so they can see a medical professional who is qualified to say if you could die or not.
- assblaster 9y agoYou can say that about 100% of medical complaints. Emergency rooms should be for emergencies. You yourself will know if you are about to die.
- piyush_soni 9y agoYou mean one should wait until the signs show with certainty that they're about to die before going to the ER? That'd a bit of a stretch :). Of course, I went because I thought it was an emergency (though I can see your definition of 'emergency' is quite different from mine). It's not like I went because I had cold.
- spsrich 9y agoAny parent has similar stories. Consumer law does not seem to apply to doctors and hospitals. Imagine if you took your car into the shop - there is no price list, they won't give you an estimate, and for weeks after they send you random bills without indicating what it's for? This affects everybody in the US, and I don't understand why it's allowed to continue, except the medical industry has bought off all the politicians
- sjg007 9y agoIt’s predicated on the HMO model where you pay a copay and your insurance company negotiates the rates. Under the guise of consumer choice insurance companies have expanded copays and coinsurance to shift the burden to the insured. Out of network Hospitals and doctors balance billing needs to be outlawed. They should only be able to balance bill up to the Medicaid rate.
- assblaster 9y agoMedicaid is already at the lowest payment rate, so balance billing to that would be a net negative actually. Why should hospitals and doctors be forced to accept contacts from insurers that underpay for services rendered for nothing in return (being part of limited network)?
- falsedan 9y ago> so balance billing to that would be a net negative actually If the regulated standard treatment costs were somehow lower than the actual delivery costs, sure. But how on eath could that happen? It's in everyone's best interest for hospital administrators to be heavily involved in setting these costs, and they have no interest in losing money.
- assblaster 9y agoHospital administrators are the problem. They don't contribute to medical care, and their job is to increase profit that goes to higher salaries of themselves and other administrators. Regarding balance billing: If Medicaid pays $100 for a $500 procedure, and private insurance pays $400 with the expectation of a 20% coinsurance from the patient but patient refuses to pay, who is going to pay the other $100? Is the expectation that hospitals or doctors shouldn't be compensated for services rendered? Should they work for free and go out of business? What other business exists where it's ok for people to get something and refuse to pay the bill? Auto repair? Groceries? Legal advice? Housing construction? Land purchase? Auto fuel? Electricity?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ClassAndBurn 9y agoNo other industry entirely hides the end price you'll pay, or even an estimate, until after you have gone through the service. It's a sad state of affairs but not something we have to be stuck with; most of the time we could get these numbers ahead of time. ER visits are difficult in their own ways; you can be brought in unconscious and go through treatment you can't agree to, you can be close to death and the time it takes to check costs could impact if you live or not. This means you'd want to do something like fixed costs for these services but with good medical coverage for everyone those fixed costs could be what people do in place of insurance. I don't have an answer other than universal healthcare. There are reasons that this can't happen at the moment and it's still difficult to implement in a way that works across the board. This is a hard problem and will take a lot of effort to get right
- humanrebar 9y ago> I don't have an answer other than universal healthcare. What about requiring published price lists? Maybe you need twelve procedures because you're in bad shape, but at least the bill won't be arbitrary.
- DoctorOetker 9y agosomething like a chargemaster? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chargemaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chargemaster That said, mandatory transparency (from both the hospitals as the insurance/healthcare plans on what exactly happens in what scenario (say x-ray for possibly broken elbow), and the current rate/probability of scenarios) should be requisite, but that is only a necessary condition. The behaviours of the medical industry should also be binding.
- noetic_techy 9y agoThe problem is, it only limits you to the cheapest hospital WITHIN your insurance companies agreed upon network.
- Talyen42 9y agoHospital corporations and insurance corporations are not your friend. You shouldn't have to do this in a first world country, but: * Go to the ER without ID * (optional) Ask how much it will cost * (optional) They do not give prices, as a matter of policy * They must treat you by law * Afterwards, offer a cash payment you deem reasonable * They will accept or decline it Transaction complete. For non-emergency care and prescriptions, get cash quotes up front, pay in cash, and order discount online prescriptions from canada, a first world country. For chronic medical conditions, leave the US and immigrate to a first world country.
- saalweachter 9y agoImportant note on ER care. The job of the ER is to prevent you from dying, not fix you. If you are injured in a way that requires an expensive surgery and therapy to fix but won't actually kill you if left untreated, even if it cripples you, they are not obligated to fix you under the law.
- swarnie_ 9y agoHow did your healthcare system get messed up to such a level? This is criminal in western Europe.
- saalweachter 9y agoThe short answer is racism and greed.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoAmerican Exceptionalism combined with FUD.
- lr4444lr 9y agoIt goes back to WWII when we had a strange price controls on labor. Health insurance was a way for employers to provide employ compensation circumventing that. Originally it was quite manageable, but as with any system where neither the consumer nor the producer of the good/service has any incentive to keep down costs, it spiraled out of control. Also, president Richard Nixon effectively linked national health care with socialism as part of Cold War propaganda. (That said, he did offer comprehensive health reform too that in a number of ways was more dramatic than we achieved under president Obama, but the congress killed it.)
- valeryB 9y ago>Patients can face steep bills even when they didn’t receive treatment. how come people receive bills without treatment? Honestly, I just don't get it. No treatment, no bills.
- Ensorceled 9y agoI recently had a spot appear in my vision. Went to my GP same day, the receptionist called around to get me into a local optometrist who determined it was a detached retina, she called and got me into the local hospital as an emergency case. It was busy but I got my first treatment that evening. The entire journey, my green OHIP card was all I needed, no insurance forms, no pre-approvals, no extra charges. 5 hospital visits with 3 treatments so far. I'm flabbergasted when I talk to American friends and family and they all seem to think two things: 1. Canadian health care "is terrible, people die waiting in emergency rooms" 2. The US system is by far the best and that's why it's so expensive
- mfoy_ 9y agoYou forgot: 3. Canadians pay for their health care in tax, anyways. (However: https://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0411/do-canadians-really-pay-more-taxes-than-americans.aspx https://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0411/do-canadian...)
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoThere's still 5% of the US budget being spent on health care: https://media.nationalpriorities.org/uploads/trumpdiscpie_large.png https://media.nationalpriorities.org/uploads/trumpdiscpie_la... Of course, over ten times as much is spent on the military. How can a country with no enemies nearby justify spending 60% of their budget on the military? Especially given how the only ones hostile to them are the ones they pissed off.
- castlecrasher2 9y agoThat budget doesn't include SSI or Medicare
- seymour333 9y agoYou forgot: 3. This is actually a good thing, because we get health care when we need it and aren't exposed to crippling debt? (your system entirely indefensible from every possible view point)
- paulsutter 9y agoI paid $5500 last year for an unnecessary emergency room visit (doctor sent me down to get a scan). They wired me up to machines and made me wait 5 hours for the scan, then 3 hours to get discharged. They wouldn’t let me leave until the doctor on duty wrote up her treatment recommendation. Even though I was just there for a scan. No insurance last year so after my “35% cash payer discount” it came out to $5500 after the many parties in the ER sent me separate bills. Scan was $2000 of that, but I could have paid $600 across town. Don’t go to the ER unless you’re unconscious. It’s that rare case where you are paying AND you are the product.
- wccrawford 9y agoI recently had an appendectomy. The doctors said that if you are having abdomen problems, you absolutely should go to the ER as there's too high a chance it's life threatening. They said that limbs and such weren't as ER-necessary and urgent care might suffice, depending on severity. But for the stomach, just go to the ER. I initially stopped at an urgent care facility, but they told me to sit and wait before even asking my symptoms. I'm not afraid of many medical things, but my appendix has always made me extra nervous. So we left and went to the ER, where they asked a few questions and rushed me into a room, and then a scan shortly after. We had caught it very early.
- softawre 9y agoI think the concept of not going to an emergency room unless it is an actual emergency is well known?
- paulsutter 9y agoThe doctor sent me there. Gave me a slip of paper and said “give this to the ER desk to get a scan”. So I did what he said.
- clarkmoody 9y agoPlenty of anecdotes in this thread, predictably. Let's talk about why things are so messed up. The thing to realize here is that total government provision of healthcare is probably cheaper than the way the US does it, but that doesn't mean the market has failed. Healthcare in the United States is anything but a free market. It's the worst of all worlds: special interests extract rents through government regulations (drug patents, occupational licensing, handouts to insurance companies in legislation); the government effectively controls prices through its own payment programs; the whole system is over-regulated to an absurd degree. There is no price mechanism to help consumers or producers make proper choices. So when someone says something like, "the free market can't effectively provide healthcare," I would kindly ask where they see a free market healthcare system. This sounds like a No True Scotsman argument, but it's not. You can't label something so ridiculous as US healthcare as "free market" without either total ignorance or intent to deceive.
- minikites 9y agoIt's impossible to make healthcare into a free market when the cost of declining to participate in that market is usually your life.
- clarkmoody 9y agoYour statement makes no sense. You can decline to participate in the current system. And there are so many ways healthcare could be better in non-life-threatening situations.
- assblaster 9y agoThis poster gets it right 100%. In an ideal hospital, you should only have doctors, nurses, nurse assistants, nurse manager, accounting, pharmacy. Think of all the unnecessary healthcare MBAs that siphon off enormous amounts of resources to generate as much profit as possible to be shared with other healthcare MBAs. Think of all the suppliers of healthcare goods that try to patent and profit off of unnecessary medical "inventions" which do not make a difference compared to what was done previously. Think of all the government bureaucrats paid to ration healthcare resources by underpaying for services which burden hospitals and doctors to raise charges for private insured. Think of all the patients who don't give a crap about their health and refuse to correct their chronic conditions and rather go to the ER when things get really bad. Think of all the lawyers who profit off of bad outcomes (not malpractice necessarily) which forces hospitals and doctors to practice defensive medicine. Making everything single payor won't work, because guess what, there will still be a private insurance system for the people who can afford it vs the system for the rest. It doesn't fix anything.
- justherefortart 9y agoJust don't pay it. That's the solution. Hospitals have these bullshit inflated fees, once they accept the insurance payout that is all they're getting from me. They're all "non-profits" that scam the system by writing all this shit off as goodwill or bad debts.
- jhall1468 9y agoYeah, they write it off as a bad debt then you end up with it on your credit report for 7.5 years. Good call.
- justherefortart 9y agoMost credit scores are ignoring medical collections or deemphasizing it. I went to the ER a while back, my insurance paid roughly 1600 for the 8k+ they billed. I have a HSA that pays out as well, yet they have tried to bill me on top of that. They'll never see another cent. Credit is overrated anyway. Causes more troubles than it's worth.
- jhall1468 9y ago> Most credit scores are ignoring medical collections or deemphasizing it. Absolutely false. Modern FICO scores are doing that. The FICO score your bank will actually use doesn't differentiate debt. > Credit is overrated anyway. Causes more troubles than it's worth. I suppose if you never want to be a homeowner that's true.
- assblaster 9y agoThe insurer only pays part of the bill because you entered into a contract with the insurer that specified that as such. No insurer pays 100% of every medical bill, no matter what, with no expectation of copay or deductible. Even if you had that sweet deal, you would be paying premiums that nobody could afford. Do you have a right to receive services from another human without appropriate payment?
- 9y ago
- sandworm101 9y agoI cannot get over how odd "in network" is for everyone outside the united states. For emergencies we all just go to the nearest hospital. They see us. They treat us. Or they stabilize us and discuss whether we should transfer to another hospital for better/faster treatment. There is no discussion of in or out of networks. Stories like this make me very happy that I no longer live in the US. The constant fear of a surprise medical bill is a stress I don't need.
- assblaster 9y agoInsurers offer guaranteed patients to hospitals and doctors in exchange for reduced payment rates. In other words, they hospitals make their money off of volume. This is why there are networks of providers. If you prefer, you can visit any hospital you want in the United States, as long as you pay for the medical care. Why should hospitals accept low insurance payment from insurers who do not give them a benefit of increased patient volume?
- sandworm101 9y agoMore questions that we never bother asking. There are fixed rates agreed nationally, not backroom deals between corporations.
- corpMaverick 9y agoSimilar thing happened to us. My 3 year old son hurt his arm. It was after 7pm so we had to go to the ER. We see a nurse, she didn't check anything. X-Rays and then they gave us a hospital room. Immediately I realized we were getting into a spending black whole. After 30 seconds I told the nurse we wanted to leave. My son wasn't crying and he was climbing a chair using his "hurt" arm. They wouldn't let us leave. After hustling with them we left. we got a $1,500 USD bill that we had to pay because we didn't know what to do.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoBalance billing is complete bullshit. My long-term plan to deal with it is to move to Texas for their superior creditor protection laws, retire off of retirement accounts + annuities + owning primary residence, have zero assets that creditors can go after, and tell the hospital and insurance company to figure it out because they are legally unable to force me to pay.
- assblaster 9y agoHere's an interesting fact: Obamacare forced everyone to enter into a contract with insurance companies (individual mandate) who are partly responsible for the exorbitant bills seen by patient. No wonder so many people are pissed about Obamacare: being forced into contracts with companies and bureaucrats which people detest is absurdly Kafkaesque.
- gm-conspiracy 9y ago...and the worst part, making it a Federal law, but creating 50 separate marketplaces based on the state in which you reside. If you want to make it a Federal requirement, make it a federal marketplace.
- esbranson 9y agoFor all the people railing against hospital corporations, please note: 1. Los Angeles County, of 10.1 million people, runs its own hospital system. 2. New York City, of 8.6 million people, runs its own hospital system. 3. Colorado, of 5.6 million people, runs its own hospital system. Etc etc. (All of them quickly add up to the population of Canada.) They still do these horrible things we're talking about here, even though they're ultimately accountable to the people and must do what our laws says they must do. And we think we're gonna suddenly be like Canada, like magic? If so, get the five people running the LA County hospitals to do so. (Yes, five people represent 10.1 million people, lol.) And the same goes for NYC and CO and the rest.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- noetic_techy 9y agoI know everyone loves to push for a single payer system, but we could have the best of both worlds if we transitioned to the Singapore model. https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/4/25/15356118/singapore-health-care-system-explained https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/4/25/15356118/s...